This article reports on the profiles of the National Agricultural Research Systems (NARS) in the three Maghreb countries: Algeria, Morocco and Tunisia, through their research policies, human resources, governance, funding and scientific production. A bibliometric study was carried out for the three selected countries based on the Scopus database covering the period between 2005 and 2019. The research shows the distinctive case of Tunisian growth of scientific production compared to the other two countries; it also stresses the universities’ emergence as a major research actor, thus challenging the predominance of the public mission-oriented institutions dedicated to agriculture and veterinary sciences. Finally, it indicates significant differences between the three countries concerning governance and funding, and human resources. Overall, the NARS in the three countries are still very fragile, and a need for significant changes in the research policy making is certainly required to overcome these shortcomings.
Agence Pour le Développement Agricole (ADA). (2018). Guide de l’investisseur dans le secteur agricole au Maroc [Guide for investors in the agricultural sector in Morocco]. Rabat, Morocco. https://www.ada.gov.ma/documents-a-telecharge
2.
ArvanitisR., HanafiS., & PanceraA. (2014). Funding research: Granting councils and funds in the Middle East and North Africa (Unpublished report commissioned by IDRC). AUB & IRD.
3.
ArvanitisR., & M’HenniH. (2010). Monitoring research and innovation policies in the Mediterranean region. Science Technology & Society, 15(2), 233–269.
4.
ArvanitisR., & O’BrienD. (Eds.) (2019). The transformation of research in the South. Policies and outcomes (p. 166). Editions des archives contemporaines. ISBN: 9782813003034. 10.4000/books.irdeditions.32782
5.
ArvanitisR., RodriguezR., & ZoheiryA. H. (2013). The policy framework of Euro-Med cooperation on research and innovation. In MoriniC., RodriguezR., ArvanitisR., & ChaabouniR. (Eds.), Moving to the future in the Euro-Mediterranean Research and Innovation partnership: The experience of the MIRA project (pp. 19–23). Options Méditerranéennes, CIHEAM.
6.
BarbierM., & ElzenB. (2012). System innovations, knowledge regimes, and design practices towards transitions for sustainable agriculture. INRA. ISBN 2-7380-1306-6.
7.
BarbouchH. (2012, March6–7). The wave of change in 2011 and its impact on C&B Market: Toward new HR challenges? Presented at the North Africa session. MERCER. https://www.econostrum.info/attachment/344585/
8.
BenouarD. (2013). Algerian experience in education, research and practice. Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences, 102, 361–367.
9.
BNEDER. (2019, July6). Développement agricole: Installation du comité de la recherche scientifique [Agricultural development: Installation of the scientific research committee]. Web site of BNEDER (Algeria). https://bneder.dz/article.php?cle=5088
10.
BonneuilC. (2000). Development as experiment: Science and state building in late colonial and postcolonial Africa, 1930–1970. Osiris, 15(1), 258–281.
11.
BonneuilC., & KleicheM. (1993). Du jardin d’essais colonial à la station expérimentale 1880–1930: Elements pour une histoire du CIRAD [From the colonial test garden to the experimental station 1880–1930: Elements for a History of CIRAD]. CIRAD Coll. Autrefois l’Agronomie. http://agritrop.cirad.fr/321550/
12.
CouasnetS. (2014). Nous comptons renforcer notre activité R&D au Maroc dans les années à venir [We intend to strengthen our R&D activity in Morocco in the coming years] (Swisseco, N°25, avril-mai 2014). https://ccsm.ma/archives-files/pdf/swisseco25.pdf
13.
ChebbiH. E., & LachaalL. (2004). L’agriculture et la sécurité alimentaire: Une étude comparative des pays du Maghreb [Agriculture and food security: A comparative study of the Maghreb countries]. Revue Méditerranéenne D’économie, Agriculture et Environnement, 3(3), 4–11.
14.
ChehatF. (1995). La recherche agronomique en Algérie [Agricultural research in Algeria]. Cahiers du CREAD, 38(3), 135–166.
15.
Currie-AlderB., ArvanitisR., & HanafiS. (2018). Research in Arabic-speaking countries: Funding competitions, international collaboration, and career incentives. Science and Public Policy, 45(1), 74–82.
16.
DécailletP.-B. (2015). Les conquérants du monde ancien. Chroniques des premiers migrants européens en Afrique du Nord 1814–1912 [The conquerors of the ancient world. Chronicles of the first European migrants in North Africa 1814–1912]. (7th ed.). Collection Hippocrate.
17.
Direction Générale de la Recherche Scientifique et du Développement Technologique (DGRSDT). (2017). Etat des lieux de la recherche scientifique et le programme de la DGRSDT pour l’année 2018 [State of the art of scientific research and the program of the DGRSDT for the year]. http://www.dgrsdt.dz/DG/Etat-Lieux-RS-programme-DGRSDT-2018.pdf
18.
EdlerJ., & JamesA. D. (2015). Understanding the emergence of new science and technology policies: Policy entrepreneurship, agenda setting and the development of the European Framework Programme. Research Policy, 44(6), 1252–1265.
