The purpose of this study is (1) to explore how financial reporting was
practised under the condition of shareholders' effective governance that
operated in Japanese industrial firms in the pre-Second World War period and (2)
to investigate reasons why the Working Rules for Financial Statements issued in
1934 had no important impact upon financial reporting practice by examining
empirical data for the pattern of reporting adopted by 18 chemical firms. The
study demonstrates that the reason for the absence of practical impact of the
Working Rules was not simply the lack of enforcement power, as suggested in
prior studies, but that financial reporting practice was influenced by: an
extreme concealment policy founded on the unfinished separation of management
from ownership; the formation of the new business concerns in the Japanese
chemical industry; and a prolonged industrial slump in the chemical industry
during the 1920s and the early 1930s.
The minutes of meetings of the board of directors of Nippon Paint Co.,
Ltd, Vols.1, 4 (from December 1898 to May
1900) and (from June 1905 to November 1907).
Interview with Mr. Shichiro Homma,
President-Director of Fukuoka Oxygen Co., Ltd
3.
Arnold, A.J.
(1997),
"`Publishing your Private Affairs to the World': Corporate Financial
Disclosures in the UK 1900-1924"
, Accounting, Business & Financial History,
Vol.7, No.2,
pp.143-73.
4.
Arnold, A.J.
and
Matthews, D.R.
(2002),
"Corporate Financial Disclosures in the UK, 1920-50: The Effects of
Legislative Change and Managerial Discretion"
, Accounting and Business Research, Vol.32,
No.1, pp.3-16.
5.
Chiba, J.
(1987a),
"Eikoku Kaisha Kaikei Seido (1844-1885) to Wagakuni Shoki Zaimu Houkoku
Seido heno Toei" [British Company Accounting System and its Influence on the
Early Financial Reporting in Japan]
, Kaikei [Accounting], Vol.131, No.3,
pp.82-97.
6.
Chiba, J.
(1987b), "
British Company Accounting 1844-1885 and its Influence on the Modernisation
of Japanese Financial Accounting
", Economy and Economics, Tokyo Metropolitan University,
Vol.60,
pp.1-27.
7.
Chiba, J.
(1987c), "Shokosho Junsoku kara Kikakuin Junsoku (Soan) he"
[From the Working Rules by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry to the Rules
(draft) by the Planning Agency], in
Kurosawa, K.
(ed.), Wagakuni Zaimu Shohyo Seido no Ayumi [The Development of
Financial Statement System in Japan],
Tokyo: Yushodo,
pp.29-34.
8.
Chiba, J.
(1988), "Wagakuni Kindai Kaikei Seido no Ninshikizo wo meguru
Ichikosatsu" [An Inquiry into the Recognized Image of Modern Accounting System
in Japan], in
Wakasugi, A.
(ed.), Sofoto-ka Shakai to Kaikei ["Softenized" Society and
Accounting] , Tokyo: Business
Kyoiku, pp.123-40.
9.
Chiba, J.
(1992),
"`Shokosho Junsoku' no Shakaiteki Rekishiteki Kino" [The Social and
Historical Significance of the "Working Rules for Financial Statements"],
Keizai to Keizaigaku [Economy and Economics]
, Tokyo Metropolitan University, Vol.71,
pp.1-17.
10.
Chiba, J.
(1994), "Kiyoshi Kurosawa: An Intellectual Portrait", inEdwards
, J.R. (ed.),
Twentieth Century AccountingThinkers, London
:
Routledge
, pp.81-97.
11.
Chiba, J.
(1995), "
Two Aspects of Japanese External Accounting in the Socio-Historical Context
of Modernization
", Economy and Economics, Tokyo Metropolitan University,
Vol.79,
pp.1-20.
12.
Chiba, J.
(1996), "
Japanese Experience of Corporate Accounting Control c.1939-c.1945
", Accounting, Business & Financial History ,
Vol.6, No.2,
pp.163-82.
13.
Chiba, J.
(1998), Nihon Kindai Kaikei Seido: Kigyo Kaikei Taisei no
Hensen [Japan's Modern Accounting System: The Development of Business Accounting
System], Tokyo: Chuo
Keizai.
