West German Defence Cooperation and Secret Arms Exports to Pakistan in the 1960s

Abstract

Based almost entirely on declassified government documents, this article seeks to provide, for the first time, a comprehensive evaluation of the Federal Republic of Germany’s (FRG) defence cooperation and the transfer of small arms, ammunition and missiles under a 1962 secret defence agreement as well as the saga of the clandestine transfer of aircraft and (unsuccessful) export of tanks to Pakistan in the 1960s. West Germany was well aware that the real motivation behind the Pakistani acquisition of arms and ammunition was to use them in a fratricidal conflict with India. An ‘influential’ Pakistani lobby, working assiduously in the West German Federal Foreign Office and West German Federal Ministry of Defence, was responsible for the sale of the F-86s. The FRG’s refusal of large-scale deliveries to Pakistan was largely because of apprehensions that an Indian recognition of the German Democratic Republic’s actions would have a cascading effect on developing countries.

Keywords

Federal Republic of Germany Pakistan India arms exports South Asia United States

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akten zur Auswärtigen Politik der Bundesrepublik Deutschland (AAPbD) [Documents on the Foreign Policy of the Federal Republic of Germany]. (1962, June 16). Trützschler von Falkenstein, German Ambassador to Pakistan, Karachi, to the Foreign Office. Telex no. 91, 114-5302/62 secret. AAPbD 1962, Band [vol.] 1, Doc. 251.

AAPbD. (1963a, May 13/15). German-American Coordination Meeting, Bonn, III A 4-81.00/430/63 secret. Band 1, Doc. 166 (Munich: R. Oldenbourg Verlag, 1994).

AAPbD. (1963b, September 20). Conversation, Foreign Minister Gerhard Schröder with Foreign Minister Dean Rusk, Washington, D.C., Z A 5 113.A/63 secret. Band 1, Doc. 349].

AAPbD. (1963c, October 5). German-American Coordination Meeting, Washington, D.C., III A 4-852/63 secret. Band 1, Doc. 378.

AAPbD. (1965a, October 11 and 13). Cf. Wire Report No. 709 und 724, Confidential-Band 2593 (I Β 5), Β150, Aktenkopien 1965, Band 1, Doc. 259.

AAPbD. (1965b, May 14). Cf. Record of Ernst Ingendaay, Representative of the Head, Department of International Economic Issues, Defence, Traffic, Post and Telecommunications and Tourism, Foreign Office, Berlin VS-Bd. [confidential-vol.] 5125 (III A 4); Β 150, Aktenkopien [File Copies] 1965. Cited in AAPbD 1965, Band 1, Doc. 214.

AAPbD. (1965c, January 19). Summary of the Conversations of Pakistani Foreign Minister Z. A. Bhutto in Bonn, 15–16 January 1965. Record by Hilmar Bassler, [Head of the South and East Asian Department, Foreign Office], I Β 5-82.21/92.32/40II/65 secret. Band 1, Doc. 24. (Munich: R. Oldenbourg Verlag, 1996).

AAPbD. (1965d, October 19). Cf. Department III A 4, Band 571. Cited in AAPbD 1965, Doc. 407.

AAPbD. (1965e, May 20). ‘German Help for the Expansion of the Pakistani Defence Industry’, Record, Hans Graf von Hardenberg, Ministerial Director [rank equivalent to Additional Secretary, MEA] and Head, Subdivision A, Department for Trade and Development Policy, Foreign Office, Berlin. Referat [Department] III A 4-81.10/1-92.3-541/65 VS-vertraulich [classified-confidential]. Band 1, Doc. 214.

10.

AAPbD. (1965f, October 29). Summary by Ministerial Director Hermann Meyer-Lindenberg, Head, Political Department I, I Β 5-83.00-92.32/1944/65 secret. Band 1, Doc. 407.

11.

