Transforming Caste Domination and the Challenges of Structural Transformations and Transformation of Consciousness: Ambedkar,Shankara and Beyond

Abstract

Caste is a multidimensional reality in history and society, and it has manifested itself through varieties of structures of domination which are simultaneously cultural, economic, political and ideological as caste has also been related in complex ways with structures of class and gender domination. These structures of domination have led to the annihilation of self and society. This led Ambedkar to challenge us for annihilating caste. For Ambedkar, annihilation of caste calls for the realization of each person as an individual and not just a caste person. It also calls for the destruction of caste privileges, discrimination and their scriptural legitimation. However, this call for annihilation mainly has been a structural project without enough attention to the project of transformation of consciousness—self and social. There is a hint of this in Ambedkar’s Annihilation of Caste when he urges us to realize each one of us as unique individuals beyond the holes of caste which is further deepened in his Buddha and His Dhamma. Transformation of consciousness is also suggested in Adi Shankara’s treatise on self, Atmastakam. The essay engages itself with Ambedkar, Shankara, Gandhi and Sri Aurobindo, among others, as they help us in the transformation of caste domination and present a new hermeneutics of self-realization and social liberation. It deals with the simultaneous challenges of structural transformation of caste as well as consciousness of caste at the levels of both self and society which can draw on multiple sources of critique, creativity and transformations in India and the world.

Brahminism is the poison which has spoiled Hinduism. You will succeed in saving Hinduism if you will kill Brahminism. There should be no opposition to this reform from any quarter. It should be welcomed even by the Arya Samajists, because this is merely an application of their own doctrine of guna-karma.

Whether you do that or you do not, you must give a new doctrinal basis to your religion—a basis that will be in consonance with liberty, equality and fraternity; in short, with democracy. I am no authority on the subject. But I am told that for such religious principles as will be in consonance with liberty, equality and fraternity, it may not be necessary for you to borrow from foreign sources, and that you could draw for such principles in the Upanishads. Whether you could do so without a complete remoulding, a considerable scraping and chipping off from the ore they contain, is more than I can say. (Ambedkar, 2002[1936], p. 303)

Keywords

Culture multicultural social work philosophy of social science religion theology and biblical studies values

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ambedkar

B. R.

(2002 [1936]). Annihilation of caste. In Rodrigues

Valerian

(ed), The essential writings of B.R. Ambedkar (pp. 263–305). Oxford University Press.

Ambedkar

B. R.

(2008). The riddles of Hinduism ( Moon

, Ed.). Department of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India.

Ambedkar

B. R.

(2011). The Buddha and his dhamma: A critical edition ( Rathore

A. S.

& Varma

, Eds.). Oxford University Press.

Beteille

(1990). Race, caste and gender. MAN, 25(3), 489–504.

Bhikhu

(2011). Paticcasamuppada: Practical codependent origination. Thammasapa Publishers.

Clooney

F. X.

(2015). Divine mother, blessed mother: Hindu goddesses and Virgin Mary. Oxford University Press.

Cohen

G. A.

(1994). Self consciousness: An alternative anthropology of identity. Routledge.

Cohen

G. A.

(2000). If you’re an egalitarian, how come you’re so rich. The Journal of Ethics, 4, 1–26.

Connolly

W. E.

(1991). Identity/difference: Democratic negotiations of political paradox. Cornell University Press.

10.

Dallmayr

(2007). Liberal democracy and its critics: Some voices from East and West. Journal of Indian Council of Philosophical Research, 24(4), 1–24.

11.

de Saint-Cheron

(2016). Gandhi: Anti-biography of a great soul. Social Science Press.

12.

Dumont

(1980). Homo hierarchicus: The caste system and its implications (complete Rev. ed., Sainsbury

, Dumont

, & Gulati

, Trans). University of Chicago Press.

13.

Forst

(2017). Normativity and power: Analyzing social orders of justification. Oxford University Press.

14.

Gandhi

M. K.

(1947). India of my dreams. Navajivan Publishing House.

15.

Giri

A. K.

(2002). Conversations and transformations: Towards a new ethics of self and society. Lexington Books.

16.

Giri

A. K.

(2013). Knowledge and human liberation: Toward planetary realizations. Anthem Press.

17.

Giri

A. K.

(2018). Learning the art of wholeness: Integral education and beyond. Indian Institute of Advanced Study.

18.

Guha

(2018). Gandhi: The years that changed the world, 1914-1948. Penguin Random House.

19.

