This paper presents a first look at the Indian IT experience from the perspective of Israel. It consists of a set of three case studies of Indian IT firms, one a multinational subsidiary, one an innovative small firm and one a mainline software export firm. The Indian IT industry is viewed in the context of the Israeli experience in fostering an internationally competitive high-tech IT industry through various policy measures, both horizontal and targeted, with special reference to venture capital and globalisation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Avnimelech, G. and M. Teubal (2001), 'Israel's Venture Capital Industry: Emergence, Development and Impact'. Report to Directorate General Enterprise, Commission of European Communities, IPS Programme, Project IFISE ('A Methodology for the Creation of Seed and Start-Up Capital Sources for High-Tech Firms in Europe following the Israeli Success Stories of Yozma'), Jerusalem .
2.
Avnimelech, G., A. Gayego and M. Teubal (2000), 'Country Report: Israel'. Typescript, Targeted Socio-Economic Research (TSER) Project ('SMEs in Europe and Asia'), Jerusalem.
3.
Bank of Israel (2001), Report of the Bank of Israel (Year 2000). Jerusalem: Bank of Israel.
4.
Bartzokas, A. and M. Teubal (2002), 'How a Policy Perspective should be Integrated in Research on Technology and Economic Growth', Economics of Innovation and New Technology (special issue), 11 (1&2).
5.
Blass, A. and Y. Yafeh (2001), 'Vagabond Shoes Longing to Stray: Why Foreign Companies List in the US', Journal of Banking and Finance , 25 (3), pp. 555-72.
6.
Gelvan, D. and M. Teubal (1997), 'Emergence of Israel's Venture Capital Industry '. Paper presented in a conference in honour of Alexander Volta, Como, Italy.
7.
Haaretz (2000), 7 August.
8.
— (2001), 1 February.
9.
Office of the Chief Scientist (OCS) (1999), 'Encouragement of Industrial R&D in Israel'. Israel Ministry of Industry and Trade, Jerusalem.
10.
Justman, Moshe and E. Zuscovitch (2000), 'The Economic Impact of Subsidized Industrial R&D in Israel'. Paper presented at the EUNIP Conference, Eindhoven Technological University, Tilburg.
11.
Lall, S. and M. Teubal (1998), 'Market Stimulating Policies for Developing Countries: Lessons from Asia', World Development, 26 (8), pp. 1369-86.
12.
Michlol (1999), 'Evaluation of the "Regular" R&D Program: Report of a Consultancy'. Michlol, Tel Aviv.
13.
Nelson, R. (1995), 'Recent Evolutionary Theorizing about Economic Change', Journal of Economic Literature, 23 (March).
14.
Saxenian, A. (1998), Regional Development: Culture and Competition in Silicon Valley and Route 128. Cambridge, MA, and London: Oxford University Press.
15.
Teubal, M. (1982), 'The R&D Performance through Time of High-tech Firms: Methodology and an Illustration', Research Policy, 11, pp. 271-87.
16.
— ( 1986), Innovation Performance, Learning and Government PolicyMadison: University of Wisconsin Press.
17.
— ( 1993), 'The Innovation System of Israel: Problems and Outstanding Issues', in R. Nelson, ed., National Innovation Systems. New York: Oxford University Press.
18.
— (1996), 'R&D and Technology Policy at NICs as Learning Process', World Development, 24, pp. 449-60.
19.
— (1997), 'A Catalytic and Evolutionary Perspective to Horizontal Technology Policy (HTP)', Research Policy, 25, pp. 1161-88
20.
— (1999), 'Towards an R&D Strategy for Israel', The Economic Quarterly (in Hebrew), December.
21.
— (2000), 'The Systems Perspective to Innovation and Technology Policy (ITP): General Principles and Selected Themes'. Paper presented to the Schumpeter Society Meeting, Manchester , July.
22.
— (2002), 'What is the Systems of Innovation Perspective to Innovation and Technology Policy (ITP), and How Can We Apply it to Developing and Newly Industrializing Countries?', Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 12 (1-2), pp. 235-53.
23.
Teubal, M. and E. Andersen (2000), 'Restructuring and Embeddedness of the Business Enterprises: A Systems and Policy Perspective', Industrial and Corporate Change, 9, pp. 87-111.
24.
Teubal. M., N. Arnon and M. Trajtenberg (1976), 'Performance in Innovation in Israel's Electronics Industry: A Case Study of Biomedical Electronics Instrumentation', Research Policy, 5, pp. 534-79.
25.
Teubal, M. and G. Avnimelech (2001), 'Who in Peripheral Economies Benefits from Globalization: Acquisitions, Indigenous Company Growth and Access to Complementary Assets in Israel's Data Security Industry'. Paper submitted to Industrial and Corporate Change.
26.
Toren, B., ( 1990), 'R&D in Industry', in D. Brodet, M. Justman and M. Teubal, eds, Industrial Policy for Israel . Jerusalem: Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies.
27.
Trajtenberg, M. (2000), 'R&D Policy in Israel: An Overview and Reassessment '. Working Paper 7930, National Bureau of Economic Research , Cambridge, MA.
