Tracking Efficiency of Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs)

Abstract

Exchange traded funds (ETFs) have emerged as a new investment vehicle in the mutual fund industry providing investors with the ability to trade the entire market through a single transaction executed at the exchange. Using a sample of 12 equity ETFs from 1 April 2011 to 31 March 2015, the present article attempts to examine the performance efficiency of ETFs in India and explore factors that drive the performance of ETFs away from their target indices. The study reveals that ETFs exhibit significant tracking error while trying to replicate the returns of their benchmark indices. The results of panel regression analysis further reveal that the assets under management and volume positively affected the tracking ability of ETFs whereas volatility is reported to have negative impact on the tracking efficiency of ETFs. The results will have important implications for investors, managers as well as for the evaluation criteria involved in assessing the performance of actively managed funds.

Keywords

Exchange traded funds tracking ability panel regression India

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agapova

(2011). Conventional mutual index funds versus exchange-traded funds. Journal of Financial Markets, 14(2), 323–343.

Blitz

Huij

Swinkels

(2012). The performance of European index funds and exchange-traded funds. European Financial Management, 18(4), 649–662.

Buetow

G. W.

Henderson

B. J.

(2012). An empirical analysis of exchange-traded funds. The Journal of Portfolio Management, 38(4), 112–127.

Chauhan

A. K.

(2015). Research analytics. New Delhi: Wiley-Dreamtech Publication.

Chu

P. K. K.

(2011). Study on the tracking errors and their determinants: Evidence from Hong Kong exchange traded funds. Applied Financial Economics, 21(5), 309–315.

Chu

P. K. K.

(2013). Tracking errors and their determinants: Evidence from Hong Kong exchange traded funds. Retrieved 2 February 2014, from http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn

Dellva

(2001). Exchange-traded funds not for everyone. Journal of Financial Planning, 14(4), 110–124.

Drenovak

Urošević

Jelic

(2012). European bond ETFs: Tracking errors and the sovereign debt crisis. European Financial Management, 20(5), 958–994.

EDHEC-Risk Institute. (2013). The EDHEC European ETF survey 2012. Retrieved 27 December 2014, from http://professoral.edhec.com/recherche/publications-edhec/2013/the-edhec-european-etf-survey-2012–183323.kjsp?RH=1358338213731

10.

Elton

E. J.

Gruber

M. J.

Comer

(2002). Spiders: Where are the bugs? The Journal of Business, 75(3), 453–472.

11.

ETFGI. (2015). ETFGI monthly news letter Q1 2015. Retrieved 4 July 2015, from http://www.etfgi.com/publications/reports/reportid/387

12.

Fassas

A. P.

(2014). Tracking ability of ETFs: Physical versus synthetic replication. The Journal of Index Investing, 5(2), 9–20.

13.

Ferri

R. A.

(2002). All about index funds: The easy way to get started. United States: McGraw-Hill.

14.

Frino

Gallagher

D. R.

(2001). Tracking S&P 500 index funds. The Journal of Portfolio Management, 28(1), 44–55.

15.

Frino

Gallagher

D. R.

(2002). Is index performance achievable? An analysis of Australian equity index funds. Abacus, 38(2), 200–214.

16.

Frino

Gallagher

D. R.

Neubert

A. S.

Oetomo

T. N.

(2004). Index design and implications for index tracking. The Journal of Portfolio Management, 30(2), 89–95.

17.

Furbush

(2002). Program trading. Retrieved from http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc1/ProgramTrading.html

18.

Garg

Singh

D. Y.

(2013). An empirical comparison of ETFs and index funds performance in India. International Journal of Applied Financial Management Perspectives, 2(3), 578–589.

19.

Gastineau

G. L.

(2001). An introduction to exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Journal of Portfolio Management and Economics, 27(3), 88–96.

20.

Grinblatt

Titman

(1989). Mutual fund performance: An analysis of quarterly portfolio holdings. The Journal of Business, 62(3), 393–416.

21.

