This article is based on a plenary address presented at the fourth Accounting History
International Conference, Braga, Portugal held in September 2005. It is an extension
of earlier calls (for example Carmona, 2002; Carnegie & Potter, 2000) to
broaden research beyond those settings and periods that have so far dominated
accounting history. Using precolonial Africa as an example, the article identifies
the challenges and opportunities associated with historical research in non-western
and/or pre-industrial cultures and sites. It then goes on to illustrate some of the
conceptual breaks needed to examine the ancient Yoruba practice of the (e)susu and
identifies the potential insights that one can gain from historical research into
the “truly unfamiliar”. It concludes on a hopeful note,
suggesting that by taking accounting history research beyond the familiar settings
of Europe and the West we create the potential for profound growth in our discipline.
Annisette, M
. (2004),
“The True Nature of the World Bank: Future Possibilities for
Accounting Research”
,Critical Perspectives on Accounting,vol 15,
No.3, pp.
303–323
.
2.
Annisette, M. (2005), “From an Ancient African Tradition to a
Female-gendered Practice in the Caribbean: The Liberating Impact of the Yoruba
Practice of the (E)susu”, Working Paper, unpublished.
3.
Ardener, S
. (1964),
“The Comparative Study of Rotating Credit Associations”
,Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and
Ireland, vol 94, No.2, pp.
201–229
.
4.
Bascom, W
. (1952),
“The Esusu: A Credit Institution of Yoruba”
,Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and
Ireland, vol 82, No.1, pp.
63–69
.
5.
Bates, R.
,
Mudimbe, V.Y.
and
O'Barr, J.
(eds.), (1993),Africa and the Disciplines: The Contributions
of Research in Africa to the Social Sciences and Humanities,
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
6.
Besson, J
. (1995),“Women's Use of ROSCAs in the
Caribbean: Reassessing the Literature”, in
Ardener, S.
and
Burman, S.
(eds.),Money-Go-Rounds: The Importance of Rotating Savings and Credit
Associations for Women,
Washington, DC: Berg Oxford
, pp.263–288.
7.
Carmona, S
. (2002),“Accounting History Research and its
Diffusion in an International Context”, Universidad Carlos III
de Madrid Working Paper 01–57, Business Economics
Series No.12.
8.
Carmona, S
. (2004),
“Accounting History Research and its Diffusion in an
International Context”
,Accounting History, vol 9, No.1, pp.
7–23
.
9.
Carnegie, G.D.
and
Potter, B.N
. (2000),
“Publishing Patterns in Specialist Accounting History Journals in
the English Language”
,Accounting Historians Journal27, No.2, pp.
177–198
.
10.
Clarke, J.H
. (1964),
“The Search for Timbuctoo”
,Journal of Negro Education, vol 33,
No.2, pp.
125–130
.
11.
Dei, G.J.S
. (1992),
“The Renewal of a Ghanan Rural Economy”
,Canadian Journal of African Studies, vol 26,
No.1, pp.
24–53
.
12.
Dei, G.J.S
. (1996),
“African Development: The Relevance and Implications of Indigenousness”
, paper presented to the Learned Societies' meeting of
the Canadian Association for the Study of International Development
(CASID), Brock University, St Catharines, Ontario,
31 May–2 June.
13.
Dia,M
. (1991),
“Development and Cultural Values in Sub-Saharan Africa”
,Finance and Development, vol 28, No.4,
December, pp.
10–13
.
14.
Diop, C.A
. (1987),Pre-colonial Black Africa, trans. Harold
Salemson,
Brooklyn, NY: Lawrence Hill Books
.
15.
Evans, J.A.S
. (1991),Herodotus, Explorer of the Past: Three Essays,
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
16.
Ezzamel, M.
(2002a),
“Accounting and Redistribution: The Palace and Mortuary Cult in
the Middle Kingdom, Ancient Egypt”
,Accounting Historians Journal vol 29, No.1,
June, pp.
59–101
.
17.
Ezzamel, M.
(2002b),
“Accounting for Private Estates and the Household in the Middle
Kingdom, Ancient Egypt”
,Abacus, vol 32, No.2, pp.
235–262
.
18.
Ezzamel, M.
