Improving economic viability of Indian agriculture is contingent upon agri-environmental sustainability (AES). Objective assessment of environmental costs of agriculture is lacking in India. Unless internalise environmental impacts of agriculture will be borne by the society at large, in terms of depletion and degradation of water resources, land degradation and emissions of greenhouse gases, etc. To assess AES of Indian agriculture, the present article builds a comprehensive agri-environmental sustainability index (AESI) based on 40 agri-environmental indicators. The study captures both spatial and temporal aspects of AES by covering 17 major Indian states over 24 years (1990–1991 to 2013–2014). The estimated AESI scores are validated with outcome indicators (e.g., groundwater depletion, depletion of soil nutrients). The results show that states having higher score in Sustainable Irrigation Index are facing lower fall in groundwater level and there are negative correlations across sub-indices of AESI and macronutrient deficiencies in soil. An inverse relationship between AESI scores and agricultural intensity (as measured by average productivity of foodgrains in kilograms per hectare) is also observed. The study comes out with policy suggestions which could help to attain AES of Indian agriculture.
AstierM., SpeelmanE. N., López-RidauraS., MaseraO. R., and Gonzalez-EsquivelC. E. 2011. “Sustainability Indicators, Alternative Strategies and Trade-offs in Peasant Agroecosystems: Analysing 15 Case Studies from Latin America.”International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability9(3): 409–22.
2.
BarbierE. B., and HochardJ. P. 2016. “Does Land Degradation Increase Poverty in Developing Countries?”PloS ONE11(5): e0152973.
3.
BinderC., FeolaG., and SteinbergerJ. 2010. “Considering the Normative, Systemic and Procedural Dimensions in Indicator-based Sustainability Assessments in Agriculture.”Environmental Impact Assessment Review30(2): 71–81.
4.
BockstallerChristian, GuichardLaurence, MakowskiDavid, AvelineAnne, GirardinPhilippe, and PlantureuxSylvain. 2008. “Agri-environmental Indicators to Assess Cropping and Farming Systems: A Review.”Agronomy for Sustainable Development28(1): 139–49.
Central Ground Water Board (CGWB). Undated. Ground Water Year Book—India2016–17. Ministry of Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation, Government of India, Faridabad, Haryana.
7.
DamerauK., DavisK. F., GoddeC., HerreroM., SpringmannM., BhupathirajuS. N., MyersS. S., and WillettW. 2020. “India Has Natural Resource Capacity to Achieve Nutrition Security, Reduce Health Risks and Improve Environmental Sustainability.”Nature Food1: 631–9. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43016-020-00157-w.
8.
DillonE. J., HennessyT., and HynesS. 2010. “Assessing the Sustainability of Irish Agriculture.”International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability8(3): 131–47.
9.
EilersW., MackayR., GrahamL., and LefebvreA. 2010. “Environmental Sustainability of Canadian Agriculture.”Agri-Environmental Indicators Report Series, Report No. 3, Agricultural and Agri-Food Canada, Ottawa, Canada.
10.
FAO. 2017. “A Literature Review on Frameworks and Methods for Measuring and Monitoring Sustainable Agriculture.”Draft Version 2, Rome: Food and Agriculture Organisation.
11.
GhoshB., and ChakmaN. 2019. “Composite Indicator of Land, Water and Energy for Measuring Agricultural Sustainability at Micro Level, Barddhaman District, West Bengal, India.”Ecological Indicators102: 21–32.
12.
GirardinP., BockstallerC., and van der WerfH. 2000. “Assessment of Potential Impacts of Agricultural Practices on the Environment.”Environmental Impact Assessment Review20(2): 227–39.
13.
GillSingh S., and SinghK. N. 2018. “Subsidy and efficiency of groundwater use and power consumption in Haryana.”Economic and Political Weekly53(50): 32–40.
14.
Gomez-LimonJ. A., and Sanchez-FernandezG. 2010. “Empirical Evaluation of Agricultural Sustainability Using Composite Indicators.”Ecological Economics69(5): 102–75.
15.
MolinaGonzález de M., FernándezD. S., Infante-AmateJ., AguileraE., TraverJ. V., and GuzmánG. I. 2017. “Decoupling Food from Land: The Evolution of Spanish Agriculture from 1960 to 2010.”Sustainability9(12): 2348. doi:10.3390/su9122348.