14.
Chiba, J.
(2001), "
The Designing of Corporate Accounting Law in Japan after the Second World
War
", Accounting, Business & Financial History,
Vol.11, No.3,
pp.311-30.
15.
Cooke, T.E.
(1991), "
The Evolution of Financial Reporting in Japan: A Shame Culture
Perspective
", Accounting, Business & Financial History,
Vol.1, No.3,
pp.251-77.
16.
Cooke, T.
and
Kikuya, M.
(1992), Financial Reporting in Japan: Regulation, Practice
and Environment, Oxford:
Blackwell .
17.
Dainihon Celluloid
(1981), Daiseru Kagaku Kogyo 60 Nenshi [60 Years of Dainihon
Celluloid], Osaka: Dainihon
Celluloid Co., Ltd.
18.
Dainihon Fertilizer
(1936), Dainihon Jinzo Hiryou Kabushiki Kaisha 50 Nenshi [50
Years of Dainihon Fertilizer], Tokyo:
Dainihon Fertilizer Co., Ltd.
19.
Edwards, J.R.
(1989), A History of Financial Accounting,
London:
Routledge.
20.
Fujita, Y.
(1991), An Analysis of the Development and Nature of
Accounting Principles in Japan, New York:
Garland.
21.
Hisano, H.
(1987), Wagakuni Zaimu Shohyo Seido Seiseishi no Kenkyu
[Historical Research on Practices and Regulations of the Accounts in
Japan] , Tokyo: Gakushuin
University.
22.
Hisano, H.
(1992), Kaikei Seidoshi Hikaku Kenkyu [Comparative Historical
Research on Accounting System], Tokyo:
Gakushuin University.
23.
Kansai Paint
(1979), Kansai Peinto 60 Nen no Ayumi [60 Years of Kansai
Paint], Osaka: Kansai Paint Co.,
Ltd.
24.
Katano, I.
(1968), Nihon Ginko Kaikei Seidoshi [The Development of the
System of Financial Statements in Japan],
Tokyo:
Dobunkan.
25.
Kawamoto, J.
(2001), "
The Development of the Group Accounts Disclosure System in Japan
", Accounting, Business & Financial History ,
Vol.11, No.3,
pp.331-48.
26.
Kawano, M.
(1987), "Zaimu Shohyo Junsoku no Hyoka to Eikyo", [The Impact
of the Working Rules for Financial Statements: The Evaluation], in
Kurosawa, K.
(ed.), Wagakuni Zaimu Shohyo Seido no Ayumi [The Development of
Financial Statement System in Japan],
Tokyo: Yushodo,
pp.23-8.
27.
Kikuya, M.
(2001), "
International Harmonization of Japanese Accounting Standards
", Accounting, Business & Financial History,
Vol.11, No.3,
pp.349-68.
28.
Kubota, H.
(2001), Nihongata Kaikei Seiritsushi [The Formative History
of Japanese-Styled Accounting Regulation],
Tokyo: Zeimu Keiri
Kyokai.
29.
Kurosawa, K.
(1979-80), "
Shiryo: Nihon no Kaikei Seido (1)-(16)" [Historical Materials: Accounting
System in Japan (1)-(16)]
, Kigyo Kaikei [Business Accounting],
Vols.31-2, Nos.1-4,
pp.98-101,
114-17,
146-9,
97-101,
98-101,
96-101,
74-8,
80-4,
95-100,
91-5.
30.
Kurosawa, K.
(1987), "Zaimu Shohyo Seido Hattenshi Josetsu" [Introduction
to the Development of Financial Statement System in Japan], in
Kurosawa, K.
(ed.), Wagakuni Zaimu Shohyo Seido no Ayumi [The Development of
Financial Statement System in Japan],
Tokyo: Yushodo,
pp.7-21.
31.
Kurosawa, K.
(1990), Nihon Kaikei Seido Hattatsushi [Accounting History in
Japan], Tokyo: Zaimu
Shoho.
32.
McKinnon, J.L.
