The literature on the political economy of development argues that many middle-income countries could not develop strong vocational education and training systems because of the lack of political coalitions that would support such systems. However, these researchers have overlooked the role of partisan politics, domain of political competition and the links of insiders and outsiders with political parties. This article addresses this gap by studying the case of Turkey in the 2000s, when the country was governed by the Justice and Development Party and experienced important changes in its vocational education and training system. It investigates the political shifts in these years and the impact of these shifts on vocational education and training policies. The article argues that the governing Justice and Development Party played a key role in the changes in the Turkish vocational education and training system. Small and medium enterprises and labour market outsiders, which were the outsiders of the political and economic system, formed Justice and Development Party’s main constituents. Different from the previous parties, Justice and Development Party focused on the economic interests of outsiders and vocational education and training became an important tool to address such interests of both groups. The Justice and Development Party governments integrated the interests of both small and medium enterprises and workers into the vocational education and training policies in the 2000s, which has led to a vocational education and training system with high state commitment, higher firm involvement and higher permeability between vocational and general education. This research is based on process-tracing of the political dynamics and vocational education and training system developments in Turkey in 2002–2011. The data comprise primary and secondary documents, as well as interviews with several stakeholders.
Acemoglu D and Pischke J S (1999). Beyond Becker: Training in Imperfect Labour Markets. The Economic Journal 109: 112–142. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0297.00405
2.
AiyarSDuvalRPuyD, et al. (2013) Growth slowdowns and the middle-income trap. IMF Working Paper. International Monetary Fund, Washington, D.C.
3.
AnsellBW (2010) From the Ballot to the Blackboard: The Redistributive Political Economy of Education.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
4.
AshtonDGreenFJamesD, et al. (eds) (1999) Education and Training for Development in East Asia: The Political Economy of Skill Formation in Newly Industrialised Economies. 1st ed.
London:
Routledge.
5.
AydoğanoğluE (2011) Dünyada ve Türkiye’de Sendika – Siyaset İlişkisi.
Ankara:
Kültür Sanat Sen.
6.
AzevedoJPAtamanovA (2014) Pathways to the middle class in Turkey – How have reducing poverty and boosting shared prosperity helped? Policy Research Working Paper no. 6834. World Bank, Washington, D.C.
7.
BirdsallNSabotR (1997) Education growth and inequality. In: BirdsallNJaspersonF (eds) Pathways to Growth: Comparing East Asia and Latin America.
Washington, DC:
Inter-American Development Bank and John Hopkins University Press, pp. 93–130.
8.
BizzarroFGerringJKnutsenCH, et al. (2018)
Party strength and economic growth. World Politics70: 275–320.
9.
BogliacciniJAMadariagaA (2018) Skills regimes in Latin America: A comparative perspective. In: Political Economy of Skill Formation. Presented at the APSA 2018 Annual Meeting, Boston, MA.
10.
BoixC (1998) Political Parties, Growth and Equality: Conservative and Social Democratic Economic Strategies in the World Economy.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
11.
BrunsBMacdonaldIHSchneiderBR (2019)
The politics of quality reforms and the challenges for SDGs in education. World Development118: 27–38.
12.
BuğraA (1998)
Class, culture, and state: An analysis of interest representation by two Turkish business associations. International Journal of Middle East Studies30: 521–539.
13.
BusemeyerMR (2009)
Social democrats and the new partisan politics of public investment in education. Journal of European Public Policy16: 107–126.
14.
BusemeyerMR (2015a) Educational institutions and socio-economic inequality, In: Skills and Inequality: Partisan Politics and the Political Economy of Education Reforms in Western Welfare States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 177–214.
15.
BusemeyerMR (2015b) Theoretical framework: Partisan politics in context. In: Skills and Inequality: Partisan Politics and the Political Economy of Education Reforms in Western Welfare States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 29–57.
16.
BusemeyerMR (2015c) Skills and Inequality: Partisan Politics and the Political Economy of Education Reforms in Western Welfare States.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
17.
BusemeyerMR (2015d) Worlds of skill formation. In: Skills and Inequality: Partisan Politics and the Political Economy of Education Reforms in Western Welfare States. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 123–174.
18.
BusemeyerMRSchlicht-SchmälzleR (2014)
Partisan power, economic coordination and variations in vocational training systems in Europe. European Journal of Industrial Relations20: 55–71.
19.
BusemeyerMRTrampuschC (2012) Introduction: The comparative political economy of collective skill formation. In: The Political Economy of Collective Skill Formation. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 3–38.
20.
BusemeyerMRCattaneoMAWolterSC (2011)
Individual policy preferences for vocational versus academic education: Microlevel evidence for the case of Switzerland. Journal of European Social Policy21: 253–273.
21.
ÇarkoğluA (2002)
Turkey’s November 2002 elections: A new beginning?Middle East Review of International Affairs6: 30–41.
