During the period 1985 to 1992, the major Victorian State Government (Australia) public trading authorities were required to prepare Rate of Return Reporting (RoRR) accounts as supplementary statements to their annual historical cost financial statements. RoRR represents a version of current (replacement) cost accounting. This paper provides a background to the Victorian RoRR requirements and an examination of the financial statements, over a five year period, of three of the six authorities required to comply with the RoRR requirements. The paper investigates the differences between the historical cost and RoRR profit and loss statements and balance sheets, analysing the major reasons for the differences and the impacts of RoRR on the reported performance and financial position of the trading authorities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Australian Society of Accountants and The Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia , (1983a), “Current Cost Accounting”, Statement of Accounting Practice SAP 1, November, Melbourne.
2.
Australian Society of Accountants and The Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia , (1983b), Guidance Notes on Statement of Accounting Practice SAP 1, “Current Cost Accounting”, November, Melbourne.
3.
Australian Society of Accountants and the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia , (1989), “Current Cost Accounting”, Statement of Accounting Practice SAP 1, February, Melbourne.
4.
Australian Society of Certified Practising Accountants and The Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia , (1995), “Conformity with Accounting Standards and UIG Consensus Views”, Miscellaneous Professional Statement APS 1, June, Melbourne.
5.
Bonbright, J.C. , (1937), The Valuation of Property, New York: McGraw-Hill .
6.
Canning, J.B. , (1929), The Economics of Accountancy, New York: Ronald Press .
7.
Carnegie, G.D. and Napier, C.J. , (1996), “Critical and Interpretive Histories: Insights into Accounting's Present and Future Through its Past” , Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, Vol.9, No.3, pp. 7-39 .
8.
Carpenter, G.J. , (1990), "Rate of Return Reporting in Australia”, in Guthrie, J. , Parker, L. and Shand, D. (eds.), The Public Sector: Contemporary Readings in Accounting and Auditing, Sydney: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich , pp.184-192.
Clarke, F.L. and Dean, G.W. , (1986), “Schmidt's BetriebswirtschaftTheory” , Abacus, Vol.22, No.2, September, pp. 65-102 .
11.
Clarke, F.L. and Dean, G.W. , (1990), Contributions of Limperg and Schmidt to the Replacement Cost Debate in the 1920s, New York and London: Garland Publishing .
12.
Comptroller-General , (1983), “Rate of Return Reporting”, Accounting Policy Statement Number 1 (APS 1), Melbourne: Department of Management and Budget .
13.
Coombes, R.J. and Eddey, P.H. , (1977), “Reactions of Company Accountants to CCA” , The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.48, No.5, November, p. 45-45 .
14.
Department of Management and Budget , (1986a), “Public Authority Policy and Rate of Return Reporting”, Information Paper No.1, Melbourne: Government of Victoria .
15.
Department of Management and Budget , (1986b), “Rate of Return Reporting”, Accounting Policy Statement Number 1 (APS 1), Melbourne: Government of Victoria .
16.
Edwards, E. and Bell, P. , (1961), The Theory and Measurement of Business Income, Berkeley: University of California Press .
17.
Ferguson, C. and Wines, G. , (1986), “Incidence of the Use of Current Cost Accounting in Published Annual Financial Statements” , Accounting Forum, Vol.9, No.1, March, pp. 13-19 .
18.
Goyal, R. , (1989), “Rate of Return Reporting”, in Hagan, L.L. and Staunton, J.J. (eds.), Government Policy, Financial Guidelines and Accounting Data: Issues for Statutory Authorities, Armidale: University of New England , pp.132-162.
19.
Graves, O.F. , (1987), “Accounting for Inflation: Henry Sweeney and the German Gold-Mark Model” , The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol.14, No.1, Spring, pp. 33-55 .
20.
Kelly, E. , (1981), “How Inflation was Reported in 1980” , The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.51, No.9, April, pp. 42-49 .
21.
Lewis, C.R. and Harris, G.J. , (1979), “Opinions of Chartered Accountants on CCA” , The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.49, No.8, March, pp. 19-23 .
22.
MacNeal, K. , (1939), Truth in Accounting, Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania .
23.
Mattessich, R. , (1984), “Fritz Schmidt (1882-1950) and His Pioneering Work of Current Value Accounting in Comparison to Edwards and Bell's Theory” , Proceedings of Fourth International Congress of Accounting Historians, Editrice, Pisa.
24.
Parry, T.R. , (1979), “The Current Cost Reporters” , The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.49, No.7, February, pp. 17-21 .
25.
Parry, T.R. , (1980), “How Inflation was Reported in 1979” , The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.50, No.7, February, pp. 32-41 .
26.
Previts, G.J. , Parker, L.D. and Coffman, E.N. , (1990), “Accounting History: Definition and Relevance” , Abacus, Vol.26, No.1, March, pp. 1-14 .
27.
Public Bodies Review Committee , (1981a), Report on a Study of the Audit and Reporting Responsibilities of Public Bodies in Victoria, March, Melbourne: Parliament of Victoria .
28.
Public Bodies Review Committee , (1981b), The Economic Impact of Public Bodies in Victoria, October, Melbourne: Parliament of Victoria .
29.
Romano, C. and Wise, T. , (1986), “Current Cost Accounting: Dead or Alive?” , The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.57, No.2, August, pp. 42-47 , 71-71 .
30.
Schmidt, F., (1921), Die organische Bilanz im Rahmen der Wirtschaft, Leipzig.
31.
Schmidt, F. , (1930), “The Importance of Replacement Value” , The Accounting Review, Vol.5, No.8, pp. 235-242 .
32.
Sweeney, H.W. , (1936), Stabilized Accounting, New York: Harper .
33.
Walker, N. , (1987), “Mirror Mirror: Public vs. Private Rate of Return Reporting” , Australian Accountant, Vol.57, No.1, February, pp. 6-11 .
34.
Walker, R.G. , Clarke, F.L. and Dean, G.W. , (1997), The Use of Replacement Price Accounting to Shape Perceptions and “Control” the Public Sector, Working Paper Series, School of Accounting, University of New South Wales, Sydney: UNSW .
35.
Zimmer, I.R. , (1979), “Attitudes to CCA: A Paradox” , The Chartered Accountant in Australia, Vol.49, No.8, March, pp. 16-19 .
