Numerous suggestions and proposals have been made on how to manage the borders in South Asia. This article analyses these proposals, including soft and open borders, fencing and making borders irrelevant. With the concept of borders undergoing a tremendous change in the last two decades, the article first looks at how the concept of security has evolved and the role that borders play in the new strategic calculus. The article then adopts a historical perspective on the geopolitical and strategic ground realities relating to borders in South Asia. How did borders evolve in South Asia, what kind of movements have been taking place ever since, and how have these two factors shaped the security concerns of respective governments relating to borders? Finally, the article studies the applicability of various proposals and assesses the best border policy options available to states in South Asia, given the ground realities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Acharya, Amitav.2001. ‘ Human Security: East versus West? ’ IDSS Working Paper 17, Singapore: Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies.
2.
Anand, Beryl , K.S. Manjunath and Seema Sridhar.2006. ‘ Indo-Pak Composite Dialogue 2004-05: A Profile ’, IPCS Special Report 12, February, accessed from http://www.ipcs.org/IPCS-Special-Report-12.pdf (on 26 July 2006).
3.
Bajpai, Kanti.2000. ‘ Human Security: Concept and Measurement ’, Kroc Institute Occasional Paper 19. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame.
4.
Baldwin, David.1995. ‘ Security Studies and the End of Cold War ’, World Politics48, October: 117–41 .
5.
Basrur, Rajesh M.2001. ‘Human Security, the State and Democracy in a Globalising World’, in Rajesh M. Basrur (ed.), Security in the New Millennium.New Delhi: India Research Press , 165–200.
6.
Bastiampillai, Bertram.1998. ‘ Role of Human Security in Regional Security and Peace in South Asia ’, Regional Studies16 (4): 37–60 .
7.
Betts, Richard.1997. ‘ Should Strategic Studies Survive? ’ World Politics50, October: 7–33 .
8.
Bharat, Thiyam.2005. ‘Indo-Myanmar Trade and the Economy of Manipur’, Manipur Online, 3 November.
9.
Bhattacharyya, Rajeev.2006. ‘ 1.5 Lakh Bangla Nationals Here: BSF ’, The Indian Express, 29 November.
10.
Bhaumik, Subir.2005. ‘ Livelihood on line at Indian Borders ’, BBC News, 28 June.
CRS Report for the Congress. 2004. ‘Border Security: Inspection Practices, Policies and Issues’, 24 May.
13.
Dikshit, Sandeep.2006. ‘ Influx of Refugees Worrisome: Navy Chief ’, The Hindu, 5 December.
14.
G4S. 2006. G4S Global Risks Ltd. Special Report. ‘ Pakistan-Afghanistan Border Conflict ’, 5 June, accessed from http://www.g4s.com/grk-special_report_afghanistan_pakistan_border_conflict_final.pdf (on 3 August 2006).
15.
INCB. 2006. ‘ Report of the International Narcotics Control Board for 2005 ’, 1 March, accessed from http://www.incb.org/incb/annual_report_2005.html (on 20 September 2006).
16.
Jamwal, N.S.2002. ‘ Management of Land Borders ’, Strategic Analysis, 26 (3), July–September: 406–26 .
17.
Kamboj, Anil.2006. ‘ Border Management: Bangladesh, Nepal and Bhutan ’, World Focus27 (8), August: 22–29 .
18.
Kathmandu Post. 2003. ‘Nepal-India Informal Trade Alarming’, Kathmandu Post, 7 May.
19.
Khan, Shaheen Rafi.2005. ‘ Can Illegal Trade between India and Pakistan be Eliminated? ’ SDPI Research and News Bulletin, 12 (3) May–June, accessed from http://www.sdpi.org/help/research_and_news_bulletin/may_june_05/can_illegal_trade%20.htm (on 20 September 2006).
20.
Kolodziej, Edward.1992. ‘ What is Security and Security Studies? Lessons from the Cold War ’, Arms Control Today13: 1–31 .
21.
Krause, Keith and Michael Williams . 1996. ‘ Broadening the Agenda of Security Studies: Politics and Methods ’, Mershon International Studies Review40 (2), October: 229–54 .
22.
Maitra, Ramtanu.2005. ‘ India's Ticking Immigrant Time Bomb ’, Asia Times Online, 14 January.
O'Harrow Jr., Robert and Scott Higham.2005. ‘ U.S. Border Security at a Crossroads: Technology Problems Limit Effectiveness of US-VISIT Program to Screen Foreigners ’, The Washington Post, 23 May.
25.
Reuters. 2006. ‘Activists ask India to help Curb Illegal Arms Trade’, 20 September.
26.
Sengupta, Ramandanda.2006. ‘Why Delhi-Dhaka Ties Ride on the Cow’, 19 April, accessed from http://in.rediff.com/news/2006/apr/19dhaka.htm (on 20 September 2006).
