This paper explores the ethical dimensions of some of the current issues engaging rural India, affecting 600 million people. It uses the evolutionary framework of Sri Aurobindo's integral yoga, and also tags on to it the rights concepts of Amartya Sen's ethics. It attempts to take a balanced view between Ambedkar's perception of the ancient Indian village as a sink of localism, a den of ignorance, narrow-mindedness and communalism, and the more common and traditional, but historically untrue, idealized view of the Vedic times. In this process it also steers clear of the pitfalls in the Marxist writings or positivist research, which has taken a wrong position that there was no rule of law and therefore no ethics as understood in modern times. It then attempts to show the more eternal features of perennial ethics in India, the idiom, institutions and the instruments it has nurtured, and the manner it is getting integrated with and is supportive of evolving modern values of democracy and social justice in Indian villages.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Amartya Sen and J. Dreze, India Economic Development and Social Opportunity ( New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1999), 47.
2.
J. Habermas , 'What does Socialism Mean Today?', New Left Review, 1990, 183(1), 3-21.
3.
Swami Vivekananda, The Complete Works , Vol. IV (Mayavati, Almora: Advaita Ashrama, 1924), 309.
4.
Burton Stein, The History of India (London: Blackwell , 1998), 36.
5.
Described in S.K. Chakraborty , The Management and Ethics Omnibus ( New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2001), xix.
6.
The theme of evolution is repeatedly described by Aurobindo typically in The Human Cycle: Selection Works, Vol.15 (Pondicherry: All India Press , 1971), 63; and
7.
Life Divine (Calcutta: Arya Publishing , 1947), 648.
8.
In this process of evolution Aurobindo pleads for adoption by India certain values in the West like liberalism, liberty and freedom, and, of course, rationalism and technological development.
9.
Paul Tillich, 'Is a Science of Human Values Possible?', in Abraham Maslow, ed., New Knowledge of Human Values ( South Bend, Indiana : Regency Gateways Inc., 1959), 196. The book is a compilation of a famous and very productive conference at MIT in 1957.
10.
Kenneth Goodpaster , 'Commentary on MacIntyre and Mangham', Organisation, 1995, 2(2), 212-16.
11.
G.E. Moore, Principia Ethica (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993), 110.
12.
R.D. Putnam , Making Democracy Work ( Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1993).
13.
P.V. Kane, History of the Dharma Sastras (Pune: Bhatkande Oriental Research Institute, 1969 ). A contrary interpretation of dharma is to see it as an imposition of the duties on different castes. This second interpretation could at best be a second-degree derivation from the first meaning and therefore dispensable.
14.
Amartya Sen , Development as Freedom ( London: Alfred Knoff, 1999).
15.
Neetishataka, shloka 25. The Tamil ethics classic, the Kural, also built its ethics on this assumption, as also a belief that market systems and agriculture are socially useful activities when reined in by trust and ethics.
16.
Described in Julian Marias, The Structure of Society ( Alabama: University of Alabama Press, 1955).
17.
I. Kant, Foundations of Metaphysics and Morals (London : Longmans, 1999 [reissue]).
18.
J.S. Mill, Utilitarianism (London: Longman and Green, 1897). Chanakya says in his Niti Darpnam, Verse 11, Chapter 3, 'Sacrifice the person for the sake of the family, a family for a village, a village for the state' (Tantrik Yogi Ramesh, New Delhi: Sahni Publications, 1997).
19.
The specific references to substantiate this are numerous and are not being given here. A short summary is available in R.C. Sekhar, 'Leadership Styles in India', lecture at the University of Cambridge and reproduced in Business Ethics: A European Review, 2001, 10(4), 360-63.
20.
John Rawls, Political Liberalism (New York: Columbia University Press, 1993), 59, 147.
21.
Amartya Sen , Development as Freedom ( London: Alfred Knoff, 1999).
22.
Jurgen Habermas , Theory of Communicative Action ( Cambridge: Polity Press, 1987).
23.
Burton Stein , The History of India (London : Blackwell, 1998), 23;
24.
and R.C. Sekhar, 'The Intellectualism of Sankara and its Influence on the Indian Manager' . Tenth Darshana Conference of Delhi Management Association , November 1999,
25.
quotes from M. Hirayanna, Outline in Indian Philosophy (London: George Allen and Unwin, 1958), 137.
26.
Sekhar, 'Leadership Styles in India' (n. 17 above).
