The formal texts of agreements establishing European works councils (EWCs) set out the ‘starting conditions’ that regulate the activity of these transnational institutions. This article complements an analysis of the formal texts of agreements in 111 EWCs in the metallurgical, chemical and financial sectors with an assessment of the experience of Portuguese members of these EWCs. An analysis of topics in the 111 EWC agreements reveals several difficulties with the functioning of EWCs. Beyond the texts of EWC agreements, the diversity of workers’ representatives’ experiences is crucial to a better understanding of how EWCs function. The final section of the article highlights several good practices experienced by (Portuguese) workers’ representatives belonging to three EWC select committees in three multinationals: VW Group (metallurgical sector), Air Liquide Group (chemical sector) and Banco Espírito Santo Group (financial sector).
BuschakW (1995) European works councils open new horizons. Transfer1(1): 133–135.
2.
BuschakW (2000) Review of the EWC Directive. In: GabaglioEHoffmannR (eds) European Trade Union Yearbook, 1999. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute, pp.161–172.
3.
CarleyMMarginsonP (2000) Comités d’entreprise européens: une etude comparative entre les accords visés à l’article 6 et à l’article 13. Luxembourg: Offices des publications officielles des Communautés européennes.
4.
CGTP (1995) Manual: Comités de Empresa Europeus. Lisbon: CGTP (mimeo).
5.
CGTP (2012) Programa de Acção (XII Congresso). Lisbon: CGTP.
6.
CostaHA (2006) Portuguese trade unionism vis-à-vis the European Works Councils. In: SantosBSNunesJA (eds) Reinventing democracy: grassroots movements in Portugal. London: Routledge, pp.218–252.
7.
CostaHA (2012) From Europe as a model to Europe as austerity: the impact of the crisis on Portuguese trade unions. Transfer18(4): 397–410.
8.
CostaHAAraújoP (2008) European Companies without European Works Councils: Evidence from Portugal. European Journal of Industrial Relations14(3): 309–325.
9.
CostaHAAraújoP (2009) As vozes do trabalho nas multinacionais: o impacto dos Conselhos de Empresa Europeus em Portugal. Coimbra: Almedina/CES.
10.
CostaHACostaPR (2011) Informação e consulta de trabalhadores nas multinacionais: análise do impacto dos Conselhos de Empresa Europeus em Portugal nos sectores metalúrgico, químico e financeiro(proj. III/7/2008). Final Research Report of the project funded by the Instituto de Investigação Interdisciplinar da Universidade de Coimbra. Coimbra: Instituto de Investigação Interdisciplinar da Universidade de Coimbra.
11.
DornelasA (2009) Perante a crise: problemas e perspectivas do emprego, do trabalho e da equidade social em Portugal. Finisterra65/66: 101–133.
12.
FerreiraAC (2012) Sociedade da austeridade e direito do trabalho de exceção. Lisbon: Vida Económica.
13.
FerreiraACCostaHA (1998/99) Para uma sociologia das relações laborais em Portugal. Revista Crítica de Ciências Sociais52/53: 141–171.
14.
GilmanMMarginsonP (2004) Negotiating European Works Councils. Contours of constrained choice. In: FitzgeraldIStirlingJ (eds) European Works Councils. Pessimism of the intellect, optimism of the will?London: Routledge, pp.93–112.
15.
HallM (2003) Unions seek more influence for EWCs. International Union Rights10(1): 6–7.
16.
HannD (2010) The continuing tensions between European works councils and trade unions – a comparative study of the financial sector. Transfer16(4): 525–540.
17.
KerckhofsPPasI (2006) European Works Councils Database – 2006. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute.
18.
LamersJJM (2010) EWC’s role recast: A European actor? In: DorssementFBlankeT (eds) The Recast of the European Works Council Directive. Antwerp: Intersentia, pp.357–397.
19.
LecherWNagelBPlatzerH-W (1999) The Establishment of European Works Councils: From Information Committee to Social Actor. Aldershot: Ashgate.
20.
LecherWPlatzerH-WRübS. (2001) European Works Councils: developments, types and networking. Aldershot: Gower.
21.
LecherWPlatzerH-WRübS. (2002) European Works Councils: negotiated Europeanism. Between statutory framework and social dynamics. Aldershot: Ashgate.
22.
LeiteJ (1996) Conselhos de Empresa Europeus: Comentários à Directiva 94/45/CE. Lisbon: Cosmos.
23.
MarginsonPGilmanMJacobiO (1998) Negotiating European Works Councils: an analysis of agreements under article 13. Report for the European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions and the European Commission. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.
24.
PaternotreM (1998) La Directive ‘Comité d’Entreprise Européen’. État des lieux avant révision. Observatoire Social Européen, Working Paper 21.
25.
RamsayH (1997) Fool’s Gold? European Works Councils and workplace democracy. Industrial Relations Journal28(4): 314–322.
26.
SpeidelF (2012) The ‘Volkswagen Law’ – guarantor of extended co-determination rights and international trade union solidarity. Transfer18(4): 497–501.
27.
StoleroffA (2013) A crise e as crises do sindicalismo: há uma revitalização possível? In: VarelaR (ed.) A Segurança Social é Sustentável. Trabalho, Estado e Segurança Social em Portugal. Lisbon: Bertrand, pp.207–239.
28.
TelljohannV (ed.) (2005) Quality inventories on the operation and results of European Works Councils. Bologna: Fondazione Istituto per il Lavoro.
WaddingtonJ (2003) What Do Representatives Think of the Practices of European Works Councils? Views from Six Countries. European Journal ofIndustrial Relations9(3): 303–325.
31.
WaddingtonJ (2006) How EWC members see it. Mitbestimmung International Edition8: 41–44.
32.
WaddingtonJ (2011) European Works Councils: a transnational industrial relations institution in the making. London: Routledge.
33.
WhittallMKnudsenHHuijgenF (eds) (2007) Towards a European Labour Identity. The Case of European Works Councils. London: Routledge.
34.
WhittallMKotthoffH (2011) Les comités d’entreprise européens, des zones libres de syndicats?La revue de L’Ires68(1): 207–233.
35.
WillsJ (2001) Uneven geographies of capital and labour: the lessons of European Works Councils. In: WatermanPWillsJ (eds) Place, space and the new labour internationalisms. Oxford: Blackwell, pp.180–205.
36.
WillsJ (2004) Re-scaling trade unions organizations: Lessons from the European front line. In: MunckR (ed.) Labour and Globalisation. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, pp.85–104.
