Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

This article investigates the relationship between financial liberalization and financial development in Pakistan, using human capital as a threshold variable over the period 1972–2023. The research finds that human capital must reach a value of 1.66 for overall financial liberalization to effectively take place. To gain deeper insights, the study decomposes overall financial liberalization into internal and external components. The estimated threshold values of human capital are 1.66 for internal and 1.53 for external financial liberalization. The results show that financial development is hindered when external financial liberalization remains below the human capital threshold, whereas the opposite effect is observed for internal financial liberalization. Once the human capital surpasses the threshold, both internal financial liberalization and external financial liberalization, as well as overall financial liberalization, positively contribute to financial development in Pakistan. These findings confirm that the positive relationship between financial liberalization and financial development is conditional upon reaching a specific threshold level of human capital. However, the relatively small magnitudes associated with each type of financial liberalization suggest that further reforms in financial sector policies are necessary. A reformed financial sector will then be better positioned to play a leading role in achieving sustainable economic growth. To this end, more focused efforts are required to improve the quality of human capital in Pakistan, ensuring its productive contribution to the finance–growth nexus. Additionally, macroeconomic variables also support financial development. Therefore, policymakers must ensure the effective utilization of physical capital stock, government expenditures and the maintenance of moderate inflation levels to foster the development of the financial sector.

Keywords

Financial development internal and external financial liberalization human capital threshold non-linearity Pakistan

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adu

, Marbuah

, & Mensah

J. T.

(2013). Financial development and economic growth in Ghana: Does the measure of financial development matter? Review of Development Finance, 3(4), 192–203.

Agoraki

M. E. K.

, Delis

M. D.

, & Pasiouras

(2011). Regulations, competition and bank risk-taking in transition countries. Journal of Financial Stability, 7(1), 38–48.

Ahmed

A. D.

(2013). Effect of financial liberalization on financial market development and economic performance of the SSA region: An empirical assessment. Economics Modelling, 30, 261–273.

Ahmed

A. D.

, & Islam

S. M.

(2009). Financial liberalization in developing countries: Issues, time series analyses and policy implications. Springer Science & Business Media.

Al–Suwailem

(2014). Complexity and endogenous instability. Research in International Business and Finance, 30, 393–410.

Aluko

O. A.

, & Ajaya

M. A.

(2018). Determinants of banking sector development: Evidence from Sub-Saharan African countries. Borsa Istanbul Review, 19(2), 122–139.

Andersen

T. B.

, & Tarp

(2003). Financial liberalization, financial development and economic growth in LDCs. Journal of International Development, 15(2), 189–209.

Andini

, & Andini

(2014). Finance growth and quantile parameter heterogeneity. Journal of Macroeconomics, 40(C), 308–322.

Ang

J. B.

, & McKibbin

W. J.

(2007). Financial liberalization, financial sector development and growth: Evidence from Malaysia. Journal of Development Economics, 84(1), 215–233.

10.

Angkinand

A. P.

, Sawangngoenyuang

, & Wihlborg

(2010). Financial liberalization and banking crises: A cross‐country analysis. International Review of Finance, 10(2), 263–292.

11.

Ariss

R. T.

(2010). On the implications of market power in banking: Evidence from developing countries. Journal of Banking & Finance, 34(4), 765–775.

12.

Bai

, & Perron

(1998). Estimating and testing linear models with multiple structural changes. Econometrica, 66, 47–78.

13.

Barrell

, Karim

, & Ventouri

(2017). Interest rate liberalization and capital adequacy in models of financial crises. Journal of Financial Stability, 33, 261–272.

14.

Barro

, & Lee

J. W.

(2010). Educational attainment in the world: 1950–2010. NBER Working Paper, 15902.

15.

Batuo

, Mlambo

, & Asongu

(2018). Linkages between financial development, financial instability, financial liberalisation and economic growth in Africa. Research in International Business and Finance, 45, 168–179.

16.

Baumol

W. J.

(2005). Education for innovation: Entrepreneurial breakthroughs versus corporate incremental improvements. Innovation Policy and the Economy, 5, 33–56.

