This paper challenges the increasingly accepted position that, internationally,
the audit profession is facing a major liability crisis. Its analysis of
auditing developments in Spain since the late 1980s reveals an audit liability
“crisis” which is more the result of the
profession’s campaign to align itself with legal regimes abroad rather
than a direct consequence of major legal settlements in favour of third parties.
The Spanish experience is made particularly interesting by the dramatic change
in the auditing profession’s stance - clearly rejecting
responsibilities and legal traditions that it had willingly accepted just over a
decade ago (when auditing was established in statute). A major implication of
the paper is the need for notions of “international” and
“crisis” to be used with great care in the audit arena and
for their mobilising power to be recognised, especially given the limited
availability of detailed studies of different national auditing contexts.
Balachandrian, B.V.
and
Nagarajan, N.J.
, (1987),
“Imperfect Information, Insurance and Auditor’s Legal Liability”
, Contemporary Accounting Research, Vol.23,
No.1, pp.
1-20
.
2.
Bercovitz, R., (1982), “Responsibilidad Civil de los
Auditores”, in Jornadas sobre elFuturo de la Auditoría en España, Madrid: ICJCE.
3.
Bougen, P.D.
, (1997),
“Spain, July 1988: Some Observations on Becoming Professional”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.22,
No.8, pp.
757-777
.
4.
Bougen, P.D.
and
Vazquez, D.
, (1997),
“Debating Spanish Audit Legislation: The Audit Law of 1988”
, European Accounting Review, Vol.6,
No.1, pp.
1-17
.
5.
Caratozzolo, M.
, (1996),
“Auditing Standards”
, in Act of the Conference on the Role, the Position and the
Liability of the Statutory Auditor within the European Union, 5-6 December,
Commission of the European Communities, pp.
129-162
.
6.
Carbajal Torre, J.
, (1994),
“La Responsibilidad de los Auditores de Cuentas”
, Revista Técnica, No.5, pp.
14-25
.
7.
Cooper, D.J.
,
Greenwood, R.
,
Hinings, B.
and
Brown, J.L.
, (1998),
“Globalisation and Nationalism in a Multinational Accounting
Firm: The Case of Opening New Markets in Eastern Europe”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.23,
No.5/6, pp.
531-548
.
8.
De Angel Yagüez, R., (1995), La Responsibilidad Civil,
Bilbao: Editorial Universidad de Deusto.
9.
Díez Picazo, L. and Gullón, A., (1995), Sistema de
Derecho Civil, Madrid: Editorial Tecnos.
10.
European Commission
, (1996), The Role, Position and the Liability of the
Statutory Auditor within the European Union, Green Paper,
Brussels: European Commission
.
11.
European Commission
, (1998), The Statutory Audit in the European Union: The Way
Forward, C143, 8.05.1998,
Brussels: European Commission
.
12.
Gabas Trigo, F.
, (1992), “Audit Professionals and Audit Firms in
Spain”, in
Gonzalo, J.A.
(ed.), Accounting in Spain 1992,
Madrid: Asociación
Española de Contabilidad y Administracion de Empresas (AECA
).
13.
García Benau, M.A.
and
Humphrey, C.
, (1992),
“Beyond the Audit Expectations Gap: Learning from the Experiences
of Britain and Spain”
, European Accounting Review, Vol.1,
No.2, December, pp.
303-331
.
14.
García Benau, M.A.
,
Humphrey, C.
,
Moizer, P.
and
Turley, S.
, (1993a),
“Auditing Expectations and Performance in Spain and Britain: A
Comparative Analysis”
, The International Journal of Accounting, Vol.28,
No.4, pp.
281-307
.
15.
García Benau, M.A., Humphrey, C., Moizer, P. and Turley, S.,
(1993b), La Auditoría y sus Expectativas: Los Casos de
España y del Reino Unido, Monografía No. 24, Madrid:
Instituto de Contabilidad y Auditoría de Cuentas.
16.
García Benau, M.A.
,
Ruíz Barbadillo, E.
,
Humphrey, C.
and
Al Husaini, W.
, (1999),
“Success in Failure? Reflections on the Changing Spanish Audit Environment”
, European Accounting Review, Vol.8,
No.4, pp.
701-730
.
17.
