Theorising professionalisation: a model for organising and understanding histories of the professionalising activities of occupational associations of accountants
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online March, 2005
Theorising professionalisation: a model for organising and understanding histories of the professionalising activities of occupational associations of accountants
This paper seeks to develop a theoretical model of professionalisation and
professionalism built on notions of conditions, dependencies and strategies in
relation to occupational associations. These notions are found in a fragmentary
way in the general professionalisation literature, as well as in the literature
pertaining to the professionalisation of accounting. This way of organising
processes of professionalisation can enhance understanding of histories of the
professionalising activities of occupational associations of accountants by
highlighting complementary and mutually supporting findings as well as
identifying contradictions that remain in need of resolution. The model
structures conditions of professionalism (professional power, associational
control and sustaining ideologies), dependent relationships with other social
institutions (work, markets for services and the state) and associational
strategies. In particular, this arrangement needs to be established and
maintained by occupational associations of accountants in the process of
professionalisation, through apposite strategies.
Abbott, A.
, (1988), The System of Professions,
Chicago: The University of Chicago Press
.
2.
Allen, K.
, (1991),
“In Pursuit of Professional Dominance: Australian Accounting 1953-1985”
, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal,
Vol.4, No.1, pp.
51-67
.
3.
Armstrong, P.
, (1985),
“Changing Management Control Strategies: The Role of Competition
Between Accountancy and other Organisational Professions”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.10,
No.2, pp.
129-148
.
4.
Bacharach, S.B.
and
Lawler, E.J.
, (1980), Power and Politics in Organizations,
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
5.
Beckman, S.
, 1990, “Professionalization: Borderline
Authority and Autonomy in Work”, in
Dingwall, R.
and
Lewis, P.
(eds.), The Sociology of the Profession Lawyers, Doctors and
Others,
London: The Macmillan Press Ltd
, pp.115-138.
6.
Birkett, B.
, (1984), “Regulation Through The Professions:
The Case of Accounting”, in
Tomasic, R.
(ed.), Business Regulation in Australia,
Sydney: CCH Australia Ltd
, pp.265-297.
7.
Booth, P.
and
Cocks, N.
, (1990), “Power and the Study of the Accounting
Profession”, in
Cooper, D.J.
and
Hopper, T.M.
(eds.), Critical Accounts,
London: Macmillan
, pp.391-408.
8.
Burrage, M.
,
Jarausch, K.
and
Siegrist, H.
, (1990), “An Actor-Based Framework for the Study
of the Professions”, in
Burrage, M.
and
Torstendahl, R.
(eds.), Professions in Theory and History,
London: Sage
, pp.203-225.
9.
Carnegie, G.D.
and
Edwards, J.R.
, (2001),
“The Construction of the Professional Accountant: The Case of the
Incorporated Institute of Accountants, Victoria (1886)”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.26,
Nos.4-5, pp.
301-325
.
10.
Carnegie, G.D.
,
Edwards, J.R.
and
West, B.
, (2003),
“Understanding the Dynamics of the Australian Accounting
Profession: A Prosopographical Study of the Founding Members of the
Incorporated Institute of Accountants, Victoria, 1886 to 1908”
, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal,
Vol.16, No.5, pp.
790-820
.
11.
Carnegie, G.D.
and
Napier, C.J.
, (1996),
“Critical and Interpretive Histories: Insights into
Accounting’s Present and Future Through its Past”
, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal,
Vol.9, No.3, pp.
7-39
.
12.
Carnegie, G.D.
and
Parker, R.H.
, (1999),
“Accountants and Empire: The Case of Co-membership of Australian
and British Accountancy Bodies, 1885 to 1914”
, Accounting, Business & Financial History,
Vol.9, No.1, March, pp.
77-102
.
13.
Carnegie, G.D.
and
Potter, B.N.
, (2000),
“Accounting History in Australia: A Survey of Published Works, 1975-99”
, Australian Economic History Review, Vol.40,
No.3, pp.
287-314
.
14.
Chua, W.F.
and
Poullaos, C.
, (1993),
“Rethinking the Profession-State Dynamic: The Case of the
Victorian Charter Attempt, 1885-1906”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.18,
No.7/8, pp.
691-728
.
15.
Chua, W.F.
and
Poullaos, C.
, (1998),
“The Dynamics of ‘Closure’ Amidst the
Construction of Market, Profession, Empire and Nationhood: An Historical
Analysis of an Australian Accounting Association, 1886-1903”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.23,
No.2, pp.
155-187
.
16.
Chua, W.F.
and
Poullaos, C.
, (2002),
“The Empire Strikes Back? An Exploration of Centre-Periphery
Interaction between the ICAEW and Accounting Associations in the
Self-Governing Colonies of Australia, Canada and South Africa, 1880-1907”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.27,
Nos.4-5,
409-445
.
