This paper takes the contemporary audit expectations gap and seeks to establish its
place in the commercial dynamics of late-Victorian England. The gap(s) in this paper
relate to the views on audit-practice expectations as differentially articulated by
the judiciary and audit practitioners. A paucity of codified guidelines on audit
expectations either in statute or by the profession provided the ultimate imperative
for consideration of expectations when the nascent profession was struggling to
establish its place in the market. Through an extensive review of judicial decisions
and the extant professional and academic literature, the paper demonstrates that a
significant inconsistency of views existed on the bench and within the profession,
causing a disjoint between the bench and the profession. As the nineteenth century
drew to a close, it became clear to the profession that it needed to address the
lack of guidance on expectations before judicial activism completed the task for them.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants
, (1978), Commission on Auditor's Responsibilities: Report,
Conclusions and Recommendations, (Cohen Commission).
2.
Andrews v Hawley [1857] 26 LJ Ex 323.
3.
Arnold v Armitage [1885] 1 TLR 670.
4.
Ashworth, H.M.
, (1885), "Some Safeguards Against Fraud",
The Accountant, 4 July, pp.7-11.
5.
Baikie v Chandless [1811] 3 Camp 17.
6.
Baker, C.
, (1993),
"Self-Regulation in the Public Accounting Profession: The Structural
Response of the Large Public Accounting Firms to a Changing Environment"
, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal,
Vol.6, No.2, pp.
68-80
.
7.
Baxt, R.
, (1987), Auditors and Accountants: Their Role, Liabilities
and Duties, third edition,
North Ryde, Sydney: CCH Australia
.
8.
Bender, L.
, (1988),
"A Lawyer's Primer on Feminist Theory and Tort"
, Journal of Legal Education, Vol.38, pp.
3-38
.
9.
Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 2 All ER 118.
10.
Bowen v Paramount Builders (Hamilton) Ltd [1977] 1 NZLR 394.
11.
Brown, R.
, (1905), A History of Accounting and Accountants,
London: Frank Cass & Co.
12.
Burchell, S.
,
Clubb, C.
,
Hopwood, A.
,
Hughes, J.
and
Nahapiet, J.
, (1980),
"The Roles of Accounting in Organizations and Society"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.5,
No.1, pp.
5-27
.
13.
Chadwick, D.
, (1883), "Auditors", The Accountant,
29 September, pp.8-10.
14.
Chandler, R.
and
Edwards, J.
(eds.), (1994a), Recurring Issues in Auditing: Professional
Debate 1875-1900,
London: Garland
.
15.
Chandler, R.
and
Edwards, J.
(eds.), (1994b), British Audit Practice 1884-1900; A Case Law
Perspective,
London: Garland
.
16.
Chandler, R.
, (1997),
"Judicial Views on Auditing from the Nineteenth Century"
, Accounting History, NS Vol.2, No.1, pp.
61-80
.
17.
Chandler, R.
,
Edwards, J.
and
Anderson, M.
, (1993),
"Changing Perceptions of the Role of the Company Auditor, 1840-1940"
, Accounting and Business Research, Vol.23,
No.92, pp.
443-459
.
18.
"Checking of Stock", (1896), The Accountant,
30 May, pp.441-443.
19.
Chisholm, R.
and
Nettheim, G.
, (1992), Understanding Law: An Introduction to Australia's
Legal System, fourth edition,
Sydney: Butterworths
.
20.
Chow, C.
,
Kramer, L.
and
Wallace, W.
, (1988), "The Environment of Auditing" in
Abdel-Khalik, A.R.
and
Solomon, I.
(eds.), Research Opportunities in Auditing: The Second Debate,
Sarasota, Florida: American Accounting Association
, pp.155-183.
21.
Clark, G.K.
, (1973), The Making of Victorian England,
London: Methuen and Co.
22.
Clarke v Adams [1950] 94 Sol Jo 599.
23.
