Corsi,Fenwick and Gramsci: How bloggers and advanced analytics are changing the National Hockey League

Abstract

Since the early 2000s, an ever growing online community of bloggers and amateur statisticians has been developing a new set of advanced analytics and performance metrics for the National Hockey League. Many of the people who are driving innovation in this field are not data scientists but, rather, intellectually curious fans of the game, who are playing a significant role in reshaping the way the game is consumed and understood. Yet, despite the body of knowledge created online, only within the last few years have the National Hockey League and the mainstream sport media begun to take notice of these innovations. I argue that the analytics movement is being driven from the fans up, rather than from the National Hockey League and other professional leagues down, and that the drivers of this movement are examples of what Antonio Gramsci calls ‘organic intellectuals’ – the analytics camp is locked into its own ‘war of position’ against the hegemony of traditional hockey fans, coaches, management and sport media. My research explores the resistance Internet-based content creators have experienced from established hockey media personalities (‘Hockey Men’) and the National Hockey League itself, connecting this resistance to a growing trend away from evidence-based discourse in the current Western media landscape.

Keywords

data science Gramsci hockey organic intellectuals mainstream media NHL social media

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alamar

Mehotra

(2012) Analytics and sports part III. Analytics Magazine. Available at: http://analytics-magazine.org/analytics-a-sports-part-iii-improving-resource-allocation-with-portfolio-decision-analysis/ (accessed 29 May 2018).

Anderson

(2016) The path to war. CrowdScout Sports. Available at: www.crowdscoutsports.com/game-theory/the-path-to-war/ (accessed 27 May 2018).

Bairner

(2009a) Sport, intellectuals and public sociology: Obstacles and opportunities. International Review for the Sociology of Sport 44(2–3): 115–130.

Bairner

(2009b) Re-appropriating Gramsci: Marxism, hegemony and sport. In: Carrington

McDonald

(eds) Marxism, Cultural Studies and Sport. London: Routledge, pp.195–212.

Beck

(2013) Advanced statistics added to revamped NBA site. New York Times, 14 February. Available at: www.nytimes.com/2013/02/15/sports/basketball/nbas-site-to-feature-updated-statistics-database.html?_r=2& (accessed 4 April 2019).

Bourne

(2018) What does an NHL statistical analyst do, how do the numbers shape strategy and where is this all going? The Athletic. Available at: https://theathletic.com/435131/2018/07/17/bourne-what-does-an-nhl-statistical-analyst-do-how-do-the-numbers-shape-strategy-and-where-is-this-all-going/ (accessed 17 July 2018).

CBC News (2016) Postmedia–Sun merger ‘foolishly’ accepted by competition bureau, prof says. CBC News, 10 January. Available at: www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/postmedia-cuts-ottawa-sun-follow-1.3411579 (accessed 17 July 2018).

Chan

Cho

Novati

(2012) Quantifying the contribution of NHL player types to team performance. Interfaces 42(2): 131–145.

Cleland

(2014) Racism, football fans and online message boards: How social media has added a new dimension to racist discourse in English football. Journal of Sport and Social Issues 38(5): 415–431.

10.

Cleland

(2015) Discussing homosexuality on association football fan message boards: A changing cultural context. International Review for the Sociology of Sport 50(2): 125–140.

11.

Crehan

(2016) Gramsci’s Common Sense: Inequality and Its Narratives. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

12.

Dallaire

Denis

(2000) ‘If you don’t speak French, you’re out’: Don Cherry, the Alberta Francophone Games, and the discursive construction of Canada’s Francophones. The Canadian Journal of Sociology 25(4): 415–440.

13.

Farkas

Schou

(2018) Fake news as floating signifier: Hegemony, antagonism and the politics of falsehood. Javnost: The Public 25(3): 298–314.

14.

Fry

Ohlmann

(2012) General sports applications. Interfaces 42(2): 105–108.

15.

Geertz

(1973) The Interpretation of Cultures. New York: Basic Books.

16.

Gillet

White

Young

(1996) The prime minister of Saturday night: Don Cherry, the CBC, and the cultural production of intolerance. In: Holmes

Taras

(eds) Seeing Ourselves: Media Power and Policy in Canada. Toronto, ON: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, pp.59–72.

17.

Gramsci

(1971) Selections from the Prison Notebooks. London: Lawrence and Wishart.

18.

Gruneau

Whitson

(1993) Hockey Night in Canada: Sport, Identities, and Cultural Politics. Toronto, ON: Garamond Press.

19.

Hall

Farrington

Price

(2013) Twitter, disintermediation and the changing role of the sports journalist. In: Gordon

(ed.) Br(e)aking the News: Journalism, Politics and New Media. Frankfurt: Peter Lang AG, pp.165–179.

