Analysing the reform of the retail financial advice sector in the United Kingdom from an agencement and performativity perspective

Abstract

The Retail Distribution Review of the regulation of financial advice resulted in a series of reforms to the UK retail advice sector in 2012. This is the latest in a series of initiatives addressing what are identified as market failures in the UK’s retail advice sector. This article uses the notions of performativity and agencement to elaborate and explain the processes by which reforms based on the economic theory of market efficiency have failed to address adequately consumer financial advice issues in the UK. The result has been a range of unresolved and unexpected problems. It is argued that the lack of success of a series of regulatory reforms intended to improve access to advice for UK consumers is destined to continue as long as the notion of market failure dominates regulatory reform.

Keywords

Retail Distribution Review performativity regulation advice

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atkinson A, McKay SD, Kempson E and Collard S (2006) Levels of financial capability in the UK: Results of a baseline survey (Consumer Research 47). Financial Services Authority.

Backhaus JG (ed.) (2012) Handbook of the History of Economic Thought: Insights on the Founders of Modern Economics. London: Springer.

Bamford M (2006) The public is very confused. IFAOnline. Available at: http://www.professionaladviser.com/ifaonline/opinion/1348116/the-public-confused (accessed 13th July 2007).

Butler JP (1993) Bodies That Matter: On the Discursive Limits of “Sex”. New York. Routledge.

Callon

(2005) Why virtualism paves the way to political impotence: A reply to Daniel Miller’s critique of the laws of markets. Economic Sociology: European Electronic Newsletter 6(2): 3–20.

Callon M (2006) What does it mean to say that economics is performative? CSI Working Article Series No.005, 2006. Available at: http://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/docs/00/09/15/96/PDF/WP_CSI_005.pdf (accessed 11th April 2014).

Callon

Latour

(1981) Unscrewing the Big Leviathan: How actors macrostructure reality and how sociologists help them to do so. In: Knorr-Cetina

Cicourel

(eds) Advances in Social Theory and Methodology: Toward an Integration of Micro- and Macro-Sociologies, Boston, MA: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Callon M, Millo Y and Muniesa F (eds) (2007) Market Devices. Oxford. Blackwell Publishing.

CII (Chartered Insurance Institute) (2010) What We Talk About When We Talk About Trust: The Future of Trust in Insurance and Financial Services, London: Chartered Insurance Institute.

10.

CII (Chartered Insurance Institute) (2011) Professionalism for the 21st Century – Revisited. Articles in Professionalism 10. London: Chartered Insurance Institute.

11.

CISI (Chartered Institute for Securities and Investment) (2012) CISI introduces mandatory integrity and ethics testing for members. Press Release, 28th March, 2012. Available at: http://www.cisi.org/bookmark/genericform.aspx?form=29848780&url=80134336 (accessed 7th July 2014).

12.

Clare

(2013) The Guidance Gap: An Investigation of the UK’s Post-RDR Savings and Investment Landscape, London: FIL Investment International.

13.

Clare A, Thomas S, Walgama O, et al. (2013) The impact of the RDR on the UK’s market for financial advice: Challenge and opportunity. June 2013. CASS Consulting. CASS Business School. Available at: http://www.cass.city.ac.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0016/202336/The-impact-of-RDR-Cass-version.pdf (accessed 7th July 2014).

14.

Clery E, Humphrey A and Bourne T (2010) Attitudes to Pensions: The 2009 Survey. Research Report No. 701. London: Department of Work and Pensions.

15.

Clery E, Mckay S, Phillips M, et al. (2007) Attitudes to Pensions: The 2006 Survey. Research Report No. 434. Leeds: Department for Work and Pensions.

16.

Cumbo J (2014) Citizens advice and TPAS to provide pension guidance. Financial Times, 18th October 2014. Available at: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/78c2be74-561e-11e4-93b3-00144feab7de.html#axzz3KdM7HcPp (accessed 11th November 2014).

17.

Dasgupta P (2007) Economics: A Very Short Introduction. New York. Oxford University Press.

18.

Davies H (2000) Open Letter from Howard Davies to the Chancellor of the Exchequer dates 1st November 2000. Available at: http://www.fsa.gov.uk/pubs/press/2000/135_letter.pdf (accessed 7th June 2014).

19.

Dean

(1996) Putting the technological into government. History of the Human Sciences 9(3): 47–68.

20.

Deleuze

Guattari

(1987) A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism and Schizophrenia, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

21.

Deloitte (2012) Recognising RDR reality: The need to challenge planning assumptions. Available at: https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/uk/Documents/financial-services/deloitte-uk-fs-recognising-rdr-reality.pdf (accessed 7th May 2014).

22.

Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (2013) The International Survey of Adults Skills 2012: Adult Literacy, Numeracy and Problem-Solving Skills in England. BIS Research Article No. 139. October, 2013. London: Department for Business, Innovation and Skills.