Coles v Reading and District Hospital Management Committee [1963] 107 Sol
Jo 115.
24.
Corbett, A.
, (1994),
"The Rationale for the Recovery of Economic Loss in Negligence and the
Problem of Auditors' Liability"
, Melbourne University Law Review, Vol.19,
No.4, pp.
814-867
.
25.
Cork Mutual Benefit Terminable Society v Atkins, Chirnside and Co. [1911]
45 Acct LR 13.
26.
Cotterrell, R.
, (1989), The Politics of Jurisprudence: A Critical
Introduction to Legal Philosophy,
London: Butterworths
.
27.
D Connell v The Himalaya Bank Ltd [1895] ILR 16-18 All 712.
28.
Daniels v Heskin [1954] IR 73.
29.
Dicksee, L.
, (1892), Auditing: A Practical Manual for Auditors,
London: Gee
.
30.
DiMaggio, P.
and
Powell, W.
, (1983),
"The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective
Rationality in Organizational Fields"
, American Sociological Review, Vol.48,
No.2, pp.
147-160
.
31.
Dugdale, A.
and
Stanton, K.
, (1982), Professional Negligence,
London: Butterworths
.
32.
Duman, D.
, (1982), The Judicial Bench in England 1727-1875: The
Re-shaping of a Professional Elite,
London: Royal Historical Society
.
"Editorial", (1879), The Accountant, 26
April, p.2-2.
35.
"Editorial", (1879), The Accountant, 17 May, p.3-3.
36.
Field v Independent Mutual Brethren Society [1885] 11 Acct LR 13.
37.
Financial Times
, "The Liabilities of Auditors", reproduced in The
Accountant, 6 June 1896, pp.478-479.
38.
Fletcher and Son v Jubb, Booth and Helliwell [1920] 1 KB 275.
39.
Fomento (Stirling Area) Ltd v Selsdon Fountain Pen Co. Ltd [1958] 1 All ER 11.
40.
Forrester, D.
, (1980),
"Early Canal Company Accounts: Financial and Accounting Aspects of the
Forth and Clyde Navigation, 1786-1816"
, Accounting and Business Research, Vol.10,
No.37A, pp.
109-123
.
41.
Forster, P.
, (1985),
"Fraud and the Auditor: No Bloodhounds, Please!"
, The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.56,
No.2, pp.
60-63
.
42.
Foster v Newnes [1894] 20 Acct LR 105.
43.
Furniss v Fitchett [1958] NZLR 396.
44.
Galoo v Bright Grahame Murray [1994] 2 WLR 1360.
45.
Gill, G.
and
Cosserat, G.
, (1996), Modern Auditing in Australia, fourth
edition,
Sydney: John Wiley and Sons
.
46.
Glautier, M.
, (1983),
"Searching for Accounting Paradigms"
, The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol.10,
No. 1, pp.
51-68
.
47.
Godefroy v Dalton [1830] 6 Bing 460.
48.
Godsell, D.
, (1990), Auditors' Legal Duties and Liabilities in
Australia,
Caulfield, Victoria: Australian Accounting
Research Foundation
.
49.
Goodrich, P.
, (1986), Reading the Law: A Critical Introduction to Legal
Method and Techniques,
Oxford: Blackwell
.
50.
Grace, Derbyshire
and
Todd
, (1957), A Short History of Grace, Derbyshire and Todd,
Chartered Accountants of Bristol, 1818-1957,
Bristol: Grace, Derbyshire and Todd
.
51.
Griffiths, J.
, (1885), "Accountants and the Public", The
Accountant, 26 December, p.8-8.
52.
Guardian Insurance Co. Ltd v Sharp [1941] 2 DLR 417.
53.
Gwilliam, D.
, (1988),
"Reasonable Skill and Care: The Interpretation of the Courts"
, The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.58,
No.7, pp.
52-53
.
54.
Halushka v University of Saskatchewan [1965] 53 DLR (2d) 436.