AAPbD. (1965g, September 29). Norbert Berger, Head, Subdivision B, Department for Trade and Development Policy, Foreign Office, Berlin to German Embassy, Karachi about the result of a meeting between Rolf Lahr, State Secretary, Foreign Office and Karl Gumbel, State Secretary, Ministry of Defence. Cf. Telegram No. 3949; VS-Bd. 5125 (III A 4); Β 150, File Copies 1965. Cited in AAPbD 1965, Band 1, Doc. 407.

12.

AAPbD. (1965h, November 8). Cf. Telegram of Ministerial Director Günther Harkort, Head, Department for Trade and Development Policy, Department] III B 1, Band 437. Cited in Band 1, Doc. 407.

13.

AAPbD. (1966a, August 1). Freiherr von Mirbach, German Ambassador to India, New Delhi, to the Foreign Office, Ζ Β 6-1-11246/66 classified-confidential, Telex No. 660. Band 1, Doc. 259.

14.

AAPbD. (1966b, May 2). Cf. Summary of Department] III A 4, 6 October 1966; Department] III A 4, Vol. 571. Cited in AAPbD 1966, Band 1, Doc. 129.

15.

AAPbD. (1966c, July 5). Cf. Wire Report No. 553; Confidential-Vol. 2593 (I Β 5); Β150, Aktenkopien 1966. Band 1, Doc. 259.

16.

AAPbD. (1966d, August 8). Ministerial Director Hermann Meyer-Lindenberg, Head, Political Department 1 to Shishir Kumar Banerji, Indian Ambassador to Germany about the Statement of the Federal Government on the sale of Sabre VI aircraft to Iran. Cf. Confidential-Vol. 5122 (III A 4); Β150, Aktenkopien 1966. Band 1, Doc. 259.

17.

AAPbD. (1967, September 26). State Secretary Rolf Lahr [in Islamabad at the time] to the Foreign Office, Ζ Β 6-1-14497/67 secret, Telex No. 284, Urgent, Band 1, Doc. 331 (Munich: R. Oldenbourg Verlag, 1998).

18.

AAPbD. (1968a, April 9). Summary of Legationsrats Karl Münch, Department for South- and East Asia, Foreign Office, I B 5-84.05/1-92.32/68. Band 1, Doc. 122.

19.

AAPbD. (1968b, June 20). Ministerial Director Harkort. Cf. Department 403, Band 764. Doc. 101.

20.

AAPbD. (1968c, June 6). ‘Visit of M. A. Rahman, Embassy of Pakistan [Germany]’, Summary of Otto Soltmann [Head, Department of International Economic Issues, Defence, Transport, Postal and Telecommunications and Tourism, Foreign Office], Department III A 4-81.20-92.32-585/68 VS-vertraulich. Doc. 180.

21.

Adenauer

(1961, January 19). Press conference in Teegesprӓche 1959-1961. Siedler Verlag, 1991.

22.

Allardt

(1962a, June 20). Letter, Ministerial Director [equivalent to Additional Secretary, MEA] Helmut Allardt [Head, Department 4 ‘Trade Policy Department’] to German Embassy, Karachi. AAPbD 1962 (Munich: R. Oldenbourg Verlag, 2010), Band 1, Doc. 251, p. 1125, Footnote 7.

23.

Allardt

(1962b, November 12). Cf. Telegram No. 212 of Ministerial Director Allardt to the German Embassy, Karachi; VS-Bd. 5032 (III A 4); Β 150, Aktenkopien 1962. Cited in AAPbD 1962, Band 1, Doc. 444.

24.

Becker

(1962, June 20). Cf. Enclosure to Letter, Brigadier General Herbert Becker [Head, Subdivision, ‘Defence Economic Planning’, Ministry of Defence], to Johann von Stechow [Head, Department 406, ‘International Economics Questions of Defence’, Foreign Office], 5 June 1962 VS-Bd. 5082 (III A 4); Β 150, Aktenkopien 1962. Cited in AAPbD 1962 (Munich: R. Oldenbourg Verlag, 2010), Band 1, Doc. 251.

25.