19.
EllatifiM. (2012). L’économie de la forêt et des produits forestiers au Maroc: Bilan et perspectives [The economy of the forest and forest products in Morocco: Assessment and prospects] (Doctorate thesis in Economy). University of Montesquieu, 424 p.
20.
ElzenB., BarbierM., CerfM., & GrinJ. (2012). Stimulating transitions towards sustainable farming systems. In DarnhoferI., GibbonD., & DedieuB. (Eds.), Farming systems research into the 21st century: The new dynamic (pp. 431–455). Springer.
21.
EvensonR. E. (2001). Economic impacts of agricultural research and extension. In GardnerB. L. & RausserG. C. (Eds.), Handbook of agricultural economics (Vol. 1., pp. 573–628). Elseiver.
22.
Food and Agricultural, Organization (FAO). (2005). Sub regional office of FAO for North Africa (Newsletter No. 3), 3rd Quarter, 2013. http://www.fao.org/3/aq709e/aq709e.pdf
23.
Food and Agricultural, Organization (FAO). (2017). Stratégie 2018–2021 en Afrique du Nord. Food and Agricultural Regional Office. http://www.fao.org/3/a-i7054f.pdf
24.
GaillardJ., & BouabidH. (2017). Le système national de recherche et d’innovation (SNRI) marocain et son internationalisation [The Moroccan National Research and Innovation, System (SNRI) and its internationalization]. In GaillardJ., & BouabidH. (Eds.), La recherche scientifique au Maroc et son internationalisation [The scientific research in Morocco its internationalization] (pp. 33–65). EUE. ISBN 978-3-330-86537-2.
25.
HammoutiB. (2010). Comparative bibliometric study of the scientific production in Maghreb countries (Algeria, Morocco and Tunisia) in 1996–2009 using Scopus. Journal of Materials and Environmental Science, 1(2), 70–77.
26.
HanafiS., & ArvanitisR. (2013). Strengths and weaknesses of science and technology institutions in Arab countries. Escwa Technology Center.
27.
HanafiS., & ArvanitisR. (2016). Knowledge production in the Arab world: The impossible promise. Routledge.
28.
HassanE. (n.d.). Diagnostic du système national de la recherche et d’innovation en Tunisie [Diagnosis of the national system of research and innovation in Tunisia]. Retrieved from http://tunisie-innovation.tn/upload/1457019093.pdf
29.
Hassan II Agronomic and Veterinary, Institute (IAV Hassan II). (2015). Rapport du Conseil d’Adminitration, 2015 [Administration council report, 2015] (unpublished document).
30.
Institut National pour la Recherche Agricole (INRA). (2017). Objectifs du programme de recherche à moyen terme de l’INRA: PMRT 2017–2020 [Objectives of INRA’s medium-term research program of INRA: PMRT 2017–2020]. https://www.inra.org.ma/fr/content/objectifs-du-programme-de-recherche-%C3%A0-moyen-terme-de-linra-prmt-2017-2020
31.
Institution de la Recherche et de l’Enseignement Supérieur Agricoles (IRESA). (2009). Rapport du comité national d’evaluation des activités de recherche scientifique. Ministry of Agriculture and Hydraulic Resources [Report of the national committee for the evaluation of scientific research activities. Ministry of Agriculture and Hydraulic Resources].
32.
Institution de la Recherche et de l’Enseignement Supérieur Agricoles (IRESA). (2014). Guide des établissements de recherche et d’enseignement supérieur agricoles relevant de l’IRESA [Guide to Agricultural Research and Higher Education Institutions under IRESA]. Ministry of Agriculture and Hydraulic Resources. http://www.iresa.agrinet.tn/announce/final.pdf
33.
Institution de la Recherche et de l’Enseignement Supérieur Agricoles (IRESA). (2018). Priorités de la recherche agricole à l’Horizon 2030 [Priorities for agricultural agricultural research to 2030]. https://fr.readkong.com/page/priorites-de-la-recherche-scientifique-agricole-a-l-horizon-9148812
34.
JouveA. (1999). Evolution des structures de production et modernisation du secteur agricole au Maghreb [Evolution of production structures and modernization of the agricultural sector in the Maghreb]. Options Méditerranéennes (CIHEAM), 36, 223–233.
35.
KarrayB., MsallamM., & KsantiniM. (2009). Programmes et acquis de recherches pour la rénovation de la filière huile d’olive et l’amélioration de ses performances [Programs and research achievements for the renovation of the olive oil sector and the improvement of its performance]. Ministère de l’Agriculture et des Ressources Hydrauliques, Institut de l’Olivier-Tunisie.
36.
KhelfaouiH. (2000). La science en Algérie: Final Report Science in Science in Africa at the daw of the 21st Century [Science in Algeria. In Science in Africa in the Dawn of the 21th century. Final report] (Report performed under the supervision of Roland Wasst and Jacques Gaillard). European Comission, DG XII.
37.
KleicheM., LaazizI., & ZebakhS. (2007). La recherche scientifique au Maroc [Scientific research in Morocco] (Synthetic Report of the Project ESTIME). IRD.
