The records of the customary law that seems to have been practised in early medieval India differ from those that survive from Western Europe, but the law that was followed in the two subcontinents seems rather similar. In both cases it offers insights to the structures and norms of the societies that produced it. It is harder to compare the evidence for the existence and the beginning of professional law since some aspects of the way that it began in Europe seem likely to be peculiar to that subcontinent. Consideration of possible reasons for the origin of European legal professions suggests, however, that it may be worth questioning any assumption there was no professional law in early medieval India.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BanerjiSures Chandra. 1998. A Companion to Dharmaśāstra, New Delhi.
2.
BarthélemyDominique. 2009. The Serf, the Knight and the Historian, trans.
EdwardsG.R.
Ithaca
3.
BrundageJames A.1995. Medieval Canon Law, New York.
4.
ChattopadhyayaBrajadulal. 1990. Aspects of Rural Settlements and Rural Society in Early Medieval India, Calcutta.
5.
ChattopadhyayaBrajadulal. 2000. A Sourcebook of Indian Civilization, Hyderabad.
6.
ClanchyMichael T.1970. ‘Remembering the Past and the Good Old Law’, History, vol. 55 (184): 165–76.
7.
Cosmas of Prague, Die Chronik der Böhmen. 1923, ed.
BretholzB.Berlin, Monumenta Germaniae Historica: Scriptores Rerum Germanicarum, NS2.
8.
DaviesRees.1986.‘The Administration of Law in Medieval Wales,’ in Charles-EdwardsT.OwenMorfydd E.WaltersD. B. (eds), Lawyers and Laymen, Cardiff: 258–73.
9.
DaviesWendyFouracrePaul (eds). 1986. The Settlement of Disputes in Early Medieval Europe, Cambridge.
10.
DavisDonald R.1999. ‘Recovering the Indigenous Legal Traditions of India’, Journal of Indian Philosophy, vol. 27 (3): 159–213.
11.
DavisDonald R.2004. The Boundaries of Hindu Law: Tradition, Custom and Politics in Medieval Kerala, Turin.
12.
DavisDonald R.2004. ‘Dharma in Practice: Acara and Authority in Medieval Dharmaśāstra’, Journal of Indian Philosophy, vol. 32 (5–6): 813–30.
13.
DavisDonald R.2005. ‘Intermediate Realms of Law: Corporate Groups and Rulers in Medieval India’, Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient, vol. 48 (1): 91–117.
14.
DavisDonald R.2008. Review of Mathur, Medieval Hindu Law, Indian Social and Economic History Review, vol. 45 (4): 588–90.
15.
DavisDonald R.2010. ‘A Historical Overview of Hindu Law’, in
LubinT.DavisDonald R.KrishnanJayanth K. (eds), Hinduism and Law: An Introduction,Cambridge: 17–27.
16.
DerrettJ.DuncanM.1964. ‘Law and the Social Order before the Muhammedan Conquests’, Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient, vol. 7: 73–120.
17.
DerrettJ.DuncanM. (1967–68). ‘Two Inscriptions Concerning the Status of Kammala and the Application of Dharmaśāstra’, in his Essays in Classical and Modern Indian Law, vol. 1: 86–110.
18.
DerrettJ.DuncanM.1977. ‘The Development of the Concept of Property in India’, in Essays in Classical and Modern Indian Law, vol. 2, Leiden: 8–130.
19.
EverettNicholas. 2003. Literacy in Lombard Italy, Cambridge.
20.
FrierBruce W.1985. The Rise of the Roman Jurists, Princeton.
21.
GarnseyPeterHumfressCaroline. 2001. The Evolution of the Late Antique World, Cambridge.
22.
GharpureJ.R. (ed. and trans.). 1936–44. Yajnavalkya Smrti with the Commentaries of the Mitāksharā by Vijñanesvara Bhikshu and Viramitrodaya by Mitramiśra, Bombay.
23.
GluckmanMax. 1965. Politics, Law and Ritual in Tribal Society, Oxford.
24.
KanePandurang Vaman. 1973. History of Dharmasastra, vol. 3, 2nd edition, Poona.
25.
Kautilya, Arthaśāstra. 1965, ed. and trans. KangleR.P., Bombay.
26.
KockaJürgen. 1996. ‘The Uses of Comparative History’, in
BjörkandR.MolinK. (eds), Societies Made up of History, Edsbruck, Sweden: 199–209.
27.
LarivièreRichard W.1981. ‘Ordeals in Europe and India’, Journal of the American Oriental Society, vol. 101: 347–49.
28.
LingatRobert. 1998. Classical Law of India, trans. DuncanJ.DerrettM.Calcutta.
29.
LubinTimothy. 2010. ‘Indic Conceptions of Authority’, in
LubinTimothy (ed.), Hinduism and Law: An Introduction, Cambridge: 137–54.
30.
MathurAshutosh Dayal. 2007. Medieval Hindu Law, New Delhi.
31.
MooreRobert Ian. 2000. The First European Revolution, Oxford.
