The Drug and Poison Information Centre (DPIC) in Singapore was piloted as a new service in April 2004. This study evaluated the cost benefits of its interventions in the first two years of its operation.
Method
A two-year retrospective review of DPIC call records was performed and the following outcome measures were noted: (A) proportion of patients who were managed onsite and hence did not need to attend the emergency department (ED); and (B) proportion of patients who were managed in the ED without the need for admission. Cost savings were calculated based on admission costs for patients with poisoning, including other out-of-hospital costs. This amounted to savings of S$1390 and S$1170 for patients who fulfilled outcome measures A and B respectively. Savings for the hospital was S$1477 per case. The cost of operating the DPIC over the same period was S$507,922.
Results
There were 831 calls on acute toxic exposures over the study period. Of these, 115 and 405 patients fulfilled outcome measure A and B respectively with consequent cost savings of S$159,850 (115 x S$1390 per patient), and S$473,850 (405 x S$1170 per patient). The hospitals saved S$768,040 (520 x S$1477) from prevented admissions. Excluding operating cost, this gave net savings of S$893,818 over the two years from DPIC interventions.
Conclusion
The cost savings from DPIC services is evident from this study. This translates to more effective use of limited healthcare resources.
Chafee-BahamonC., LovejoyF.H.JrEffectiveness of a regional poison center in reducing excess emergency room visits for children's poisonings. Pediatrics1983; 72(2): 164–9.
2.
ChanY.C., FungH.T., LeeC.K., TsuiS.H., NganH.K., SyM.Y.A prospective epidemiological study of acute poisoning in Hong Hong. Hong Kong J Emerg Med2005; 12(3): 156–61.
3.
ChienC., MarriottJ.L., AshbyK., Ozanne-SmithJ.Unintentional ingestion of over the counter medications in children less than 5 years old. J Paediatr Child Health2003; 39(4): 264–9.
4.
HonK.L., HoJ.K., LeungT.F., WongY., NelsonE.A., FokT.F.Review of children hospitalised for ingestion and poisoning at a tertiary centre. Ann Acad Med Singapore2005; 34(5): 356–61.
5.
LamireauT., LlanasB., KennedyA., FayonM., PenouilF., Favarell-GarriguesJ.C.Epidemiology of poisoning in children: a 7-year survey in a paediatric emergency care unit. Eur J Emerg Med2002; 9(1): 9–14.
6.
ShannonM.Ingestion of toxic substances by children. New Engl J Med2000; 342(3): 186–91.
7.
YangC.C., WuJ.F., OngH.C., HungS.C., KuoY.P., SaC.H.Taiwan National Poison Center: epidemiologic data 1985-1993. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol1996; 34(6): 651–63.
8.
LitovitzT., KearneyT.E., HolmK., SolowayR.A., WeismanR., OderdaG.Poison control centers: is there an antidote for budget cuts?Am J Emerg Med1994; 12(5): 585–99.
9.
PhillipsK.A., HomanR.K., HiattP.H., LuftH.S., KearneyT.E., HeardS.E.The costs and outcomes of restricting public access to poison control centers. Results from a natural experiment. Med Care1998; 36(3): 271–80.
10.
WatsonW.A., LitovitzT.L., RodgersG.C.Jr, Klein-SchwartzW., ReidN., YounissJ.2004 annual report of the American Association of Poison Control Centers Toxic Exposure Surveillance System. Am J Emerg Med2005; 23(5): 589–666.
11.
McCaigL.F., BurtC.W.Poisoning-related visits to emergency departments in the United States, 1993-1996. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol1999; 37(7): 817–26.
12.
HolohanT.W., HumphreysC.P., JohnsonH., CaseyP.B., TraceyJ.A., LaffoyM.Sources of information for acute poisoning in accident and emergency departments in Dublin, Ireland. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol2000; 38(1): 29–36.
PonampalamR., AnantharamanV.Determining the extent of adverse drug reactions and poisonings encountered by physicians in Singapore. SGH Proceedings2002; 11: 17–25.
18.
TayS.Y., TaiD.Y.H., SeowE., WangY.T.Patients admitted to an intensive care unit for poisoning. Ann Acad Med Singapore1998; 27(3): 347–52.
19.
ChaoT.C., TayM.K., BloodworthB.C., LimK.H.Poisons information in Singapore. Ann Acad Med Singapore1993; 22(2): 237–41.
20.
LernerW.M., WarnerK.E.The challenge of privately-financed community health programs in an era of cost containment: a case study of poison control centers. J Pub Health Pol1988; 9(3): 411–28.
21.
LauF.L.Emergency management of poisoning in Hong Kong. Hong Kong Med J2000; 6(3): 288–92.
22.
PonampalamR., AnantharamanV.The need for drug and poison information - the Singapore physicians' perspective. Singapore Med J2003; 44(5): 231–42.
23.
HarrisonD.L., DraugalisJ.R., SlackM.K., LangleyP.C.Cost-effectiveness of regional poison control centers. Arch Intern Med1996; 156(22): 2601–8.
24.
KrenzelokE.P.The use of poison prevention and education strategies to enhance the awareness of the poison information center and to prevent accidental pediatric poisonings. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol1995; 33(6): 663–7.
25.
MillerT.R., LestinaD.C.Costs of poisoning in the United States and savings from poison control centers: a benefit-cost analysis. Ann Emerg Med1997; 29(2): 239–45.
26.
MvrosR., DeanB.S., KrenzelokE.P.Poison center funding - who should pay?J Toxicol Clin Toxicol1994; 32(5): 503–8.
27.
WilliamsR.M.Are poison control centers cost-effective?Ann Emerg Med1997; 29(2): 246–7.
DominguezK.D., GupchupG.V., BensonB.E.A survey of the expectations of New Mexico emergency physicians regarding the services of the New Mexico Poison and Drug Information Center. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol2000; 38(3): 309–19.
32.
CaravatiE.M., McElweeN.E.Use of clinical toxicology resources by emergency physicians and its impact on poison control centers. Ann Emerg Med1991; 20(2): 147–50.
33.
KearneyT.E., OlsonK.R., BeroL.A., HeardS.E., BlancP.D.Health care cost effects of public use of a regional poison control center. West J Med1995; 162(6): 499–504.
34.
AwangR., RahmanA.F., AbdullahW.Z., LajisR., MajidM.I.Trends in inquires on poisoning: a five-year report from the National Poison Centre, Malaysia. Med J Malaysia2003; 58(3): 375–9.
35.
Burillo-PutzeG., MunneP., DuenasA., PinillosM.A., NaveiroJ.M., CobJ.Clinical Toxicology Working Group, Spanish Society of Emergency Medicine (SEMESTOX). National multicentre study of acute intoxication in emergency departments of Spain. Eur J Emerg Med2003; 10(2): 101–4.
36.
PonampalamR., TanH.H., NgK.C., LeeW.Y., TanS.C.Demographics of toxic exposures presenting to three public hospital emergency departments in Singapore 2001-2003. Int J Emerg Med2009; 2: 25–31.