16.
HajkowiczS., CollinsK., and CattaneoA. 2008. “Review of Agri-environment Indexes and Stewardship Payments.”Environmental Management43(2): 221–36.
17.
HataiL. D., and SenC. 2008. “An Economic Analysis of Agricultural Sustainability in Orissa.”Agriculture Economics Research Review21: 273–82.
18.
HayatiDariush, RanjibarZahra, and KaramiEzatollah. 2011. “Measuring Agricultural Sustainability.”In Biodiversity, Biofuels, Agroforestry and Conservation Agriculture, edited by Eric Lichtfouse, Chapter 2, pp. 73–100. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
19.
HuffmanE., EilersR. G, PadburyG., WallG., and MacdonaldK. B. 2000. “Canadian Agri-environmental Indicators Related to Land Quality: Integrating Census and Biophysical Data to Estimate Soil Cover, Wind Erosion and Soil Salinity.”Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment81(2): 113–23.
20.
KareemullaK., VenkattakumarR., and SamuelManoj O. 2017. “An Analysis on Agricultural Sustainability in India.”Current Science112(2): 258–66.
21.
KellyE., LatruffeL., DesjeuxY., RyanM., UthesS., DiazabakanaA., DillonE., and FinnJ. 2018. “Sustainability Indicators for Improved Assessment of the Effects of Agricultural Policy Across the EU: Is FADN the Answer?”Ecological Indicators89: 903–11.
22.
KoohafkanP., AltieriM. A., and GimenezE. H. 2012. “Green Agriculture: Foundations for Biodiverse, Resilient and Productive Agricultural Systems.”International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability10(1): 61–75.
23.
KrólczykJolanta B., and LatawiecAgnieszka E. 2015. “Sustainability Indicators for Agriculture in the European Union.”In Sustainability Indicators in Practice, edited by Agnieszka Latawiec and Dorice Agol, Chapter 10. Warsaw, Poland: De Gruyter Open.
24.
LangeveldJ. W. A, VerhagenA., NeetesonJ. J., van KeulenH., ConjinJ. G, SchilsR. L. M., and OenemaJ. 2007. “Evaluating Farm Performance Using Agri-environmental Indicators: Recent Experience for Nitrogen Management in the Netherlands.”Journal of Environmental Management82(3): 363–76.
25.
LewandowskiI., HärdtleinM., and KaltschmittM. 1999. “Sustainable Crop Production: Definition and Methodological Approach for Assessing and Implementing Sustainability.”Crop Science39(1): 184–93.
26.
Lopez-RidauraS., van KeulenH., van IttersumM., and LeffelaarP. 2005. “Multi-scale Methodological Framework to Derive Criteria and Indicators for Sustainability Evaluation of Peasant Natural Resource Management Systems.”Environment, Development and Sustainability7(1): 51–69.
27.
MukherjeeS. 2008. “Economics of Agricultural Nonpoint Source Water Pollution: A Case Study of Groundwater Nitrate Pollution in the Lower Bhavani River Basin, Tamil Nadu.”Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Madras ( Madras School of Economics ), Chennai, Tamil Nadu.
28.
MukherjeeS. 2020. “Agri-environmental Sustainability of Indian States during 1990–91 to 2013–14.”NIPFP Working Paper No. 290. New Delhi: National Institute of Public Finance and Policy ( NIPFP ), January 2020.
29.
MukherjeeS., and ChakrabortyD. 2009. “Environment, Human Development and Economic Growth: A Contemporary Analysis of Indian States.”International Journal of Global Environmental Issues9(1&2): 20–49.
30.
MukherjeeS., and KathuriaV. 2006. “Is Economic Growth Sustainable? Environmental Quality of Indian States after 1991.”International Journal of Sustainable Development9(1): 38–60.
31.
OECD. 2013. “OECD Compendium of Agri-environment Indicators.”Paris, France: OECD Publishing. Available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264181151-en( last accessed on 19 July 2019 ).
32.
OECD. Undated. “Glossary of Statistical terms: Environmental Debt.” Available https://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=820> (last accessed on 9 June 2016 ).
33.
PrasadR. 2011. “Nitrogen and Foodgrain Production in India.”Indian Journal of Fertilisers7(12): 66–76.
