Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2006-5
The accounting records of the Monastery of Silos throughout the eighteenth century: the accumulation and management of its patrimony in the light of its accounts books
This article firstly presents the sophisticated bookkeeping system used by the Benedictine monks of the Monastery of Silos (Spain) during the eighteenth century, the procedures for which were set down in the Constitutions of 1701 of the Congregation of Saint Benedict of Valladolid. In the light of these regulations and the bookkeeping records that are still preserved to this day at the monastery, the activities that sustained the economic life of the monastery and led to the accumulation of its patrimony are examined. The study includes an itemized breakdown of the different types of income: capital rents, rents from land and livestock, ecclesiastical dues, and retributions for religious services. Similarly, the use made of the financial flows arising from the income is also analysed and a summary of the results is presented for the period under analysis (1694–1801), which sheds light on the role of the monastery as an administrator of its assets and its rights. Both sections lead to a set of conclusions reflecting on the contributions, attributes and functions of the accounting procedures in use at the time, as well as on the role of this institution as an economic and social agent with an interest in preserving the privileges and assets it had acquired while continuing to intervene in economic affairs.
Libro del Mayordomo: 1692–1705, 334 folios. (Cellarer's Book)
2.
Libro del Mayordomo: 1720–1731, 339 folios.
3.
Libro del Mayordomo: 1732–1741, 325 folios.
4.
Libro del Mayordomo: 1742–1753, 420 folios.
5.
Libro del Mayordomo: 1754–1769, 472 folios.
6.
Libro del Mayordomo: 1793–1809, 390 folios.
7.
Libro del Mayordomo: 1814–1824, 188 folios.
8.
Libro del Depósito: 1697–1722, 333 folios. (Deposit Book)
9.
Libro del Depósito: 1722–1742, 270 folios.
10.
Libro del Depósito: 1742–1769, 437 folios.
11.
Libro del Depósito: 1770–1803, 600 folios.
12.
Libro de Censos: 1665–1801, 132 folios. (Book of Censos)
13.
Libro de la obra de la Iglesia: 1751–1768, 178 folios. (Book of the Church Building Works)
14.
Libro de la obra de la Iglesia: 1768–1793, 256 folios. Obra Pía de D. Manuel Rojo del Río, Silos 33, folio 3. Letter from the Secretary of the Council, P. Antonio Quintanal, 25 June 1753.
15.
Libros de Consejos del Monasterio (1613–1835) (Books of the Monastery Council)
16.
Manuscript 64 (1612–1652)
17.
Manuscript 65 (1652–1730)
18.
Manuscript 66 (1730–1774)
19.
Manuscript 67 (1774–1835)
20.
Manuscript 56 (various papers)
21.
Memorial al Señor Carlos II (Memorial to Carlos II.) Document dated 13 September 1693, San Martín de Madrid (AMS, Ms. 56, f. 72–73).
22.
Manuscript 58 (various papers) Estado De Los Monasterios De La Orden Benedictina (State Of The Monasteries Of The Benedictine Order) Document dated 21 March 1743 in the Monastery of San Martín de Madrid. (AMS, Ms. 58, f. 1–40v).
23.
List of works of San Martín, nº 3
24.
Libro de Depósito 1664–1687, folios. 45–53. (Deposit Book)
25.
Libro de Actas de los Capítulos Generales (ACG) Volume I (1500–1610) and II (1613–1721)
26.
Volume 30 folios 115–333 (Book of the Minutes of the General Chapters)
27.
Constituciones de 1671 y 1701 de la Congregación de Nuestro Glorioso Padre San Benito de España e Inglaterra (Constitutions of 1671 and 1701 of the Congregation of our Glorious Father Saint Benedict of Spain and England), printed in Madrid.
28.
Additions to the Constitutions of 1701 approved in the General Chapters between 1701 and 1789.
29.
Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal (2004), Special Issue on “Theological Perspectives on Accounting” , Vol. 17, No. 3.
30.
Barnabè, F. and Ruggiero, P. (2004), “Contabilità e controllo in un Ente monastico: Monte Oliveto Maggiore nel XIX secolo” , Contabilità e Cultura Aziendale, Vol.4, No.2, pp. 211–214 .
31.
Booth, P. (1993), “Accounting in Churches: A Research Framework and Agenda” , Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, Vol.6, No.4, pp. 37–67 .
32.
Boyns, T. and Carmona, S. (2002), “Accounting History Research in Spain, 1996–2001: An Introduction” , Accounting, Business & Financial History, Vol.12, No. 2 pp. 149–155
33.