55.
Harmood-Banner, J.
, (1894), "The True Meaning of an Audit", The
Accountant, 27 October, p.938-938.
56.
Hart and Hodge v Frame Son & Co. [1838] 6 Cl & Fin 193.
57.
Hart, H.L.A.
, (1988), The Concept of Law,
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
58.
Henry Squire, Cash Chemist Ltd v Ball Baker & Co. [1912] 106 LT 197.
59.
Hopwood, A.
, (1983),
"On Trying to Study Accounting in the Contexts in Which it Operates"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.8,
No.2/3, pp.
287-305
.
60.
Hopwood, A.
, (1987),
"The Archaeology of Accounting Systems"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.12,
No.3, pp.
207-234
.
61.
Howse v Priagula [1977] 78 DLR (3d) 596.
62.
Hunt, B.
, (1953),
"Auditor Independence"
, The Journal of Accountancy, Vol.59, June, p.
453-453
.
63.
Hutchinson, A.
, (1988), Dwelling on the Threshold,
London: Sweet & Maxwell
.
64.
Hutton, G.J.
, (1889), "On Auditing Commercial and Company
Books", The Accountant, 26 November,
pp.562-564; continued 23 November, pp.613-5.
65.
In re Alexandra Palace Co. [1882] 21 Ch D 149.
66.
In re City Equitable Fire Insurance Co. Ltd [1925] 1 Ch 407.
67.
In re Exchange Banking Co. [1882] 21 Ch D 519.
68.
In re Joseph Hargreaves Ltd [1900] 1 Ch 347.
69.
In re Kingston Cotton Mill Co. (No 2) [1895] 1 Ch 331.
70.
In re Kingston Cotton Mill (No 2) [1896] 2 Ch 279.
71.
In re London and General Bank [1895] 1 Ch 331.
72.
In re London and General Bank (No 2) [1896] 2 Ch 673.
73.
In re New Oriental Bank Corporation [1892] 18 Acct LR 166.
74.
In re Republic of Bolivia Exploration Syndicate Ltd [1914] 1 Ch 139.
75.
In re S P Catterson & Sons Ltd [1937] 81 Acct LR 62.
76.
In re The Liberator Permanent Benefit Building Society [1893] 19 Acct LR 73.
77.
In re The Royal British Bank (Nicol's Case) [1859] 3 De G & J 387.
78.
In re The West London and General Permanent Building Society [ 1894] 20
Acct LR 79.
79.
In re Thomas Gerrard & Son Ltd [1967] 2 All ER 525.
80.
In re Townsend (The Portsea Building Society) [ 1894] 20 Acct LR 79.
81.
Ingleby, R.
and
Johnstone, R.
, (1995), "Judicial Decision Making" in
Hunter R.
,
Ingleby, R.
and
Johnstone, R.
(eds.), Thinking About Law: Perspectives on the History, Philosophy and
Sociology of Law,
St Leonards, NSW: Allen and Unwin
, pp.174-188.
82.
Inns v D Miles Griffiths, Piercy & Co. [1980] 255 Estates Gazette 623.
83.
International Laboratories Ltd v Dewar [1933] 3 DLR 665.-
84.
Irish Woollen Company, Lim. v Tyson [1900] 25 Acct LR 89.
85.
Irish Woollen Company, Lim. v Tyson [1900] 26 Acct LR 13.
86.
J and J C Abrams Ltd v Ancliffe [1978] 2 NZLR 420.
87.
Jackson, R.
and
Powell, J.
, (1997), Jackson & Powell on Professional
Negligence, fourth edition,
London: Sweet and Maxwell
.
88.
Johnson, T.
, (1977), "The Professions in the Class Structure"
in
Scase, R.
(ed.), Industrial Society: Class, Cleavage and Control,
London: Allen and Unwin
, pp.93-110.
89.
Kemp v Horton [1895] 21 Acct LR 93.
90.