34.
RasmussenL. V., BierbaumR., OldekopJ. A., and AgrawalA. 2017. “Bridging the Practitioner-researcher Divide: Indicators to Track Environmental, Economic, and Sociocultural Sustainability of Agricultural Commodity Production.”Global Environmental Change42: 33–46.
35.
RockströmJ., SteffenW., NooneK., PerssonÅ., ChapinF. S., LambinE., LentonT. M., SchefferM., FolkeC., SchellnhuberH., NykvistB., De WitC. A., HughesT., van der LeeuwS., RodheH., SörlinS., SnyderP. K., CostanzaR., SvedinU., FalkenmarkM., KarlbergL., CorellR. W., FabryV. J., HansenJ., WalkerB., LivermanD., RichardsonK., CrutzenP., and FoleyJ. 2009. “Planetary Boundaries: Exploring the Safe Operating Space for Humanity.”Ecology and Society14(2): 32.
36.
RoyR., and ChanN. W. 2012. “An Assessment of Agricultural Sustainability Indicators in Bangladesh: Review and Synthesis.”The Environmentalist32(1): 99–110.
37.
SajjadH., NasreenI., and AnsariS. A. 2014. “Assessing Spatiotemporal Variation in Agricultural Sustainability Using Sustainable Livelihood Security Index: Empirical Illustration from Vaishali District of Bihar, India.”Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems38(1): 46–68.
38.
SandsGary R., and PodmoreTerence H. 2000. “A Generalised Environmental Sustainability Index for Agricultural Systems.”Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment79(1): 29–41.
39.
ShahAmita. 2012. “Agriculture and Environment in India: Policy Implications in the Context of North-South Trade.”In Environmental Scenario in India: Successes and Predicaments, edited by S. Mukherjee and D. Chakraborty, Chapter12, pp. 219–42. UK: Routledge.
40.
SharmaD., and ShardenduS. 2011. “Assessing Farm-level Agricultural Sustainability over a 60-year Period in Rural Eastern India.”The Environmentalist31(3): 325–37.
41.
SrivastavaP., SinghR., TripathiS., and RaghubanshiA. S. 2016. “An Urgent Need for Sustainable Thinking in Agriculture—An Indian Scenario.”Ecological Indicators67: 611–622.
42.
United Nations Development Programme (UNDP). 2019. “Human Development Report 2019—Beyond Income, beyond Averages, beyond Today: Inequalities in Human Development in the 21st century.”UNDP: New York.
43.
van der WerfH. M. G., and PetitJ. 2002. “Evaluation of the Environmental Impact of Agriculture at the Farm Level: A Comparison and Analysis of 12 Indicator-based Methods.”Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment93(1-3): 131–45.
44.
VandermeulenV., and HuylenbroeckG. V. 2008. “Designing trans-disciplinary research to support policy formulation for sustainable agricultural development.”Ecological Economics67(3): 352–361.
45.
VeluguriD., RamanjaneyiluG. V., and JaacksL. 2019. “State-wise Report Cards on Ecological Sustainability of Agriculture in India.”Economic and Political Weekly54(26-27): 19–27.
46.
von Wirén-LehrS. 2001. “Sustainability in Agriculture: An Evaluation of Principal Goal-oriented Concepts to Close the Gap between Theory and Practice.”Agriculture, Ecosystem and Environment84(2): 115–29.
47.
WilsonG. A., and BullerH. 2001. “The Use of Socio-economic and Environmental Indicators in Assessing the Effectiveness of EU Agri-environmental Policy.”European Environment11: 297–313.
48.
XavierAntónio, Freitas de BelémC. M., FragosoR., and Rosário do SocorroM. 2018. “A regional composite indicator for analysing agricultural sustainability in Portugal: A goal programming approach”. Ecological Indicators89(June 2018): 84–100.
49.
YangQ., LiuJ., and ZhangY. 2017. “Decoupling Agricultural Nonpoint Source Pollution from Crop Production: A Case Study of Heilongjiang Land Reclamation Area, China.”Sustainability9(6): 1024. https://doi.org/10.3390/su9061024.
50.
ZhenLin, and RoutrayJayant Kumar. 2003. “Operational Indicators for Measuring Agricultural Sustainability in Developing Countries.”Environmental Management32(1): 34–46.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