17.

Beck

, Demirgic-Kunt

, & Levine

(2003). Law, endowments and finance. Journal of Financial Economics, 70(2), 137–181.

18.

Becker

G. S.

(1964). Human capital: A theoretical and empirical analysis, with special reference to education. University of Chicago Press.

19.

Bekaert

, Harvey

C. R.

, & Lundblad

(2005). Does financial liberalization spur growth? Journal of Financial Economics, 77(1), 3–55.

20.

Berthelemy

J. C.

, & Varoudakis

(1996). Economic growth, convergence clubs, and the role of financial development. Oxford Economic Papers, 48(2), 300–328.

21.

Bilman

M. E.

, & Karaoglan

(2020). Does the twin deficit hypothesis hold in the OECD countries under different real interest rate regimes? Journal of Policy Modeling, 42(1), 205–215.

22.

Bittencourt

(2011). Inflation and financial development: Evidence from Brazil. Economic Modelling, 28(1), 91–99.

23.

Blejer

, & Sagari

(1988). Sequencing the liberalization of financial markets. Finance and Development, 25(1), 18–20.

24.

Bogutoglu

, & Ekinci

(2010). Austrian business cycle theory and global financial crisis: Some lessons for macroeconomic risk and financial stability. http://mises.org/journals/scholar/ekinci.pdf

25.

Boikos

, Panagiotidis

, & Voucharas

(2022). Financial development, reforms and growth. Economic Modelling, 108, 105734.

26.

Boot

(2000). Relationship banking: What do we know? Journal of Financial Intermediation, 9(1), 7–25.

27.

Boyd

J. H.

, Levine

, & Smith

B. D.

(2001). The impact of inflation on financial sector performance. Journal of Monetary Economics, 47(2), 221–248.

28.

Brada

J. C.

, & Iwasaki

(2024). Does financial liberalization spur economic growth? A meta-analysis. Borsa Istanbul Review, 24(1), 1–13.

29.

Broock

W. A.

, Scheinkman

J. A.

, Dechert

W. D.

, & LeBaron

(1996). A test for independence based on the correlation dimension. Econometric Reviews, 15(3), 197–235.

30.

Chinn

M. D.

, & Ito

(2006). What matters for financial development? Capital controls, institutions, and interactions. Journal of Development Economics, 81(1), 163–192.

31.

Chinn

M. D.

, & Ito

(2008). A new measure of financial openness. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis, 10(3), 309–322.

32.

Claessens

, Demirguc-Kunt

, & Huizinga

(2001). How does foreign entry affect domestic banking markets? Journal of Banking & Finance, 25(5), 891–911.

33.

Cobham

(2002). Capital account liberalization and poverty. Global Social Policy, 2(2), 163–188.

34.

Cubillas

, & González

(2014). Financial liberalization and bank risk-taking: International evidence. Journal of Financial Stability, 11, 32–48.

35.

Demetriades

, & Andrianova

(2004). Finance and growth: What we know and what we need to know. In Financial development and economic growth (pp. 38–65). Palgrave Macmillan.

36.

Demirguc-Kunt

, & Detragiache

(1998). The determinants of banking crises in developing and developed countries. Staff Papers, 45(1), 81–109.

37.

Easterly

, & Rebelo

(1993). Fiscal policy and economic growth. Journal of Monetary Economics, 32(1), 417–458.

38.

Elkhuizen

, Hermes

, Jacobs

, & Meesters

(2018). Financial development, financial liberalization and social capital. Applied Economics, 50(11), 1268–1288.

39.

Faria

, & Mauro

(2009). Institutions and the external capital structure of countries. Journal of International Money and Finance, 28(3), 367–391.

40.

Gibson

H. D.

, & Tsakalotos

(1994). The scope and limits of financial liberalisation in developing countries: A critical survey. The Journal of Development Studies, 30(3), 578–628.

41.

Goldin

(2016). Human capital. In Diebolt

& Haupert

(Eds), Handbook of cliometrics (pp. 55–86). Springer Verlag.