Busto Marroquín, B. (1991), La Universidad de Valladolid en el s. XVIII a través de sus cuentas, Madrid: ICAC, Ministerio de Economía y Hacienda.
34.
Calvo Cruz, M. (1999), “La Contabilidad de los Espolios y las Vacantes: el caso de la Diócesis de ‘Canaria’ 1753–1851”. Doctoral thesis, University of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria.
35.
Caro López, C. (1998), El Patrimonio de los Regulares Madrileños en los Siglos XVII y XVIII. Hispania Sacra. Año 50. July–December, pp.509–50.
36.
Carmona, S. , Ezzamel, M. and Gutiérrez, F. (1997), “Control and Cost Accounting Practices in the Spanish Royal Tobacco Factory” , Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.22, No.5, pp. 411–445 .
37.
Castro Pérez, C. (2005), “La institución parroquial a través de los registros contables del señorío episcopal de la villa de Agüimes (1500–1860)”. Doctoral Thesis, University of Las Palmas.
38.
Domínguez Ortiz, A. (1992), La Sociedad Española en el siglo XVII. Granada: CSIC.
39.
Duncan, J.B. , Flesher, D.L. and Stocks, M.H. (1999), “Internal Control Systems in US Churches: an Examination of the Effects of Church Size and Denomination on Systems of Internal Control” , Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, Vol.12, No.2, pp. 142–164 .
40.
Duncan, J.B. , Flesher, D.L. (2002), “Does your church have appropriate internal control for cash receipts? (Statistical Data Included)” , The National Public Accountant, February, pp. 15–19 .
41.
Duncan, J.B. and Stocks, M.H. (2003), “The Understanding of Internal Control Principles by Pastors” , Nonprofit Management and Leadership, Vol.14, No. 2, pp. 213–225 .
42.
Edwards, J.R. and Newell, E. (1991), “The Development of Industrial Cost and Management Accounting before 1850: A Survey of the Evidence” , Business History, Vol.33, No.1, pp. 35–57 .
43.
Fernández de Pinedo, E. (1985), “Del Censo a la Obligación” in Historia Agraria de la España Contemporánea, pp.279–309. Barcelona: Crítica.
44.
Flesher, T.K. and Flesher, D.L. (1979), “Managerial Accounting in an Early 19th Century German-American Religious Commune” , Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.4, No.4, pp. 297–304 .
45.
Fleischman, R. and Parker, L. (1991), “British Entrepreneurs and Pre-Industrial Revolution Evidence of Cost Management” , The Accounting Review, Vol. 66, No.2, pp. 361–375 .
46.
Fleischman, R. , Kalbers, L. , and Parker, L. (1996), “Expanding the Dialogue: Industrial Revolution Costing Historiography” , Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol. 7, No.3, 315–337 .
47.
Flori, L. (1636), Trattato del modo di tenere il libro doppio domestico col suo esemplare, ecc., Palermo. In Giuseppe Cerboni (1889), Elenco cronologico delle opere di computisteria e ragioneria venute alla luce in Italia dal 1202 sino al 1888, Rome: Ed.Tipografia Nazionale di Reggiani e soci, p.54.
48.
Fonfeder, R. , Holtzman, M.P. , and Maccarrone, E. (2003), “Internal controls in the Talmud: The Jerusalem Temple” , The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol.30, No.1, pp. 73–93 .
49.
Futcher, T. and Phillips, T. (1986), “Church Budgeting: A Secular Approach” , The National Public Accountant, September, pp. 28–30 .
50.
González Ferrando, J.M. (1988), “De las tres formas de llevar cuenta y razón según el licenciado Diego del Castillo, natural de Molina”, in Revista Española de Financiación y Contabilidad. Vol. XVIII, No. 55, January–April, pp.183–222.
51.
González Ferrando, J.M. (1996), Panorama histórico de las fuentes de la Historia de la Contabilidad en España, siglos XII (España cristiana) al XVIII. In En torno a la elaboración de una Historia de la Contabilidad, pp.191–296. AECA.
52.
Grady, P. (1957), “The Broader Concept of Internal Control” , The Journal of Accountancy, Vol.103, No.5, pp. 36–41 .
53.
Gutierrez, F. , Larrinaga, C. and Núñez, M. (2005), “Management Accounting in the 18th Century: A Cross-Section Study in Spain” , Accounting Historian Journal, Vol.23, no.1, pp. 111–148 .
54.
Harper, B. and Harper, P. (1988), “Religious Reporting: Is It the Gospel Truth?”Management Accounting, February, pp.34–39.
55.