Kenny v Lockwood [1932] 1 DLR 507.
91.
Lancashire, C.
, (1896), "The Kingston Mills Judgment: Liabilities of
Auditors", The Accountant, 4 January, p.10-10.
92.
Lanphier v Phipos [1838] 8 C & P 475.
93.
Lee, T.A.
, (1979), "A Brief History of Company Audits:
1840-1940" in
Lee, T.
and
Parker, R.
(eds.), The Evolution of Corporate Financial Reporting,
Sunbury-on-Thames: Nelson
, pp. 153-163.
94.
Lee, T.A.
, (1986), Company Auditing, third edition,
Melbourne: Nelson
.
95.
Leeds Estate, Building and Investment Co. v Shepherd [1887] 36 Ch D 787.
96.
Levy v Spyres [1856] 1 F & F 3.
97.
Liggio, C.D.
, (1974),
"The Expectation Gap: The Accountant's Legal Waterloo?"
, Journal of Contemporary Business, Summer, pp.
27-44
.
98.
Lister Lea and Son v Wenham Bros [1884] 10 Acct LR 11.
99.
Littleton, A.
, (1981), Accounting Evolution to 1900,
Alabama: University of Alabama Press
.
100.
Lloyds Bank Ltd v E B Savory & Co. [1933] AC 201.
101.
Lobban, M.
, (1996),
"Nineteenth Century Frauds in Company Formation: Derry v Peek in Context"
, The Law Quarterly Review, No.112, pp.
287-334
.
102.
Loft, A.
, (1986),
"Towards a Critical Understanding of Accounting: The Case of Cost
Accounting in the UK, 1914-1925"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.11,
No.2, pp.
137-170
.
103.
M E Kane Agencies Ltd v Coopers & Lybrand [1985] 17 DLR 695.
104.
MacCormick, N.
, (1978), Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory,
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
105.
Male v Hopmans [1967] 64 DLR (2d) 105.
106.
Mather, J.
, (1896), "The Present Position of Accountancy in View of
Recent Legal Decisions", The Accountant, 21 March, pp.238-239.
107.
McLachlan, P.
, (1985),
"Auditor's Duty to Detect Fraud"
, The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.55,
No. 11, pp.
44-46
.
108.
Menon, K.
and
Williams, D.D.
, (1994),
"The Insurance Hypothesis and Market Prices"
, The Accounting Review, Vol.69, No.2,
April, pp.
327-342
.
109.
Merrett Wade, J.
, (1894), "An Auditor's Duties", The
Accountant, 23 June, pp.574-576.
110.
Miller, P.
and
O'Leary, T.
, (1987),
"Accounting and the Construction of the Governable Person"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.12,
No.3, pp.
235-266
.
111.
Miller, P.
, (1986),
"Accounting for Progress-National Accounting and Planning in France: A
Review Essay"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.11,
No.1, pp.
83-104
.
112.
Miller, P.
, (1990),
"On the Interrelations Between Accounting and the State"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.15,
No.4, pp.
315-340
.
113.
Miller, P.
and
Napier, C.
, (1993),
"Genealogies of Calculation"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.18,
No.7-8, pp.
631-648
.
114.
Miller, P.
,
Hopper, T.
and
Laughlin, R.
, (1991),
"The New Accounting History: An Introduction"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.16,
No.5/6, pp.
395-404
.
115.
Mills, M.
, (1990),
"The Expectation Gap and Auditors' Responsibilities"
, University of Western Australia Law Review,
Vol.20, No.3, pp.
538-572
.
116.
Murray, A.
, (1896), in "The Present Position of Accountancy in View
of Recent Legal Decisions", The Accountant, 21 March, p.238-238.
117.
Murray Bourne Dyck v F MA Farm Management Associates Ltd [1996] 3 WWR 509.
118.
Naime, W.
, (1896), in "The Present Position of Accountancy in View
of Recent Legal Decisions', The Accountant, 21 March, pp.228-253.
