Technology Policies and Acquisition of Technological Capabilities in the Industrial Sector: A Comparative Analysis of the Indian and Korean Experiences

Abstract

This paper reviews the science and technology policy of India and Korea in a comparative perspective to draw relevant lessons for India. It shows that policies, strategies and struc tures of science and technology evolved under a planned development approach in both Korea and India. However, while Korea created a strong national innovation system and acquired phenomenal technological capabilities, India had vital links missing that weak ened the performance of this system and resulted in a poor R&D performance of firms in the industrial sector. Four conditions need to be satisfied for building an effective national innovation system: (a) strong competitive pressures on domestic firms; (b) the presence of high-quality human capital; (c) well-developed industry-institutes-academia links; and (d) access to foreign technologies. While Korea tailored its policies to accommodate these conditions in each stage of its development, India failed to evolve an appropriate mix of these critical ingredients. The paper proposes to adopt a more focused but a multidimen sional integrated approach to create technological dynamism within the country.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abramovitz, M. (1956), 'Resources and Output Trends in the United States since 1870', American Economic Review and Proceedings, 46(2), pp. 5-23.

—. (1989), Thinking about Growth. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.

Ahluwalia, I.J. (1991), Productivity and Growth in Indian Manufacturing . New Delhi: Oxford University Press .

Ahmad, R. and M. Rakesh (1991), Insight into Scientific Research in Indian Universities and the Institutes of Technology. New Delhi: Council of Scientific and Industrial Research.

Aicte (1994), Report of the High Power Committee for Mobilization of Additional Resources for Technical Education by All India Council for Technical Education. New Delhi : AICTE.

Alam, G. (1993), 'Research and Development by Indian Industry: A Study of the Determinants of its Size and Scope', Mimeo, Centre for Technology Studies, New Dclhi.

Balakrishanan P. , K. Pushpangadan and M. Suresh Babu (2000), 'Trade Liberalization and Productivity Growth in Manufacturing: Evidence from Firm level Panel Data', Economic and Political Weekly, 35(41), pp. 3679-82.

Barber J. and G. White (1987), 'Current Policy Practice and Problems from a UK Perspective', in P. Dasgupta and Paul Stoneman, (eds), Economic Policy and Technological Performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 24-50.

Basant, R. and B. Fikkert (1996),'The Effects of R&D, Foreign Technology Purchase and Domestic and International Spillovers on Productivity in Indian Firms ', Review of Economics and Statistics, 78(1), pp. 187-99.

10.

Bhagwan, M.R. (1995), 'Technological Implications of Structural Adjustment: The Case of India', Economic and Political Weekly, 30(7 and 8), pp. M2-M12.

11.

Chandra, P. and P.R. Shukla (1994), 'Manufacturing Excellence and Global Competitiveness ', Economic and Political Weekly, 29(9), pp. 679-90.

12.

Csir 1996, 'CSIR 2001 Vision and Strategy' Draft paper, Council for Scientific and Industrial Research, New Delhi, January.

13.

Das, D.K. 1998, 'Trade Liberalization and Productivity Growth: A Disaggregated Analysis of Indian Manufacturing Sectors'. Working Paper Series No. E/200/98, Institute of Economic Growth, Delhi.

14.

Denison, E. (1962), 'United States Economic Growth', Journal of Business, August.

15.

Desai, A.V. (1980),'The Origin and Direction of R&D in India', Research Policy, 9(1), pp. 74-96.

16.

—. (1984), 'India's Technological Capability: An Analysis of Its Achievements and Its Limitations', Research Policy , 13, pp. 303-10.

17.

—. (1985), 'Market Structure and Technology: Their Interdependence in Indian Industry', Research Policy, 14, pp. 161-70.

18.

—. (1990), 'Recent Technology Imports into India: Results of A Survey', Development and Change, 21(4), pp. 723-49.

19.

Dst (1999a), R&D in Industry, 1996-97. Delhi: Government of India .

20.

—. (1999b), Research and Development Statistics, 1996-97 . Delhi: Government of India.

21.

—. (2000), Data Book 2000. Delhi: Government of India.

22.

Goldar, B.N. (1995), 'Technology Acquisition and Productivity Growth: A Study of Industrial Firms in India'. IEG Working Paper Series E/172/95, Delhi.

