This article aims to explore the psychosocial practices in one of the sites that respond to vulnerable women who suffer abuse in their couple relationships: the criminal justice system. A discursive theoretical–methodological perspective is used (Foucault 1969; Ibáñez and Iñiguez 1997; Wetherell and Potter 1993), based on the discourse analysis and their positions that can be found in the practices of professionals in the criminal justice system (judges, prosecutors, lawyers, police), as well as in some of the narratives of vulnerable women. These accounts have been gathered through participant observations in courtrooms and police stations where complaints are filed, and through in-depth interviews. The results show the influence and the effects of: (a) an ‘empiricist position’ characterised by objectivity and emotional distance, and (b) a ‘professional position’ characterised by the predominance of professional roles and pragmatic experiences over reflexive practice. Nevertheless, emerging resistant practices include elements that could be placed in a ‘feminist position’ and provide new insights for the treatment of vulnerable women.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Albertín, P. and L. Iñiguez (2008). Using ‘drugs’. The meaning of opiate substances and their consumption from the consumer perspective . Addiction Research & Theory, 16 (5), 434–52 .
2.
Asbring, P. and A.L. Närvänen (2002). Women's experiences of stigma in relation to chronic fatigue syndrome and fibrommyalgia . Qualitative Health Research, 12 (2), 148–60 .
3.
Asnani, V. and M. Sawhney (2004). Social support and occupational health of working women . Journal of Health Management, 6 (2), 129–39 .
4.
Boonzaier, F. (2008). ‘ If the man says you must sit, then you must sit’: The relational construction of woman abuse: Gender, subjectivity and violence . Feminism Psychology, 18 (2), 183–206 .
5.
Burman, E. (1996). Identificación, subjetividad y poder en la psicoterapia feminista. In A.J. Gordo and J.L Linaza (eds), Psicologías, discursos y poder (PDP) (pp. 285–99). Madrid: Aprendizaje.Visor .
6.
Burman, E. (1997). Differentiating and de-developing critical social psychology. In T. Ibañez and L. Iñiguez (eds), Critical social psychology (pp. 229–40). London: Sage Publications .
7.
Butler, J. (1997). Mecanismos psíquicos del poder. Teorías sobre la sujecciän.Madrid: Cátedra .
8.
Campbell, J. , L.Rose , J. Kub and D. Nedd (1998). Voices of strength and resistance: A contextual and longitudinal analysis of women's responses to battering . Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 13 (6), 743–62 .
9.
Cavanagh, K. (2003). Understanding women's responses to domestic violence . Qualitative Social Work, 2 (3), 229–49 .
10.
Cubells, J. , P.Albertín , E. Rusiñol and M. Hernáez (2006). Sailing between stories: recovering silences and subjectivity. Resources psychosocials in the attention to victims of gender violence in the criminal context (Navegant entre narracions: recuperant silencis i subjectivitats. recursos psicosocials en l'atenció a víctimes de violència de gènere en l'àmbit penal (jutjats i cos policial). Available at http://www.gencat.net/dji/cejfe/investiga.htm. Accessed on 20 June 2008.
11.
Damant, D. , J. Bélanger and J. Paquet (2000). Analyse du processus d'empowerment dans des trajectoires de femmes victimes de violence conjugale à travers le système judiciaire . Criminologie, 33 (1), 73–95 .
12.
Denzin, N.K. , Y. Lincoln and S. Yvonna (eds) (1994). Handbook of qualitative research. California: Sage Publications .
13.
Edin, K.E. , A Lalos and L. Dahlgren (2008). Violent men: Ordinary and deviant . J Interpers Violence, 23 (2), 225–44 .
14.
Edwards R. and J. Ribbens (1988). Feminist dilemmas in qualitative research. London: Sage Publications .
15.
Erez, E. and L. Rogers (1999). Victim impact statements and sentencing outcomes and processes . British Journal of Criminology, 39 (2), 216–39 .
16.
Foucault, M. (1969). Archaeology of knowledge (trans. A. M. Sheridan Smith ). London: Routledge , 2002.
17.
Foucault, M. (1980). Power/Knowledge: selected interviews and other writings (1972–77). Brighton: Haverster .
18.
Geertz, C. (1975). The interpretation of cultures. New York: Basic Books .
19.
Gilligan, C. (1982). In a different voice: Psychological theory and women's development. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press .
20.
Gillum, T.L. (2008). Community response and needs of African American female: Survivors of domestic violence . J Interpers Violence, 23 (1), 39–57 .
21.
Gover, A.R. (2007). A specialized domestic violence court in South Carolina. An example of procedural justice for victims and defendants . Violence Against Women, 13 (6), 603–23 .
22.
Goodrum, S. (2007). Victims’ rights, victims’ expectations, and law enforcement workers’ constraints in cases of murder . Law & Social Inquiry, 32 (3), 725–57 .