23.

Dixon

(2006) Rethinking Financial Capability: Lessons from Economic Psychology and Behavioural Finance, London: Institute for Public Policy Research.

24.

Dunn S (2009) Six scandals from the darkest days of an already murky industry. The Observer Online, 21st June 2009. Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/money/2009/jun/21/financial-advisers-scandals (accessed 7th July 2014).

25.

Edelman (2012) 2012 Edelman Trust Barometer: Executive Summary. Chicago, Ilinois, USA: Edelman.

26.

Elliott A, Dolan P, Vlaev I, et al. (2011) Transforming Financial Behaviour: Developing Interventions That Build Financial Capability. CFEB Consumer Research Report 01. July 2010. London. Consumer Finance Education Board.

27.

FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) (2013a) Supervising Retail Investment Advice: How Firms are Implementing the RDR. Thematic Review TR13/5. July 2013. London: Financial Conduct Authority.

28.

FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) (2013b) Supervising Retail Investment Advice: Delivering Independent Advice. March 2014. London: Financial Conduct Authority.

29.

FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) (2014a) Retail Investment Advice: Clarifying the Boundaries and Exploring the Barriers to Market Development. Guidance consultation. July 2014. London: Financial Conduct Authority.

30.

FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) (2014b) Developments in the Distribution of Retail Investments: Purchasing Investments Without a Personal Recommendation or With Simplified Advice. Thematic Review TR 14/10. July 2014. London: Financial Conduct Authority.

31.

FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) (2015) Conduct of Business Sourcebook. Available at: http://fshandbook.info/FS/html/FCA/COBS (accessed 12th January, 2015).

32.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2002a) Reforming Polarisation: Making the Market Work for Consumers. Consultation Article 121. London: FSA.

33.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2002b) Polarisation: Consumer Research, London: FSA.

34.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2003) Reforming Polarisation: Removing the Barriers to Choice. Consultation Article 166. London: FSA.

35.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2006) Financial Capability in the UK: Establishing a Baseline. London, FSA.

36.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2007) A Review of Retail Distribution. Discussion Article 07/01. London: FSA.

37.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2008a) Retail Distribution Review. Feedback Statement 08/06. London: FSA.

38.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2008b) Consumer Responsibility, Discussion Article 08/5. London: FSA.

39.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2009a) Distribution of Retail Investments: Delivering the RDR. Discussion Article 09/18. London: FSA.

40.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2009b) Delivering the Retail Distribution Review: Professionalism; Corporate Pensions; and Applicability of RDR Proposals to Pure Protection Advice. Consultation Article 9/31. London: FSA.

41.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2010) Delivering the RDR: Professionalism, Including its Applicability to Pure Protection Advice, With Feedback to CP09/18 and CP09/31. Consultation Article 10/14. London: FSA.

42.

FSA (Financial Services Authority) (2015) RDR Library. Available at: http://www.fsa.gov.uk/about/what/rdr/rdr-library#cp (accessed 8th August 2014).

43.

Foucault

(1970) The Order of Things, London: Navistock.

44.

Fowler S (2011) Reforming the Financial Advice Market: Bridging the Gap or Widening the Chasm. London. Fowler Drew. Available at: http://www.fowlerdrew.co.uk/monkey/wp-content/uploads/rdr-research-article-july20111.pdf (accessed 12th August 2013).

45.

Fundscape (2014) Navigating the Post-RDR Landscape in the UK: Assessing the Potential Impact of an RDR Regime on the European Fund Industry, London: Fundscape.

46.

Georgosouli

(2007) The debate over the economic rationale for investor protection regulation: A critical appraisal. Journal of Financial Regulation and Compliance 15(3): 236–249.

47.

Goff S and Cadman E (2014) UK banks count climbing cost of PPI mis-selling. Financial Times online, 3rd February 2014. Available at: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/8310b6ec-8ced-11e3-ad57-00144feab7de.html#axzz39ilDIrVS (accessed 7th July 2014).

48.

Hamilton P (2014) The blurred line between advice and information. Money Marketing, 28th July 2014. Available at: http://www.moneymarketing.co.uk/2012410.article?cmpid=pmalert_439364 (accessed 11th August, 2014).

49.

Henriksen

(2013) Economic models as devices of policy change: Policy paradigms, paradigm shift, and performativity. Regulation & Governance 7: 481–495.

50.

House of Commons Public Accounts Committee (2009) Skills for Life: Progress in Improving Adult Literacy and Numeracy, Third Report of Session 2008–09. Available at: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200809/cmselect/cmpubacc/154/154.pdf (accessed 17th January 2013).

51.

Hurman N and Costain I (2012) Researching the ‘Advice Gap’. March 2012. Financial Services Consumer Panel. Available at: http://www.fs-cp.org.uk/publications/pdf/advice-gap.pdf (accessed 13th April 2014).