22.
ÇarkoğluA (2008)
Ideology or economic pragmatism? Profiling Turkish voters in 2007. Turkish Studies9: 317–344.
23.
ÇarkoğluA (2012)
Economic evaluations vs. ideology: Diagnosing the sources of electoral change in Turkey, 2002–2011. Electoral Studies31: 513–521.
24.
ÇarkoğluAHinichMJ (2006)
A spatial analysis of Turkish party preferences. Electoral Studies25: 369–392.
25.
ÇelikA (2013)
Trade unions and deunionization during ten years of AKP rule. Perspectives Turkey7: 44–49.
CulpepperPD (2003) Creating Cooperation: How States Develop Human Capital in Europe.
Ithaca:
Cornell University Press.
28.
De LeonCDesaiMTuğalC (2009)
Political articulation: Parties and the constitution of cleavages in the United States, India, and Turkey. Sociological Theory27: 193–219.
29.
DonerRFSchneiderBR (2016)
The middle-income trap: More politics than.World Politics68: 608–644.
30.
DonerRFSchneiderBR (2019)
Technical education in the middle income trap: Building coalitions for skill formation. The Journal of Development Studies0: 1–18.
31.
DorlachT (2015)
The prospects of egalitarian capitalism in the global South: Turkish social neoliberalism in comparative perspective. Economy and Society44: 519–544.
32.
Duran B and Yildirim E (2005) Islamism, trade unionism and civil society: The case of Hak-Iş labour confederation in Turkey. Middle Eastern Studies 41: 227–247.
EderM (2010)
Retreating state? Political economy of welfare regime change in Turkey. Middle East Law and Governance2: 152–184.
35.
EmmeneggerPHäusermannSPalierB, et al. (eds) (2012) The Age of Dualization: The Changing Face of Inequality in Deindustrializing Societies. 1st ed.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
Estevez-AbeMIversenTSoskiceD (2001) Social protection and the formation of skills: A reinterpretation of the welfare state. In: HallPASoskiceD (eds) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press, pp. 145–183.
FleckensteinTLeeSC (2019)
The political economy of education and skills in South Korea: Democratisation, liberalisation and education reform in comparative perspective. The Pacific Review32: 168–187.
45.
Garay C (2016) Social Policy Expansion in Latin America. New York: Cambridge University Press.
GürBSÖzoğluMAkgeyikT, et al. (2012) Türkiye’nin İnsan Kaynağının Belirlenmesi.
Ankara:
SETA.
48.
HaggardSKaufmanRR (2008) Development, Democracy, and Welfare States: Latin America, East Asia, and Eastern Europe.
Princeton: Princeton University Press.
49.
HansonM (2008) Economic Development, Education and Transnational Corporations.
London:
Routledge.
50.
HanushekEAWoessmannL (2008)
The role of cognitive skills in economic development. Journal of Economic Literature46: 607–668.
51.
HollandACSchneiderBR (2017)
Easy and hard redistribution: The political economy of welfare states in Latin America. Perspectives on Politics15: 988–1006. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1537592717002122
52.
Huber E (1996) Options for Social Policy in Latin America: Neoliberal versus Social Democratic Models, in: Esping-Andersen, G. (Ed.), Welfare States in Transition. London: Sage Publications, pp. 141–191.
IversenTStephensJD (2008)
Partisan politics, the welfare state and three worlds of human capital formation. Comparative Political Studies41: 600–637.
57.
KalaycıoğluE (1994)
Elections and party preferences in Turkey: Changes and continuities in the 1990s. Comparative Political Studies27: 402–424.
58.
KaradagR (2010) Neoliberal restructuring in Turkey: From state to oligarchic capitalism. MPIfG Discussion Paper 10.
59.
KaufmanRNelsonJ (2004) The politics of education sector reform: Cross-national comparisons. In: KaufmanRNelsonJ (eds) Crucial Needs, Weak Incentives.
Baltimore:
John Hopkins University Press, pp. 249–277.
60.
KenarN (2010) Mesleki ve Teknik Eğitim Sisteminin Genel Değerlendirmesi.
Istanbul:
MESS Eğitim Vakfı.
61.
KohliA (2004) State-Directed Development: Political Power and Industrialization in the Global Periphery.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
62.
LeeK (2011) Industrial upgrading and innovation capability for inclusive growth: Lessons from East Asia. In: FoxleyASossdorfF (eds) Making the Transition: From Middle-Income to Advanced Economies.
Washington, DC:
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, pp. 59–88.
63.
MardinŞ (1973)
Center-periphery relations: A key to Turkish politics?Daedalus102: 169–190.
64.
MEB (2012a) National Education Statistics: Formal Education 2011–2012.
Ankara:
MEB.
65.
MEB (2012b) Mesleki ve Teknik Eğitim Çalıştayı.