Guru

(2017). Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar’s modern moral idealism: A metaphysics of emancipation. In Ganeri

(Ed.), Oxford Handbook of Indian Philosophy (pp. 743–744). NY: Oxford U. Press.

20.

Guru

, & Sarukkai

(2019). Experience, caste and the everyday social. Oxford University Press.

21.

Habermas

(1990). Moral consciousness and communicative action. MIT Press.

22.

Hirst

J. S.

(2005). Samkara’s advaita vedanta: A way of teaching. Routledge.

23.

Ikeda

, & Chandra

(2009). Buddhism: A way of life. Eternal Ganges Press.

24.

Ilaiah

(1996). Why I am not a Hindu? Samya.

25.

Ingold

(1986). Evolution and social life. Cambridge University Press.

26.

Khilnani

(2018). Foreword to republic of caste: Thinking equality in the time of Neoliberal Hindutva by Anand Teltumde. Navayana.

27.

Kim

(2018). A history of Chinese political thought. Polity Press.

28.

Krishan

A. V.

(2018). Sree Narayana Guru: The perfect union of Buddha and Sankara. Konark.

29.

Lindlely

(2002). Changes in Mahatma Gandhi’s views on caste and intermarriage. Social Sciences Journal, 1.

30.

Mahadevan

(2018). Rethinking the post-secular and secular with Habermas and Ambedkar. Cahiers d’Edtudes Germaniques, 74, 103–118.

31.

Mahadevan

(2021). Pragmatism, spirituality, and the calling of a new democracy: The populist challenge and Ambedkar’s integration of Buddhism and Dewey. In Giri

A. K.

(Ed), Pragmatism, spirituality and society: Border crossings, transformations and planetary realizations (pp. 325–346). Palgrave Macmillan.

32.

Mahadevan

T. P.

(1968). Philosophy of Shankara.

33.

Mohanty

(Ed.). (2004). Caste, class, gender. Sage.

34.

Nadkarni

M. V.

(2006). Hinduism: A Gandhian perspective. Anne Books.

35.

Narayan

(2016). Fractured tales: Invisibles in Indian democracy. Oxford University Press.

36.

Painadath

(2007). We are co-pilgrims. ISPCK.

37.

Pande

G. C.

(1994). Life and thought of Sankaracharya. Motilal Banarsidass.

38.

Patterson

(1982). Slavery and social death: A comparative study. Harvard University Press.

39.

Rege

(Ed.). (2013). Against the madness of Manu: B.R. Ambedkar’s writings on Brahmanical patriarchy. Navayana.

40.

Reubke

K-J.

(2020). Struggles for justice and peace: India, Ekta Parishad and the globalization of solidarity. Studera Press.

41.

Roy

(2006). Gandhi and Ambedkar: A study in contrast. Shipra.

42.

Saxena

N. B.

(2021). Women, goddesses and tantric praxis: A liberatory antidote to ‘Hindutva’ nationalist politics. Contemporary South Asia, 29(2), 288–295.

43.

Sen

(2009). The idea of justice. Penguin.

44.

Sohn-Rethel

(1978). Intellectual and manual labour: A critique of epistemology ( Sohn-Rethel

, Trans). Humanities Press.

45.

Sri Aurobindo. (2001). Record of Yoga-1. Sri Aurobindo Ashram.

46.

Srinivas

M. N.

(2003). An obituary on caste as a system. Economic & Political Weekly, 38(5).

47.

Strydom

(2012). Cognition and recognition: On the problem of the cognitive in Honneth. Philosophy and Social Criticism, 38(6), 591–607.

48.

Teltumbde

(2018). Republic of caste: Thinking equality in the time of neoliberal Hindutva. Navayana.

49.

Teltumbde

, & Yengde

(Eds.). (2018). The radical in Ambedkar: Critical reflections. Penguin Random House.

50.

Unger

R. M.

(2001). False necessity: Anti-necessitarian social theory in the service of radical democracy. Verso.

51.

Vattimo

(2002). After Christianity. Columbia University Press.

52.

Vattimo

(2011). A farewell to truth. Columbia University Press.

53.

Velumla

(2016). My birth is my fatal accident. Letter before ending his life on January 17, 2016.

54.

Vivekananda

2009. The collected works of Swami Vivekananda (Vol 1.). Advaita Ashram.

55.

Watanabe

(2000). The influence of Hindu tantrism on Rammohan Roy’s ideas. Journal of Indian and Buddhist Studies, 48(2), 1136–1140.

56.

Wilkerson

(2020). Caste: The lies that divide us. Allen Lane.

57.

Yengde

(2019). Caste matters. Penguin.