20.

Hall

(2019) Taylor Hall on Twitter, 31 May. Available at: https://twitter.com/hallsy09/status/1134536367873167360 (accessed 3 June 2019).

21.

Henderson

(2017) Oh, hi Todd. Oilers Nation. Available at: https://oilersnation.com/2017/12/02/oh-hi-todd/ (accessed 29 May 2018).

22.

Himma-Kadakas

(2017) Alternative facts and fake news entering journalistic content production cycle. Cosmopolitan Civil Societies: An Interdisciplinary Journal 9(2): 25–40.

23.

Holstein

Gubrium

(1995) The Active Interview. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

24.

Jhally

(1989) Cultural studies and the sports/media complex. In: Wenner

(ed.) Media, Sports, and Society. London: SAGE, pp.70–96.

25.

Kozinets

(2010) Netnography: Doing Ethnographic Research Online. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

26.

Laclau

(2014) The Rhetorical Foundations of Society. London: Verso.

27.

Lile

(2016) The factors working against advanced stats in hockey. WFAA, 28 July. Available at: www.wfaa.com/article/sports/nhl/the-factors-working-against-advanced-stats-in-hockey/283414597 (accessed 30 July 2016).

28.

McDonald

(2013) The reproduction of biological ‘race’ through physical education textbooks and curriculum. European Physical Education Review 19(2): 183–198.

29.

Millington

(2015) ‘The datafication of everything’: Toward a sociology of sport and big data. Sociology of Sport Journal 32(2): 140–160.

30.

Norman

(2012) Saturday night’s alright for tweeting: Cultural citizenship, collective discussion, and the new media consumption/production of Hockey Day in Canada. Sociology of Sport Journal 29(3): 306–324.

31.

Norman

(2014) Online community or electronic tribe? Exploring the social characteristics and spatial production of an Internet hockey fan culture. Journal of Sport and Social Issues 38(5): 395–414.

32.

Norman

Esmonde

Szto

(2019) Public sociology of sport and digital media: A self-reflexive analysis of public engagement in the ‘hockey blogosphere’. Sociology of Sport Journal 36(2): 135–143.

33.

Proteau

(2016) Hockey’s advanced stats proponents best served by a teaching spirit. In: Hockeybuzz. Available at: www.hockeybuzz.com/blog/Adam-Proteau/Hockeys-advanced-stats-proponents-best-served-by-a-teaching-spirit/225/78284 (accessed 22 May 2018).

34.

Pucktistic (2017) On John Chayka, hockey media and the myth of ‘hockey men’. Five for Howling. Available at: www.fiveforhowling.com/2017/5/1/15479398/nhl-mark-spector-arizona-coyotes-on-john-chayka-hockey-media-and-the-myth-of-hockey-men (accessed 26 May 2018).

35.

Richardson

(2014) Analytics gaining acceptance in the NHL. Spector’s Hockey. Available at: www.spectorshockey.net/2014/08/analytics-gaining-acceptance-in-the-nhl/ (accessed 29 May 2018).

36.

Seraj

(2012) We create, we connect, we respect, therefore we are: Intellectual, social, and cultural value in online communities. Journal of Interactive Marketing 26(4): 209–222.

37.

Spector

(2017) Adam Larsson’s Oilers prevail in game Taylor Hall’s never could have. Sportsnet, 27 April. Available at: www.sportsnet.ca/hockey/nhl/adam-larssons-oilers-prevail-game-taylor-halls-never/ (accessed 29 May 2018).

38.

Stinson

(2017) Long after Moneyball, skeptics and nerds are still fighting about analytics. National Post, 28 December. Available at: https://nationalpost.com/sports/long-after-moneyball-skeptics-and-nerds-are-still-fighting-about-analytics (accessed 29 May 2018).

39.

Vollman

(2016) Stat Shot: The Ultimate Guide to Hockey Analytics. Toronto, ON: ECW Press.

40.

Vollman

(2018) Stat Shot: A Fan’s Guide to Hockey Analytics. Toronto, ON: ECW Press.

41.

Whitson

Gruneau

(2006) Introduction. In: Whitson

Gruneau

(eds) Artificial Ice: Hockey, Culture, and Commerce. Peterborough, ON, Canada: Broadview Press, pp.1–25.

42.

Yost

(2014) New NHL stat hires challenge conventional media paradigm on analytics. Sporting News, 11 August. Available at: https://www.sportingnews.com/us/nhl/news/one-more-thing-hockey-analytics-nhl-numbers-corsi-fenwick-tyler-dellow-oilers/1je2hmrg5ufx41ccj8qhho3mxa (accessed 22 May 2018).