To compare the efficacy of oral (PO) diclofenac potassium (Cataflam®) and intramuscular (IM) diclofenac sodium (Voltaren®) in acute pain relief, with a hypothesis of equivalence between the two.
Patients and methods
In this prospective randomised single center clinical study, adult Chinese patients attending the emergency department and suffering from renal colic, acute musculoskeletal injury or arthritis were enrolled. They were randomly assigned either 75 mg of IM Voltaren® or 75 mg of PO Cataflam®. Pain was assessed by the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and evaluations were performed at baseline, 30 minutes, 1 hour and 2 hours after treatment. Blood pressure, pulse rate and respiratory rate were also recorded at similar time intervals.
Results
We recruited 46 cases in the Voltaren® group and 45 cases in the Cataflam® group. Both treatment groups showed statistically highly significant reduction (P<0.0001) in pain VAS, systolic blood pressure and pulse rate compared with the baseline. Voltaren® was statistically more effective in pain relief at 30 minutes (P=0.012) and 1 hour (P=0.010) but not at 2 hours (P=0.311) compared with Cataflam®. The changes in blood pressure, pulse rate and respiratory rate were not statistically significant between the two treatment groups at all time points.
Conclusion
IM Voltaren® was more effective in acute pain relief compared with PO Cataflam®.
SkoutakisV.A., CarterC.A., MickleT.R.Review of diclofenac and evaluation of its place in therapy as a nonsteroidal antiinflammatory agent.Drug Intell Clin Pharm1988; 22(11): 850–9.
2.
Babic-NaglicD.Voltaren – the gold standard.Reumatizam2000; 47(2): 29–31.
3.
KantorT.G.Use of diclofenac in analgesia.Am J Med1986; 80(4B): 64–9.
4.
SuperviaA., Pedro-BotetJ., NoguesX.Piroxicam fast-dissolving dosage form vs diclofenac sodium in the treatment of acute renal colic: a double-blind controlled trial.Br J Urol1998; 81(1): 27–30.
5.
MackwayJ.Towards evidence-based emergency medicine: best BETs from the Manchester Royal Infirmary.Emerg Med J2001; 18: 462–70.
6.
SteinA., Ben DovD., FinkelB., MeczY., KitzesR., LurieA.Single-dose intramuscular ketorolac versus diclofenac for pain management in renal colic.Am J Emerg Med1996; 14(4): 385–7.
7.
LaerumE., OmmundsenO.E., GronsethJ.E., ChristiansenA., FagertunH.E.Intramuscular diclofenac versus intravenous indomethacin in the treatment of acute renal colic.Eur Urol1996; 30(3): 358–62.
8.
Al-WailiN.S., SaloomK.Y.Intramuscular piroxicam versus intramuscular diclofenac sodium in the treatment of acute renal colic: double-blind study.Eur J Med Res1999; 4(1): 23–6.
9.
CohenE., HafnerR., RotenbergZ., FadillaM., GartyM.Comparison of ketorolac and diclofenac in the treatment of renal colic.Eur J Clin Pharmacol1998; 54(6): 455–8.
10.
LundstamS., WahlanderL., KralJ.G.Treatment of ureteral colic by prostaglandin synthetase inhibition with diclofenac sodium.Curr Ther Res1980; 28(3 I): 355–8.
11.
VignoniA., FierroA., MoreschiniG.Diclofenac sodium in ureteral colic: a double-blind comparison trial with placebo.J Int Med Res1983; 11(5): 303–7.
12.
SimonL.Low back pain.Eur J Rheumatol Inflamm1987; 8(1): 65–7.
13.
van TulderM.W., ScholtenR.J., KoesB.W., DeyoR.A.Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs for low back pain.Cochrane Database Syst Rev2000; (2): CD000396.
14.
NgP., KamC.W., YauH.H.A comparison of ketoprofen and diclofenac for acute musculoskeletal pain relief: a prospective randomized clinical trial.Hong Kong J Emerg Med2001; 8(2): 73–7.
15.
MoranM.Double-blind comparison of diclofenac potassium, ibuprofen and placebo in the treatment of ankle sprains.J Int Med Res1991; 19(2): 121–30.
16.
HoogewijsJ., DiltoerM.W., HubloueI.A prospective, open, single blind, randomized study comparing four analgesics in the treatment of peripheral injury in the emergency department.Eur J Emerg Med2000; 7(2): 119–23.
17.
BahamondeL.A., SaavedraH.Comparison of the analgesic and anti-inflammatory effects of diclofenac potassium versus piroxicam versus placebo in ankle sprain patients.J Int Med Res1990; 18(2): 104–11.
18.
VerstraetenA., BakshiR.Diclofenac potassium for the treatment of traumatic joint distortions: an open multicentre study.J Int Med Res1991; 19(2): 165–70.
19.
BakshiR., RotmanH., ShawM., SussmanH.Double-blind, multicenter evaluation of the efficacy and tolerability of diclofenac dispersible in the treatment of acute soft-tissue injuries.Clin Ther1995; 17(1): 30–7.
20.
ColomboG., GiombiniA., PamichT., PeruzziE., PisatiR.Diclofenac dispersible provides superior analgesia with faster onset of action compared to naproxen granular in patients with acute, painful, minor sports injuries.J Sports Med Phys Fitness1997; 37(3): 228–33.
21.
MoranM.An observer-blind comparison of diclofenac potassium, piroxicam and placebo in the treatment of ankle sprains.Curr Med Res Opin1990; 12(4): 268–74.
GreenS., BuchbinderR., BarnsleyL.Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) for treating lateral elbow pain in adults.Cochrane Database Syst Rev2002; (2): CD003686.
