This article proposes a statistical analysis of the Italian mutual aid societies’ annual report data from 1862, 1873 and 1904, and tests the hypothesis, supported by the mainstream literature, that mutual financial support for the poor is just a facade for organizing the political activity of the working classes. Factor analysis allows the data, signaling these two commitments, to be kept separate. Their time evolution, as outlined by an inter-temporal comparison of a latent class cluster analysis, reveals that political commitment, even if generally prevalent, oscillates as a function of environmental conditions, whereas the mutual financial support retains a solid foundation, regardless. The study demonstrates the potential of unconventional annual report data analysis to reveal the deepest nature of the organizations and contributes to exploring the links between political activism and accounting data in not-for-profit organizations.
Atti della Giunta centrale di statistica (1880) Sessione dell’anno 1875, ‘Annali di statistica’, serie 2° vol. 15. Italian Institute of Statistics Historical Archive (IISHA)
2.
Ministero di Agricoltura, Industria e Commercio (1880) Statistica delle società di mutuo soccorso: anno 1878. Roma: Stamperia reale.
3.
Ministero di Agricoltura, Industria e Commercio (1888) Statistica delle società di mutuo soccorso e delle istituzioni cooperative annesse alle medesime: anno 1885. Roma: Tipografia Metastasio.
4.
Ministero di Agricoltura, Industria e Commercio (1898) Elenco delle società di mutuo soccorso. Roma: Tipografia della casa editrice italiana
5.
Ministero di Agricoltura, Industria e Commercio (1864) Società di Mutuo Soccorso. Anno 1862. Torino: Tipografia Letteraria.
6.
Ministero di Agricoltura, Industria e Commercio (1875) Statistica delle società di mutuo soccorso: 1873. Rome: Regia Tipografia.
7.
Ministero di Agricoltura, Industria e Commercio (1906) Le società di mutuo soccorso in Italia al 31 dicembre 1904: studio statistico. Rome: Tipografia Nazionale di G. Bertero.
8.
Ministry of Economy and Finance Historical Archive (MEFHA) Atti del Consiglio della Previdenza – Sessione del1897 (Roma: Ministero di Agricoltura, Industria e Commercio. Divisione credito e previdenza).
9.
Pinerolo Mutual Aid Society Historical Archive (PMASHA) ‘Pinerolo Mutual Aid Society’ Collection, ‘Accounting and Finance’ Series, Bundle 4.
10.
State Central Archive (SCA) Legge 15 Aprile 1886, n. 3818 – ‘Costituzione legale delle società di mutuo soccorso’.
11.
AllioR (1980) Società di mutuo soccorso in Piemonte, 1850–1880: attività economica, gestione amministrativa, ambiente sociale. Torino: Deputazione Subalpina di Storia Patria.
12.
BakerMEadsforthC (2011) Agency reversal and the steward’s lot when discharge exceeds charge: English archival evidence, 1739–1890. Accounting History16(1): 87–109.
13.
BakerRRennieMD (2012) Accounting for a nation’s beginnings: Challenges arising from the formation of the Dominion of Canada. Accounting History17(3–4): 415–435.
14.
BakerRRennieMD (2013) An institutional perspective on the development of Canada’s first public accounts. Accounting History18(1): 31–50.
15.
Baños Sánchez-MatamorosJLópez-ManjónJDCarrasco-FenechFFunnellW (2013) Symbolic capital, accounting and caciques in local political life: The charity of Mr Rafael Tenorio (1909–20). Accounting History18(4): 491–506.
16.
BartlettMS (1954) A note on the multiplying factors for various chi square approximations. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society16(series B): 296–298.
17.
BonifaziASalvaraniG (1976) Dalla parte dei lavoratori, storia del movimento sindacale italiano. Milano: FrancoAngeli.
18.
BracciEMaranLVagnoniE (2010) Saint Anna’s Hospital in Ferrara, Italy: Accounting and organizational change during the devolution. Accounting History15(4): 463–504.
19.
CarnegieGDNapierCJ (1996) Critical and interpretive histories: Insights into accounting’s present and future through its past. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal9(3): 7–39.
20.
CarnegieGDNapierCJ (2012) Accounting’s past, present and future: The unifying power of history. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal25(2): 328–369.
