Recent cross-country studies suggest that finance and economic growth are
significantly related. The characteristics and geographical scope of this
relationship have become central to explain differences in economic development and
financial exclusion. Two concepts are highly relevant in this context. First,
financial deepening, which involves the development of traditional and
non-traditional financial services in these territories. Second, bank dependence,
which makes households and firms rely heavily on banks. Employing dynamic causality
and panel data techniques on a sample of Spanish banks during 1993-9 we find that at
a regional level, economic growth predicted financial deepening in this period.
Regarding bank dependence, the bank-lending specialization appears to be a key issue
in financing firms and households compared to other bank specializations.
Allen, F.
and
Gale, D.
(1994) Financial Innovation and Risk Sharing.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
2.
Allen, F.
and
Santomero, A.M.
(2001)
âWhat Do Financial Intermediaries Do?â
, Journal of Banking and Finance25:
271-294
.
3.
Al-Yousif, Y.K.
(2002)
âFinancial Development and Economic Growth: Another Look at the
Evidence from Developing Countriesâ
, Review of Financial Economics11:
131-150
.
4.
Arellano, M.
and
Bondt, S.
(1991)
âSome Tests of Specification for Panel Data: Monte-Carlo Evidence
and an Application to Employment Equationâ
, Review of Economic Studies58:
277-287
.
5.
Arellano, M.
and
Bover, O.
(1995)
âAnother Look at the IV Estimation of Error Components Modelâ
, Journal of Econometrics68:
29-62
.
6.
Bank for International Settlements (BIS)âInternational Financial Statistics: Securitiesâ
, published in the annex section of BIS Quarterly Review.
7.
Barth, J.
,
Brumbaugh, R.D.
and
Wilcox, J.
(2000) The Repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act and the Advent of
a Broad Banking, Economic Policy Analysis WP (2000-5).
Washington, DC: Office of the Comptroller of
the Currency
.
8.
Beck, T.
and
Levine, R.
(forthcoming)
âStock Markets, Banks and Growth: Panel Evidenceâ
, Journal of Banking and Finance.
9.
Becsi, Z.
and
Wang, P.
(1997)
âFinancial Development and Growthâ
, Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, fourth
quarter:
46-62
.
10.
Berger, A.
and
Udell, G.
(1995)
âRelationship Lending and Lines of Credit in Small Firms Financeâ
, Journal of Business68:
351-379
.
11.
Boyd, J.H.
and
Gertler, M.
(1994)
âAre Banks Dead or Are the Reports Greatly Exaggerated?â
, Quarterly Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis
18(3):
2-23
.
12.
Bresnahan, T.F.
(1989) âEmpirical Studies of Industries with
Market Powerâ, in
R. Schmalensee
and
R.D. Willig
(eds) Handbook of Industrial Organisation, II, pp.
1011-1057.
Amsterdam: North Holland
.
13.
CarbĂł, S.
,
Humphrey, D.
and
RodrĂguez, F.
(2003a)
âDeregulation, Bank Competition and Regional Growthâ
, Regional Studies37 (3):
227-237
.
14.
CarbĂł, S.
,
Humphrey, D.
and
RodrĂguez, F.
(2003b)
âBank Deregulation is Better than Mergersâ
, Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money13 (5):
429-449
.
15.
Cetorelli N.
and
Gambera, M.
(2001)
âBanking Market Structure, Financial Dependence and Growth:
International Evidence from Industry Dataâ
, Journal of Finance56:
617-648
.
16.
Claessens, C.
and
Glaessner, T.
(1997) Are Financial Sector Weaknesses Undermining the East
Asian Miracle?Washington, DC: World Bank
.
17.
Cruickshank, D.
(2000) Competition in UK Banking. A Report to the Chancellor
of the Exchequer.
Norwich: Her Majestyâs Stationery Office
.
18.
Dermiguç-Kunt, A.
and
Maksimovic, V.
(2002)
âFunding Growth in Bank-based and Market-based Financial Systems:
Evidence from Firm-level Dataâ
, Journal of Financial Economics65:
337-363
.
19.
Dow, S.C.
and
RodrĂguez Fuentes, C.J.
(1997)
âRegional Finance: a Surveyâ
, Regional Studies31 (9):
903-920
.
20.
EUROSTATâFINA database - Financial Accounts - within the statistics contained
in the database New Cronos (Theme 2: Economy and Finance).
21.
Ford, J.
and
Rowlingson, K.
(1996),
âLow-income Households and Credit: Exclusion, Preference and Inclusionâ
, Environment and Planning28:
1345-1360
.
22.
Fuller, D.