24.
BrogdenR.N., HeelR.C., PakesG.E., SpeightT.M., AveryG.S.Diclofenac sodium: a review of its pharmacological properties and therapeutic use in rheumatic diseases and pain of varying origin.Drugs1980; 20(1): 24–48.
25.
ShaikhK.A., AliM., SharafatullahT.Comparative study of diclofenac sodium and flurbiprofen in osteoarthritis.J Pak Med Assoc1996; 46(12): 270–2.
26.
McKennaF., BorensteinD., WendtH., WallemarkC., LefkowithJ.B., GeisG.S.Celecoxib versus diclofenac in the management of osteoarthritis of the knee.Scand J Rheumatol2001; 30(1): 11–8.
27.
ChungC.H.A review on the use of injectable nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs in local accident & emergency practice.Hong Kong J Emerg Med2002; 9(2): 65–71.
28.
KurowskiM.Pharmacokinetics and biological availability of diclofenac preparations following intramuscular injection of 75 mg and oral administration of 150 mg of active drug.Z Rheumatol1988; 47(1): 37–42.
29.
ReinerV., ReinerA., ReinerG., ContiM.Increased absorption rate of diclofenac from fast acting formulations containing its potassium salt.Arzneimittelforschung2001; 51(11): 885–90.
30.
WillisJ.V., KendallM.J., FlinnR.M., ThornhillD.P., WellingP.G.The pharmacokinetics of diclofenac sodium following intravenous and oral administration.Eur J Clin Pharmacol1979; 16(6): 405–10.
31.
Pinto PereiraL.M., ChenD., ClementY., SimeonD.Analgesic effects of diclofenac suppository and injection after preoperative administration.Int J Clin Pharmacol Res1999; 19(2): 47–51.
32.
LotschJ., KettenmannB., RennerB.Population pharmacokinetics of fast release oral diclofenac in healthy volunteers: relation to pharmacodynamics in an experimental pain model.Pharm Res2000; 17(1): 77–84.
33.
SilvaL.C., SimoesI.G., LernerF.E., BelemG.R., de MoraesM.E., de NucciG.Comparative bioavailability of two different diclofenac formulations in healthy volunteers.Arzneimittelforschung1999; 49(11): 920–4.
34.
MarzoA., Dal BoL., VergaF.Pharmacokinetics of diclofenac after oral administration of its potassium salt in sachet and tablet formulations.Arzneimittelforschung2000; 50(1): 43–7.
35.
DaviesN.M., AndersonK.E.Clinical pharmacokinetics of diclofenac. Therapeutic insights and pitfalls.Clin Pharmacokinet1997; 33(3): 184–213.
36.
MustofaM., SuryawatiS., DwiprahastoI., SantosoB.The relative bioavailability of diclofenac with respect to time of administration.Br J Clin Pharmacol1991; 32(2): 246–7.
37.
WillisJ.V., KendallM.J., JackD.B.The influence of food on the absorption of diclofenac after single and multiple oral doses.Eur J Clin Pharmacol1981; 19(1): 33–7.
ToddP.A., SorkinE.M.Diclofenac sodium. A reappraisal of its pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic properties, and therapeutic efficacy.Drugs1988; 35(3): 244–85.
41.
LockeyA.S.Emergency department drug therapy for status epilepticus in adults.Emerg Med J2002; 19(2): 96–100.
42.
SerratriceG.Study of diclofenac injectable.Tribune Medicine1982; 46: 43–8.
43.
AliM.T., MathiasI.M.Continued problems with diclofenac injections.Anaesthesia1991; 46(12): 1089–90.
44.
BarrettP.J., FayleR.Complications following intramuscular diclofenac.Anaesthesia1992; 47(1): 83–4.
45.
TweedieD.G.Unusual reaction to diclofenac.Anaesthesia1989; 44(11): 932.
46.
SchaadH.J., ZurcherR.M.Erythema and fever after diclofenac i.m.Ther Umsch1998; 55(9): 586–8.
de CourcyJ.G., NichollsB.J.Neurogenic pain associated with diclofenac injection.Anaesthesia1993; 48(5): 455.
49.
PowerI.Muscle damage with diclofenac injections.Anaesthesia1992; 47(5): 451.
50.
PillansP.I., O'ConnorN.Tissue necrosis and necrotizing fasciitis after intramuscular administration of diclofenac.Ann Pharmacother1995; 29(3): 264–6.
51.
StrickerB.H., van KasterenB.J.Diclofenac-induced isolated myonecrosis and the Nicolau syndrome.Ann Intern Med1992; 117(12): 1058.
52.
RygnestadT., KvamA.M.Streptococcal myositis and tissue necrosis with intramuscular administration of diclofenac (Voltaren).Acta Anaesthesiol Scand1995; 39(8): 1128–30.
53.
GiovannettiM., MachadoM.A., Borrelli JuniorM., IkejiriC.I., AlonsoN., BrancoP.D.Tissue necrosis: a side effect of sodium diclofenac: report of cases and discussion of the physiopathology.Rev Hosp Clin Fac Med Sao Paulo1993; 48(1): 39–42.
54.
KornowskiR., PinesA., LevoY.Ischemic stroke following an intramuscular injection of diclofenac. Case report.Angiology1995; 46(12): 1145–7.
55.
SchabitzW.R., BergerC., KnauthM., MeinckH.M., SteinerT.Hypoxic brain damage after intramuscular self-injection of diclofenac for acute back pain.Eur J Anaesthesiol2001; 18(11): 763–5.