27.
The contents of this section are by and large from R.C. Sekhar, 'The Joy and Pain of Living in the Indian Village', presented at the Indiana University, and is available at the website http://www.Indiana.edu/ ~workshop/Colloquim Announcements and Abstracts/ Fall 2000.
28.
Ashok Mukhopadhyaya , 'India's Grass Root Judiciary', Quarterly Journal of Indian Institute of Public Administration , 1999, 45(3), 536-44;
29.
and Mahi Pal, 'Village Level Decentralisation', Quarterly Journal of the Indian Institute of Public Administration, 1999, 45(3), 544-56.
30.
D.D. Kosambi , The Culture and Civilization of Ancient India (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul , 1964).
31.
P.S. Krishnan , Three Historical Addresses of Babasaheb Ambedkar (New Delhi: Ambedkar Foundation Cell, 1999).
32.
J. Duncan and M. Derret, Dharma Sastras and Judicial Literature (Weisbadden : Otto Harowitz, 1973), 23.
33.
Satish Sabharwal , 'Why do We Need Rules and Laws', in S. Sabharwal and Heiko Sievers, eds, Rules, Laws and Constitution (New Delhi: Sage Publications , 1999).
34.
R.C. Sekhar , 'Indian Law and Ethics: Patterns of Convergence and Divergence', Quarterly Journal of the Indian Institute of Public Administration, 1999, 44(3), 314-20.
35.
U.C. Sarkar , Epochs in Hindu Legal History ( Horshiarpur : Vedic Research Institute, 1958) quotes from the well-known jurist Narad:
Ashutosh Varshney , Democracy Development and the Countryside (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 89.
42.
Sen and Dreze, India Economic Development and Social Opportunity, (n. 1 above), 16, 18, 21, 97-98.
43.
R.C. Sekhar et al., 'IRMA Interim Report on the Study of Interventions in Handlooms' . Institute of Rural Management, Anand, 1998, 55.
44.
S.K. Chakroborty, 'Ethics and Marketing and Advertising', in S.K. Chakroborty and S.R. Chaterjee, eds, Applied Ethics in Management ( Berlin: Springer Verlag, 1999), 146-61.
45.
Amartya Sen, Development as Freedom (n. 19 above).
46.
R.C. Sekhar, Ethical Choices in Business (New Delhi: Sage Publications, 1997), 72.
47.
S.K. Chakroborty , Values and Ethics for Organisations (New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1998), 129-41.
48.
He has relied on the distorted information from George Shanti, A Matter of People (New Delhi: Oxford University Press , 1994),
49.
which has since been universally discredited as having a hidden agenda. He has also stood on its head the criticism in Shah Tushar, Catalyzing Cooperatives (New Delhi: Sage Publications , 1996), which in fact said that the dairy cooperatives did not go far enough in the capitalist direction and ignored distributive justice.
50.
Sekhar, Ethical Choices in Business (n. 38 above), 217-18 and 225-28.
51.
Gail Omvedt , 'Women Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Raj' , Economic Political Weekly, 1990, 25(31), 1687-91.
52.
Bela Bhasin and John Dreze, 'Freedom of Information is Key to Anti-Corruption Campaign in Rural India' . Working Paper of Transparency International, Berlin, 1998.
53.
Sekhar, Ethical Choices in Business (n. 38 above), 98.
54.
Pratap K. Reddy and R.C. Sekhar, 'Civic Culture Ambience and Control Systems' Proceedings of the International Symposium on Cooperatives, IRMA, Anand, 1993.
55.
S. Mitra and V.B. Singh, Democracy and Social Change (New Delhi: Sage Publications, 1999), 243.
56.
Sekhar, 'Leadership Styles in India' (n. 17 above);
57.
and Marriot Mckim, 'Hindu Ritual as a Means of Social Change'. Proceedings of the 16th European Modem South Asian Studies Conference, Edinburgh University, Edinburgh, 2000 (details a case in which such adaptation had been done).
58.
R.C. Sekhar , 'Plural Philosophies and Pathways to Reconstruct Police Ethics', in P.J. Alexander, ed., Policing India in the New Millennium (New Delhi: Allied Publishers, 2002).
59.
R.C. Sekhar , 'Ethics: The Other Name of Good Governance' , Quarterly Journal of the Indian Institute of Public Administration, 44(3), 354-61.