52.

Llewellyn D (1999) The Economic Rationale for Financial Regulation. Occasional Article No. 1. London: Financial Services Authority.

53.

MacKenzie

(2006) An Engine, Not a Camera: How Financial Models Shape Markets, Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

54.

MacKenzie D (2007) Is economics performative? Option theory and the construction of derivative markets. In: Mackenzie D, Muniesa F and Siu L (eds) Do Economists Make Markets: On the Performativity of Economics. Princeton: Princeton University Press, pp.54–86.

55.

Mackenzie

Muniesa

Siu

(2007) Do Economists Make Markets: On the Performativity of Economics, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

56.

Moore

(2007) General Equilibrium and Welfare Economics: An Introduction, Berlin: Springer.

57.

Muniesa F, Millo Y and Callon M (2007) An introduction to market devices. In: Callon M, Millo Y and Muniesa F (eds) Market Devices. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, pp.1–12.

58.

National Numeracy (2014) Facts and Figures. Available at: http://www.nationalnumeracy.org.uk/what-the-research-says/index.html (accessed 16th August 2014).

59.

NMG Consulting (2014) The Motivations, Needs and Drivers of Non-Advised Investors. A Qualitative Research Report, London: NMG Consulting.

60.

OECD (2013) OECD Skills Outlook 2013: First Results from the Survey of Adult Skills. OECD Publishing. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264204256-en (accessed 17th July 2014).

61.

OECD (2014) Economic Outlook 2014, May 2014. Available at: http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/household-saving-rates-forecasts_2074384x-table7 (accessed 19th July 2014).

62.

OFT (Office of Fair Trading) (1999) The Rules on the Polarisation of Investment Advice: A report by the Director General of Fair Trading, London: Office of Fair Trading.

63.

ONS (Office for National Statistics) (2010) Social Trends, No. 40, 2010 Edition. Available at: http://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/social-trends-rd/social-trends/social-trends-40/index.html (accessed 17th July 2014).

64.

Personal Financial Education Group (2013a) Annual Report 2013: Making a Difference. London: PFEG.

65.

Personal Financial Education Group (2013b) Financial education’s place in the new National Curriculum confirmed. 12th September 2013. Available at: http://www.pfeg.org/about-us/news/financial-educationper centE2per cent80per cent99s-place-new-national-curriculum-confirmed (accessed 7th July 2014).

66.

Preda A (2007) Where do analysts come from? The case of financial chartism. In Callon M, Millo Y and Muniesa F (eds) Market Devices. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, pp.40–64.

67.

Redman

(2000) Introduction. In: du Gay

Evans

Redman

(eds) Identity: A Reader, London: Sage, pp. 9–14.

68.

Reichmann C (2014) National IFA chief calls for end to advice ‘middle ground’. Professional Adviser, 3rd March 2014. Available at: http://www.professionaladviser.com/ifaonline/news/2331849/national-ifa-chief-calls-for-end-to-advice-middle-ground (accessed 12th June 2014).

69.

Ring

(2004) A critical analysis of depolarisation. Journal of Financial Regulation and Compliance 12(3): 248–262.

70.

Ring

(2010) Governance and governmentality: A discussion in the context of UK private pension provision. Economy and Society 39(4): 534–550.

71.

Sandel

(2012) What Money Can’t Buy. The Moral Limits of Markets, London: Allen Lane.

72.

Sandler

(2001) Review of Medium and Long-Term Retail Savings, London: HM Treasury.

73.

Selnow

(2004) Motivating retirement planning: Problems and solutions. In: Mitchell

Utkus

(eds) Pension Design and Structure: New Lessons From Behavioural Finance, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 43–52.

74.

Thaler

Sunstein

(2008) Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness, New Haven: Yale University Press.

75.

the Money Advice Service (2011) The Money Advice Service Launches To Give Free, Unbiased Advice To All. Press Release, 4th April, 2011. Available at: https://www.moneyadviceservice.org.uk/en/static/money-advice-service-launches (accessed 11th July 2013).

76.

the Money Advice Service (2013) The Financial Capability of the UK. November, 2013. London: The Money Advice Service.

77.

the Money Advice Service (2014) About us. Available at: https://www.moneyadviceservice.org.uk/en/static/about-us (accessed 17th July, 2014).

78.

The Personal Finance Society (2014) The RDR and Consumers: The Public’s Views Towards the Retail Investment Advice Market. February 2014. London: The Personal Finance Society.

79.

Webb

Watson

Ring

Bryce

(2014) Pension confusion, uncertainty and trust in Scotland: An empirical analysis. Journal of Social Policy 43(3): 595–613.

80.

Wonderling

(2005) Introduction to Health Economics, Maidenhead: Open University Press.