Comparison of Whistle-blower Protection Mechanism of Select Countries

Abstract

Whistle-blower protection mechanisms (WPMs) play a critically significant role in combating corruption through ethics, corporate governance and statutes. This article examines the essence of whistle-blower mechanism existing in the developed and developing countries in order to unearth the legislative structure of countries supporting the whistle blower mechanism and pursuit of ethical conduct for sound corporate governance. The article attempts to identify, evaluate and analyse the attributes of whistle-blower mechanism across nations and finds that despite off-symmetric attributes, the mechanisms are asymmetric specific to the countries’ corporate culture. It has also been found that most significant attribute of a sound whistle-blower mechanism is the level of protection provided to the whistle-blowers followed by coverage of sectors, anonymity and the regulator of whistle-blowing complaints in the country. The attributes vary widely across nations on the basis of coverage of sectors, anonymity withheld and the level of protection, with United States of America delivering the best protection to whistle-blowers trailed by Australian whistle-blower protection laws and then South Africa; India, China and Indonesia lag considerably behind in having a sound whistle-blower mechanism.

Keywords

Corporate governance whistle blowing whistle blower protection mechanism AHP technique Delphi technique Legislative reforms

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander

(2005). The role of whistleblowers in the fight against economic crime. Journal of Financial Crime , 12(2), 131–138.

Armstrong

Francis

(2015). Protecting the whistleblower (pp. 583–601). Chetenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Bajpai

G. N.

(2016). The essential book of corporate governance . New Delhi, India: SAGE Publications.

Banisar

(2011). Whistleblowing: International standards and developments. In Sandoval

(Ed.), Corruption and transparency: Debating the frontiers between state, market and society . Washington, DC: World Bank-Institute for Social Research.

Brennan

N. M.

Solomon

(2008). Corporate governance accountability and mechanisms of accountability: An overview. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal , 21(7), 885–906.

Cadbury

(1992). Report of the committee on the financial aspects of corporate governance . London: Great Britain: Burgess Science Press.

Callahan

E. S.

Dworkin

T. M.

(1994). Who blows the whistle to the media and why: Organisational characteristics of media whistleblowers. American Business Law Journal , 32 (2), 151–184.

Cavico

F. J.

(2004). Private sector whistleblowing and the employment at-Will doctrine. South Texas Law Review , 54 (3), 543–645.

Chen

Chan

C. K.

(2009). Research on Chinese accounting issues. The Chinese Economy , 26(5), 98–128.

10.

Collier

(2007). The bottom billion. Economic Review—Deddington , 25(1), 17.

11.

Cook

(1981). Whistleblowers—Friend or foe? Industry Week , 211(1), 50–56.

12.

Council of Europe. (2014). Protection of whistleblowers. Recommendations CM/REC (2014) on the protection of whistleblowers . Retrieved 13 August 2017, from https://rm.coe.int/16807096c7#search=protection%20of%20whistleblowers%20G20

13.

De Brauw Blackstone Westbroek. (2013). Transparency international’s principles on whistleblowing . Amsterdam: De Brauw Blackstone Westbroek.

14.

Das

Barman

(2010). An AHP framework of supplier evaluation with reference to high value and critical items: A case study. International Journal of Services and Operations Management , 7 (4), 465–482.

15.

Davis

(1989). Avoiding the tragedy of whistleblowing. Journal of Business and Professional Ethics , 8 (4), 3–19.

16.

Delbecq

ven

A. V.

Gustafson

(1975). Group techniques for program planning: A guide to nominal and Delphi processes . Glenview, IL: Scott, Forseman & Co.

17.

Dempster

(1997). Whistleblowers . Sydney, NSW: ABC Books.

18.

Devine

T. M.

(1999). The whistleblower protection act of 1989: Foundation for the modern law of employment dissent. American Law Review , 51(2), 531–579.

19.

Devine

Walden

(2012). International best practices for whistleblower policies. Government Accountability Project (GAP). Retrieved 13 April 2018 from http://www.whistlebower.org/storage/documents/Best_Practices_Document_for_website_March_13_2013.pdf

20.

Devine

Walden

(2013). International best practices for whistleblower policies . Retrieved 13 April 2018 from https://www.whistleblower.org/sites/default/files/pictures/Best_Practices_Document_for_website_March_13_2013.pdf

21.

Dozier

J. B.

Miceli

M. P.

(1985). Potential predictors of whistle-blowing: A prosocial behavior perspective. The Academy of Management Review , 10(4), 823–836.

22.

Eisenhardt

K. M.

(1989). Agency theory: An assessment and review. Academy of Management Review , 14(1), 57–74.

23.

Ellliston

F. A.

(1982a). Anonymity and whistleblowing. Journal of Business Ethics , 1(3), 167–177.

24.

Ellliston

F. A.

(1982b). Civil disobedience and whistleblowing: A comparative appraisal of two forms of dissent. Journal of Business Ethics , 1(1), 23–28.

25.

Farrell

Peterson

J. C.

(1982). Patterns of political behavior in organization. Academy of Management Review , 7(3), 403–412.

26.

Fasterling

Lewis

(2014). Leaks, legislation and freedom of speech: How can the law effectively promote public interest whistleblowing. International Labour Review , 153(1), 71–92.

27.

Ferguson

G. A.

(2015). Global corruption: Law, theory and practice . Canada: International Centre for Criminal Law Reform and Criminal Justice Policy.

28.

Ffolkes-Goldson

(2015). Commonwealth Caribbean corporate governance . London: Routledge.

29.

Francis

R. D.

Armstrong

(2011). Corruption and whistleblowing in International humantarian aid agencies. Journal of Financial Crime , 18(4), 319–335.

30.

