This article presents an historical study of the accounting issues and challenges arising from the creation of a new nation, the Dominion of Canada. We document the issues associated with combining the accounting of three separate pre-confederation political entities and describe how the first accounting system for Canada was put in place. The study identifies significant challenges resulting from a lack of formal accounting policies, the settling of accounts between the provinces and the new dominion, accounting for the division of responsibilities between the federal and provincial governments, and the poor quality of accounts from the former provinces. This study reveals that Canada’s first accounting system was not developed specifically for the new nation despite the creation of a new political entity, but was inherited from one of the former pre-confederation provinces.
BakerRRennieM (2006) Forces leading to the adoption of accrual accounting by the Canadian federal government: An institutional perspective. Canadian Accounting Perspectives5(1): 83–112.
2.
BallsHR (1940) John Langton and the Canadian Audit Office. Canadian Historical Review21(2): 150–176.
3.
Board of Audit (1856) Minutes of the Board of Audit, September 29, 1856. Ottawa: Archives Canada.
4.
Board of Audit (1864) Minutes of the Board of Audit, June 1, 1864. Ottawa: Archives Canada.
5.
Board of Audit (1867) Minutes of a meeting of the Board of Audit held June 25, 1867. Ottawa: Archives Canada.
6.
Board of Audit (1868) Report of the Board of Audit upon the doubtful points which arise in the settlement of accounts between the Dominion and the several provinces, Amicus ref: 10292241. Ottawa: Archives Canada.
7.
Board of Audit (1870) Memorandum, December 1870. Ottawa: Archives Canada.
8.
BookerMD (1991) Toward Financial Accountability: The Creation of the Board of Audit in Upper Canada, 1791–1864. Master of Arts (History) Thesis, Wilfred Laurier University.
BryceRB (1986) Maturing in Hard Times: Canada’s Department of Finance through the Great Depression. Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
11.
CarelessJMS (1967) The Unions of the Canadas. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart Limited.
12.
ColquhounAHU (1916) Chronicles of Canada: The Fathers of Confederation. Toronto: Glasgow, Brook & Company.
13.
CourtneyJShorttA (1914) Dominion finance, 1867–1912. In: ShorttADoughtyAG (eds) Canada and its Provinces, Volume 7. Toronto: Glasgow, Brook & Company, pp.471–514.
14.
CreightonD (1957) Dominion of the North. Toronto: MacMillan Company of Canada.
15.
CreightonD (1964) The Road to Confederation: The Emergence of Canada: 1863–1867. Toronto: MacMillan of Canada.
16.
FarrDML (2000) Rose, Sir John. In: Dictionary of Canadian Biography Online. Available at: www.biographi.ca (accessed 13 December 2010).
17.
Government of Canada (1867) Orders in Council 1867-0001 to 1867-0019. Ottawa: Archives Canada. Available at www.collectionscanada.ca
18.
Government of Canada (1868) Sessional Papers No. 2: Public Accounts of the Province of Canada for the Fiscal Year Ended 30th June, 1867. Ottawa: Government of Canada.
19.
Government of Canada (1869) Sessional Papers No. 4: Public Accounts of the Dominion of Canada for the Fiscal Year Ended 30th June 1868. Ottawa: Government of Canada.
20.
Government of Canada (1870) Sessional Papers No. 7: Public Accounts of the Dominion of Canada for the Fiscal Year Ended 30th June, 1869. Ottawa: Government of Canada.
21.
Government of Canada (1886) Public Accounts for the fiscal year ended 30th June, 1885. Ottawa: Government of Canada.
22.
Government of Canada (2010) Public Accounts of Canada 2010, Volume I, Summary Report and Financial Statements. Ottawa: Government of Canada. Available at: http://www.tpsgc-pwgsc.gc.ca/recgen/pdf/49-eng.pdf (accessed 7 December 2010).
23.
Government of New Brunswick (1867) Journal of the Legislative Council of the Province of New Brunswick, from the 11th May to the 17th June 1867, Appendix 1: Report of the Auditor General on The Public Accounts for the year 1866, Fredericton: Government of New Brunswick.
24.
Government of Nova Scotia (1867) Journal and Proceedings of the House of Assembly of the Province of Nova Scotia, Session 1867. Halifax: Government of Nova Scotia.
25.
Government of Nova Scotia (1868) Journal and Proceedings of the House of Assembly of the Province of Nova Scotia, Session 1868. Halifax: Charles Annand, Printer to the House of Assembly.
