The health workforce is the channel for delivering health interventions to populations. A critical mass of health professionals is necessary to manage a health system and is often a crucial limiting factor in the delivery of quality health services. India’s current situation, juxtaposed with its medium-term and long-term HRH (human resources for health) requirements, necessitates reassessing the policy levers that are available at the national level.
Objective:
To suggest strategic options to recommend India’s way forward to meet challenges related to health service delivery and public health with an HRH focus.
Methodology:
We reviewed and compared studies from different countries which focused on strengthening HRH at the national level. A two-step approach towards identifying and selecting HRH strategic options was adopted: desk review and discussions. A list of strategic options for reforming the current state of HRH in India was developed on the basis of lessons learnt from the review. These options were then scored and plotted on a grid (for innovation, disruption, difficulty of implementation, budget for implementation, importance and time period for implementation) in discussion with experts.
Result:
Based on the lessons learnt, eight strategic options were suggested for India: instituting a national HRH body; developing partnership models for the public sector and the private sector; setting benchmark HRH ratios; allocating at least 2.5% of the GDP to health; allocating at least 25% of all development assistance for health to HRH; halving the current levels of disparity in health worker distribution between urban and rural areas; evaluating HRH support through the National Health Mission (NHM); and maintaining a live register of HRH.
Conclusion:
The research is timely as India moves towards the implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) with a particular focus on universal health coverage (UHC) and Ayushman Bharat Yojana. The suggested strategic options for the way forward shall help India in dealing with the current health crisis to emerge with a strong public health system.
American Hospital Association. (2001). The hospital workforce shortage: Immediate and future. Trend Watch, 3(2), 1.
2.
Belgian government (Directorate-General for Development Co-operation) and the Ministries of Education and Sciences of Flanders. (2020). Analysing health systems to make them stronger: Belgian government (Directorate-General for Development Co-operation) and the Ministries of Education and Sciences of Flanders. http://www.strengtheninghealthsystems.be/framework_servicedelivery.html
3.
BhardwajA. (2020). COVID-19: A bigger challenge to the Indian Healthcare System India: Developing economics. https://developingeconomics.org/2020/04/13/covid-19-a-bigger-challenge-to-the-indian-healthcare-system/
4.
BirchS. (2015). Improving the fiscal and political sustainability of health systems through integrated population needs-based planning (Seminar Briefing #17). Office of Health Economics Research.
5.
CampbellJ., DussaultG., BuchanJ., Pozo-MartinF., Guerra AriasM., LeoneC., SiyamA., & ComettoG. (2013, November). A universal truth: No health without a workforce. Global Health Workforce Alliance and World Health Organization.
6.
Central Bureau of Health Intelligence. (2019). National health profile. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.
7.
ChetterjeP. (2020, May). Gaps in India's preparedness for COVID-19 control. The Lancet Infectious Diseases, 20(5), 544.
8.
DaviaudE., & ChopraM. (2008). How much is not enough? Human resources requirements for primary health care: A case study from South Africa. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 86, 46–51.
9.
DeoM. G. (2016). Time to revisit recommendations on doctor to population ratio in India. Journal of The Association of Physicians of India, 64, 72.
10.
Department of Health—South Africa. (2015). White paper on National Health Insurance South Africa. Government of South Africa (No. 39506). https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201512/39506gon1230.pdf
11.
DHHS, Public Health Service. (1994). The public health workforce: An agenda for the twenty-first century. U.S. Government Printing Office.
12.
DoostyF., MalekiM. R., & YarmohammadianM. H. (2019). An investigation on workload indicator of staffing need: A scoping review. Journal of Education and Health Promotion, 2019, 8.
13.
GebbieK., MerrillJ., & TilsonH. H. (2002). The public health workforce. Health Affairs, 21(6), 57–67.
14.
Global Health Workforce Alliance and World Health Organization. (2020). Human resources for health action framework. WHO. https://www.who.int/workforcealliance/knowledge/resources/haf/en/
15.