Francis

Armstrong

Foxley

(2015). Whistleblowing: A three part view. Journal of Financial Crime , 22 (2), 208–218.

31.

Government of Canada. (2004). A comparative international Analysis of regimes for the disclosure of wrongdoing (Whistleblowing) . Ottawa: Public Service Integrity Office.

32.

Heacock

M. V.

McGee

G. W.

(1987). Whistleblowing: An ethical issue in organizational and human behavior. Business and Professional Ethics Journal , 6(4), 35–46.

33.

Homewood

Lewis

D. B.

(2009). Five years of the public interest disclosure act in the UK: Are whistleblowers adequately protected? Middlesex University Research Repository , 5, 1–9.

34.

Hsu

C. C.

Sandford

(2007). The Delphi technique: Making sense of consensus. Practical Assessment, Research & Evaluation , 12(10), 1–8.

35.

James

(1980). Whistleblowing: its nature and justification. In Profits and Professions (pp. 287–303). NY: Humana Press.

36.

Janis

(1972). Victims of groupthink: A psychological study of foreign-policy decisions and fiascoes. Boston and Houghton: Mifflin.

37.

Janis

Mann

(1977). Decision making . New York, NY: Free Press.

38.

Jensen

Meckling

(1976). Theory of the firm: Managerial behaviour, agency costs and ownership structure. Journal of Financial Economics , 3 (4), 305–360.

39.

Latimer

Brown

A. J.

(2008). Whistleblower laws: International best practices. UNSW Law Journal , 31 (3), 766–794.

40.

Lewis

D. B.

Carr

(2010). Combating corruption through employment law and whistleblower protection. Industrial Law Journal , 39(1), 1–30.

41.

Lewis

Homewood

(2004). Five years of public interest disclosure act in the UK: Are whistleblowers adequately protected? Web Journal of Current legal issues . Retrieved from http://webjcli.ncl.ac.uk/2004/issue5/dlewis5.html#Heading96

42.

Lindeman

(1975). Delphi survey of priorities in clinical nursing research. Nursing Research , 24 (6), 434–441.

43.

(2017). China SOX: What is it and why was it introduced? WSEAS Transactions on Business and Economics , 14, 446–457. Retrieved from http://www.wseas.org/multimedia/journals/economics/2017/a925907-035.pdf

44.

Maria

W. D.

(2002). Common law—common mistakes: The dismal failure of whistleblower laws in Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Ireland and United Kingdom, University of Indiana, 12-13 April 2002. International Whistleblowers Conference.

45.

Miceli

Near

(1985). Characteristics of organisational climate and perceived wrongdoing associated with whistleblowing. Personnel Psychology , 38 (3), 525–544.

46.

Miceli

Near

(1992). Blowing the whistle: The organization and legal implications for companies and employees . New York, NY: Exington Books.

47.

Miceli

Near

(2002). What makes whistleblowers effective? Three field studies. Human Relations , 55 (4), 455–479.

48.

Miceli

M. P.

Near

J. P.

Schwenk

(1991). Who blows the whistle and why? ILR Review , 45(1), 113–130.

49.

Nader

Petkas

P. J.

Blackwell

(1972). Whistleblowing . New York, NY: Grossman Publishers.

50.

Near

J. P.

Miceli

M. P.

(1985). Organizational dissidence: The case of whistleblowing. Journal of Business Ethics , 4(1), 1–16.

51.

OECD. (2012). Protection of whistleblowers: Study on whistleblower protection frameworks, compendium of best practices and guiding principles for legislation . France: OECD.

52.

Pill

(1971). The Delphi method: Substance, context, a critique and an annotated bibliography. Socio-Economic Planning and Science , 5 (1), 57–71.

53.

Popescu

(2015). A critical analysis of whistleblower protection in the European Union. Journal of Public Administration, Finance and Law , (7), 135–140.

54.

Powell

(2003). The Delphi technique: Myths and realities. Journal of Advanced Nursing , 41(4), 376–382.

55.

Pyper

(2016). Whistleblowing and gagging clauses. UK: Parliament.

56.

Ramirez

M. K.

(n.d.). Blowing the whistle on whistleblower protection: A tale of reform versus power. University of Cincinnati Law Review , 76(1), 183–233.

57.

Rongine

(1985). Toward a coherent legal response to the public policy posed by whistleblowing. American Business Law Journal , 23(2), 296.

58.

Rowe

Wright

Bolger

(1991). Delphi: A revaluation of research and theory. Technical Forecasting Social Change , 39 (3), 235–251.

59.

Saaty

(1980). The analytical hierarchical process . New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

60.

Saaty

(1990). How to make decision: The analytic hierarchy process. European Journal of Operational Research , 48 (1), 9–26.

61.

Saaty

(2008). Decision making with the analytic hierarchy process. International Journal of Services Sciences , 1 (1), 83–98.

62.

Sackman

(1975). Delphi critique . Boston, MA: Lexington Books.

63.

Scott

D. W.

(1989). Policing corporate collusion. Criminology , 23(3), 559–586.

64.

Thomsen

Pedersen

(2000). Ownership structure and economic performance in the largest European companies. Strategic Management Journal , 21 (6), 689–705.

65.

Transparency International. (2013a). International principles for whistleblower legislation . Transparency International.

66.

Transparency International. (2013b). Whistleblower Protection and the UN convention against corruption . Transparency International.

67.

USMSPB. (1981). Whistleblowing and the federal employee . Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.

68.

Vaughn

R. G.

(2012). The successes and failures of whistleblower laws . Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.

69.

Weintein

(1979). Bureaucratic opposition . UK: Pergamon Press.

70.

Wolfe

Worth

Dreyfus

Brown

(2014). Whistleblower protection laws in G20 countries: Priorities for action. Blueprint for Free Speech. Melbourne: Transparency International Australia.