Hernández Borreguero, J.J. (2002), “El Cabildo catedral de Sevilla: Organización y sistema contable (1625–1650)”, doctoral thesis, University of Seville.
56.
Hernández Esteve, E. (1996), “Merchants Organizations and Accounting Regulations in Eighteenth-Century Spain: The Ordinances of the Tribunal of Commerce of Bilbao” , Accounting, Business and Financial Research, Vol.6, No.3, pp. 277–299 .
57.
Hernández Esteve, E. (1998), “Las contadurías de libros de la Contaduría Mayor de Hacienda y la contabilidad de cargo y data en la gestión del Imperio Español (siglos XV al XVII)”, II Encuentro de Trabajo, Seville: AECA. Mairena del Aljarafe.
58.
Jouanique, P. (1996), “Propuesta de Elaboración de una Historia General de la Contabilidad”, in En torno a la elaboración de una Historia de la Contabilidad, pp.31–43, Madrid: AECA.
59.
Landi, F. (1999), “The Great Estates of the Regular Male Clergy: Distinctive Characteristic of a Managerial and Accounting System”, in Landi, F. (ed.), Accumulation and Dissolution of Large Estates of the Regular Clergy in Early Modern Europe, Rimini: Guaraldi , pp.267–279.
60.
Lightbody, M. (2000), “Storing and Shielding: Financial Management Behaviour in a Church Organization” , Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal, Vol. 13, No. 2, pp. 156–174 .
61.
Lillo Criado, J.L. (2004), “Personas, técnicas y cambios contables en la Santa Capilla de San Andrés de Jaén (1650–1900)”, doctoral thesis, University of Jaen.
62.
Llopis, E. , Fidalgo, E & Méndez, M.T. (2002), “The ‘Hojas de ganado’ of the Monastery of Guadalupe, 1597–1784: An Accounting Instrument for Fundamental Economic Decisions” , Accounting, Business & Financial History (ABFH), Vol.12, No.2, pp. 203–229 .
63.
López Manjón, J. D. (2004), Contabilidad Señorial en España: Estudio de la Casa Ducal de Osuna desde un Enfoque Interdisciplinario, doctoral thesis, University Pablo de Olavide de Sevilla.
64.
Marcos Martín, A. (1992), “En torno al significado del crédito privado en Castilla La Vieja en la Edad Moderna: Los Censos Consignativos del Hospital de San Antolín de Palencia”. pp.193–217. In De esclavos a señores. Estudios de Historia Moderna. University of Valladolid.
65.
Martín Riego, M. (1991), Diezmos eclesiásticos. Rentas y Gastos de la Mesa Arzobispal Hispalense (1750–1800). Gráficas del Sur. Seville.
66.
Napier, C.J. (1991), Aristocratic accounting: the Bute estate in Glamorgan 1814–1880, Accounting and Business Research, Spring, pp.163–174.
67.
Oliveira, J.M. (2003), A Contabilidade do Mosteiro de Arouca: 1786–1825, doctoral thesis, Faculty of Economy, University of Porto.
68.
Pezzi, E. (1993), Libro de Cuentas del Convento Franciscano de Cuevas de Almanzora (1670–1693). Unicaja, Almería.
69.
Pietra, A. (1586), Indirizzo degri Economi. Mantua.
70.
Prieto, B. and Larrinaga, C. (2001), “Cost Accounting in Eighteenth Century Spain: the Royal textile Factory of Ezcaray” , Accounting History, Vol.6, No.2, pp. 59–90 .
71.
Quattrone, P. (2004), “Accounting for God. Accounting and Accountability Practices in the Society of Jesus (Italy, 16th-17th centuries)” , Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.29, No.7, pp. 647–683 .
72.
Ramos, C. Rivero, D. and Gallego, E. (2005), La rendición de cuentas en la Orden del Cister de Castilla: El Libro de Estados del Monasterio de Oseira (1614–1832). Revista De Computis, pp.181–98.
73.
Rodríguez Molina, J. (2004), “Patrimonio y rentas de la Iglesia en Andalucía”, in Confische e sviluppo capitalistico. I grandi patrimoni del clero regolare in età moderna in Europa e nel continente Americano, Milano: Temi di Storia Franco Angeli, pp.235–66.
74.
Villaluenga de Gracia, S. (2004), “La catedral de Toledo en la primera mitad del siglo XVI: organización administrativa, rentas y contabilidad”, doctoral thesis, University of Castilla-La Mancha.
75.
Yamey, B. (1996), “Historia de la Contabilidad. Un inventario”, In En torno a la elaboración de una Historia de la Contabilidad, AECA. Madrid, pp.13–30.
