This article examines the development and operation of management accounting in a significant UK papermaking firm, Alex. Cowan & Sons Ltd, of Penicuik, Scotland, over a period in excess of 150 years, and is the first known study of management accounting within the UK paper industry in the academic historical literature. It explains developments in the firm’s management accounting systems in the context of internal and external factors affecting the firm and in terms of the key individuals who made changes, by means of the Systems/Contingency model. Based on the Cowan case, the authors hypothesize that management accounting across the UK papermaking industry is likely to have been well developed for a long period of time, in view of the commercial pressures under which the industry operated.
NAS, GD311/5/2, Production Records, Machine 1, 1914–1930.
10.
NAS, GD311/7/4, Miscellanea, 1884.
11.
NAS, GD311/7/69/1, Miscellanea, 1843–1857.
12.
CowanC (1878) Reminiscences. Printed for private circulation.
13.
Diary of Charles Cowan, 1832–1836, University of Guelph Library.
14.
Paper and Printing Trades Journal published from1878–1898.
15.
The Paper Maker and British Paper Trade Journal: The Independent and Practical Journal for the Paper Trade, 1900–1979.
16.
The Paper Market, 1948–1964.
17.
Paper, 1971–1993.
18.
Boog WatsonCB (1915) Alexander Cowan of Moray House and Valleyfield, His Kinsfolk and Connection. Perth: Leslie D Watson & Annandale.
19.
BoynsT (1993) Cost accounting in the South Wales coal industry, c. 1870–1913. Accounting, Business & Financial History3(3): 327–352.
20.
BoynsT (1998a) Budgets and budgetary control in British business to c1945. Accounting Business & Financial History8(3): 261–301.
21.
BoynsT (1998b) The development of costing in Britain, c.1900–c.1960. Entreprises et Histoire20: 33–66.
22.
BoynsT (2009) Accounting, information, and communication systems. In: JonesGZeitlinJ (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Business History. Oxford: University Press, pp.447–469.
23.
BoynsTEdwardsJR (1997) Cost and management accounting in early-Victorian Britain: A Chandleresque analysis. Management Accounting Research8(1): 19–46.
24.
BoynsTEdwardsJR (2007) The development of cost and management accounting in Britain. In: ChapmanCSHopwoodAGShieldsM (eds) Handbook of Management Accounting Research, Vol. 2. Oxford: Elsevier, pp.969–1035.
25.
BremnerD (1869) The Industries of Scotland: Their Rise, Progress and Present Condition. Edinburgh: David and Charles Black.
26.
Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (2005) Terminology. London: Elsevier.
27.
ColemanDC (1958) The British Paper Industry, 1495–1860: A Study in Industrial Growth. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
28.
Companies Act, 1948 (11 & 12 Geo.6c.38).
29.
DruryC (1994) Costing: An Introduction. London: Chapman & Hall.
30.
FleischmanRK (2009) Management accounting: Theory and practice. In: EdwardsJRWalkerSP (2009) The Routledge Companion to Accounting History. London and New York: Routledge, pp.189–223.
31.
FleischmanRKParkerLD (1991) British entrepreneurs and pre-industrial revolution evidence of cost management. The Accounting Review66(2): 361–75.
32.
FleischmanRKParkerLD (1997) What is Past is Prologue: Cost Accounting in the British Industrial Revolution, 1760–1850. New York & London: Garland.
33.
FleischmanRKTysonTN (1993) Cost accounting during the Industrial Revolution: The present state of historical knowledge. Economic History Review46(3): 503–517.
34.
HillsRL (1988) Papermaking in Britain, 1488–1988, A Short History. London: The Athlone Press.
35.
MacLeodAD (2011) The man who beat Macaulay: Charles Cowan, MP, and the business of the disruption. Unpublished manuscript.
36.
MageeGB (1997) Productivity and Performance in the Paper Industry: Labor Capital, and Technology in Britain and America, 1860–1914. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
37.
PollardS (1968) The Genesis of Modern Management. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
38.
OtleyDT (1980) The contingency theory of management accounting: Achievement and prognosis. Accounting, Organizations and Society5(4): 413–428.
39.
RoddickG (1950) Costing of paper manufacture. Cost Accountant28: 346–350.
40.
SpicerAD (1907) The Paper Trade: A Descriptive and Historical Survey of the Paper Trade from the Commencement of the Nineteenth Century. London: Methuen & Co.
41.
The World’s Paper Trade Review (1912) The Valleyfield Mills of Messrs Alex. Cowan & Sons Ltd., Penicuik. The World’s Paper Trade Review18(2): July12.
42.
ThomsonAG (1974) The Paper Industry in Scotland, 1590–1861. Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press.
43.
WheldonGJ (1944) Rag paper-making and esparto paper-making. In: Applied Costing in Selected Industries. London: Macdonald & Evans, pp.71–77.
