Pakistan and Afghanistan,2014 and Beyond: Not Friends,Not Yet Enemies?

Abstract

As the American withdrawal is approaching, the future stability of Afghanistan and its effects on the region are increasingly being debated. The predominant view is that due to the mishandling of the situation by the Americans, post 2014 Afghanistan would be unstable and the whole region especially Pakistan will face the consequences of this failure. A stable and peaceful Afghanistan is in Pakistan’s interest as it will ensure that no more drugs, extremism and refugees pour into the country. Islamabad is of the view that like in 1989, the Americans would once again be leaving Afghanistan without finishing what they have started. This coupled with the increasing Indian influence in Afghanistan brings back the historical fear, which has been the driving force behind its Afghan policy since 1947, of being sandwiched between two hostile neighbours. This article flags five points: first, Islamabad has legitimate security concerns in Afghanistan; second, historically, Pakistan’s security concerns regarding India are a major factor in deciding Pakistan’s position in and about Afghanistan; third, Pakistan supported the Taliban government in Kabul due to its geostrategic and security concerns; fourth, there can be no solution of the Afghanistan problem without Islamabad on board; fifth, the solution to the Afghan problem lies not only in Afghanistan but also around it, in the region; therefore, a regional approach is a must.

Keywords

Afghanistan Pakistan regional security India and South Asia US–Afghanistan US–Pakistan relations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asia Society Report. The United States and South Asia after Afghanistan. Retrieved from http://asiasociety.org/files/pdf/as_us_southasia.pdf (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

Bell

Coral

. (1971). Conventions of crisis: A study in diplomatic management. London: Oxford University Press.

Curtis

Lisa.

(2011). The bin Laden aftermath: The US and Pakistan are still stuck with each other. 3 May 2011. Retrieved from http://www.heritage.org/research/commentary/2011/05/the-bin-laden-aftermath-the-us-and-pakistan-are-still-stuck-with-each-other (accessed on 11 July 2013).

Daily Times. (2006, January 10). Pakistan has evidence of Indian involvement in Balochistan: FO. Daily Times, Retrieved from http://dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2006\01\10\story_10-1-2006_pg1_5 (last accessed on 9 August 2013).

Daily Times. (2006, March 12). Mr Karzai can’t have it both ways. Daily Times. Retrieved from http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2006%5C03%5C12%5Cstory_12-3-2006_pg3_1 (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

De Souza

Shanthie

. (March 2011). India, Afghanistan and the end game? ISAS Working Paper No. 124. Institute for South Asian Studies, National University of Singapore.

Ejaz

Manzur

. (2001, October 7). Fundamental change in Pakistan’s approach. The News.

Fair

C. Christine

. (2009). Pakistan’s own war on terror: What the Pakistani public thinks. Journal of International Affairs, 63(1): 39–55.

Fair

C. Christine

Jones

Seth G.

(2010). Pakistan’s war within. Survival, 51(6): 161–188.

10.

Fair

Christine

. (2011, May 11). Spies, lies and Pakistan. Retrieved from http://nationalinterest.org/commentary/spies-lies-pakistan-5289 (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

11.

Filkins

Dexter

. (2012, July 9). After America. The New Yorker. Retrieved from http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2012/07/09/120709fa_fact_filkins (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

12.

Gregory

Shaun

. (2007). The ISI and the war on terrorism. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 30(12): 1013–1031.

13.

Gul

Imtiaz

. (2002). Unholy nexus: Pak-Afghan relations under the Taliban. Lahore: Vanguard.

14.

Gul

Imtiaz

. (2009). The al Qaeda connection. New Delhi: Viking.

15.

Gunaratna

Rohan

Iqbal

Khuram

. (2011). Pakistan: Terrorism ground zero. London: Reaktion Books.

16.

Hameed

Sadika

. (2012). Prospects for Indian-Pakistani cooperation in Afghanistan. A report of CSIS program on crisis, conflict and cooperation. Washington, DC: CSIS.

17.

Hanauer

Larry

Chalk

Peter

(n.d.) India’s and Pakistan’s strategies in Afghanistan implications for the United States and the region. Retrieved from http://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/occasional_papers/2012/RAND_OP387.pdf (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

18.

Harrison

Selig

. (1981). In Afghanistan’s shadow. Washington, DC: CEIP.

19.

Hart

Michael.

(2012, February 28). West’s Afghan hopes collide with reality. The National Interests. Retrieved from http://nationalinterest.org/print/article/wests-afghan-hopes-collide-reality-6510 (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

20.

Hussain

Rifaat

. (2001, November 3). Pakistan’s Hobson’s choice. Dawn.

21.

Hussain

Shaiq

. (2008, July 27). Probe into RAW’s involvement ordered. Nation (Islamabad), p. 38.

22.

Hussain

Zahid

. (2010). The scorpion’s tail. New York: Free Press.

23.

International Crisis Group. (2012). Afghanistan: The long, hard road to the 2014 transition. 8 October. Retrieved from http://www.crisisgroup.org/en/regions/asia/south-asia/afghanistan/236-afghanistan-the-long-hard-road-to-the-2014-transition (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

24.