42.

Hanif

M. N.

(2003). Restructuring of financial sector in Pakistan. Journal of the Institute of Bankers Pakistan, 70(1), 43–74.

43.

Hansen

B. E.

(1999). Threshold effects in non-dynamic panels: Estimation, testing and inference. Journal of Econometrics, 93(2), 345–368.

44.

Hansen

B. E.

(2000). Sample splitting and threshold estimation. Econometrica, 68, 575–603.

45.

Hansen

B. E.

, & Seo

(2002). Testing for two-regime threshold co-integration in vector error-correction models. Journal of Econometrics, 110(2), 293–318.

46.

Haque

(2011). The capital account and Pakistani rupee convertibility: Macroeconomic policy challenges. Lahore Journal of Economics, 16, 95–121.

47.

Hardy

D. C.

, & Di Patti

E. B.

(2005). Financial sector liberalization, bank privatization, and efficiency: Evidence from Pakistan. Journal of Banking & Finance, 29, 2381–2406.

48.

Hartwell

C. A.

(2017). If you’re going through hell, keep going: Nonlinear effects of financial liberalization in transition economies. Emerging Markets Finance and Trade, 53(2), 250–275.

49.

Hasan

M. A.

, Khan

A. H.

, & Ali

S. S.

(1996). Financial sector reform and its impact on investment and economic growth: An econometric approach. The Pakistan Development Review, 35(4), 885–895.

50.

Hassan

M. K.

, Sanchez

, Ngene

G. M.

, & Ashraf

(2012). Financial liberalization and foreign bank entry on the domestic banking performance in MENA countries. African Development Review, 24(3), 195–207.

51.

Hellmann

T. F.

, Murdock

K. C.

, & Stiglitz

J. E.

(2000). Liberalization, moral hazard in banking, and prudential regulation: Are capital requirements enough? American Economic Review, 90(1), 147–165.

52.

Henry

P. B.

(2000). Do stock market liberalizations cause investment booms?. Journal of Financial Economics, 58(1–2), 301–334.

53.

Henry

P. B.

(2006). Capital account liberalization: Theory, evidence, and speculation [NBER Working Paper Series, Working Paper 2007-32].

54.

Hermes

, & Lensik

(2005). Does financial liberalization influences saving, investment and economic growth? [World Institute for Development Economics Research, Research Paper No. 2005/69].

55.

Hermes

, & Meesters

(2015). Financial liberalization, financial regulation and bank efficiency: A multi-country analysis. Applied Economics, 47(21), 2154–2172.

56.

Hope

C. J.

, Gwatidzo

, & Ntuli

(2013). Investigating the effect of bank competition on financial stability in ten African countries. International Business & Economics Research Journal, 12(7), 755–767.

57.

Huang

(2006). Emerging markets, financial openness and financial development. [Working Paper No. 06/588, Department of Economics, University of Bristol, UK].

58.

Huang

(2010). Political institutions and financial development: An empirical study. World Development, 38(12), 1667–1677.

59.

Imran

, & Nishat

(2013). Determinants of bank credit in Pakistan: A supply side approach. Economic Modelling, 35, 384–390.

60.

Ito

(2006). Financial development and financial liberalization in Asia: Thresholds, institutions and the sequence of liberalization. The North American Journal of Economics and Finance, 17(3), 303–327.

61.

Jalil

, & Ma

(2008). Financial development and economic growth: Time series evidence from Pakistan and China. Journal of Economic Cooperation, 29(2), 29–68.

62.

Kaminsky

G. L.

, & Schmukler

S. L.

(2008). Short-run pain, long-run gain: Financial liberalization and stock market cycles. Review of Finance, 12(2), 253–292.

63.

Kates

(2010). Macroeconomic theory and its failings: Alternative perspectives of the global financial crisis. Edward Elgar.

64.

Khan

, Ahmed

, & Bibi

(2018). Financial development and economic growth nexus for Pakistan: A revisit using maximum entropy bootstrap approach. Empirical Economics, 57(4), 1157–1169.