23.

Goldar, B.N. and VS Renganathan (1998), 'Economic Reforms and R&D Expenditures of Industrial Firms in India', Indian Economic Journal, 46(2), pp. 60-75.

24.

Goldman M. , H. Ergas , E. Ralph and G. Felker (1997), 'Technology Institutions and Policies: Their Role in Developing Technological Capability in Industry'. World Bank Technical Paper No. 383, World Bank.

25.

Government of India (2001), Economic Survey 2000-2001. New Delhi: Ministry of Finance.

26.

Griliches, Z. (1958), 'Research Costs and Social Returns: Hybrid Corn and Related Innovations', Journal of Political Economy, 66(5), pp. 419-31.

27.

—. (1986), 'Productivity, R&D and Basic Research at the Firm Level in the 1970s',American Economic Review, 76(1), pp. 141-54.

28.

Icici (1994), Productivity in Indian Manufacturing: Private Corporate Sector 1972-73 to 1991-92. Mumbai: Industrial Capital and Investment Corporation of India.

29.

Jain, Aradhana (1998), 'TNCs, Technology and Industrial Structure: Indian Experience in the 1980s'. Ph.D. Dissertation, Delhi School of Economics, Delhi.

30.

Jain, A. and A. Oberoi (1993), 'Science and Technology Policies: A Comparative Study of Japanese and Indian Experience', Journal of Scientific and Industrial Research, 52 (November), pp. 717-27.

31.

Jain, A. et. al (1989), 'Science and Technology Policies and in India', in P.J. Lavakare and J.G. Waardenberg (eds), Science Policies in International Perspective: The Experience of India and Netherlands. New Delhi: Pinter, pp. 139-152.

32.

Jha, Jyotsna (1994), 'Drains and Gains through International Migration of Trained Manpower: The Indian Case with a Study of Migrating IIT Graduates '. Ph.D. Dissertation, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi.

33.

Hyung Sup Choi (1986), 'Science and Technology Policies for Industrialisation of Developing Countries', Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 29(3), pp. 225-39.

34.

Kim, L. ( 1987), Imitation and Apprentice: How Korea Acquired Technological Capability Fast Korea: College of Business Administration, Korea University.

35.

—. (1988), 'Entrepreneurship and Innovation in a Rapidly Developing Country', Journal of Development Planning, 18, pp. 183-194.

36.

—. (1991), Absorptive Capability and Industrial Growth: A Conceptual Framework and Korea's Experience'. Paper presented at the 20th Anniversary Symposium on Economic Growth and Social Capability, Seoul, July.

37.

Kim, L. and C.J. Dahlman (1992), 'Technology Policy for Industrialization: An Integrative Framework and Korea's Experience', Research Policy, 27, 437-52.

38.

Kim, S.G. (1995), 'S&T promotion Policy and the Incentive Scheme for Technological Capability Building in Korea: Facts and Characteristics ' in Review of Science and Technology Policy for Industrial Competitiveness in Korea. Korea: Science and Technology Policy Institute, pp. 69-116.

39.

Krishna, V.V. (1997), 'A Portrait of the Scientific Community in India: Historical Growth and Contemporary Problems', in J. Gaillard , V.V. Krishna and R. Waast , eds, Scientific Communities in the Developing World. New Delhi: Sage Publications, pp. 237-79.

40.

—. (2001), 'Reflections on the Changing Status of Academic Science in India', International Social Science Journal (Special issue on Science and Cultures) (168), pp. 232-45.

41.

Krishna, V.V. and Binod Khadria (1997), 'Phasing Scientific Migration in the Context of Brain Gain and Brain Drain in India', Science, Technology & Society, 2(2), pp. 347-85.

42.

Kumar, N. (1998), Globalization, Foreign Direct Investment and Technology Transfers: Impacts on and Prospects for Developing Countries. London and New York: Routledge .

43.

Kumar N. and A. Aggarwal (2000), 'Liberalisation, Outward Orientation and In-house R&D Activity of Multinational and Local Firms: A Quantitative Exploration for Indian Manufacturing'. Paper presented at a conference organised by GDN, Tokyo, 10-13 December.

44.

Kumar, N. and N.S. Siddharthan (1997), Technology, Market Structure and Internationalization: Issues and Policies for Developing Countries. London and New York: Routledge .