Ankara:
Başak Matbaacılık.
MiddletonJZidermanAArvilVA (1993) Skills for Productivity: Vocational Education and Training in Developing Countries.
Washington, DC:
Oxford University Press.
NilssonA (2010)
Vocational education and training – An engine for economic growth and a vehicle for social inclusion?International Journal of Training and Development14: 251–272.
71.
OECD (2018) Dataset: Trade Union Density. Paris: OECD.
72.
OECD (2019) Education Database: Enrolment by Type of Institution, OECD Education Statistics (Database). Paris: OECD.
73.
OECD (2019) Education Database: Educational expenditure by source and destination OECD Education Statistics (database), https://doi.org/10.1787/1c1c86c4-en (accessed on 07 November 2019).
Öztürk A (2018) Islamists against the class cleavage: identity formation and interest representation in the case of Hak-İş in Turkey. Middle Eastern Studies 54: 459–474.
81.
PattonMJ (2009)
The synergy between neoliberalism and communitarianism: ‘Erdoğan’s Third Way’.Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East29: 438–449.
82.
RanisGStewartFRamirezA (2000)
Economic growth and human development. World Development28: 197–219.
83.
RodrikD (2015)
Premature deindustrialization.NBER Working Paper20935: 1–33.
RuedaD (2006)
Social democracy and active labour-market policies: Insiders, outsiders and the politics of employment promotion. British Journal of Political Science36: 385–406.
86.
SancakM (2011) Social Security Reforms in Clientelistic Social Policy Regimes: A Comparison between the Turkish and Greek Cases (MSc).
Oxford:
University of Oxford.
87.
SancakMÖzelI (2018)
When politics gets in the way: Domestic coalitions and the making of skill systems. Review of International Political Economy25: 340–363.
88.
SchneiderBR (2004)
Organizing interests and coalitions in the politics of market reform in Latin America. World Politics56: 456–479.
89.
SchneiderBR (2009)
Hierarchical market economies and varieties of capitalism in Latin America. Journal of Latin American Studies41: 553–575.
90.
SchneiderBR (2013) Hierarchical Capitalism in Latin America: Business, Labor, and the Challenges of Equitable Development.
New York:
Cambridge University Press.
91.
SchneiderBRKarcherS (2010)
Complementarities and continuities in the political economy of labour markets in Latin America. Socio-Economic Review8: 623–651.
92.
SecorAJ (2001)
Ideologies in crisis: Political cleavages and electoral politics in Turkey in the 1990s. Political Geography20: 539–560.
93.
ŞencanH (2008) Türkiye’de Mesleki ve Teknik Eğitim: Sorunlar ve Öneriler. İstanbul: MÜSİAD.
94.
Taşkın-AlpY (2014) State Policies on Vocational High Schools in Turkey 1970–2013 (MA).
Istanbul:
Boğaziçi University.
95.
TaşlıV (2017) MNCs and Host Country Employment Institutions: A Comparative Case Study of Automotive Firms in Turkey’s VET System (PhD).
Manchester:
University of Manchester.
96.
TEPAV (2010) BECERİ’10 Uzmanlaşmış Meslek Edindirme Merkezleri Projesi.
Ankara:
TEPAV.
97.
ThelenK (2014) Vocational education and training. In: Varieties of Liberalization and the New Politics of Social Solidarity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 71–111.
98.
ThelenK (2004) How Institutions Evolve: The Political Economy of Skills in Germany, Britain, the United States, and Japan.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
99.
TOBB (2006) TOBB 5. Sanayi Kongresi.
Ankara:
TOBB.
100.
TOBB (2015) VII. Türkiye Ticaret ve Sanayi Şurası.
Ankara:
TOBB.
101.
TOBB-ETÜ (2011) BECERİ’10 Projesi Kapsamında Yapılanlar ve Yapılacaklar.
Ankara:
TOBB-ETÜ.
102.
TuğalC (2012)
Fight or acquiesce? Religion and political process in Turkey’s and Egypt’s neoliberalizations. Development and Change43: 23–51.
TÜSİAD (2011) Türkiye’de Mesleki ve Teknik Eğitim Hakkında TÜSİAD Görüş Dokümanı.
İstanbul:
TÜSİAD.
105.
UNDP IICPSD (2014) How the Private Sector Develops Skills: Lessons from Turkey.
New York:
UNDP.
106.
WadeR (1990) Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization.
Princeton: Princeton University Press.
107.
World Bank (2008) Investing in Turkey’s Next Generation: The School-to-Work Transition and Turkey’s Development.
Washington, DC:
World Bank.
108.
World Bank (2013) Enterprise Surveys Turkey (Dataset).
Washington, DC:
World Bank.
109.
World Bank (2019) Secondary Education, Vocational Pupils & Secondary Education, Pupils. World Development Indicators (Dataset).
Washington, DC:
World Bank.