(2002c),
“Accounting Working for the State: Tax Assessment and Collection
During the New Kingdom,Ancient Egypt”
,Accounting and Business Research, vol 32,
No.1, pp.
17–39
.
19.
Ezzamel, M.
(2004),
“Accounting and Work Organisation in the Middle Kingdom, Ancient Egypt”
,Organization, vol 11, No.4, July, pp.
497–537
.
20.
Falola, T
. (1995), “Money and Informal Credit Institutions
in Colonial Western Nigeria”, in
Guyer, J.I.
(ed.),Money Matters: Instability Values and Social Payments in the
Modern History of West African Communities,
Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann
, pp.162–187.
21.
Falola, T.
and
Adebayo, A
. (2000),Culture Politics and Money Among the Yoruba,
New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers
.
22.
Falola, T.
and
Jennings, C.
(eds.), (2003),Sources and Methods in African History: Spoken
Written, Unearthed,
New York: University of Rochester Press
.
23.
Feierman, S
. (1993),“African Histories and the Dissolution
of World History”, in
Bates, R.H.
,
Mudimbe, V.Y.
and
O'Barr, J.
(eds.),Africa and the Disciplines: The Contributions of Research in
Africa to the Social Sciences and Humanities,
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
24.
Geertz, C
. (1962),
“The Rotating Credit Association: A ‘Middle
Rung’ in Development”
,Economic Development and Cultural Change, vol 10,
No.3, pp.
241–263
.
25.
Greenspan, A. (2002), “Testimony of Chairman Alan
Greenspan”, Federal Reserve Board's Semiannual Monetary Policy
Report to the Congress, Before the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs,
US Senate, 16 July.
26.
Hammond, T
. (1997),
“From Complete Exclusion to Minimal Inclusion: African Americans
and the Public Accounting Industry 1965–1988”
,Accounting Organizations and Society, vol 22,
No.1, pp.
29–53
.
27.
Hammond, T
. (2002),A White-CollarProfession: African American CPAs Since 1921,Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press
.
28.
Hegel, G.W.F
. (1956),Philosophy of History,
New York: Dover Publications
.
29.
Herskovits, M.J.
and
Herskovits, F.S
. (1964),Trinidad Village,
New York: Octagon Books
.
30.
Kirkham, L.
and
Loft, A
. (2001),
“The Lady and the Accounts: Missing from accounting History?”
,Accounting Historians Journal, vol 28,
No.1, pp.
67–90
.
31.
Levin, D
. (1975),
“SUSU”
,Caribbean Review, vol 11, No.1, pp.
19–23
.
32.
Lu, W.
and
Aiken, M.
(eds), (2003),
Special Issue on Chinese Accounting History
, Accounting Business and Financial History, vol 13, No.1.
33.
McBrearty, S.
and
Brooks, A
. (2000),
“The Revolution that wasn't: A New Interpretation on the
Origin of Modern Behavior”
,Journal of Human Evolution, vol 39,
No.5, pp.
453–563
.
34.
McNicholas, P.
,
Humphries, M.
and
Gallofer, S
(2004),
“Maintaining Empire: Maori’ Women's
Experiences in the Accounting Profession”
,Critical Perspectives in Accounting, vol 15,
No.1, pp.
57–93
.
35.
Mattessich, R
. (1994),
“Archaeology of Accounting and Schmandt-Basserat's Contributions”
,Accounting Business and Financial History, vol 4,
No.1, pp.
5–24
.
36.
Mattessich, R
. (2000),The Beginnings of Accounting and Accounting
Thought,
New York: Garland Publishers
.
37.
Maynard, E
. (1996),
“The Translocation of a West African Banking System: The Yoruba
ESUSU Rotating Credit Association in the Anglophone Caribbean”
,Dialectical Anthropology, vol 21, No.1, pp.
99–107
.
38.
Maywell, H
. (2003),“When did ‘Modern’
Behavior emerge in Human Beings”,National Geographic
News (20 February) (http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2003/02/0220_030220_humanorigins2.html).
39.
Miller, J.C
. (1999),
“History and Africa/Africa and History”
,American Historical Review, vol 104, No.1,
February, pp.
1–32
.
40.
