By comparing two natural disasters, earthquakes and epidemics, in particular the plague, this article tries to reconstruct general features of debates around disasters in medieval Islam. It points out several similarities such as the function as a punishment and warning in the early Islamic tradition, the apocalyptic dimension and the status of victims of both disasters as martyrs and comparisons with the problem of flight and desertion. Furthermore, there are conflicts between Islamic religion and Greek science, but in both cases the debates took place in separate bodies of literature. Apart from these common features there are also differences which can be partly explained by the natures of the phenomena and partly by specific developments in the debates around them.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Akasoy, Anna, forthcoming.‘Approaches to Earthquakes in Islamic Theology and Science’, in the proceedings of the conference Natural Disasters and Cultural Strategies: Responses to Disasters in Global Perspective, held at the German Historical Institute, Washington, D.C., February 2004.
2.
AmbraseysN.N., MelvilleC.P., and AdamsR.D.1994. The Seismicity of Egypt, Arabia and the Red Sea: a Historical Review, Cambridge.
3.
AntuñaM.M.1928. ‘Abenjátima de Almeria y su tratado de la peste’, Religión y Cultura (El Escorial/Madrid), vol. 1(4): 68–90.
4.
Calero SecallMaría Isabel.1991. ‘La peste en Málaga, según el malagueño al-Nubāhī’, in Homenaje al Profesor Jacinto Bosch Vilá, 2 vols, Granada: i, 57–72.
5.
ClémentJean-François.1984. ‘Jalâl al-Dîn al-Suyût'î (!), séismosophe’, in Tremblements de terre, Histoire et archéologie, IVèmes rencontres internationales d'archéologie et d'histoire d'Antibes, Valbonne: 253–87.
6.
ConradLawrence I.1981. ‘Arabic Plague Chronologies and Treatises: Social and Historical Factors in the Formation of a Literary Genre’, Studia Islamica, vol. 54: 51–93.
7.
ConradLawrence I.1982. ‘ā'ūn and wabā’: Conceptions of Plague and Pestilence in Early Islam’, Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient, vol. 25(3): 268–307.
8.
ConradLawrence I.1992. ‘Epidemic Disease in Formal and Popular Thought in Early Islamic Society’, in RangerTerence, and SlackPaul (eds), Epidemics and Ideas: Essays on the Historical Perception of Pestilence, Cambridge: 77–99.
9.
ConradLawrence I.1996. ‘Die Pest und ihre soziales Umfeld im Nahen Osten des frühen Mittelalters’, Der Islam, vol. 73: 81–112.
10.
ConradLawrence I.1998. ‘Umar at Sargh: The Evolution of an Umayyad Tradition on Flight from the Plague’, in LederStefan (ed.), Story-Telling in the Framework of Non Fictional Arabic Literature, Wiesbaden: 488–528.
11.
ConradLawrence I.1999. ‘Medicine and Martyrdom: Some Discussions of Suffering and Divine Justice in Early Islamic Society’, in HinnellsJohn R., and PorterRoy (eds), Religion, Health and Suffering, London: 212–36.
12.
ConradLawrence I.2000. ‘A Ninth-Century Muslim Scholar's Discussion of Contagion,’ in ConradLawrence I., and WujastykDominik (eds), Contagion: Perspectives from Pre-Modern Societies, Aldershot: 163–77.
13.
CookDavid.2002. Studies in Muslim Apocalyptic, Princeton.
14.
CookDavid.2007. Martyrdom in Islam, Cambridge.
15.
DaiberHans.1975. Ein Kompendium der aristotelischen Meteorologie in der Fassung des Ḥunain ibn Isḥâ, Amsterdam.
16.
DaiberHans.1980. Aetius Arabus. Die Vorsokratiker in arabischer Überlieferung, Wiesbaden.
17.
MichaelDols1974. ‘The Comparative Communal Responses to the Black Death in Muslim and Christian Societies’, Viator, vol. 5: 269–87.
18.
DaiberHans.1982. ‘Al-Manbijī's Report on the Plague: A Treatise on the Plague of 764-5/1362-64 in the Middle East’, in WillimanDaniel (ed.), The Black Death: Impact of the Fourteenth Century Plague, Binghamton: 65–75.
19.
FaroqhiSuraiya.1999. Approaching Ottoman History: An Introduction to the Sources, Cambridge.
20.
Gil'adiAvner.1989. '⋅abr (steadfastness) of Bereaved Parents. A Motif in Medieval Muslim Consolation Treatises and Some Parallels in Jewish Writings’, The Jewish Quarterly Review, vol. 80: 35–48.
21.
Gil'adiAvner.1995. ‘Islamic Consolation Treatises for Bereaved Parents. Some Bibliographical Notes’, Studia Islamica, vol. 81: 197–202.
22.
HanskaJussi.2002. Strategies of Sanity and Survival. Religious Responses to Natural Disasters in the Middle Ages, Helsinki.
23.
HawtingGerald.1999. The Idea of Idolatry and the Emergence of Islam. From Polemic to History, Cambridge.
24.
HeinenAnton M.1982. Islamic Cosmology: A Study of as-Suyūī's al-Hay'a as-sanīya fī 1-hay'a as-sunnīya with Critical Edition, Translation, and Commentary, Beirut.
25.
HirschlerKonrad.2006. Medieval Arabic Historiography. Authors as Actors, London.
26.
al-KhaŦībIbn, al-DīnLisān1863. ‘Ibnualkhatīb's Bericht über die Pest’, ed. M.J. Müller, in Sitzungsberichte der Königlichen Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu München: 1–34.
27.
KhātimahIbn1927. ‘Die Schrift von Abī Ja'far Aḥmed ibn ‘Alī ibn Moḥammed ibn ‘Alī ibn Hātimah aus Almeriah über die Pest’, ed. Taha Dinānah, in Archiv für Geschichte der Medizin, vol. 19: 27–81.