Berger

(1965, September 29). Telegram No. 3951, of Head, Subdivision B of Department for Trade and Development Policy, VS-Band 5125 (III A 4); Β150, Aktenkopien 1965. Cited in AAPbD (1966, 2 May. Discussion of Foreign Minister Gerhard Schröder with Ghulam Faruque Khan, Pakistani Federal Minister for Commerce and Defence Advisor, Ζ A 5-32.A/66 VS-vertraulich. AAPbD 1966, Band 1, Doc. 129, p. 566, Footnote 16.

26.

Caroll, Lt. Gen. J. F. (1967, May 5). Statement by Director, Defense Intelligence Agency. US, 90th Cong., 1st sess., 1967, Executive Sessions of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, vol. 19, Washington, DC, 2006).

27.

Cummings

(1967, April 13). Statement of President, International Armament Corp. (Interarmco). Cited in US Congress, 90th, 1st sess., Senate, Committee on Foreign Relations, Subcommittee on Near Eastern and South Asia Affairs, Hearings, Arms Sales to Near East and South Asian Countries. Washington, DC., p. 29.

28.

Das Gupta

(2004). Handel, Hilfe, Hallstein-Doktrin: Die bundesdeutsche Suedasienpolitik unter Adenauer aund Erhard 1949 bis 1966. Mattjoesem Verlag.

29.

Das Gupta

(2015, May 25). The Alliance of the Crestfallen. Outlook. https://magazine.outlookindia.com/story/the-alliance-of-the-crestfallen/294337

30.

Der Spiegel. (1967, August 21). Falsche Perser [False Persians]. Nr. 35, pp. 20, 22–23.

31.

Der Spiegel. (1974, November 18). Mit Billetal und BND [With Billetal and BND [German Foreign Intelligence Service], pp. 65–69.

32.

Dowling

(1962, May 25). Defense: Disposition of Equipment and Materials’, Agreement effected by exchange of notes. Department of Defence. US, 90th Cong., Senate, Committee on Foreign Relations, 1st sess., Hearings, Arms Sales to Near East and South Asian Countries. U.S. Government Printing Office.

33.

Feinstein

(2011). The shadow world: Inside the global arms trade. Hamish Hamilton.

34.

Gervasi

(1981). American Military Power in the 1980s and the Origins of the Cold War with a Survey of American Weapons and Arms Exports. The Book Service.

35.

Globe and Mail. (1966, August 17). Expect Bonn to ask for Ottawa permit to sell more Sabres.

36.

Hoopes

T. W.

(1967, April 25). Statement of the Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defence for International Security Affairs, Department of Defence. US, 90th Cong., Senate, Committee on Foreign Relations, 1st sess., Hearings, Arms Sales to Near East and South Asian Countries. U.S. Government Printing Office.

37.

Kamath

M. V.

(1966, August 11). Bonn makes ‘Lame Excuses’ over overhaul of Sabres in Pakistan. Times of India.

38.

Khan

(1967). Friends not masters: A political biography. Oxford University Press.

39.

Khan

O. H.

(2005). Instruments of influence: Canada and arms exports to South Asia, 1947–1971 [Unpublished master’s thesis]. Department of History, Carleton University.

40.

Kuss Jr.

H. J.

(1967, March 14). Statement by Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defence. US, 90th Cong., Senate, Committee on Foreign Relations, 1st sess., Hearings, Arms Sales to Near East and South Asian Countries. U.S. Government Printing Office.

41.

Kuss Jr.

H. J.

(1968, May 14). Sale of M-47 Tanks by Italy to Pakistan, Arms Sales to Pakistan. Statement by Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defence. US, 90th Cong., 2nd sess., 1968, Executive Sessions of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee (Historical Series), vol. 20. US Government Printing Office, 2010.

42.

Library and Archives Canada. (1965). Record Group 20, Vol. 1657, File 20-242-15, part 1, External to Washdc, NOVI 9/65.

43.