21.
CatellRB (1966) The scree test for number of factors. Multivariate Behavioral Research1(2): 245–276.
22.
ChandarNMirantiPJ (2009) Integrating accounting and statistics: Forecasting, budgeting and production planning at the American Telephone and Telegraph Company during the 1920s. Accounting and Business Research39(4): 373–395.
23.
CherubiniA (1972) Storia della previdenza sociale in Italia. Roma: Editori Riuniti.
24.
CinelliM (2013) Diritto della previdenza sociale. Torino: Giappichelli.
25.
ColquhounP (2013) Political and organizational legitimacy of public sector auditing in New Zealand local government. Accounting History18(4): 473–489.
26.
CorderyCJ (2012) Funding social services: An historical analysis of responsibility for citizens’ welfare in New Zealand. Accounting History17(3–4): 463–480.
27.
CorderyCJBaskervilleRF (2007) Charity financial reporting regulation: A comparative study of the UK and New Zealand. Accounting History12(1): 7–27.
28.
Della PerrutaFMisianiSPepeA (2000) Il sindacalismo federale nella storia d’Italia. Milano: Francoangeli.
29.
Federazione Italiana delle Società di Mutuo Soccorso (1909) Manuale per società di mutuo soccorso. Milano: Tipografia Cooperativa Varesina.
30.
GardenghiG (1895) Manuale tecnico per le società di mutuo soccorso. Milano: Hoepli.
31.
Gheza-FabbriL (2000) Solidarismo in Italia fra XIX e XX secolo. Le società di mutuo soccorso e la casse rurali. Torino: Giappichelli.
32.
GobbiU (1901) Le società di mutuo soccorso. Milano: Società Editrice Libraria.
33.
GonettaG (1887) Le società di mutuo soccorso e cooperative in Europae specialmente in Italia, loro origine, scopo, utilità. Torino: Loecher.
34.
GrecoE (1916) Le società di mutuo soccorso. Torino: Unione Tipografico-Editrice Torinese.
35.
HernandezS (1972) Lezioni di storia della previdenza sociale. Padova: Cedam.
36.
HollisterJSchultzS (2010) Slavery and emancipation in rural New York: Evidence from nineteenth-century accounting records. Accounting History15(3): 371–405.
37.
HopwoodAG (1983) On trying to study accounting in the contexts in which it operates. Accounting, Organizations and Society8(2–3): 287–305.
38.
HopwoodAG (1987) The archaeology of accounting systems. Accounting, Organizations and Society12(3): 207–234.
39.
HornJL (1965) A rationale and test for the number of factors in factor analysis. Psychometrika30(2): 179–185.
40.
JacksonWJ (2012) ‘The collector will call’: Controlling philanthropy through the annual reports of the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, 1837–1856. Accounting History Review22(1): 47–72.
41.
JiXLuW (2013) The evolution of bookkeeping methods in China: A Darwinist analysis of developments during the twentieth-century. Accounting History18(3): 317–341.
42.
JonesMJ (2010) Sources of power and infrastructural conditions in medieval governmental accounting. Accounting, Organizations and Society35(1): 81–94.
43.
KaiserH (1970) A second generation Little Jiffy. Psychometrika35(4): 401–415.
44.
KaiserH (1974) An index of factorial simplicity. Psychometrika39(1): 31–36.
45.
LaiALeoniGStacchezziniR (2012) Governmentality rationales and calculative devices: The rejection of a seventeenth-century territorial barter proposed by the King of Spain. Accounting History17(3–4): 369–392.
46.
MartuscelliE (1876) Le società di mutuo soccorso. Firenze: Le Monnier.
47.
MaruccoD (1981) Mutualismo e sistema politico, il caso italiano (1862–1904). Milano: FrancoAngeli.
48.
MerliS (1972) Proletariato di fabbrica e capitalismo industriale: il caso italiano 1880–1900. Scandicci (Firenze): La Nuova Italia Editrice.
49.
MillerP (1994) Accounting as a social and institutional practice: An introduction. In: HopwoodAGMillerP (eds) Accounting as Social and Institutional Practice. Cambridge: University Press, pp.1–39.
50.