Neu, D
. (2000a),
“‘Presents’ for the
‘Indians’: Land, Colonialism and Accounting in Canada”
,Accounting, Organizations and Society, vol 25,
No.2, pp.
163–184
.
41.
Neu, D
. (2000b),
“Accounting and Accountability Relations: Colonization, Genocide
and Canada's First Nations”
,Accounting,Auditing & Accountability Journal, vol
13, No.3, pp.
268–288
.
42.
Nwabughuogu,A.I
. (1984),
“The Isusu: An Institution for Capital Formation among the NGWA
IGBO; Its Origin and Development to 1951”
. Africa, vol 54, No.4, pp.
46–58
.
43.
Okafor, V.A
. (1997),
“Toward an Africological Pedagological Approach to African Civilization”
,Journal of Black Studies, vol 27, No.3, pp.
299–317
.
44.
Parker, L
. (1999),
“Historiography for the New Millennium: Adventures in Accounting
and Management”
,Accounting History, vol 4, No.2, pp.
11–42
.
45.
Preston-Blier, S
. (1993), “Truth and Seeing: Magic, Custom and
Fetish in Art History”, in
Bates, R.H.
,
Mudimbe, V.Y.
and
O'Barr, J.
(eds.),Africa and the Disciplines: The Contributions of Research in
Africa to the Social Sciences and Humanities,
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
, pp.139–166.
46.
Seibel, H.D
. (1967),
“Labor Co-operatives among the Mano”
,Liberian Studies, vol 1, No.1, pp.
47–60
.
47.
Seibel, H.D
. (2000), “Informal Finance: Origins, Evolutionary
Trends and Donor Options, Hans Dieter Seibel, Rural Finance Adviser,
International Fund for Agricultural Development
(IFAD)”,IFAD Rural Finance Working Paper
Series,No.A3, 1999, revised February 2000 (http://www.alternative-finance.org.uk/cgibin/summary.pl?id=88&language=E).
48.
Seibel, H.D
. (2001),
“Mainstreaming Informal Financial Institutions”
,Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship, vol 6,
No.1, pp.
83–95
.
49.
Sihag, B.S
. (2004),
“Kautilya on the Scope and Methodology of Accounting,
Organizational Design and the Role of Ethics in Ancient India”
,Accounting Historians Journal, vol 31,
No.2, pp.
125–148
.
50.
Smith, M.G
. (1957),
“The African Heritage in the Caribbean”
, in
Rubin, V.
(ed.), Caribbean Studies: A Symposium, Kingston and
New York: Institute of Social and Economic Research, University of the West
Indies and Research and Training Program for the Study of Man in the Tropics,
Columbia University, pp.
34–46
.
51.
Sy, A.
and
Tinker, T
. (2005),
“Archival Research and the Lost Worlds of Accounting”
, Accounting History, vol 10, No.1, pp.
47–69
.
52.
Trevor-Roper, H
. (1965),The Rise of Christian Europe.
New York: Harcourt, Brace and World
.
53.
Twitty, M.
(2000),
“The Persistence of Memory”
,Journal of Negro History,vol 85, No.3, pp.
176–182
.
54.
Walker, S.
and
Llewlyn, S
. (2000)
Accounting at Home: Some Interdisciplinary Perspectives
,Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, vol
13, No.4, pp.
425–449
.
55.
Wallace, R.S.O.
and
Briston, R
. (1993) “Improving the Accounting Infrastructure
in Developing Countries”, in
Wallace, R.S.O
,
Samuels, J.
and
Briston, R.
(eds.), Research in Third World Accounting, Vol.2,
London: JAI
.
56.
Waring, M.
(1988),If Women Counted: A New Feminist Economics,
New York: Harper & Row
.
57.
Warner-Lewis, M.
(2003),Central Africa in the Caribbean: Transcending Time,
Transforming Cultures,
Kingston, Jamaica: University of the West
Indies Press
.
58.
Wilford, J.N
. (2001),“African Artifacts Suggest and Earlier,
Modern Human”,New York Times (2 December), Section
A, p.1.
59.
Zaid, O.A
. (2004),
“Accounting Systems and Recording Procedures in the Early Islamic State”
,Accounting Historians Journal, vol 31,
No.2, pp.
149–170
.
