Support for Social Health Insurance in South Africa

Abstract

A national cross-sectional survey was carried out in South Africa to gain an understanding of the perceptions and priorities of the likely members of a future social health insurance (SHI). More than 1,000 employees were interviewed in a variety of employment sectors, including state and parastatal organisations, formal and informal private sectors. This article reports on respondents’ level of support for a compulsory contribution towards a hospital insurance scheme funding care at public sector hospitals in South Africa.

The results showed that only 11 per cent of employees supported an SHI scheme if public hospitals remain as they are. Support increased to 53 per cent if preferential access to treatment was offered to those contributing to the scheme. Support was almost unanimous (87 per cent) if public hospitals were improved. The levels of support differed by current type of health insurance.

Thus, support for a compulsory SHI tax to fund care in public hospitals was conditional upon either improving the hospitals or providing differential treatment to contributing members. If one or both of these conditions are not met, its long-term success will be compromised.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abel Smith, B. and P. Rawal (1994). Employer's willingness to pay: The case for compulsory health insurance in Tanzania . Health Policy and Planning, 9 (4), 409–18 .

Atim, C. (1999). Social movements and health insurance: A critical evaluation of voluntary, non-profit insurance schemes with case studies from Ghana and Cameroon . Social Science and Medicine, 48 (7), 881–96 .

Blecher, M. and S. Thomas (2004). Health care financing. In P. Ijumba , C. Day and A. Ntuli (eds.), South African health review 2003/04 (pp. 269–90). Durban: Health Systems Trust .

Cornell, J. , M.J. Smith and G. Solanki (2001). Study of Public Priorities, Willingness and Ability to Pay for Social Health Insurance in South Africa. Pretoria: Department of Health .

Department of Health (1997). A Social Health Insurance Scheme for South Africa: Policy Document. Pretoria: Department of Health .

Doherty, D. , D. McIntyre and L. Gilson (2000). Social Health Insurance. In A. Ntuli (ed.), South African health review, 2000 (pp. 169–82). Durban: Health Systems Trust .

Gafni, A. (1997). Willingness to pay in the context of an economic evaluation of healthcare programs: Theories and practice . American Journal of Managed Care, 3 (Supplement), S21–32 .

Gumber, A. and V. Kulkarni (2000). Health insurance for informal sector: Case study from Gujarat . Economic and Political Weekly, 30 September, 3607–13 .

Lalloo, R. , M.J. Smith , N.G. Myburgh and G.C. Solanki (2004). Access to health care in South Africa: The influence of race and class . South African Medical Journal, 94 (8), 639–41 .

10.

Leon, N. and R. Mabope (2005). The private health sector. In P. Ijumba and P. Barron (eds.), South African health care review 2005 (pp. 32–43). Durban: Health Systems Trust .

11.

Mathiyazhagan, K. (1998). Willingness to pay for rural health insurance through community participation in India . International Journal of Health Planning and Management, 13 (1), 47–67 .

12.

Schneider, P.A. (2004). Why should the poor insure? Theories of decision-making in the context of health insurance . Health Policy and Planning, 19 (6), 349–55 .

13.

Wadee, H. , S. Gilson , D. Blaauw , E. Erasmus and A. Mills (2004). Public–private interactions in the South African health sector: Experience and perspectives from national, provincial and local levels. Johannesburg: Centre for Health Policy, University of Witwatersrand and Health Policy Unit, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine .

14.

Walraven, G. (1996). Willingness to pay for district hospital services in rural Tanzania . Health Policy and Planning, 11 (4), 428–37 .