For many developing countries export processing zones (EPZs) are vital investment-promotion strategies. Even though most African EPZs have not attracted much investment, interest in developing them continues to grow. Over the years EPZs have acquired a bad image because of widespread reports of violations of national and international labour standards. The experiences of countries in other regions show that labour problems arise from an underestimation of the need to address the labour-related aspects of activities in EPZs, the non-observance of national labour standards, lack of social dialogue and weak supervisory institutions. There are signs that the conditions that have led to labour problems in other regions are being replicated in Africa, causing tensions in certain zones. The article argues that on-going efforts in different regions to deal with these problems hold useful lessons for EPZ host countries in Africa.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbeywardeneJ. (1994) Export Processing Zones in Sri Lanka: Economic Impact and Social Issues. Multinational Enterprises Programme (MEP) Working Paper (WP) No. 69, Geneva: ILO.
2.
BayliesC.WrightC. (1993) “Female Labour in the Textile and Clothing Industry in Lesotho”. African Affairs, 92, pp. 577–591.
3.
BotchieG. (1984) Employment and Multinational Enterprises in Export Processing Zones: The Cases of Liberia and Ghana, MEP, WP No. 30, Geneva: ILO.
4.
Esta Semana (1991) “Cuando en espejismo quiebra”, del 3 al 19 de diciembre, San José.
5.
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (1994) International Trade: Trends and Statistics 1994, Geneva: GATT.
6.
ICFTU (1996) Behind the Wire: Anti-Union Repression in the Export Processing Zones, Brussels: ICFTU (prepared for the ICFTU by J-P Marthoz with the assistance of M. Szymanski).
7.
ICFTU (n.d.) From the Ashes: A Toy Factory Fire in Thailand (an exposé of the toy industry).
8.
International Labour Organisation/United Nations Centre on Transnational Corporations (1988) Economic and Social Effects of Multinational Enterprises in Export Processing Zones, Geneva: ILO.
9.
International Labour Office (1992) Summary of Reports submitted by Governments and by Employers' and Workers' Organisations for the Fifth Survey on the Effect Given to the Tripartite Declaration of Principles concerning Multinational Enterprises and Social Policy, submitted to the Committee on Multinational Enterprises, TDME/REP 5 (Rev.)
10.
International Labour Office (1995a) Information provided by the Government and/or EPZ Authority of Cameroon, Kenya, Madagascar: Mauritius and Nigeria.
11.
International Labour Office (1995b) Report of the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations, Report III (Part 4A) ILC 82nd Session, Geneva: ILO.
12.
International Labour Office (1997a) GB.270/3/1 (November) see Appendices I & II, pp. 11–16.
13.
International Labour Office (1997b) Report of the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations, Report III (Part 1A) International Labour Conference (ILC) 85th Session, Geneva: ILO.
14.
JaobarisonR. (1996) “Au Gouvernement de faire respecter les textes”. Madagascar TribuneNo. 2204, 25 March, p. 5.
15.
Latin American Weekly Report (1997) 5 August, p. 356.
16.
LeongA. (1994) “Masters no more”. Asian Labour Update, Issue 14, January-March, pp. 1–8.
17.
Lesotho National Development Corporation (1994) LNDC Annual Report 1993/94 (Maseru).
18.
Marchés tropicaux et méditerranéens (1994a) “Spécial Tunisie”, 16 décembre, Paris, pp. 2630–2648.
19.
Marchés tropicaux et méditerranéens (1994b) 4 mars, p. 438.
20.
Marchés tropicaux et méditerranéens (1996a) 1 mars, p. 422.
21.
Marchés tropicaux et méditerranéens (1996b) 19 avril, p. 822.
22.
Mexico and NAFTA Report (1996) “Focus on the maquiladora industry”, 13 June, pp. 3 & 6.
23.
Middle East Executive Reports (1994) September & October, Washington D.C., p. 6.
24.
NababsinghV. (1996) “Workers in EPZs in Mauritius: A Review of Employment, Workers' Rights, Working Conditions and Labour Relations”, presented at ILO Regional Workshop on the Protection of Workers' Rights and Working Conditions in EPZs, Johannesburg 15–18 July (mimeo).
25.
La Nación (1991) “Insisten en sanciones drásticas a empresas” el 29 de noviembre (San José).
26.
NevinT. (1996) “Namibia: The making of an industrial power-house”. African Business, November, pp. 8–11.
27.
RazafintsalamaH. (1996) “Un Bilan de la Zone franche industrielle de Madagascar”, Marchés tropicaux et méditerranéens, 17 mai, p. 996.
28.
RemedioE. M. (1996) Export Processing Zones in the Philippines: A Review of Employment, Working Conditions and Labour Relations, MEP, WP No. 77, Geneva: ILO.
29.
La República (1991) “Maquilas objetan informe del Ministerio de Trabajo”, el 22 de noviembre (San José).
30.
RomeroA. T. (1993) “Safety and Health in Multinational Enterprises: What Have We Learnt?”Labour Education 92–1993/3, pp. 31–42.
31.
RomeroA. T. (1995) “Labour Standards and Export Processing Zones: Situation and Pressures for Change”. Development Policy Review, 13. (3) September, pp. 247–276.
32.
SeshieD. (1996) ‘Togo: La franchise est-elle payante?”Jeune Afrique Economie, No. 220, 17 juin, pp. 60–62.
33.
SooklallM. Y. (1994) “Industrial Peace as Key to EPZ Success: The Role of Workers and their Organisations [Mauritian experience]”, Report of the Joint ILO/NECA/NLC Seminar on Industrial Relations in the Export Processing Zone held at the Nicon-Noga Hilton Hotel, Abuja, Nigeria, 13–15 October 1993, ImoisiliI. C. (ed.) Nigeria, 1994, pp. 56–64.
34.
United Nations (1995) World Investment Report, New York and Geneva: UN.
35.
United Nations (1997) World Investment Report, New York and Geneva: UN.
36.
United Nations Economic Commission for Africa (1993) The Role of Industrial Free Zones in the Industrialization of African Countries in the Context of the Second Industrial Development Decade, ECA/HDS/IPPIS/007/92, Addis Ababa.
37.
United Nations Industrial Development Organization (1993) Expert Group Meeting on Export Processing Zones Development, Management and Promotion, Vienna 8–11 Dec. 1992, Doc. No. 10.63 (SPEC).
38.
The Wall Street Journal Europe, 17 July 1995, p. 9.
39.
WeissmanR. (1996) “Waiting to Export: Africa Embraces Export Processing Zones”. Multinational Monitor, July/August, pp. 12–16.
40.
World Bank (1994) Trends in Developing Economies 1994, Washington D.C.: The World Bank.
41.
World Trade Organization (1995) International Trade: Trends and Statistics 1995, Geneva: WTO.
42.
World Trade Organization (1996) Annual Report 1996, Vol. II.
43.
ZoltyA. (1989) “Zone franche industrielle de Dakar: Nouvelle effort de promotion”. Afrique Industrie, janvier, Paris, pp. 20–22.