119.
Nairne, W.
, (1889), "An Address", The Accountant,
23 November, pp.626-630.
120.
Napier, C.
, (1989),
"Research Directions in Accounting History"
, British Accounting Review, Vol.21,
No.3, pp.
237-254
.
121.
Neilson v James [1882) 9 QBD 546.
122.
Nelson Guarantee Corporation v Hodgson [1958] NZLR 609.
123.
Neu, D.
, (1991),
"Trust, Impression Management and the Public Accounting Profession"
, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol.2,
No.3, pp.
295-313
.
124.
New Plymouth Borough v R [1951] NZLR 49.
125.
Ormindale Holdings Ltd v Ray, Wolfe, Connel, Lightbody and Reynolds [1981]
116 DLR.
Pasewark, W.
,
Shockley, R.
and
Wilkerson, J. Jr.
, (1995),
"Legitimacy Claims of the Auditing Profession vis-a-vis the Behaviour of
Its Members: An Empirical Examination"
, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol.6,
No. 1, pp.
77-94
.
128.
Pendelbury's Ltd v Ellis Green & Co. [1936] 80 Acct LR 39.
129.
Perkin. H.
, (1989), The Role of Professional Society: England Since
1880,
London and New York: Routledge
.
130.
Pixley, F.
, (1881), Auditors: Their Duties and Responsibilities under
the Joint-Stock Companies and the Friendly Societies and Industrial and
Provident Societies Acts, second edition,
London: Effingham Wilson
.
131.
Pixley, F.
, (1883), "Auditing: Address to the Chartered Accountants
Student Society", The Accountant, 26 May, pp.6-10.
132.
Porter, B.
, (1993),
"An Empirical Study of the Audit Expectation-Performance Gap"
, Accounting and Business Research, Vol.24No.93, pp.
49-68
.
133.
Price, H.
, (1896), "An Auditor's Duties and
Responsibilities", The Accountant, 18 July, pp.611-615.
134.
Price, H.
, (1896a), in "The Present Position of Accountancy in View
of Recent Legal Decisions", The Accountant, 21 March, pp.241-242.
135.
Rehaag, G.
, (1994), The Limited Company: Replacing the Victorian Steam
Engine,
Aldershot: Avebury
.
136.
Revelstoke Credit Union v Miller [1984] 28 CCLT 17.
137.
Robb, G.
, (1992), White Collar Crime in Modern England,
Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press
.
138.
Robson, K.
and
Cooper, D.
, (1990), "Understanding the Development of the Accountancy
Profession in the United Kingdom", in
Cooper, D.
and
Hopper, T.
(eds.), Critical Accounts,
London: Macmillan
, pp.366-390.
139.
Ross and Co. v Wright, Fitzgibbons and Mayes [1896] 22 Acct LR 105.
140.
Schultz and Comins v Carlton Bank Ltd [1899] 25 Acct LR 53.
141.
Schwartz, K.
and
Menon, K.
, (1985),
"Auditor Switches by Failing Firms"
, The Accounting Review, Vol.LX, No.2,
April, pp.
248-261
.
142.
Sedley, S.
, (1999), "In Judges' Lodgings", London
Review of Books, 11 November, p.37-37.
143.
Shannon, H.A.
, (1933),
"The Limited Companies of 1866-83"
, Economic History Review, Vol.IV, October, pp.
290-316
.
144.
Smith v Auckland Hospital Board [1964] NZLR 241.
145.
Spackman v Evans [1868] 3 LR 171.
146.
Spicer, E.
and
Pegler, E.
, (1911), Practical Auditing, second edition,
London: H. Foulks Lynch and Co.
147.
Stevenson v Rowland [1830] 2 Dow & Cl 104.
148.
Stewart, R.
, (1992),
"Pluralizing Our Past: Foucault in Accounting History"
, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal,
Vol.5, No.2, pp.