MillerPNapierC (1993) Genealogies of calculation. Accounting, Organizations and Society18(7–8): 631–647.
51.
MillerPHopperTLaughlinR (1991) The new accounting history: An introduction. Accounting, Organizations and Society16(5–6): 395–403.
52.
MussoS (1999) Tra fabbrica e società: mondi operai nell’Italia del Novecento. Milano: Feltrinelli.
53.
NapierCJ (1989) Research directions in accounting history. British Accounting Review21(3): 237–254.
54.
NapierCJ (2006) Accounts of change: 30 years of historical accounting research. Accounting, Organizations and Society31(4): 445–507.
55.
Ó hÓgartaighCÓ hÓgartaighMTysonT (2012) ‘Irish property should pay for Irish poverty’: Accounting for the poor in pre-famine Ireland. Accounting History Review22(3): 227–248.
56.
PalazzoD (1974) Le società operaie di mutuo soccorso. Mandria: Lacaita editore.
57.
PapaER (1976) Origini delle società operaie in Piemonte. Milano: Giuffrè.
58.
PernaC (1981) Breve storia del sindacato: dalle società di mutuo soccorso al patto federativo. Bari: De Donato.
59.
PessiR (2012) Lezioni di diritto della previdenza sociale. Padova: Cedam.
60.
PotterBN (2005) Accounting as a social and institutional practice: Perspectives to enrich our understanding of accounting change. Abacus41(3): 265–289.
61.
RodriguesLLSchmidtPdos SantosJLDutra FonsecaPC (2011) A research note on accounting in Brazil in the context of political, economic and social transformations, 1860–1964. Accounting History16(1): 111–123.
62.
SaporiA (1955) I precedenti della previdenza sociale. In: SaporiAStudi di Storia Economica. Firenze: Sansoni, pp.427–441.
63.
SargiacomoM (2006) Using accounting records to enhance an understanding of a seventeenth-century Italian feudal community: The case of the commune of Penne (1664–90). Accounting History11(4): 475–502.
64.
SargiacomoM (2008) Accounting and the ‘art of government’: Margaret of Austria in Abruzzo (1539–1586). European Accounting Review17(4): 667–695.
65.
SargiacomoM (2009) Accounting for ‘the good administration of justice’: The Farnese state of Abruzzo in the sixteenth century. Accounting History14(3): 235–267.
66.
SargiacomoMGomesD (2011) Accounting and accountability in local government: Contributions from accounting history research. Accounting History16(3): 253–290.
67.
SargiacomoMServalliSCarnegieGD (2012) Accounting for killing: Accountability for death. Accounting History17(3–4): 393–413.
68.
ServalliS (2013) The interface of power and charity in the government of poor: A case from the Italian context in the sixteenth–seventeenth centuries. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal26(8): 1306–1341.
69.
SivakumarKWaymireG (2003) Enforceable accounting rules and income measurement by early 20th century railroads. Journal of Accounting Research41(2): 397–432.
70.
SpenceC (2010) Accounting for the dissolution of a nation state: Scotland and the Treaty of Union. Accounting, Organizations and Society35(3): 377–392.
71.
TabachnikBGFidellLS (2007) Using Multivariate Statistics, 5th edn.Boston: Pearson Education.
72.
VermuntJKMagidsonJ (2002) Latent class cluster analysis. In: HagenaarsJAMcCutcheonAL (eds) Applied Latent Class Analysis. Cambridge: University Press, pp.89–106.
73.
VermuntJKMagidsonJ (2003a) Latent class models for classification. Computational Statistics and Data Analysis41(3): 531–537.
VernaN (2001) Società operaie di mutuo soccorso. Pescara: Ires Abruzzo Edizioni.
77.
WalkerSP (2004) Expense, social and moral control: Accounting and the administration of the old poor law in England and Wales. Journal of Accounting and Public Policy23(2): 85–127.
78.
WalkerSP (2008) Accounting, paper shadows and the stigmatised poor. Accounting, Organizations and Society33 (4–5): 453–487.
79.
XuLCorteseCZhangE (2014) Ideology diffusion and the role of accounting: A Gramscian approach to understanding China’s transition from 1949 to 1957. Accounting History19(4): 434–451.