28.
IbnRushd.1994. Risālat al-āthār al- ‘ulwiyyah, ed. al-‘AjamRafīq, and JihāmīJīrār, Beirut.
29.
al-WardīIbn1974. ‘Ibn al-Wardī's Risālah al-naba’ ‘an al-waba’, A Translation of a Major Source for the History of the Black Death in the Middle East’, trans. Michael W. Dols, in KouymijanDickran K. (ed.), Near Eastern Numismatics, Iconography, Epigraphy and History: Studies in Honor of George C. Miles, Beirut: 443–56.
30.
JankriftKay Peter.2005. ‘Die Pest im Nahen Osten und in der mittelalterlichen arabischen Welt’, in MeierMischa (ed.), Pest. Die Geschichte eines Menschheitstraumas, Stuttgart: 225–33.
31.
KrausPaul.1936. ‘Extraits du kitâb a'lâm al-nubuwwa d'Abû Ḥâtim al-Râzî (Raziana II)’, Orientalia, N.S. vol. 5: 35-56 and 358-78, reprint in Paul Kraus, 1994. Alchemie, Ketzerei, Apokryphen im frühen Islam. Gesammelte Aufsätze, ed. Rémi Brague, Hildesheim, Zürich, New York.
32.
LettinckPaul.1999. Aristotle's Meteorology and its Reception in the Arab World, With an Edition and Translation of Ibn Suwār's Treatise on Meteorological Phenomena and Ibn Bājja's Commentary on the Meteorology, Leiden.
33.
LittleDonald P.1999. ‘Data on Earthquakes Recorded by Mamluk Historians: An Historiographical Essay’, in ZachariadouElizabeth (ed.), Natural Disasters in the Ottoman Empire, Rethomnon: 137–51.
34.
LozanoIndalecio.1990. Tres tratados árabes sobre el cannabis indica, Textos para la historia del hachís en las sociedades islámicas, S. XIII-XVI, Madrid.
35.
Al-Manbijī al-Ḥanbalī, Abū ‘Abdallāh Muḥammad ibn Muḥammad ibn Muḥammad, 1406/1986. Tasliyyat ahl al-ma⋅ā'ib, Beirut.
36.
NeuwirthAngelika.2003. ‘Qur'an and History—A Disputed Relationship. Some Reflections on Qur'anic History and History in the Qur'an’, Journal of Qur'anic Studies, vol. 5(1): 1–18.
37.
OrmsbyEric L.1984. Theodicy in Islamic Thought. The Dispute over al-Ghazālī's ‘Best of All Possible Worlds’, Princeton.
38.
PuigJosep.1992. ‘Materials on Averroes's Circle’, Journal of Near Eastern Studies, vol. 51(4): 241–60.
39.
The Qur'an.2004. Trans. M.A.S. Abdel Haleem, Oxford.
40.
RadtkeBernd.1992. Weltgeschichte und Weltbeschreibung im mittelalterlichen Islam, Beirut.
41.
SchulzeReinhard.2004. ‘Islamische Deutungen von Erdbeben und anderen Naturkatastrophen’, in PfisterChristian, and SummermatterStephanie (eds), Katastrophen und ihre Bewältigung: Perspektiven und Positionen, Bern: 101–117.
42.
StearnsJustin.2007. ‘Contagion in Theology and Law: Ethical Considerations in the Writings of Two 14th Century Scholars of Na⋅rid Granada’, Islamic Law and Society, vol. 14.
43.
StetkevychJaroslav.1996. Muḥammad and the Golden Bough: Reconstructing Arabian Myth, Bloomington.
Al-Suyūī1971. Kashf al-⋅al⋅ala ‘an wa⋅f al-zalzala (The Study of Rattle for the Description of the Earthquake), ed. al-Sa'dānīAbd al-Laīf, Fez.
46.
TahirMustafa Anwar.1979. Corpus de textes arabes relatifs aux tremblements de terre et autres catastrophes naturelles de la conquête arabe au XII H/XVIII J.C. Unpubl. Thèse de doctorat d'état, Paris I.
47.
TuckerWilliam.1999. ‘Environmental Hazards, Natural Disasters, Economic Loss, and Mortality in Mamluk Syria’, Mamluk Studies Review, vol. 3: 109–28.
48.
Al-ŦurŦūshīAbū Bakr.1993. Kitāb al-ḥawādith wa-l-bida’ (El libro de las novedades y las innovaciones) (al-Ma⋅ādir al-andalusiyya, 14) Madrid.
49.
UllmannManfred.1970. Die Medizin im Islam, Leiden.
50.
van EssJosef.2001. Der Fehltritt des Gelehrten: Die ‘Pest von Emmaus’ und ihre theologischen Nachspiele, Heidelberg.
51.
Van GelderGeert Jan.1998. ‘Four Perfumes of Arabia. A Translation of al-Suyūī's al-Maqāma al-Miskiyya’, Res Orientales, vol. 11: 203–11.
52.
Waldherr, GerhardH.1997. Erdbeben: Das auβergewöhnliche Normale. Zur Rezeption seismischer Aktivitäten in literarischen Quellen vom 4. Jahrhundert v. Chr. bis zum 4. Jahrhundert n. Chr., Stuttgart.
53.
WensinckA.J.1927. A Handbook of Early Muhammadan Tradition, Leiden.
54.
WitkamJan Just (ed.). 1986. ‘The Kitāb Qam ‘al-Wāšīn fī Damm al-Barrāšīn by Nūr al-Dīn ‘Alī b. al-Ǧazzār. A Facsimile Edition of the Unique Manuscript’, Manuscripts of the Middle East, vol. 1: 86–99.