57-73
.
149.
"The Duties and Responsibilities of Auditors", (1899),
The Accountant, 18 November, pp.1121-1122.
150.
"The Liabilities of Auditors", (1896), The
Accountant, 29 August, pp.705-707.
151.
"The Liability of Auditors: The Kingston Cotton Mill Case",
(1896), The Accountant, 11 January, pp.23-26.
152.
"The Liability of Auditors: The Kingston Cotton Mill Case",
(1896), The Accountant, 6 June, pp.458-460.
153.
"The Valuation of Stock-in-Trade: The Kingston Cotton Mill Case",
(1896), The Accountant, 25 January, pp.57-59.
154.
Tinker, T.
, (1985), Paper Prophets: A Social Critique of
Accounting,
New York: Praeger
.
155.
Todd, G.
, (1932-1933),
"Some Aspects of Joint Stock Companies: 1844-1900"
, Economic History Review, Vol.IV, pp.
46-71
.
156.
Trevor, C.R.
, (1889), "Auditing", The Accountant, 7
December, pp.658-663.
157.
Trevor v Whitworth [1887] 12 App Cass 409.
158.
Trustee of the Property of Blue Band Navigation Co Ltd v Price Waterhouse
& Co. (No 2) [1933] 3 DLR 53.
159.
United Kingdom
, (1850), Report of the Select Committee on Official
Salaries, House of Commons, (611), vii.
160.
United Kingdom
, (1849), Report of the House of Lords Select Committee on the
Audit of Railway Accounts (BPP 469).
161.
United Kingdom
, (1852), Report of the Select Committee on Evidence
Associations (BPP 1852/2).
162.
United Kingdom
, (1850), Report on Judges' Salaries, House of Commons,
pp.XXXIII-XXXIII, passum.
163.
Van De Linde, G.
, (1885), "The Preparation and Audit of Income and
Expenditure Accounts", The Accountant, 25 April, pp.7-10.
164.
Wallace, W.
, (1987),
"The Economic Role of the Audit in Free and Regulated Markets: A Review"
, Research in Accounting Regulation, Vol.1, pp.
7-34
.
165.
Watts, R.
and
Zimmerman, J.
, (1983),
"Agency Problems, Auditing and the Theory of the Firm: Some Evidence"
, Journal of Law and Economics, Vol.XXVI, No., pp.
613-634
.
166.
Welton, T.A.
, (1883), "Auditors: Their Duties and
Responsibilities", The Accountant, 3 November, pp.17-18.
167.
Westmoreland v Watson [1895] 21 Acct LR 45.
168.
Whinney, F.
, (1888), "Some Remarks on the Companies Acts",
The Accountant, 27 October, pp.691-696.
169.
Whinney, F.
, (1891), "Audits and Certificates", The
Accountant, 28 October, p.836-836.
170.
Whitehouse v Jordan [1981] 1 All ER 267.
171.
Whittingham v Crease & Co. [1978] 88 DLR (3d) 353.
172.
Wilmott, H.
, (1986),
"Organising the Profession: A Theoretical and Historical Examination of the
Development of the Major Accountancy Bodies in the UK"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.11,
No.6, pp.
555-582
.
173.
Wilson, J.F.
, (1995), British Business History,
Manchester: Manchester University Press
.
174.
Wood, D.
,
Hunter, R.
and
Ingleby, R.
, (1995), "Themes in Liberal Legal and Constitutional
Theory" in
Hunter, R.
,
Ingleby, R.
and
Johnstone, R.
(eds.), Thinking About Law: Perspectives on the History, Philosophy and
Sociology of Law,
St. Leonards, NSW: Allen and Unwin
, pp.41-60.
175.
Yamey, B.
, (1962), "The Case Law Relating to Company
Dividends" in
Baxter, W.
and
Davidson, S.
(eds.), Studies in Accounting Theory, second edition,
London: Sweet and Maxwell
, pp.428-442.