65.

Khan

A. H.

, & Hasan

(1998). Financial liberalization, savings, and economic development in Pakistan. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 46(3), 581–597.

66.

Khan

M. A.

, & Khan

S. A.

(2011). Foreign direct investment and economic growth in Pakistan: A sectoral analysis [Working Paper No. 67, Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE)].

67.

Khan

M. A.

, Qayyum

, Sheikh

S. A.

, & Siddique

(2005). Financial development and economic growth: The case of Pakistan [with Comments]. The Pakistan Development Review, 819–837.

68.

Khan

M. A.

, & Qayyum

(2007). Trade, financial and growth nexus in Pakistan. Economic Analysis Working Paper, 6(14), 1–24.

69.

King

R. G.

, & Levine

(1993). Finance, entrepreneurship, and growth: Theory and evidence. Journal of Monetary Economics, 32(3), 513–42.

70.

Kitchen

R. L.

(1986). Finance for the developing countries. John Wiley and Sons.

71.

Kodila-Tedika

, & Asongu

S. A.

(2015). The effect of intelligence on financial development: A cross-country comparison. Intelligence, 51, 1–9.

72.

Koenker

, & Bassett Jr

(1978). Regression quantiles. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society, 46(1) 33–50.

73.

Law

S. H.

, & Demetriades

(2006). Openness, institutions and financial development. [Paper No. 0012, ESRC World Economy and Finance Research Programme, Birkbeck, University of London].

74.

Levine

(2005). Finance and growth: Theory and evidence. Handbook of Economic Growth, 1, 865–934.

75.

Loayza

N. V.

, & Ranciere

(2006). Financial development, financial fragility, and growth. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 1051–1076.

76.

Martin

, & Rey

(2002). Financial globalisation and Emerging Markets: With or without cash? NBER Working Papers No. 9288, Cambridge.

77.

Mattoo

, Rathindran

, & Subramanian

(2001). Measuring services trade liberalization and its impact on economic growth: An illustration (Vol. 2655). World Bank Publications.

78.

McKinnon

R. I.

(1973). Money and capital in economic development. Brookings Institution Press.

79.

Mello

, & Perrelli

(2003). Growth equations: A quantile regression exploration. The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 43(4), 643–667.

80.

Mody

, & Murshid

A. P.

(2005). Growing up with capital flows. Journal of International Economics, 65(1), 249–266.

81.

Mohammad

S. D.

(2010). The effectiveness of financial development and openness on economic growth: Case study of Pakistan. European Journal of Social Sciences, 13(3), 415–426.

82.

Moyo

, & Le Roux

(2020). Financial liberalization, financial development and financial crises in SADC countries. Journal of Financial Economic Policy, 12(4), 477–494.

83.

Mukherjee

, Roy Chowdhury

, & Bhattacharya

(2021). Does financial liberalization lead to financial development? Evidence from emerging economies. The Journal of International Trade and Economic Development, 30, 1263–1287.

84.

Nam

H. J.

, Bang

, & Ryu

(2024). Nonlinear effects of financial openness on financial development in ASEAN. Journal of Multinational Financial Management, 73, 100846.

85.

Naveed

, & Mahmood

(2019). Impact of domestic financial liberalization on economic growth in Pakistan. Journal of Economic Policy Reform, 22(1), 16–34.

86.

Njikam

(2017). Financial liberalization and growth in African economies: The role of policy complementarities. Review of development finance, 7(1), 73–83.

87.

Odhiambo

N. M.

(2012). The impact of inflation on financial sector development: Experience from Zambia. Journal of Applied Business Research, 28(6), 1497.

88.

Ozkok

(2015). Financial openness and financial development: An analysis using indices. International Review of Applied Economics, 29(5), 620–649.

89.

Pagano

(1993). Financial markets and growth: An overview. European Economic Review, 37(2–3), 613–622.

90.

Quinn

D. P.

(2003). Capital account liberalization and financial globalization, 1880-1999: A synoptic view. International Journal of Finance and Economics, 8, 189–204.