GreuningenMv. (2016). Health workforce planning in the Netherlands: How a projection model informs policy regarding the general practitioner and oral health care workforces. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/309111392_Health_workforce_planning_in_the_Netherlands_how_a_projection_model_informs_policy_regarding_the_general_practitioner_and_oral_health_care_workforces
16.
Jain-ChandraS., KindaT., KochharK., PiaoS., & SchauerJ. (2016). Sharing the growth dividend: Analysis of inequality in Asia. International Monetary Fund.
17.
JongudomsukP., LimwattananonS., PrakongsaiP., SrithamrongsawatS., PachaneeK., MoharaA., PatcharanarumolW., & TangcharoensathienV. (2012). Evidence-based health financing reform in Thailand. In CoadyD., ClementsB., & SanjeevG. (Eds.), The economics of public health care reform in advanced and emerging economies (pp. 307–326). International Monetary Fund.
18.
JowettM., BrunalM. P., FloresG., & CylusJ. (2016). Spending targets for health: No magic number. World Health Organization.
19.
KaranA., NegandhiH., NairR., SharmaA., TiwariR., & ZodpeyS. (2019). Size, composition and distribution of human resource for health in India: New estimates using National Sample Survey and Registry data. BMJ Open, 9(4), e025979.
20.
KunjuS. S. (2019, January 11). Cabinet approves 3 new AIIMSs in Gujarat, Jammu and Kashmir. ndtvcom. https://www.ndtv.com/education/cabinet-approves-3-new-aiimss-in-gujarat-jammu-and-kashmir-1975940#:~:text=The%20Union%20cabinet%20has%20today,statement%20from%20the%20Central%20government
21.
LiuJ. X., GoryakinY., MaedaA., BrucknerT., & SchefflerR. (2017). Global health workforce labor market projections for 2030. Human Resources for Health, 15(1), 11.
22.
MahlerD., LaknerC., AguilarA., & WuH. (2020). The impact of COVID-19 (Coronavirus) on global poverty: Why Sub-Saharan Africa might be the region hardest hit. World Bank. https://blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/impact-covid-19-coronavirus-global-poverty-why-sub-saharan-africa-might-be-region-hardest.
23.
MbweleB., ReddyE., & ReyburnH. (2012). A rapid assessment of the quality of neonatal healthcare in Kilimanjaro region, northeast Tanzania. BMC Pediatrics, 12(1), 182.
24.
McCafferyJ. A. (2011). Overcoming the hurdle of implementation: Putting human resources for health tools into action. Revista peruana de medicina experimental y salud publica, 28, 316–322.
25.
McintyreD., MeheusF., RøttingenJ.-A. (2017). What level of domestic government health expenditure should we aspire to for universal health coverage?Health Economics, Policy and Law, 12(2), 125–137.
26.
McQuideP. A., Kolehmainen-AitkenR.-L., & ForsterN. (2013). Applying the workload indicators of staffing need (WISN) method in Namibia: Challenges and implications for human resources for health policy. Human Resources for Health, 11(1), 64.
27.
Ministry of Health & Family Welfare. (2017). National health policy. Ministry of Health & Family Welfare.
28.
MisedaM. H., WereS. O., MuriankiC. A., MutukuM. P., & MutwiwaS. N. (2017). The implication of the shortage of health workforce specialist on universal health coverage in Kenya. Human Resources for Health, 15(1), 80.
29.
MoodieR., StucklerD., MonteiroC., SheronN., NealB., ThamarangsiT., LincolnP., CasswellS., & Lancet NCD Action Group. (2013, February 23). Profits and pandemics: Prevention of harmful effects of tobacco, alcohol, and ultra-processed food and drink industries. Lancet, 381(9867): 670–679.
30.
MureithiL., BurnettJ. M., BertscherA., & EnglishR. (2018). Emergence of three general practitioner contracting-in models in South Africa: A qualitative multi-case study. International Journal for Equity in Health, 17(1), 107.
31.
