Health Research: A Tool for Social Justice and the Poor

Abstract

Health research can, and must, contribute to the alleviation of social injustice and powerlessness and their consequences. In so doing, it needs to ensure that the poor are healthy, productive and happy (that is, they can enjoy the fruits of their productivity).

Poverty, unemployment and low health status are symptoms of deprivation borne of powerlessness. Therefore, health research that empowers the researched must address their poverty, unemployment as well as vulnerability to diseases. This can be achieved through their participation in the research funding process. The appropriate participatory research design must allow the poor and deprived to participate in research design, implementation, analysis, and dissemination of information. Such an approach is essential in order to avoid studying the poor to enrich the wealthy.

Experiences with, and examples of, health research have demonstrated the consequences of ignoring the need to place the well-being of the researched at the centre of analysis. These have resulted in career advantages for the researchers and the manipulation of results without social justice for the researched. Research has also lead to monetary responses to deprivation without addressing the social and economic inequalities accompanying powerlessness. A shift in the centre of analysis could precipitate different results and actions. It would enable the poor to study the rich to learn how to become wealthy and achieve social justice.

Keywords

Unemployment Pacific deprivation and health health research social justice poverty powerlessness

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Durie MA. Maori perspective on health. Soc Sci Med 1985;20:483–5.

2. Blaidsell RK. The health status of Kanaka Maoli (Indigenous Hawaiians). Asian-Am Pac Islander J Health 1993;1 (2):117–60.

3. Weeramanthri TS , Plummer C. Land, body and spirits; talking about adult mortality in an Aboriginal community. Aust J Public Health 1994;18:197–200.

4. Finau SA.

Development and health in the Pacific: which way to die?

P N G Med J 1993;36:324–36.

5. Werner D. The life and death of primary health care. (The McDonalization of Alma Ata). Pac Health Dialog 1996;3(1): 81–9.

6. Barnett P. Unemployment, work and health: opportunities for healthy pub-licpolicy. NZ Med J 1995;108:138–40.

7. Kerr C , Tavlor R. Overview Of unemployment and health. In: Procedding of the First Australian Conference on Unemployment and Health 1992. Department Of Public Health, University of Sydney: 3–15.

8. Whelan CT. The role of income, lifestyle deprivation and financial strain in mediating the impact of unemployment on psychological distress: evidence from the Republic of Ireland. J Occup Orhanisation Psychol 1992;65:331–4.

9. Jackson PR , War PB. Mental health of unemployed men in different parts of England and Wales. Bri Med J 1987;295:525–7.

10.

10. Fryer D , Payne R. Being unemployed: a review of the literature on the psychological experience of unemployment. In: Cooper CL , Robertson I , editors. International Review of Industrial and Organizational Psychology. J Wiley, London; 1986:235–78.

11.

11. Finau SA. Health research in the Pacific: in search of a reality. NZ Med J 1995;108:16–9.

12.

12. Kapeer N. Monitoring poverty as if gender mattered : a methodology for rural Bangladesh. IDS Discussion Paper 225: February 1989.

13.

13. Bolton W , Oatley P. A longitudinal study of social support and depression in unemployed men. Psychol Med 1987;17:453–60.

14.

14. Weil DEC , Alicbusan AP , Wilson IF et al. The Impact of Development Policies on Health. WHO Geneva: 1990.

15.

15. Graetz B. Health consequences of employment and unemployment: longitudinal evidence for Young men and women. Soc Sci Med 1993;36:715–24.

16.

16. Chambers R. Poverty in India: concepts, research and reality. IDS Discussion Paper 241, January 1988.

17.

17. Wennemo L. Infant mortality, pubic policy and inequality - a comparison of 18 industrialised Countries 1950 −1985. Social Health Illness 1993;15:429–46.

18.

18. Siegert RJ , Chun-RC , Taylor AJ. Unemployment stress and social support. Community Ment Health N Z 1990;5:49–59.

19.

19. Finau SA. The Tongan family: relevance to health. N Z Med J 1982;95:880–3.

20.

20. Altman D. The primacy of politics: organisms around AIDS. AIDS 1991;5 (Supplement 2): 5231–8.

21.

21. VanMeijl T. A Maori perspective on health and its politicization. Med Anthropol 1993;15:283–97.

22.

22. Leeflang RLI , Klein-Hesselink DJ , Spruit IP. Health effects of unemployment - II: men and women. Soc Sci Med 1992:34:351–63.

23.

23. Wadsworth Y. The politics of social research: a social research strategy for the community health, education and welfare movements. Aust J Soc Issues 1982:17(30): 232–46.

24.

24. Abdel-Smith B. Poverty, Development and Health Policy. WHO, Geneva: 1978.

25.

25. Nossal GJV. The Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research 1965-1995: from basic research to clinical triumphs. Med J Aust 1995;163:599–603.

26.

26. Firkin BG. As times goes by: reflections on 40 years of academic medicine and biomedical research. Med J Aust 1995, 163:604–6.

27.

27. Finau SA. Health science of the South Pacific: the challenge. Fiji Med J 1992;18:29–34.

28.

28. Moodie R. The politics of evaluating Aboriginal health services. Community Health Studies 1989;XIII(4): 503–09.

29.

29. Armstrong MJ , Armstrong RW. New Zealand Maori women's health: status and self help action 1980s. Women Health 1991;17: 45–64.

30.

30. Reid E. Placing women at the centre of the analyses : the case of HIV/ AIDS. Pac Health Dialog 1995;2 (1):69–72.

31.

31. Scanlon JW , Horst P , Nay JN el al. Evaluability assessment: avoiding Type III and Type IV errors. In: Gilbert GR , Conklin PJ , editors. Evaluation Management: A Source Book of Readings. Chariotville, US Civil Service Commision: 1977

32.

32. WHO. Development of Indicators for Monitoring Progress Towards Health for All by the Year 2000. WHO, Geneva: 1981.

33.

33. Giusti WL , Yates NA , McDougall, JG. Where the national research dollar goes; allocation of NHMRC resources to clinical categories, 1989-1995. Med J Aust 1995;163: 607–8.

34.

34. Benson PR. The social control of human biomedical research: an overview and review of the literature. Soc Sci Med 1989;29: 1–12.

35.

35. Hall D. The research imperative and bureaucratic control: the case of clinical research. Soc Sci Med 1991; 32:333–42.

36.

36. Lewis PJ. The drawbacks of Research Ethic Committees. J Med Ethics 1982;6: 61–3.

37.

37. Brown JL , Gershoff SN , Cook JT. The politics of hunger: when science and ideology clash. Int J Health Serv 1992;22:221–37.

38.

38. Thomson IE. , French K , Melia KM , et al. Research Ethical Committees in Scotland. Bri Med J 1981:282:718–20.

39.

39. Brooks CH. The Influence of medical school clinical experiences on career preferences: a multidimentional perspective. Soc Sci Med 1991; 327–32.