Manocherians

, & Curtis

(2017). The strange case of the Iranian Canadair CL-13B Sabres. Small Air Forces Observer, 40(4), 112–116. archive.org/stream/alan_147/SAFO%20160_djvu.txt

44.

Politisches Archiv des Auswӓrtigen Amts (PA) [Political Archive of the Foreign Office, Berlin]. (1956, December 6). Ministerbüro [Ministerial Office], Band 19, Private Service Letter of Hans Podeyns [German Ambassador in Karachi] to Foreign Minister Heinrich von Brentano.

45.

PA. (1957, April 4). Ref 709, Band 1437. Summary, File No. 317-82.50/92.32/375/57, Schmidt-Horix.

46.

PA. (1962, June 5). Department III A 4, Band 750, Administrative Agreement attached to a Letter of the Ministry of Defence to the Foreign Office, VLR I v. Johann von Stechow [Head, Department 406, International Economic Questions of Defence, Foreign Office] W I-Diary No. 763II/62 secret.

47.

PA. (1965a, December 10). Department III B 7, Band 571. Letter to Department III A 4, File No. IB5-84.00/92.32, Carstens.

48.

PA. (1965b, January 18). Ref III B 7, Band 750. Schreiben of Department III A 6 to Department IV B 5 of Federal Ministry of Economics, i.A. Kl.

49.

PA. (1965c, October 29). B 150, 1965. Secret Paper, Hermann Meyer-Lindenberg [Head, Political Department 1, Foreign Office] to Karl Carstens, State Secretary, Foreign Office, No. 1944/65 secret; PA, Ref III B 7, Band 580. Undated Overview of ‘Authorized Shipments of Arms and Ammunition to Pakistan’.

50.

PA. (1965d, January 6). Ref I B 5, Band 21, Letter of Department I B 5 to Department III A 4, [Hilman] Bassler [Head, Department South and East Asia, Foreign Office].

51.

PA. (1965e, September 7). Ref I B 5, Band 198. List of Arms Exports to India and Pakistan from 1963 to 1965’, Attachment to a Letter of Department III A 6 to Department I B 5.

52.

PA. (1965f, December 9). PA, B 150, 1965. Telegram no. 538, Günther Scholl, German Ambassador in Pakistan, Karachi, cited in VS-Tgb. [confidential-classified Diary] No. 10226/65 secret.

53.

PA. (1966a, September 19). B 150, 1966. Summary, Hilmar Bassler [Head Department, South- and East Asia, Foreign Office], File No. IB5-1177I/66 secret.

54.

PA. (1966b, January 5). B 150, 1966. Letter, Günther Harkort, [Head, Department, Trade and Development Policy, Foreign Office] to the State Secretary, Foreign Office, File No. III A 4-81/10/1--92.18-4/66 VS-V [classified-confidential].

55.

PA. (1966c, July 5). B 150, 1966. Telegram, German Embassy, New Delhi, File No. IB5-88-78 SSTR 66 classified–confidential, No. 553.

56.

PA. (1966d, May 6). Ref I B 5, Bd. 274. Letter, Günther Scholl [German Ambassador to Pakistan at the time in Bonn], VSNfD [For Official use only], p. 442, Note 489.

57.

PA. (1966e, October 6). Ref III B 7, Band 571. Paper, File No. III A 4-81.10-81.30-92.32, Subject: Discussion Briefs for the Trip of Chancellor [Ludwig Erhard], here: Armaments Cooperation with Pakistan.

58.

SIPRI. (1977). Arms trade with the third world. Stockholm.

59.

Stanley

, & Pearson

(1972). The international trade in arms. Praeger.

60.

Trützschler von Falkenstein

(1962, May 19). Report, German Ambassador to Pakistan, Karachi. VS-Band [classified-vol.] 5082 (III A 4); Β 150, File Copies 1962. Cited in AAPbD 1962, Doc. 251.

61.

Venkataramani

M. S.

(1982). The American role in Pakistan, 1947–1958. Radiant.