NamagandaG., OketchoV., ManipleE., & ViadroC. (2015). Making the transition to workload-based staffing: Using the workload indicators of staffing need method in Uganda. Human Resources for Health, 13(1), 89.
32.
NandanD., & AgarwalD. (2012). Human resources for health in India: Urgent need for reforms. Indian Journal of Community Medicine: Official Publication of Indian Association of Preventive & Social Medicine, 37(4), 205.
33.
NarainJ. P. (2016). Public health challenges in India: Seizing the opportunities. Indian Journal of Community Medicine: Official publication of Indian Association of Preventive & Social Medicine, 41(2), 85.
34.
National Department of Health. (2015). Framework and strategy for disability and rehabilitation services in South Africa 2015–2020. Department of Health Pretoria.
35.
National Health Mission. (2019). District hospital strengthening. https://nhm.gov.in/index1.php?lang=1&level=2&sublinkid=1216&lid=584
36.
OnoT., LafortuneG., & SchoensteinM. (2013). Health workforce planning in OECD countries. https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health/health-workforce-planning-in-oecd-countries_5k44t787zcwb-en
37.
Press Trust of India. (2012, May 20). One year rural posting mandatory for medical students. https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/one-year-rural-posting-mandatory-for-medical-students-483683
38.
Public Health Foundation of India. (2011). Masters of public health programs in India. Public Health Foundation.
39.
RaoK. D., BhatnagarA., & BermanP. (2012). So many, yet few: Human resources for health in India. Human Resources for Health, 10(1), 19.
40.
RoserM., RitchieH., Ortiz-OspinaE., & HasellJ. (2020). Coronavirus Pandemic (COVID-19). Our World in Data.
41.
RoussosS. T., & FawcettS. B. (2000). A review of collaborative partnerships as a strategy for improving community health. Annual Review of Public Health, 21(1), 369–402.
42.
Scheil-AdlungX. (2013). Health workforce benchmarks for universal health coverage and sustainable development. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 91, 888–889.
43.
SenguptaA., & NundyS. (2005). The private health sector in India. British Medical Journal Publishing Group.
44.
ShengeliaB., MurrayC. J., & AdamsO. B. (2003). Beyond access and utilization: Defining and measuring health system coverage. Health systems performance assessment: Debates, methods and empiricism (pp. 221–234). World Health Organization.
45.
SinghP., BrahmaD., & ChakrabortyS. (2020). Does India have enough doctors? An analysis of growing COVID-19 patients and existing medical capacity. Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2020/03/27/covid-19-does-india-have-enough-doctors-an-analysis-of-growing-covid-19-patients-and-existing-medical-capacity/
46.
SinhaK. (2012). 1,333 doctors migrated abroad last year. The Times of India, May 14. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/1333-doctors-migrated-abroad-last-year/articleshow/13128728.cms
47.
SmithA., RanchodS., StrugnellD., & WishniaJ. (2018). Human resources for health planning and National Health Insurance: The urgency and the opportunity. South African Health Review, 2018(1), 23–31.
48.
StevensF. C. J., KronemanM. W., & van der ZeeJ. (2017). Health-care delivery systems. International Encyclopedia of Public Health.
49.
SwaminathanS., HemalathaR., PandeyA., KassebaumN. J., LaxmaiahA., & LongvahT. (2019). The burden of child and maternal malnutrition and trends in its indicators in the states of India: The global burden of disease study 1990–2017. The Lancet Child & Adolescent Health, 3(12), 855–870.
50.
TalisunaA., YahayaA. A., RajatonirinaS. C., StephenM., OkeA., MpairweA., DialloA. B., MusaE. O., YotaD., BanzaF. M., WangoR. K., RobertsN. A., SreedharanR., KandelN., RashfordA. M., BoulangerL. L., HudaQ., ChungongS., YotiZ., & FallI. S. (2019). Joint external evaluation of the International Health Regulation (2005) capacities: Current status and lessons learnt in the WHO African region. BMJ Global Health, 4(6), e001312.
51.
