A Journey into the Bleeding City

Abstract

This article unfolds rubric-by-rubric the orgy of violence that shook the city of Ahmedabad postearthquake and riots. Informed by psychoanalytic ideas on the origins and vicissitudes of violence, hatred, evil, envy, notions of otherness, repudiation of femininity, and borrowing insights from cultural studies and trauma theory, the paper maps the recent sociopolitical turmoil in the city. Against the backdrop of the two disasters—2001earthquake and 2002 riots—the paper traces and explores the psychic composition of the recent violence in Ahmedabad with a view to deepen the discourse on communal trauma. One question that remains central to the proposed research is how does the communal dimension of trauma emerge as one of its distinctive clinical signatures? The research develops this question by exploring the memories (or forgettings) of violence in one form of narratives from both the Hindu and Muslim communities to those who were either witness or victims of it. The methodology included exploring and evolving ideas around memories of urban and sectarian violence through case studies and using recent literature and commentaries on both these events. Through an exploration of the psychodynamics of the survivor syndrome, collective memory, pathological mourning, the paper develops an understanding of the communal dimension of violence in the cultural setting of Ahmedabad. Drawing understandings from the psychoanalytic conceptions of traumatic memory, gradations of temporality and its impact on remembering and reconstructing of traumatic events, group dynamics, origins and impact of fundamentalist ideology—the article examines the radical gaps and disruptions, precursors of traumatic and violent experiences in the Indian sociopolitical terrain. The article aspires to keep up the verve to problematise and critique politically loaded categories like politics of traumatic memory as seen in PTSD, victims–survivor debate, and trauma from within-and-without (external reality). A key concern alongside is to evolve possibilities of anchoring the clinical significance of the narratives through elaboration on the processes of mourning, and thereby relocating individual losses in their own life contexts. The questions that haunt the city are: will the violence merely linger in the individual memory or be part of a collective depository? How would the city locate its victims and how would it look at the guilty?

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ball, K. (2000). Introduction: Trauma and its institutional destinies . Cultural Critique, 46, 1–44 .

Baxi, U. (2002, August 24). The second Gujarat catastrophe . Economic and Political Weekly, 3519–3531 .

Butler, J. (2003). Violence, mourning and politics . Studies in Gender and Society, 4(1), 9–37 .

Cixous, H. (1995). Sorties: Out and out: attacks/ways out/forays (1986). In D. Tallack (Ed.), Critical theory: A reader (pp. 200–211). London: Harvester Wheatsheaf .

Das, V. (Ed.). (1990). The mirrors of violence: Communities, riots and survivors in South Asia. New Delhi: OUP .

Das, V. (Ed.). (1995). Critical events: An anthropological perspective on contemporary India. New Delhi: OUP .

Ember, C.R. , & Ember, M. (1992). Resource unpredictability, mistrust, and war: A cross-cultural study . The Journal of Conflict Resolution, 36(2), 242–262 .

Erikson, K. (1995). Notes on trauma and community. In C. Caruth (Ed.), Trauma: Explorations in memory (pp. 183–199). Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins Press .

Freud, S. (1921). Group psychology and the analysis of the ego. Standard edition of the collected works of Sigmund Freud (18, pp. 65–143). International Psychoanalytic and Hogarth Press .

10.

Kakar, S. (1996). The colours of violence. New Delhi: Penguin/Viking .

11.

Kakar, S. (2001). The Essential Writings of Sudhir Kakar. New Delhi: Oxford University Press .

12.

Kakar, S. (2005). Rumors and religious riots. In G.A. Fine , V. Campion-Vincent , & C. Heath (Eds), Rumor mills: The social impact of rumor and legend (pp. 53–60). New York: Aldine .

13.

Klein, K.L. (2000). On emergence of memory in the historical discourse . Representations, 69, 127–150 .

14.

Kumar, M. (2005). Lost field and abandoned notes: Remnants of an encounter with Preeti . The Journal of Psychological Foundations, VII(I), 23–29 .

15.

Mehta, L. (2001, August 4). Reflections on Kutch earthquake . Economic and Political Weekly, 2931–2936 .

16.

Mukhia, H. (1995, June 10). Communal violence and transmutation of identities . Economic and Political Weekly, 1365–1368 .

17.

Nandy, A. (1980). At the edge of psychology: Essays in politics and culture. New Delhi: Oxford University Press .

18.

Nandy, A. (2002). Obituary of a culture . Seminar, 513, 15–18 .

19.

Nussbaum, M. (2004, July 29). The body of the nation . Boston Review of Literature. Weblink: http://bostonreview.net/BR29.3/nussbaum.html.

20.

Oliver-Smith, A. (1996). Disaster research in anthropology . Annual Review of Anthropology, 25, 303–328 .

21.

Pandey, G. (1992). In defence of the fragment: Writing about Hindu–Muslim riots in India today . Representations, Special issue on imperial fantasies and postcolonial histories, 37, 27–55 .

22.

Pandey, G. (1994). The prose of otherness. In D. Arnold & D. Hardiman (Eds), Subaltern Studies: Essays in the honor of Ranajit Guha, Vol. VIII (pp. 189–221). New Delhi: Oxford University Press .

23.

Pandey, G. (1999). Can a Muslim be an Indian? Comparative Studies in Society and History, 41(4), 608–629 .

24.

Purwani, J. (2002). The carnage at Godhra. In S. Varadarajan (Ed.), Gujarat: The making of a tragedy (pp. 46–74). New Delhi: Penguin Books .

25.

Rawal, V. , & Nair, T.S. (2001, March 10). Earthquake plan prepared in Haste . Economic and Political Weekly, 820–823 .

26.

Roiser, M. , & Willig, C. (2002). The strange death of the authoritarian personality: 50 years of psychological and political debate . History of the Human Sciences, 15(4), 71–96 .

27.

Sarkar, T. (2002, July 13). Semiotics of terror: Muslim children and women in Hindu rashtra . Economic and Political Weekly, 2872–2876 .

28.

Setalvad, T. (2002). When guardians betray. In S. Varadarajan (Ed.), Gujarat: The making of a tragedy (pp. 171–211). New Delhi: Penguin Books .

29.

Spodek, H. (1989). From Gandhi to violence: Ahmedabad's 1985 riots in historical perspective . Modern Asian Studies, 23(4), 765–795 .

30.

Spodek, H. (2001, May 12). Crises and response: Ahmedabad 2000 . Economic and Political Weekly, 1627–1638 .

31.

Stein, R. (2003). Vertical mystical homoeros: An altered form of desire in fundamentalism . Studies in Gender and Sexuality, 4(1), 38–58.

32.

Varadarajan, S. (2002). Chronicle of a tragedy foretold. In S. Varadarajan (Ed.), Gujarat: The making of a tragedy (pp. 3–41). New Delhi: Penguin Books .

33.

Welldon, S.V. (1992). Mother Modonna, Where: The Idealization and Degeneration of motherhood. London: Karmac Books .

34.

Wieviorka, M. (2003). Violence and the subject . Thesis Eleven, 73, 42–50 .

35.

Yagnik, A. (2002). The pathology of Gujarat . Seminar, Special edition on Gujarat: A society under siege, 513, 19–22 .

36.

Zimbardo, P.H. (2004). A situationist perspective on the psychology of evil: Understanding how good people are transformed into perpetrators. In A. Miller (Ed.), The social psychology of good and evil: Understanding our capacity for kindness and cruelty (pp. 1–23). New York: Guilford .