45.

Kuznets, P.W. (1988), 'An East Asian Model of Development: Japan, Taiwan and South Korea', Economic Development and Cultural Change , 36(3), pp. S11-S43.

46.

Lall, S. (1987), Learning to Industrialize: The Acquisition of Technological Capability by India. London: Macmillan.

47.

—. (1992), 'Technological Capabilities and Industrialization ', World Development 20(2), pp. 165-86.

48.

—. (1998), 'Technology and Human Capital in Maturing Asian Countries', Science, Technology and Society, 3(1), pp. 11-48.

49.

Kong-Rae Lee (2001), 'From Fragmentation to Integration: Development Process of Innovation Clusters in Korea', Science, Technology and Society', 6(2), pp. 305-27.

50.

Lim, Y. ( 1995), 'Establishment of Korean National R and D Program in the 1980s and its Development in the 1990s: Its Content and Role in Building the Korean System of Innovation', in Review of Science and Technology Policy for Industrial Competitiveness in Korea. Science and Technology Policy Institute, pp. 145-84.

51.

Metcalfe, J.S. (1995), 'Technology Systems and Technology Policy in an Evolutionary Framework', Cambridge Journal of Economics, 19(1) pp. 25-46.

52.

Mowery, D.C. and J.E. Oxley (1995), 'Inward Technology Transfer and Competitiveness: The Role of National Innovation System', Cambridge Journal of Economics, 19(1), 67-93.

53.

Nagpaul, P.S. (1997), Scientrometric Profile of Academic Science in India. New Delhi: NISTADS.

54.

Nam, Y-H. (1995), 'The Changing Roles of Government-supported Research Institutes in Korea: Analysis of their Missions from their Inception to the Present', in Review of Science and Technology Policy for Industrial Competitiveness in Korea. Korea: Science and Technology Policy Institute, pp. 185-236.

55.

Nistads (1989), A Study of Linkages of Research Institutions with Academic Institutions and Industrial Organisations . New Delhi: NISTADS, CSIR.

56.

Parthasarthi, A. (1987), 'Acquisition and Development of Technology', Economic and Political Weekly, 48, M131-M138.

57.

Reserve Bank of India (1992), Monthly Bulletin, April 1992.

58.

—. ( 1999), Monthly Bulletin, April 1999.

59.

Rosenberg, N. (1990), 'Science and Technology Policy for the Asian NICs: Lessons from Economic History', in R.E. Evenson and G. Ranis , eds, Science and Technology Lessons for Development Policy. London: Intermediate Technology Publications, pp. 149-50.

60.

Sandhya, G.D. , A. Jain and P. Mathur (1990), 'S&T Planning, Policy Direction and CSIR', Economic and Political Weekly, 25(51), 2800-2805.

61.

Shultz, T.W. (1953), The Economic Organization of Agriculture. New York: McGraw Hill.

62.

Solow, R. (1957), 'Technical Change and the Aggregate Production Function', Review of Economics and Statistics, 19(1), pp. 312-20.

63.

Srivastava V. (1996), The Impact of Liberalization on Productivity and Competition: A Panel Study of Indian Manufacturing, 1980-89. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.

64.

—. (2000), 'Production Functions, Productivity and Efficiency: A Study of Indian Manufacturing Companies, 1980-97'. Discussion Paper, National Council of Applied Economic Research, Delhi .

65.

Tulder, R. Van and G. Junne (1988), European Multinationals in Core Technologies. London: Wiley.

66.

Unctad (1992), World Investment Report, 1992. Geneva and New York : UN.

67.

—. (1998), World Investment Report, 1998. Geneva and New York: UN.

68.

—. (1999), World Investment Report, 1999. Geneva and New York: UN.

69.

Urata, S. (1998), 'Japanese Foreign Direct Investment in Asia: Its Impact on Export Expansion and Technology Acquisition of the Host Economies ', in N. Kumar , eds., Globalization, Foreign Direct Investment and Technology Transfers. London : Routledge, pp. 146-73.

70.

World Bank (1980), World Tables, 1980. Washington DC: World Bank .

71.

—. (1999), World Development Indicators, 1999. Washington DC: World Bank.

72.

—. (2000), World Development Indicators, 2000. Washington DC: World Bank.