17.
Collins, R.
, (1979), The Credential Society,
London: Academic Press
.
18.
Collins, R.
, (1990), “Market Closure and the Conflict Theory
of the Profession”, in
Burrage, M.
and
Torstendahl, R.
(eds.), Professions in Theory and History,
London: Sage
, pp.24-43.
19.
Eagleton, T.
, (1983), Literary Theory,
Oxford: Blackwell
.
20.
Elliott, P.
, (1972), The Sociology of the Professions,
London: Macmillan
.
21.
Edwards J.R.
, (2001),
“Accounting Regulation and the Professionalization Process: An
Historical Essay Concerning the Significance of P.H. Abbott”
, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol.12,
No.6, pp.
675-696
.
22.
Etzioni, A.
, (1969), “Preface”, in
Etzioni, A.
(ed.), The Semi-Professions and their Organization,
New York: Free Press
, pp.5-18.
23.
Fleischman, R.K.
and
Tyson, T.
, (1999),
“Opportunity Lost? Chances for Cost Accountants’
Professionalization under the National Industrial Recovery Act of 1933”
, Accounting, Business & Financial History,
Vol.9, No.1, March, pp.
51-75
.
Freidson, E.
, (1970), Professional Dominance: The Social Structure of
Medical Care,
New York: Atherson Press
.
26.
Freidson, E.
, (1986), Professional Powers: A Study of the
Institutionalization of Formal Knowledge,
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
27.
Freidson, E.
, (1988), Profession of Medicine: A Study of the Sociology of
Applied Knowledge,
Chicago: University of Chicago Press
.
28.
Freidson, E.
, (1994), Professionalism Reborn,
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
29.
Gramsci, A.
, (1971), Selections from the Prison Notebooks,
Hoare, Q.
and
Nowell-Smith, G.
(edited and translated),
London: Lawrence & Wishart
.
30.
Johnson, T.J.
, (1972), Professions and Power,
London: Macmillan
.
31.
Kirkham, L.M.
, (1992),
“Integrating Herstory and Hisstory in Accountancy”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.17,
No.3/4, pp.
287-297
.
32.
Krause, E.A.
, (1996), Death of the Guilds: Professions, States, and the
Advance of Capitalism, 1930 to the Present,
New Haven: Yale University Press
.
33.
Larson, M.S.
, (1977), The Rise of Professionalism A Sociological
Analysis,
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
34.
Larson, M.S.
, (1990), “In the Matter of Experts and
Professionals, or How it is to Leave Nothing Unsaid”, in
Torstendahl, R.
and
Burrage, M.
(eds.), The Formation of Professions Knowledge, State and
Strategy,
London: Sage
, pp.24-50.
35.
Loft, A.
, (1992),
“Accountancy and the Gendered Division of Labour: A Review Essay”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.17,
No.3/4, pp.
367-378
.
36.
Lukes, S.
, (1974), Power: A Radical View,
London: The Macmillan Press Ltd.
37.
Macdonald, K.M.
, (1985),
“Social Closure and Occupational Registration”
, Sociology, Vol.19, No.4, November, pp.
541-556
.
38.
Macdonald, K.
, (1995), “A Professional Project - The Case of
Accountancy” in The Sociology of the Professions,
London: Sage
.
39.
Mann, M.
, (1993), The Sources of Power, Vol.II,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
40.
Milner, A.
, (1993), Cultural Materialism,
Melbourne: Melbourne University Press
.
41.
Mintzberg, H.
, (1979), The Structuring of Organizations: A Synthesis of the
Research,
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall
.
42.
Mintzberg, H.
, (1988), “The Professional
Context”, in
Quinn, J.B.
,
Mintzberg, H.
and
James R.M.
(eds.), The Strategy Process Concepts, Contexts, and Cases,
Englewood Clifts, NJ: Prentice-Hall
, pp.638-660.
43.
Murphy, R.
, (1988), Social Closure,
Oxford: The Clarendon Press
.
44.
Parkin, F.
, (1979), Marxism and Class Theory: A Bourgeois
Critique,
New York: Columbia University Press
.
45.
Plamenatz, J.
, (1970), Ideology,
London: Pall Mall Press Ltd.
46.
Poullaos, C.
, (1994), Making the Australian Chartered Accountant,
New York and London: Garland Publishing
.
47.
Puxty, A.G.
,
Willmott, H.C.
,
Cooper, D.J.
and
Lowe, T.
, (1987),
“Modes of Regulation in Advanced Capitalism: Locating Accountancy
in Four Countries”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, pp.
273-291
.
48.
Ramsey, M.
, (1988), Professional and Popular Medicine in France,
1770-1830,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
49.
Ramirez, C.