Heino

Kromlid

(2014). Does size matter? The effect of assets under management on tracking error in the American ETF market (Unpublished bachelor thesis). Sweden: School of business, economics and law, University of Gothenburg.

22.

Houweling

(2012). On the performance of fixed income exchange traded funds. The Journal of Index Investing, 3(1), 39–44.

23.

Lofton

(2007). Getting started in exchange traded funds (ETFs). Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley Sons.

24.

Malkiel

B. G.

(1995). Returns from investing in equity mutual funds 1971 to 1991. The Journal of Finance, 50(2), 549–572.

25.

Meinhardt

Mueller

Schoene (2014). Physical and synthetic exchange traded funds: The good, the bad or the ugly? Retrieved 25 November 2014, from http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2026409

26.

Milonas

N. T.

Rompotis

G. G.

(2010). Dual offerings of ETFs on the same stock index: US vs. Swiss ETFs. The Journal of Alternative Investments, 12(4), 97–113.

27.

Narend

Thenmozhi

(2014). Performance of ETFs and index funds: A comparative analysis. Retrieved 4 October 2014, from http://www.nseindia.com/research/content/RP_15_Mar2014.pdf

28.

Perold

A. F.

(1988). The implementation shortfall: Paper versus reality. The Journal of Portfolio Management, 14(3), 4–9.

29.

Pope

P. F.

Yadav

P. K.

(1994). Discovering errors in tracking error. The Journal of Portfolio Management, 20(2), 27–32.

30.

Poterba

J. M.

Shoven

J. B.

(2002). Exchange traded funds: A new investment option for taxable investors (Working Paper No. w8781). USA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

31.

Roll

(1992). A mean/variance analysis of tracking error. The Journal of Portfolio Management, 18(4), 13–22.

32.

Rompotis

G. G.

(2005). An empirical comparing investigation on exchange traded funds and index funds performance. Retrieved 15 March 2013, from http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.903110

33.

Rompotis

G. G.

(2008a). Exchange-traded funds vs. index funds. ETF and Indexing, 2008 (1), 111–123.

34.

Rompotis

G. G.

(2008b). Performance and trading characteristics of German passively managed ETFs. International Research Journal of Finance and Economics, 15(3), 210–223.

35.

Rompotis

G. G.

(2011a). Predictable patterns in ETFs’ return and tracking error. Studies in Economics and Finance, 28(1), 14–35.

36.

Rompotis

G. G.

(2011b). The performance of actively managed exchange-traded funds. The Journal of Index Investing, 1(4), 53–65.

37.

Rompotis

G. G.

(2012). An empirical look at Swiss exchange traded funds market. Aestimatio: The IEB International Journal of Finance, 4, 52–81.

38.

Rowley

J. J.

Jr Kwon

D. T.

(2015). The ins and outs of index tracking. The Journal of Portfolio Management, 41(3), 35–45.

39.

Shanmugham

Zabiulla (2012). Pricing efficiency of Nifty BeES in bullish and bearish markets. Global Business Review, 13(1), 109–121.

40.

Shin

Soydemir

(2010). Exchange-traded funds, persistence in tracking errors and information dissemination. Journal of Multinational Financial Management, 20 (4–5), 214–234.

41.

Svetina

Wahal

(2008). Exchange traded funds: Performance and competition. Retrieved 2 April 2013, from http://ssrn.com/abstract=1303643

42.

Vardharaj

Fabozzi

F. J.

Jones

F. J.

(2004). Determinants of tracking error for equity portfolios. The Journal of Investing, 13(2), 37–47.

43.

Welch

(2013). On performance tracking error in exchange-traded funds and index mutual funds. Retrieved 2 December 2013, from http://digitalcommons.csbsju.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1006&context=acct_pubs

44.

Wiandt

McClatchy

(2002). Exchange traded funds. New York: John Wiley Sons.

45.

Wong

K. H.

Shum

W. C.

(2010). Exchange-traded funds in bullish and bearish markets. Applied Economics Letters, 17(16), 1615–1624.