23.
Halse, C. and A. Honey (2007). Rethinking ethics review as institutional discourse . Qualitative Inquiry, 13 (3), 336–52 .
24.
Halldorsdottir, S. (2000). Feeling empowered: A phenomenological case study of the lived experience of health. In B. Fridlund and C. Hildingh (eds), Qualitative methods in the service of health (pp. 82–96). Lund, Sweden: Studentlitteratur .
25.
Hamilton, M. (2006). Judicial discourses involving domestic violence and expert testimony. Ph.D. thesis, The University of Texas at Austin .
26.
Hartman, J.L. and J. Belknap (2003). Beyond the gatekeepers: Court professionals’ self-reported attitudes about and experiences with misdemeanor domestic violence cases . Criminal Justice and Behavior, 30 (3), 349–73 .
27.
Hydén, M. (2005). ‘ I must have been an idiot to let it go on’: Agency and positioning in battered women's narratives of leaving . Feminism & Psychology, 15 (2), 169–88 .
28.
Ibáñez, T. and L. Iñiguez (eds) (1997). Critical social psychology.London, Thousand Oaks, New Delhi: Sage Publications .
29.
Iñiguez L. (1996). Introducciän. In A.J. Gordo and J.L Linaza . Psicologías, discursos y poder (PDP) (pp. 109–13). Madrid: Aprendizaje.Visor .
30.
Lavis, V. , C. Horrocks and N. Kelly (2005). Domestic violence and health care: Opening pandora's box—challenges and dilemmas . Feminism & Psychology, 15 (4), 441–60 .
31.
Larrauri, E. (2007). Criminología crítica y violencia de género. Barcelona: Ed. Trotta. S.A.
32.
Lea, S.J. (2007). A discursive investigation into victim responsibility in rape . Feminism Psychology, 17 (4), 495–514 .
33.
Lonne, B. , C McDonald and T. Fox (2004). Ethical practice in the contemporary human services . Journal of Social Work, 4 (3), 345–67 .
34.
Moreno, C.L. (2007). The relationship between culture, gender, structural factors, abuse, trauma, and HIV/AIDS for latinas . Qualitative Health Research, 17 (3), 340–52 .
35.
Muñoz, J. (2005). Análisis cualitativo de datos textuales con ATLAS.ti 5 en. Available at http://antalya.uab.es/jmunoz/cuali/Atlas5.pdf. Accessed on 5 June 2008.
36.
Observatory Gender Violence (2008). Annual report of the State Observatory of Violence on the women. Available at http://www.observatorioviolencia.org/informes.php?id=10. Accessed on 12 June 2008.
37.
Perez, M. and S. Ross (2008). Police response to domestic violence: Making decisions about risk and risk management . Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 23, 454–73 .
38.
Ptacek, J. (1999). Battered women in the courtroom: The power of judicial responses.Boston: Northeastern University Press .
39.
Pujal, M. (2003). La tarea crítica: interconexiones entre lenguaje, deseo y subjetividad . Sociedad y política, 40 (1), 129–40 .
40.
Russo, N.F. , M.P. Koss and L. Goodman (1995). Male violence against women: A global health and development issue. In L.L. Adler and F.L. Denmark (eds), Violence and the prevention of violence (pp. 121–27). Connecticut: Praeger .
41.
Rusell, B.L and L.S. Melillo (2006). Attitudes toward battered women who kill: Defendant typicality and judgments of culpability . Criminal Justice and Behavior, 33 (2), 219–41 .
42.
Sánchez-Candamio, M. , M Pla , P. Albertín and M. Rodríguez (2001). The process of socialization of the medical personnel in formation. Contributions of the social qualitative research in the analysis of professional initiation (El procés de socialitzaciä dels personal mèdic intern resident. Aportacions de la investigaciä social qualitativa a l'anàlisi de l'iniciaciä professional en un context institucional). Barcelona: Generalitat de Catalunya & Instituto de Estudios de la Salud .
43.
Stalans, L.J. and M.A. Finn (1995). How novice and experienced officers interpret wife assaults: Normative and efficiency frames . Journal of Law & Society Review, 29 (29), 287–321 .
44.
Skuladorttir, H. and S. Halldorsdottir (2008). Women in Chronic pain: sense of control and Encounters with health professionals . Qualitative Health Research, 18 (7), 891–901 .
45.
Walklate, S. (ed.) (2007). Understanding criminology.London: McGraw-Hill companies .
46.
Wetherell, M.S. and J. Potter (1993). Mapping the language of racism. Brighton: Harvester .
47.
World Health Organization (2001). Strategic action plan for the health of women in Europe. Copenhager Denmark: WHO . Available from http://www.euro.who.int. Accessed on12 June 2008.