32.
MooreSally Falk. 1989. ‘History and the Redefinition of Custom on Kilimanjaro’, in
StairJ.CollierJ.F.(eds), History and Power in the Study of Law, Ithaca: 277–301.
33.
MukhiaHarbans. 1998. ‘“Medieval India”: An Alien Conceptual Hegemony?’, The Medieval History Journal, vol. 1(1): 91–105.
34.
Nilakanta SastriKallidaikurichi Aiyah. 1932. Studies in Cōla History and Administration, Madras.
35.
Oxford English Dictionary. 1989, 2nd edition, Oxford.
36.
OlivellePatrick(ed and trans.).2005. Manu’s Code of Law: A Critical Edition and Translation of the Mānava-Dharmaśāstra, Oxford.
37.
RaddingCharles M.AntonioCiaralli. 2007. The Corpus Iuris Civilis in the Middle Ages: Manuscripts and Transmission from the Sixth Century to the Juristic Revival, Leiden.
38.
RaddingCharles M.AntonioCiaralli. 1988. The Origins of Medieval Jurisprudence, Newhaven.
39.
ReuterTimothy. ‘
Assembly Politics in Western Europe from the Eighth Century to the Twelfth’, in
LinehanPeterNelsonJanet L. (eds), The Medieval World, London: 432–50.
40.
ReynoldsSusan. 1994. Fiefs and Vassals: The Medieval Evidence Reinterpreted, Oxford.
41.
ReynoldsSusan. 1997. Kingdoms and Communities in Western Europe 900–1300, 2nd edition, Oxford.
42.
ReynoldsSusan. 2001. ‘Medieval Law’, in
LinehanPeterNelsonJanet L. (eds), The Medieval World, London: 485–502.
43.
ReynoldsSusan. 2003. ‘The Emergence of Professional Law in the Long Twelfth Century’, Law and History Review, vol. 21 (2): 347–66 (repr. in The Middle Ages without Feudalism).
44.
ReynoldsSusan. 2007. ‘Did All the Land Belong to the King?’, in
ShagritI.EllenblumRonnieRiley-SmithJonathan (eds), In Laudem Hierosolymitani: Studies in Crusades and Medieval Culture in Honour of Benjamin Z. Kedar, Aldershot: 263–71.
45.
ReynoldsSusan. 2012. ‘Assembly Government and Assembly Law’, in
NelsonJanetReynoldsSusanSueJohns (eds), Gender and Historiography: Studies in the Earlier Middle Ages in Honour of Pauline Stafford, London: 191–99.
46.
ReynoldsSusan. 2012. The Middle Ages without Feudalism, Farnham, Surrey: selected articles with two hitherto unpublished essays.
47.
ReynoldsSusan. 2012. ‘Vocabularies for Comparative and Interdisciplinary History’, in The Middle Ages without Feudalism (chap. XVII), Farnham, Surrey. 1–17.
48.
RioAlice. 2009. Legal Practice and the Written Word in the Early Middle Ages: Frankish Formulae, c. 500–1000, Cambridge.
49.
RocherLudo. 1969. ‘“Lawyers” in Classical Hindu Law’, Law and Society Review, vol. 3 (2/3): 383–401.
50.
SircarDinesh Chandra. 1973. Epigraphic Discoveries in East Pakistan, Calcutta.
51.
StaceyRobin. 2007. Dark Speech: The Performance of Law in Early Ireland, Philadelphia.
52.
ThaparRomila. 2002. Early India: From the Origins to AD 1300, London.
53.
VeluthatKesavan. 2009. The Early Medieval in South India, New Delhi.
54.
WeitzelJürgen. 1985. Dinggenossenschaft und Recht, Cologne.
55.
WhiteStephen D.1978. ‘“Pactum … legem vincit et amor judicium”: The Settlement of Disputes by Compromise in Eleventh-century France’,American Journal of Legal History, vol. 22 (4): 281–308.
56.
WhiteStephen D.1995. ‘Proposing the Ordeal and Avoiding It: Strategy and Power in Western French Litigation, 1050–1110’, in
BissonTmoas N. (ed.), Cultures of Power, Philadelphia: 89–123.
57.
WickhamChris. 1986. ‘Land Disputes and their Social Framework in Lombard–Carolingian Italy, 700–900’, in
DaviesWendyFouracrePaul (eds), The Settlement of Disputes in Early Medieval Europe, Cambridge: 105–24.
58.
WickhamChris. 1997. ‘Justice in the Kingdom of Italy in the Eleventh Century’, Settimane di studio del Centro italiano di studi sull’alto medioevo, vol. 44: 179–250.
59.
WickhamChris. 2009. ‘Problems in Doing Comparative History’, in SkinnerP. (ed.), Challenging the Boundaries of Medieval History: The Legacy of Timothy Reuter, Turnhout: 5–28.
60.
WickhamChris. 2010. ‘Historical Transitions: A Comparative Approach’, The Medieval History Journal, vol. 13 (1): 1–21.