(1986), The Historical Development and Operational Form of
Corporate Reporting Regulation in Japan, New
York: Garland.
33.
McKinnon, J.
(1994), "
The Historical and Social Context of the Introduction of Double Entry
Bookkeeping to Japan
", Accounting, Business & Financial History,
Vol.4, No.1,
pp.181-201.
34.
Ministry of Commerce and Industry
(1934), Zaimu Shohyo Junsoku [The Working Rules for Financial
Statements], Tokyo: The Ministry
of Commerce and Industry.
35.
Miyajima, H.
(1995), "Senmon Keieisha no Seiha: Nihongata Keieisha Kigyo
no Seiritsu" [Hegemony of Professional Managers: The Formation of Japanese
Management Styled-firms], in
Yamasaki, H.
and
Kitsukawa, T.
(eds.), "Nihonteki" Keiei no Renzoku to Danzetsu [Continuity and Change
in "Japanese" Management], Tokyo:
Iwanami,
pp.75-124.
36.
Miyajima, H.
(2004), Sangyo Seisaku to Kigyo Tochi no Keizaishi: Nihon
Keizai Hatten no Mikuro Bunseki [Economic History from the Viewpoints of
Industrial Policy and Corporate Governance: The Micro-based Analysis of the
Development of Japanese Economy], Tokyo:
Yuhikaku .
37.
Morita, H.
(1987), "Zaimu Shohyo Seidoshi no Kenkyu: Jitsurei Kenkyu -
Kabushiki Kaisha Hitachi Seisakusho" [Research on the Development of the System
of Financial Statements: An Empirical Research on Hitachi Works], in
Kurosawa, K.
(ed.), Wagakuni Zaimu Shohyo Seido no Ayumi [The Development of
Financial Statement System in Japan],
Tokyo: Yushodo,
pp.45-51.
38.
Napier, C.
(1995), "The History of Financial Reporting in the UK
", in
Walton, P.
(ed.), European Financial Reporting: A History,
London:
Academic, pp.259-83.
Nihon Oxygen
(1966), Nihon Sanso 50 Nenshi [50 Years of Nihon
Oxygen] , Tokyo: Nihon Oxygen Co.,
Ltd.
41.
Nihon Soda
(1992), Nihon Soda 70 Nenshi [70 Years of Nihon Soda] ,
Tokyo: Nihon Soda Co.,
Ltd.
42.
Nippon Paint
(1982), Nippon Peinto 100 Nenshi [100 Years of Nippon
Paint], Osaka: Nippon Paint Co.,
Ltd.
43.
Nishikawa, N.
(1992), Mitsuike Kanjo Kanken [Research in the Bookkeeping
System of the House of Mitsui: A Study of the Internal Accounting System and the
Manners of Accounting Procedures of the House of Mitsui in the Edo Era] ,
Tokyo:
Hakuto.
44.
Nobes, C.
(1998), "
Towards a General Model of the Reasons for International Differences in
Financial Reporting
", Abacus, Vol.34, No.2,
pp.162-87.
45.
Ogura, E.
(1962), Koshu Nakaike Choai no Ho [The Bookkeeping System of
the Nakai Family in Goshu Area], Kyoto:
Mineruba.
46.
Okazaki, T.
(1991), "Senji Keikaku Keizai to Kigyo" [The Wartime Planned
Economy and the Firms], in
the Institute of Social Science
(ed.), Gendai Nihon Shakai 4 Rekishiteki Zentei [Modern Japanese
Society, Vol.4, Historical Premises],
pp.363-98.
47.
Okazaki, T.
(1993), "
The Japanese Firm under the Wartime Planned Economy
", Journal of the Japanese and International Economies,
Vol.7,
pp.175-203.
48.
Okazaki, T.
(1994),
"Nihon ni okeru Corporate Governance no Hatten: Rekishiteki Perspective"
[The Development of Corporate Governance in Japan: A Historical
Perspective]
, Kinyu Kenkyu [Research on Finance], The Research Institute of
Finance, Vol.13, No.3,
pp.59-95.
49.
Okazaki, T.
,
Hamao, Y.
and
Hoshi, T.
