Recent research has highlighted the shifting media representation of para-athletes some of whom have been increasingly visible as national sporting figures. Their mediation entangles themes of disability, nationalism, gender and technology. In this light, we explore New Zealand print media narrativisation of the nation's most prolific disability athlete, para swimmer Sophie Pascoe. First, we contextualise Pascoe's emergence as a national sporting icon characterised by plaudits and awards. Second, we explore the press narrativisation of Pascoe between 2005 and 2020 which entangled intersecting tropes of disability, athleticism, femininity and ‘kiwi’ nationalism. Pascoe is narrated as a national hero who overcomes both competitors and her disability, which is made ‘hypervisible’. There are contradictions and tensions in this narration. Her gendering reflects a ‘post-feminist’ sensibility; poised between individualistic strength and overcoming, yet simultaneously emotional fragility, dependence and dimunition as a ‘babe’ and ‘princess’. Her celebration contradictorily affirms hierarchies of disability, centring the ‘able-disabled’. The mediation of Pascoe is symptomatic of an ableist rehabilitation supercrip narrative that frames New Zealand sport (and the nation writ large) as progressive and inclusive, yet selectively celebrates an idealised type of disabled athlete.
Banet-WeiserSGillRRottenbergC.(2000)Postfeminism, popular feminism and neoliberal feminism? Sarah banet-weiser, rosalind gill and catherine rottenberg in conversation. Feminist Theory21(1): 3–24.
BarwellI (2009) Understanding narratives and narrative understanding. The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism67(1): 49–59.
5.
BooherAK (2010) Docile bodies, supercrips, and the plays of prosthetics. IJFAB: International Journal of Feminist Approaches to Bioethics3(2): 63–89.
6.
BruceT (2009) Winning space in sport: The Olympics in the New Zealand sports media. In Olympic Women and the media. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 150–167.
7.
BruceT (2014) Us and them: The influence of discourses of nationalism on media coverage of the paralympics. Disability and Society29(9): 1443–1459.
8.
BruceTPringleR (2015) Manliness and mountaineering: Sir Edmund Hillary as New Zealand adventurer and male icon. In KnijnikJAdairD (eds). Embodied Masculinities in Global Sport. Morgantown, VA, USA: Fitness Information Technology Press, pp. 171–196.
9.
BruceTScott-ChapmanS (2010) New Zealand: Intersections of nationalism and gender in Olympics newspaper coverage. In BruceTHovdenJMarkulaP. Sportswomen at the Olympics., Rotterdam: Sense Publishers, pp. 273–287.
10.
BuysseJAMBorcherdingB (2010) Framing gender and disability: A cross-cultural analysis of photographs from the 2008 paralympic games. International Journal of Sport Communication: 3(3): 308–321.
11.
CheongJPGKhooSRazmanR (2016) Spotlight on athletes with a disability: Malaysian newspaper coverage of the 2012 London Paralympic games. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly33(1): 15–32.
12.
CherneyJLindemannKHardinM (2015) Research in communication, disability, and sport. Communication and Sport3(1): 8–26.
CosgroveABruceT (2005) “The way New Zealanders would like to see themselves”: Reading white masculinity via Media coverage of the death of sir peter blake. Sociology of Sport Journal22: 336–355.
15.
de LéséleucEPappousAMarcelliniA(2010)The media coverage of female athletes with disability. Analysis of the daily press of four European countries during the 2000 Sydney Paralympic Games. European Journal for Sport and Society7(3–4): 283–296.
16.
EllisKGogginG (2015) Disability and the media. Basingstoke, England: Palgrave MacMillan.
17.
Falcous, M., & Turner, L. (2021). Sport, nationalism, and the narration of cultural scripts: The death of Colin Meads and the New Zealand imagination. Sociology of Sport Journal, 1(aop): 1–10.
18.
FrenchLLe Clair JM2018Game changer? Social media, representations of disability and the paralympic games. In The Palgrave Handbook of Paralympic Studies. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 99–121.
19.
GilchristP (2006) The politics of totemic sporting heroes and the conquest of EverestAnthropological Notebooks12(2): 35–52.
20.
GillR (2007) Postfeminist media culture: Elements of a sensibility. European Journal Of Cultural Studies10(2): 147–166.
21.
GrueJ (2015) The problem of the supercrip. Disability Research Today: International Perspectives204–218.
22.
Hardin MMHardinB (2004) The ‘supercrip; in sport media: wheelchair athletes discuss hegemony’s disabled hero. Sociology of Sport Online-SOSOL, 7(1).
23.
HowePD (2011) Cyborg and supercrip: The paralympics technology and the (dis) empowerment of disabled athletes. Sociology45(5): 868–882.
HowePDSilvaCF (2017)The cyborgification of paralympic sport. Movement and Sport Sciences-Science and Motricité (97): 17–25.
26.
KamaA (2004) Supercrips versus the pitiful handicapped: Reception of disabling images by disabled audience members. Communications447–466.
27.