, (2001),
“Understanding Social Closure in its Cultural Context: Accounting
Practitioners in France (1920-1939)”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.26,
Nos.4-5, pp.
391-418
.
50.
Richardson, A.J.
, (1997),
“Social Closure in Dynamic Markets: The Incomplete Professional
Project in Accountancy”
, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol.8,
No.6, pp.
635-653
.
51.
Roberts, J.
and
Coutts, J.A.
, (1992),
“Feminization and Professionalization: A Review of an Emerging
Literature on the Development of Accounting in the United Kingdom”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.17,
No.3/4, pp.
379-395
.
52.
Siegrist, H.
, (1990), “Professionalization as a Process:
Patterns, Progression and Discontinuity”, in
Dingwall, R.
and
Lewis, P.
(eds.), The Sociology of the Profession Lawyers, Doctors and
Others,
London: The Macmillan Press Ltd
, pp.177-202.
53.
Skocpol, T.
, (1985), “Bringing the State Back In: Strategies
of Analysis in Current Research”, in
Evans, P.B.
,
Rueschemeyer, D. andSkocpol, T.
(eds.), Bringing the State Back In,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
, pp.3-43.
54.
Sriram, R.S.
and
Vollmers, G.
, (1997),
“A Reexamination of the Development of the Accounting Profession
- Critical Events from 1912-1940”
, The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol.24,
No.2, December, pp.
65-90
.
55.
Sternberg, R.J.
and
Horvath, J.A.
, (1999), Tacit Knowledge in Professional Practice: Researcher
and Practitioner Perspectives,
L. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ
.
56.
Streeck, W.
and
Schmitter, P.C.
, (1985), “Community, Market, State - and
Associations? The Prospective Contribution of Interest Governance to Social
Order”, in
Streeck, W.
and
Schmitter, P.C.
(eds.), Private Interest Government,
London: Sage Publications
, pp.1-29.
57.
Therborn, G.
, (1980), The Ideology of Power and the Power of
Ideology,
London: Left Books
.
58.
Turner, C.
and
Hodge, M.N.
, (1970), ”Occupations and
Professions”, in
Jackson J.A.
(ed.), Professions and Professionalization,
Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
, pp.17-50.
59.
Velayutham, S.
and
Perera, H.
, (1995),
“The Historical Context of Professional Ideology and Tension and
Strain in the Accounting Profession”
, The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol.22,
No.1, pp.
81-101
.
60.
Vollmer, H.M.
and
Mills, D.L.
, (eds.), (1966), Professionalization,
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall
.
61.
Walker, S.
, (1991),
“The Defence of Professional Monopoly: Scottish Chartered
Accountants and ‘Satellites in the Accounting Firmament’ 1854-1914”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.16,
No.3, pp.
257-283
.
62.
Walker, S.
, (1995),
“The Genesis of Professional Organization in Scotland: A
Contextual Analysis”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.20,
No.4, pp.
285-310
.
63.
Walker, S.P.
, (2004),
“The Genesis of Professional Organization in English Accountancy”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.29,
No.2, pp.
127-156
.
64.
Walker, S.P.
and
Shackleton, K.
, (1995),
“Corporatism and Structural Change in the British Accountancy
Profession, 1930-1957”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.20,
No.6, pp.
467-503
.
65.
Walker, S.P.
and
Shackleton, K.
, (1998),
“A Ring Fence for the Profession: Advancing the Closure of
British Accountancy 1957-1970”
, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal,
Vol.11, No.1, pp.
34-71
.
66.
Weber, M.
, (1978), Economy and Society,
Roth, G.
and
Wittich, C.
(eds.),
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
67.
West, B.P.
, (1996),
“The Professionalisation of Accounting”
, Accounting History, NS Vol.1, No.1, pp.
77-97
.
68.
Wilensky, H.L.
, (1964),
“The Professionalization of Everyone?”
, American Journal of Sociology, Vol.70,
No.2, pp.
137-158
.
69.
Willmott, H.
, (1986),
“Organising the Profession: A Theoretical and Historical
Examination of the Development of the Major Accountancy Bodies in the UK”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.11,
No.6, pp.
555-580
.
70.
Willmott, H.C.
, (1990), “Serving the Public Interest? A
Critical Analysis of a Professional Claim”, in
Cooper, D.J.
and
Hopper, T.M.
(eds.), Critical Accounts,
London: Macmillan
, pp.315-331.
71.
Willmott, H.
,
Cooper, D.
and
Puxty, T.
, (1993),
“Maintaining Self-regulation Making
‘Interests’ Coincide in Discourses on the Governance of
the ICAEW”
, Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal,
Vol.6, No.1, pp.
68-93
.
72.
Witz, A.
, (1992), Professions and Patriarchy,
London: Routledge
.