Gietzmann, M.B.
and
Quick, R.
, (1998),
“Capping Auditor Liability: The German Experience”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.23,
No.1, pp.
81-103
.
18.
Gonzalo Angulo, J.A., (1995), “La Auditoría, una
Profesión en la Encrucijada de los Noventa”, Revista
Española de Financiación y Contabilidad, Vol.XXIV,
No.84, pp.595-630.
19.
Gwilliam, D.
, (1997), “Changes in the Legal
Environment”, in
Sherer, M.
and
Turley, S.
(eds.), Current Issues in Auditing, third edition,
London: Paul Chapman Publishing
.
20.
Hopwood, A.
, (1989), (ed.), International Pressures for Accounting
Change,
London: ICAEW
.
21.
Humphrey, C.
, “Debating Audit Expectations”, in
Sherer, M.
and
Turley, S.
(eds.), Current Issues in Auditing, third edition,
London: Paul Chapman Publishing
.
22.
Instituto de Censores Jurados de Cuentas de España (ICJCE),
(1997), Libro Blanco de la Auditoría de Cuentas en
España, Madrid: ICJCE.
23.
International Federation of Accountants (IFAC)
, (1995), Auditors’ Legal Liability in the Global
Marketplace: A Case for Limitation,
New York: IFAC
.
24.
Larriba Díaz-Zorita, A. and Serrano Moracho, F., (1999),
“La Ley de Auditoría Española, su
Significación y Bases para una Posible Reforma”, Revista de
Contabilidad, Vol.2, No.4, pp.49-107.
25.
London Economics
, (1998), The Economics of Audit Liability. A Report for the
International Federation of Accountants,
London: London Economics
.
26.
Martinez García, F.J., (1992), La Regulación de la
Auditoría en España, Madrid: Instituto de Censores
Jurados de Cuentas de España.
27.
Napier, C.
, (1998),
“Intersections of Law and Accountancy: Unlimited Auditor
Liability in the United Kingdom”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.23,
No.1, pp.
105-128
.
28.
Palmrose, Z.
, (1988),
“An Analysis of Auditor Litigation and Audit Service Quality”
, Accounting Review, Vol.63, No.1, pp.
55-73
.
29.
Pantaleón, F., (1996), La Responsibilidad Civil de los
Auditores: Extensión, Limitación,
Prescripción, Madrid: Editorial Civitas.
30.
Peck, J.J.
, (1999),
“Proportionate Liability: The Emerging Global Standard”
, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol.10,
No.3, pp.
377-386
.
31.
Pont Mestres, M., (1991), Al Servicio de la Profesión
Auditoría desde la Presidencia deInstituto de Censores Jurados de Cuentas de España, Madrid: ICJCE.
32.
Power, M.
, (1997), The Audit Society: Rituals of Verification,
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
33.
Power, M.
, (1998),
“Auditor Liability in Context”
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.23,
No.1, pp.
77-79
.
Prado Lorenzo, J.M., González Bravo, I. and Martín
Jiménez, D., (1995), “La Situación de la
Auditoría en España desde la Perspectiva de los
Auditores”, Revista Española de Financiación y
Contabilidad, Vol.XXIV, No.84, pp.631-66.
36.
Ruíz Barbadillo, E., (1996), “La Crisis de los Fallos de
Auditoría: Un Analisis de las Fases del Conflicto de la
Auditoría en España”, Revista
Española de Financiación y Contabilidad, Vol.XXV,
No.89, pp.785-820.
37.
Siliciano, J.A.
, (1997),
“Trends in Independent Auditor Liability: The Emergence of a Sane Consensus”
, Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, Vol.16,
No.4, pp.
339-353
.
38.
Subcomisión del Congreso de los Diputados, (1999),
Subcomisión para el Estudio de laProblemática de la Profesión de Auditor de Cuentas,
Congreso de los Diputados, 14 December.
39.
United Nations
, (1996), Responsibilities and Liabilities of Accountants and
Auditors: Proceedings of a Forum, United Nations Conference on Trade and
Development, United Nations, New York/Geneva.
40.
Ward, G.
, (1999),
“Auditors’ Liability in the UK: The Case for Reform”
, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, Vol.10,
No.3, pp.
387-394
.