(2005),
"Senzen Nihon ni okeru Shihon Shijo no Seisei to Hatten: Tokyo Kabushiki
Torihikijo heno Kabushiki Jojo wo Chushin toshite" [The Genesis and
Development of the Pre-war Japanese Stock Market]
, Keizai Kenkyu [Economic Research], Vol.56,
No.1,
pp.15-29.
50.
Ota, T.
(1968), Kindai Kaizei Sokumenshi: Kaikeigaku no 60 Nen
[Another Aspect of Modern Accounting: 60 Years of Accountancy],
Tokyo: Chuo
Keizai.
51.
Previts, G.J.
and
Merino, B.D.
(1998), A History of Accountancy in the United States: The
Cultural Significance of Accounting,
Columbus: Ohio State
University.
52.
Sasaki, S.
(2001), "
The Historical Significance of the Revaluation of Fixed Assets in Japan's
State-owned Railway System, 1955-6
", Accounting, Business & Financial History,
Vol.11, No.3,
pp.293-309.
53.
Someya, K.
(1989), "
Accounting `Revolutions' in Japan
", The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol.16,
No.1,
pp.75-86.
54.
Someya, K.
(1996), Japanese Accounting: A Historical Approach,
New York: Oxford
University.
55.
Takahashi, K.
(1930), Kabushiki Kaisha Bokokuron [Business Corporation
Ruining the Country], Tokyo:
Banri kaku.
56.
Takatera, S.
(1974), Meiji Genkashokyakushi no Kenkyu [A Study on the
History of Depreciation in the Meiji Era],
Kyoto:
Mineruba.
57.
Takatera, S.
and
Nishikawa, N.
(1984), "
Genesis of Divisional Management and Accounting Systems in the House of
Mitsui, 1710-1730
", The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol.11,
No.1,
pp.141-9.
58.
Toyo Ink
(1988), Toyo Inki 80 Nenshi [80 Years of Toyo Ink],
Toyo Ink Production Co., Ltd
.
59.
Toyo Oxygen
(1959), Toyo Sanso Kabushiki Kaisha 40 Nen no Ayumi [40 Years
of Toyo Oxygen Co., Ltd. 1918-1958] ,
Toyo Oxygen Co., Ltd
.
60.
Toyoshima, Y.
(2000),
"Kobe Mitsubishi Zosenjo no Kotei Shisan Syokyaku Meisaihyo to Kotei Zaisan
Hyoka Keisansho" [The Schedule of Depreciation and Reports on Appraisal of
Fixed Assets at Kobe Works of Mitsubishi Shipbuilding and Engineering Co.,
Ltd]
, Nihon Kaikeishi Gakkai Nenpo [Yearbook of Accounting History
Association], Vol.19,
pp.1-13.
61.
Udagawa, M.
(2004), Senmon Keieisha no Seiha [Hegemony of Professional
Managers], in
Yamasaki, H.
and
Japan Business History Institute
(eds.), Nihon Keieishi no Kiso Chishiki [The Foundation of Japanese
Business History] , Tokyo: Yuhi
kaku, pp.252-3.
62.
Yamaguchi, F.
(1998), Nihon Yusen Kaikeishi: Zaimu Kaikei Hen [Accounting
History of Japan Mail Steamer: Financial Accounting],
Tokyo:
Hakuto.
63.
Yamaguchi, F.
(2000), Nihon Yusen Kaikeishi: Yosan Genka Keisan Hen
[Accounting History of Japan Mail Steamer: Budget and Cost Accounting],
Tokyo:
Hakuto.
64.
Yamaguchi, F.
(2001), "
Asset Valuation and Accounting Strategy within the Japanese Shipping
Industry c.1876-c.1950
", Accounting, Business & Financial History,
Vol.11, No.3,
pp.283-92.
65.
Yamashita, T.
(1995), Mitsubishi Zosenjo no Genka Keisan: Mitsubishi
Kindaika no Kiso [Cost Accounting at Mitsubishi Shipbuilding and Engineering Co.
Ltd.: The Foundation of Modernized Mitsubishi],
Tokyo :
Sosei.