38.
LundvallB.-Å. (Ed.) (1996). National systems of innovation. Towards a theory of innovation and interactive learning. Pinter Publishers.
39.
LasramM. (2013). Histoire de l’INRAT: Cent ans au service de l’agriculture tunisienne [History of INRAT: One hundred years at the service of Tunisian agriculture]. Annales de l’INRAT, 86, 4–44.
40.
Ministère de l’Agriculture et de la Pêche Maritime (MAPM). (2012). Note de présentation du mécanisme compétitif [Note on the presentation of the mechanism competitive] (Note circulaire n°2435/DEFR du 24 décembre 2012). http://212.217.47.12/sites/default/files/Note-circulaire-MCRDV.pdf
41.
Ministère de l’Agriculture et de la Pêche Maritime (MAPM). (2014). Etude sur la stratégie national de la formation et recherche agricole-SNFRA (Rapport de synthèse phase 3 [Study on the National Strategy for training and agricultural, research (Synthesis report phase 3)]—(Internal document)). Ministère de l’Agriculture et de la Pêche Maritime.
42.
Ministère de l’Agriculture et de la Pêche Maritime (MAPM). (2015). Contrats programmes pour le développement des filières de production [Program contracts for the development of production sectors]. http://www.agriculture.gov.ma/sites/default/files/contrats_programmes_vf.pdf
43.
Ministère de l’Enseignement Supérieur et de la Recherche Scientifique-Direction Générale des Enseignements et de la Formation Supérieurs (MESRS-DGEFS). (2015). L’enseignement supérieur en Algérie [Higher education in Algeria]. http://www.univ-ouargla.dz/MESRS/Lenseignement_sup%C3%A9rieur_EN_DZ.pdf
44.
Ministère de l’Enseignement Supérieur et de la Recherche Scientifique-Direction Générale de la Recherche Scientifique et du Développement Technologique (MESRS-DGRSDT). (2012). Bilan et perspectives. http://algerianembassy-saudi.com/PDF/bilan_perspectives.pdf
45.
MoutonJ., & WaastR. (2009). Comparative study on national research systems: Findings and lessons. In MeekV. L., TeichlerU., & KearneyM. L. (Eds.), Higher education, research and innovation: Changing dynamics (pp. 147–170). International Centre for Higher Education Research Kassel.
46.
Office Chérifien de Phosphate (OCP). (2017). Switch to digital. Rapport Annuel. Groupe OCP. https://www.ocpgroup.ma/sites/default/files/2018-11/RA%20OCP%202017%20VF.pdf
RahmouniH. (2015). La concrétisation des budgets de recherche en Algérie. Cas de l’Université des Sciences et de la Technologie d’Oran [The realization of research budgets in Algeria. Case of the University of Sciences and Technology of Oran] (Master’s thesis, University of Oran 2 Mohamed Ben Ahmed, Oran, Algeria). http://www.univ-oran2.dz/images/these_memoires/FSC/Magister/TMSC-6/memoire%20final-1%20(2)%20PDF.pdf
49.
RouhaS. (2015). La passerelle entre le monde socio-économique et la recherche scientifique [The bridge between the socio-economic world and scientific research], l’Agence Nationale de Valorisation de Résultats de la Recherche et du Développement Technologique (ANVREDET). El-Djazaïr Com, 83, 2–4.
50.
SolariJ. (1965). L’enseignement agricole en Algérie de 1830 à 1962 [Agricultural education in Algeria from 1830 to 1962]. 1–26. http://www.algerie-ecole-1830-1962.com/temoignage/temoignage_24.pdf
US Congress, House Committee on Foreign Affairs. (1982). Foreign assistance legislation for fiscal year 1983 (part 1): Hearings before the Committee on Foreign Affairs, House of Representatives, Ninety-seventh Congress, second session. U.S. G.P.O.
55.
WaastR., & Kleiche-DrayM. (2009). Evaluating a national research system: Morocco. European Commission.
56.
WaibelH. (2006). Impact assessment of agricultural research for development and poverty reduction (Working Paper No. 2). Development and Agricultural Economics, University of Hannover.
57.
World Bank. (2020). World Bank national accounts data, and OECD national accounts data files. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NV.AGR.TOTL.ZS?end=2015&start=1960
58.
ZebakhS., ArvanitisR., BoutrachehH., & SadikiM. (2017). Trends in the Moroccan agricultural research: An exploratory bibliometric analysis (2005–2015). STI 2017. Open Indicators: Innovation, Participation and Actor-Based STI Indicators, 5, 255–268.
59.
ZebakhS., & FinanceJ. (2017). La coopération scientifique avec l’Europe: la participation du Maroc aux programmes européens [Scientific cooperation with Europe: Morocco’s participation in European in European programs]. In GaillardJ. & BouabidH. (Eds.), La recherche scientifique au Maroc et son internationalisation [Scientific research in Morocco and its internationalization]. (pp. 121–156). Editions Universitaires Européennes.