TanahashiT. (1978). Health service coverage and its evaluation. Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 56(2), 295.
52.
ThakurK. (2017). Mind the gap: Health workforce shortage. The Pioneer, August 7, 2017. https://www.dailypioneer.com/2017/columnists/mind-the-gap-health-workforce-shortage.html
53.
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). (2019). Health at a glance 2019—OECD indicators. OECD.
54.
ThompsonM., & Walton-RobertsM. (2018). International nurse migration from India and the Philippines: The challenge of meeting the sustainable development goals in training, orderly migration and healthcare worker retention. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 2018, 1–17.
55.
Transparency International Health Initiative. (2020). Delivery of healthcare services United Kingdom: Transparency International UK. https://ti-health.org/delivery-of-healthcare-services/
56.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Office of the Director—Office of Strategy and Innovation. (2011). Introduction to program evaluation for public health programs: A self-study guide. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
57.
Van der ZeeJ., BoermaW., & KronemanM. (2004). Health care systems: Understanding the stages of development. R Jones, N Britten, L Culpepper et al. 2004.
58.
Van GreuningenM., BatenburgR. S., & Van der VeldenL. F. (2012, August 13). Ten years of health workforce planning in the Netherlands: A tentative evaluation of GP planning as an example. Human Resources for Health, 10, 21.
59.
WalwynD. R., & NkoleleA. T. (2018). An evaluation of South Africa’s public–private partnership for the localisation of vaccine research, manufacture and distribution. Health Research Policy and Systems, 16(1), 30.
60.
WeldegebrielZ., EjiguY., WeldegebrealF., & WoldieM. (2016). Motivation of health workers and associated factors in public hospitals of West Amhara, Northwest Ethiopia. Patient Preference and Adherence, 10, 159.
61.
World Bank. (2018). Poverty and shared prosperity 2018: Piecing together the poverty puzzle. World Bank.
62.
World Bank. (2020, May 7). Life expectancy at birth, total (years)—India 2018. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN?locations=IN
63.
World Health Organization. (2000). The world health report 2000: Health systems: Improving performance. World Health Organization.
64.
World Health Organization. (2008). Establishing and monitoring benchmarks for human resources for health: The workforce density approach. Spotlight on Health Workforce Statistics, 6, 1–2.
65.
World Health Organization. (2010). Increasing access to health workers in remote and rural areas through improved retention: Global policy recommendations. WHO.
66.
World Health Organization. (2016). Global strategy on human resources for health: Workforce 2030. WHO.
67.
World Health Organization. (2018). Density of nursing and midwifery personnel (total number per 1000 population, latest available year). Data GHOG.
68.
World Health Organisation. (2020). WHO announces COVID-19 outbreak a pandemic. WHO. http://www.euro.who.int/en/health-topics/health-emergencies/coronavirus-covid-19/news/news/2020/3/who-announces-covid-19-outbreak-a-pandemic
69.
World Health Organization (WHO). (2020). Regional office for Europe. Public health services: WHO Regional Office for Europe. http://www.euro.who.int/en/health-topics/Health-systems/public-health-services/public-health-services
70.
World Health Organisation. (2020). Health workforce: WHO. https://www.who.int/healthsystems/topics/workforce/en/
71.
World Health Organisation. (2020, May 25). WHO calls for healthy, safe and decent working conditions for all health workers, amidst COVID-19 pandemic. WHO. https://www.who.int/news-room/detail/28-04-2020-who-calls-for-healthy-safe-and-decent-working-conditions-for-all-health-workers-amidst-covid-19-pandemic
72.
ZopdeyS., TiwariR., & NegandhiH. (2019). Human resources for health. IAPSM's Book of Community Medicine. Jaypee Publishers.
73.
ZopdeyS., SharmaK., & NegandhiH. (2011). Public health education initiatives in India Public Health Foundation of India.
74.
ZurnP., Dal PozM. R., StilwellB., & AdamsO. (2004). Imbalance in the health workforce. Human Resources for Health, 2(1), 13.