Jafar

Ghani

Zeb

Rizwan

. (2006). Pakistan: Countering global terrorism. Islamabad: IRS.

25.

Jalal

Malik Ahmed

. (2010). Why Pakistan can’t. Harvard National Security Journal, August 6. Retrieved from http://harvardnsj.com/2010108/why-pakistan-cant/ (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

26.

Jetly

Rajsheree

. (1999). Ethnicity and nation-building in South Asia: Case studies of the Baluch movement in Pakistan and the Khalistan movement in India. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Australian National University.

27.

Jinnah Institute. (2011). Pakistan, the United States and the endgame in Afghanistan: Perceptions of Pakistan’s foreign policy elite. Jinnah Institute Policy Brief, 25 July, Jinnah Institute, Islamabad.

28.

Judah

Tim

. (2002). The Taliban papers. Survival, 44(1): 69–88.

29.

Khan

Raiz M.

(2011). Afghanistan and Pakistan: Conflict, extremism, and resistance to modernity. Washington, DC: Johns Hopkins University Press.

30.

Malik

Hafeez

. (2001). Pakistan’s relations with the Soviet Union and Russia. In Malik

Hafeez

(ed.), Pakistan: Founder’s aspiration and today’s realities. Karachi: OUP.

31.

Mir

Amir

. (2008). The fluttering flag of Jehad. Lahore: Mashal.

32.

Murshid

Iftikhar

. (2006). Afghanistan: The Taliban years. London: Bennett & Bloom.

33.

Musharraf

Pervaz

. (2008). In the line of fire. New York: Free Press.

34.

Nation. (2009, December 9). Solid evidences of Indian involvement in Pak provided to foreign office: Rehman Malik. Nation, p. 36.

35.

Noor

Arifa

. (2001, September 30). The neighbour within. The News.

36.

Obama

Barak

. (2011). Remarks by the president on the way forward in Afghanistan. 12 June. Retrieved from http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2011/06/22/remarks-president-way-forward-Afghanistan (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

37.

Pakistan Times. (2001, May 5). Pakistan committed to eradicate drug menace. Pakistan Times.

38.

Qassem

Ahmed Shayaq

. (2007). Afghanistan-Pakistan relations: Border controversies as counterterrorist impediments. Australian Journal of International Affairs, 61(1): 65–80.

39.

Qassem

Ahmed Shayaq

. (2009). Afghanistan’s political stability. Surrey: Ashgate.

40.

Qureshi

S.M.M.

(1966). Pushtunistan: The frontier dispute between Afghanistan and Pakistan. Pacific Affairs, 35, Spring-Summer (1/2).

41.

Raja

Mudassir

. (2013). Pakistani victims: War on terror toll put at 49,000. The Express Tribune, 27 March 2013. Retrieved from http://tribune.com.pk/story/527016/pakistani-victims-war-on-terror-toll-put-at-49000/?print=true (last accessed on 11 July 2013).

42.

Rashid

Ahmed

. (2001). Taliban, Islam, oil and the new great game in Central Asia. London, UK: l.B. Tauris.

43.

Saikel

Amin

. (2012). Modern Afghanistan. London: I.B. Tauris.

44.

Saleem

Farrukh.

(2001, September 23). The saviour general. The News.

45.

Shezad

Saleem

. (2011). Inside al-Qaeda and the Taliban: Beyond bin Laden and 9/11. London: Pluto.

46.

Taj

Farhat

. (2011). Taliban and anti-Taliban. New Castle Upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.

47.

The Friday Times. (2001, October 12–18). In the national interest. Editorial, The Friday Times, pp. 1–2.

48.

Zaafir

Muhammad Saleh

(2008, August 1). Bush gives Malik a pat on the back. The News (Rawalpindi-Islamabad), p. 37.

49.

Zaafir

Muhammad Saleh

(2009, July 17). India, Pakistan de-link terrorism from dialogue. The News (Rawalpindi-Islamabad).

50.

Zeb

Rizwan

. (2002). War against terror: Lessons for Pakistan. Journal of South Asian and Middle Eastern Studies, XXV, Spring (3).

51.

Zeb

Rizwan

. (2003, October 22). Gwadar and Chabahar: Competition or complimentarity? CACI Analyst. Retrieved from http://www.cacianalyst.org/?q=node/1578 (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

52.

Zeb

Rizwan

. (2004). Russia and South Asia. Regional Studies, XXII, Spring (2), 52, 48–78.

53.

Zeb

Rizwan

. (2006). Cross border terrorism issues plaguing Pakistan–Afghanistan relations. China and Eurasia Forum Quarterly, 4(2), 69–74.

54.

Zeb

Rizwan

. An uncertain future: The Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline. Retrieved from http://www.futuredirections.org.au/publications/energy-security/27-energy-security-swa/448-an-uncertain-future-the-iran-pakistan-gas-pipeline.html (last accessed on 11 July 2013)

55.

Zeb

Rizwan

. (2011, May 4). Does Iran-Pakistan pipeline have a future? Daily Times. Retrieved from http://dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2012/05/04/story_4-5-2012_pg3_6 (last accessed on 11 July 2013)