91.

Rahman

, & Khan

M. A.

(2022). Financial liberalization, democratic institutions, and income inequality: New insights from Pakistan. The Singapore Economic Review, 1–34. https://doi.org/10.1142/S0217590822500230

92.

Rahman

, & Khan

M. A.

(2024). Role of consistent regime-specific policies in recovering the negative relationship between financial development and economic growth. Economic Change and Restructuring, 57(4), 142.

93.

Rahman

, Khan

M. A.

, & Charfeddine

(2020a). Financial development–economic growth nexus in Pakistan: New evidence from the Markov switching model. Cogent Economics & Finance, 8(1), 1716446.

94.

Rahman

, Khan

M. A.

, & Charfeddine

(2020b). Does financial sector promote economic growth in Pakistan? Empirical evidences from Markov switching model. SAGE Open, 10(4), 2158244020963064.

95.

Rahman

, Khan

M. A.

, & Charfeddine

(2021). Regime-specific impact of financial reforms on economic growth in Pakistan. Journal of Policy Modeling, 43(1), 161–182.

96.

Raza

S. H.

, Shahzadi

, & Akram

(2014). Exploring the determinants of financial development (using panel data on developed and developing countries). Journal of Finance and Economics, 2(5), 166–172.

97.

Rehman

, & Cheema

(2013). Financial development and real sector growth in Pakistan. Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research in Business, 5(1), 618–636.

98.

Rodrik

, & Subramanian

(2009). Why did financial globalization disappoint?. IMF Staff Papers, 56(1), 112–138.

99.

Rossi

M. M.

(1999). Financial fragility and economic performance in developing economies: Do capital controls, prudential regulation and supervision matter? [Paper No. 99/66, International Monetary Fund].

100.

Sarma

(2008). Index of financial inclusion [Working paper no. 215, Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations, India].

101.

Schmukler

S. L.

(2004). Financial globalization: Gain and pain for developing countries. Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Economic Review, 89(2), 39–66.

102.

Schumpeter

J. A.

(1911). The theory of economic development. Harvard University Press.

103.

Shabir

(2013). Financial liberalization and its impact on economic growth of Pakistan [Doctoral dissertation, Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, Islamabad].

104.

Shaw

E. S.

(1973). Financial deepening in economic development. Oxford University Press.

105.

Shehzad

C. T.

, & De Haan

(2009). Financial reform and banking crises [CESIFO Working Paper No. 2870 Category 7: Monetary Policy and International Finance].

106.

Singh

, & Weisse

B. A.

(1998). Emerging stock markets, portfolio capital flows and long-term economic growth: Micro and macroeconomic perspectives. World Development, 26(4), 607–622.

107.

Slesman

, Baharumshah

A. Z.

, & Azman–Saini

W. N. W.

(2019). Political institutions and finance–growth nexus in emerging markets and developing countries: A tale of one threshold. The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 72, 80–100.

108.

Stiglitz

J. E.

(2000). Capital market liberalization, economic growth, and instability. World Development, 28(6), 1075–1086.

109.

Swamy

, & Dharani

(2020). Thresholds of financial development in the Euro area. The World Economy, 43(6), 1730–1774.

110.

Tariq

, Khan

M. A.

, & Rahman

(2020). How does financial development impact economic growth in Pakistan? New evidence from threshold model. Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business, 7(8), 161–173.

111.

Templeman

J. H.

(2010). Austrian business cycle theory and the global financial crisis: Confessions of a mainstream economist. The Journal of Austrian Economics, 13(1), 3–15.

112.

Tran

(2018). Debt threshold for fiscal sustainability assessment in emerging economies. Journal of Policy Modeling, 40(2), 375–394.

113.

Triki

M. B.

, & Maktouf

(2012). Financial liberalization and banking crisis: A spatial panel model. Journal of Applied Finance and Banking, 2(3), 81.

Modelling Trilogies Between Financial Liberalization,Human Capital and Financial Development: Evidence from Pakistan Using Threshold Model Approach

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References