KearneySBrittainIKipnisE (2019) “Superdisabilities” vs “disabilities”? theorizing the role of ableism in (mis) representational mythology of disability in the marketplace. Consumption Markets and Culture22(5–6): 545–567.
28.
KingSJ (2005) Methodological contingencies in sport studies. In AndrewsDLMasonDSSilkML (Ed.), Qualitative Methods in Sports Studies. Oxford, UK: Burg, pp. 21–39.
29.
MaikaMDanylchukK (2016) Representing paralympians: The ‘other’ athletes in Canadian print media coverage of London 2012. The International Journal of the History of Sport33(4): 401–417.
30.
McDonaldMGBirrellS (1999) Reading sport critically: A methodology for interrogating power. Sociology of Sport Journal16: 283–300.
31.
McGillivrayDO’DonnellHMcPhersonG,et al. (2019) Repurposing the (super) crip: Media representations of disability at the Rio 2016 Paralympic Games. Communication and Sport9(1): 3–32.
32.
McPhersonGO’DonnellHMcGillivrayD, et al. (2016) Elite athletes or superstars? Media representation of para-athletes at the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth games. Disability and Society31(5): 659–675.
33.
McRobbieA (1992) New sexuality in girls’ and women’s magazines. In Back to Reality?: Social Experience and Cultural Studies. Manchester: Manchester University Press, pp. 190.
34.
MitchellTSnyderS (2015) The biopolitics of disability: neoliberalism, ablenationalism, and peripheral embodiments. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
35.
PappousAMarcelliniAde LéséleucE. (2011) Contested issues in research on the media coverage of female paralympic athletes. Sport in Society14(9): 1182–1191.
36.
PascoeS (with Tony Smith) (2013) Sophie Pascoe – Stroke of Fate. Welington: Royal New Zealand Foundation of the Blind.
37.
PhillipsJ (1987) A Man’s Country?: The Image of the Pākehā Male, a History. Auckland, NZ: Penguin Books.
38.
PringleR (2017) Males, masculinities and gender relations: A socio-historic examination and critique. In BellAElizabethVMcIntoshTWynyardM (eds.) A Land of Milk and Honey? Making Sense of Aotearoa. New Zealand Auckland: Auckland University Press, pp. 198–211.
39.
PullenEJacksonDSilkM (2020) (Re-) presenting the paralympics: Affective nationalism and the “able-disabled”. Communication and Sport8(6): 715–737.
40.
PullenEJacksonDSilkM, et al. (2019) Re-presenting the paralympics:(contested) philosophies, production practices and the hypervisibility of disability. Media, Culture And Society41(4): 465–481.
41.
PullenEJacksonDSilkM, et al.(2020)Extraordinary normalcy, ableist rehabilitation, and sporting ablenationalism: The cultural (Re) production of paralympic disability narratives. Sociology of Sport Journal1: 1–9.
42.
PullenESilkM (2020) Gender, technology and the ablenational paralympic body politic. Cultural Studies34(3): 466–488.
43.
ReesLRobinsonPShieldsN (2019) Media portrayal of elite athletes with disability–a systematic review. Disability and Rehabilitation41(4): 374–381.
44.
SchantzOJGilbertK (2001) An ideal misconstrued: Newspaper coverage of the Atlanta Paralympic games in France and Germany. Sociology of Sport Journal18(1): 69–94.
45.
SchellLABDuncanMC (1999) A content analysis of CBS’s coverage of the 1996 paralympic games. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly16(1): 27–47.
46.
SilvaCFHoweD (2012) The (in) validity of supercrip representation of paralympian athletes. Journal of Sport and Social Issues36(2): 174–194.
47.
SmartB (2005) The sport star: Modern sport and the cultural economy of sporting celebrity. London: Sage.
48.
SmithAThomasN (2005) The ‘inclusion’ of elite athletes with disabilities in the 2002 manchester commonwealth games: An exploratory analysis of British newspaper coverage. Sport, Education and Society10(1): 49–67.
49.
SmithBSparkesAC (2009b) Narrative analysis and sport and exercise psychology: Understanding lives in diverse ways. Psychology Of Sport And Exercise10(2): 279–288.
50.
SmithBSparkes AC (2009a) Narrative inquiry in sport and exercise psychology: What can it mean, and why might we do it?Psychology of Sport and Exercise10(1): 1–11.
51.
AndrewsDJacksonS (2001) Sport stars. The cultural politics of sporting celebrity. London and New York: Routledge.
52.
TasconS (2008) Narratives of race and nation: Everyday whiteness in Australia. Social Identities, Journal for the study of Race, Nation and Culture14(2): 253–274.
53.
ThomasNSmithA (2003) Preoccupied with able-bodiedness? An analysis of the British media coverage of the 2000 paralympic games. Adapted Physical Activity Quarterly20(2): 166–181.
54.
ToffolettiK (2016) Analyzing media representations of sportswomen—expanding the conceptual boundaries using a postfeminist sensibility. Sociology Of Sport Journal33(3): 199–207.
55.
ToffolettiK (2018) Sport, postfeminism and women with disabilities: Female paralympians on social media. In New Sporting Femininities. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 253–275.