26.
HodgettsJE (1955) Pioneer Public Service: An Administrative History of the United Canada, 1841–1867. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
27.
LangtonJ (1856) Memorandum on contemplated changes with the view of facilitating the preparation of the Annual Public Accounts, in Minutes of the September 12, 1856 Meeting of the Board of Audit. Ottawa: Archives Canada.
28.
LangtonJ (1859a) Report to the Inspector General on the Public Accounts, in Minutes of the February 7, 1859 Meeting of the Board of Audit. Ottawa: Archives Canada.
29.
LangtonJ (1859b) Memorandum on the subject of the distribution of the expenditure of Public works in the Accounts, 3 November 1859. Ottawa: Archives Canada.
30.
LangtonJ (1868) Letter to Deputy Minister of Agriculture, November 17, 1868, Audit Office Correspondence. Ottawa: Library and Archives Canadareference RG58B Volume 5.
31.
LangtonWA (1926) Early Days of Upper Canada: Letters of John Langton from the Backwoods of Upper Canada and the Audit Office of the Province of Canada. Toronto: Macmillan Company of Canada.
32.
MacMullenJ (1868) The History of Canada from its First Discovery to the Present Time. Brockville: McMullen & Co.
33.
McArthurD (1914) History of public finance, 1840–1867. In: ShorttADoughtyAG (eds) Canada and its Provinces, Volume 5. Toronto: Glasgow, Brook & Company, pp.165–182.
34.
McWattersCS (1998) Accounting thought, practice and legislation: Early Canadian evidence. Accounting History3(2): 103–142.
35.
MartinG (1990) The case against Canadian confederation. In: MartinG (ed.) The Causes of Canadian Confederation. Fredericton: Acadiensis Press.
36.
PrevitsGJParkerLDCoffmanEN (1990) Accounting history: Definition and relevance. ABACUS26(1): 1–16.
37.
ReidJHSMcNaughtKCroweHS (1959) A Source-book of Canadian History: Selected Documents and Personal Papers. Toronto: Longmans Canada Limited.
38.
RoySPSpraakmanG (1996) Transaction cost economics and nineteenth century fur trade accounting: Relevance of a contemporary theory. Accounting History1(2): 55–78.
39.
SargiacomoMGomesD (2011) Accounting and accountability in local government: Contributions from accounting history research. Accounting History16(3): 253–290.
40.
SpraakmanGDavidsonR (1998) Transaction cost economics as a predictor of management accounting practices at the Hudson’s Bay Company, 1860 to 1914. Accounting History3(2): 69–101.
41.
Statutes of the Province of Canada (1855) An Act to secure the more efficient Auditing of the Public Accounts. Quebec City: Province of Canada.
42.
Statutes of the Province of Canada (1864) An Act to amend the law respecting the Public Accounts, and the Board of Audit. Quebec City: Province of Canada.
43.
Statutes of Canada (1867) 31 Victoria: An Act respecting the collection and management of the Revenue, the Auditing of Public Accounts, and the liability of Public Accountants. Ottawa: Dominion of Canada.
44.
TimsT (1868) Letter to Deputy Inspector General. In: Financial Inspector’s Letterbook – Nova Scotia. Ottawa: Library and Archives Canada, RG19 v. 3455
45.
TimsT (1869a) New Brunswick – Year Ended 30 June 1868. In: Financial Inspector’s Letterbook – New Brunswick. Ottawa: Library and Archives Canada, RG19 v 3456.
46.
TimsT (1869b) Letter to John Langton, November 9, 1869. In: Financial Inspector’s Letterbook – New Brunswick. Ottawa: Library and Archives Canada, RG19E3(a) v. 3456.
47.
TimsT (1869c) Letter to Beverley Robinson, February 4, 1869. In: Financial Inspector’s Letterbook – New Brunswick. Ottawa: Library and Archives Canada, RG19 v. 3456.
48.
WaitePB (2001) The Life and Times of Confederation 1864–1867: Politics, Newspapers and the Union of British North America. Toronto: Robin Brass Studio.
49.
WardN (1951) The Public Purse: A Study in Canadian Democracy. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
50.
WinksRW (1960) Canada and the United States: The Civil War Years. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press.
51.
WithrowWH (1878) A Popular History of the Dominion of Canada from the Discovery of America to the Present Time. Boston: B.B. Russell.