(1998)
âCredit Union Development: Financial Inclusion and Exclusionâ
, Geoforum29 (2):
145-157
.
23.
Fuller, D.
and
Jonas, A.E.G.
(2002)
âInstitutionalising Future Geographies of Financial Inclusion:
National Legitimacy versus Local Autonomy in the British Credit Union Movementâ
, Antipode34 (1):
85-110
.
24.
Galetovic, A.
(1996)
âSpecialization, Intermediation and Growthâ
, Journal of Monetary Economics38:
549-559
.
25.
Greenwood, J.
and
Jovanovic, B.
(1990)
âFinancial Development, Growth, and the Distribution of Incomeâ
, Journal of Political Economy98:
1076-1107
.
26.
Haughton, G.
(1999) Community Economic Development.
Norwich: The Stationery Office
.
27.
Holtz-Eakin, D.
,
Newey, W.
and
Rosen, H.
(1988)
âEstimating Vector Autoregressions with Panel Dataâ
, Econometrica56:
1371-1395
.
28.
Houston, J.F.
and
James, C.
(1998)
âDo Bank Internal Capital Markets Promote Lending?â
, Journal of Banking and Finance22:
899-918
.
29.
Jayaratne, J.
and
Strahan, P.E.
(1996)
âThe Finance-Growth Nexus: Evidence from Bank Branch Deregulationâ
, Quarterly Journal of Economics111 (3):
639-670
.
30.
Kempson, E.
and
Wiley, C.
(1999) Kept Out or Opted Out? Understanding and Combating
Financial Exclusion.
Bristol: The Policy Press
.
31.
King, R.
and
Levine, R.
(1993)
âFinance and Growth: Schumpeter Might be Rightâ
, Quarterly Journal of Economics108:
717-737
.
32.
Levine, R.
(1999)
âLaw, Finance and Economic Growthâ
, Journal of Financial Intermediation8:
8-35
.
33.
Levine, R.
(2002)
âBank-based and Market-based Financial Systems: Which is Better?âJournal of Financial Intermediation11:
398-428
.
34.
Levine, R.
and
Zervos, S.
(1998)
âStock Markets and Economic Growthâ
, American Economic Review88:
537-558
.
35.
Levine. R.
,
Loayza, N.
and
Beck, T.
(2000)
âFinancial Intermediation and Growth: Causality and Causesâ
, Journal of Monetary Economics46:
31-77
.
36.
Leyshon, A.
and
Pollard, J.
(2000)
âGeographies of Industrial Convergence: the Case of Retail Bankingâ
, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers25 (2):
203-220
.
37.
Leyshon, A.
and
Thrift, N.
(1995)
âGeographies of Financial Exclusion. Financial Abandonment in
Britain and the United Statesâ
, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers20 (3):
312-341
.
38.
Lindgren, C.
,
Balino, J.
,
Enoch, C.
,
Guide, M.
,
Quintyn, M.
and
Teo, L.
(2000) âFinancial Sector Crisis and Restructuring:
Lessons from Asiaâ, International Monetary Fund Occasional
Paper, No. 88.
Washington, DC.
39.
MacKay, R.R.
and
Molyneux, P.
(1996)
âBank Credit and the Regions: a Comparison within Europeâ
, Regional Studies30 (8):
757-764
.
40.
Martin, R.
(1999) âThe New Economic Geography of
Moneyâ, in
R. Martin
(ed.) Money and the Space Economy, pp. 3-28.
Chichester: Wiley
.
41.
Moore, R.R.
(1998),
âConcentration, Technology, and Market Power in Banking: Is
Distance Dead?â
, Financial Industry Studies (Dec.):
1-24
.
42.
Nair-Reichert, U.
and
Weinhold, D.
(2001)
âCausality Tests for Cross-country Panels: a New Look at FDI and
Economic Growth in Developing Countriesâ
, Oxford Bulletin of Economics & Statistics63:
153-171
.
43.
OECD âBank Profitability: Financial Statements of
Banksâ, Vol. 2002 release.
44.
Petersen, M.A.
and
Rajan, R.J.
(1995)
âThe Effect of Credit Market Competition on Lending Relationshipsâ
, Quarterly Journal of Economics110:
407-443
.
45.
Pilloff, S.J.
(1999)
âMultimarket Contact in Bankingâ
, Review of Industrial Organization14:
163-182
.
46.
Pratt, D.J.
,
Leyshon, A.
and
Thrift, N.
(1996) âFinancial Exclusion in the 1990s: the
Changing Geography of UK Financial Marketsâ, Working Paper on
Producer Services, No. 34.
University of Birmingham and University of Bristol
.
47.
Rajan, R.
and
Zingales, L.
(1998)
âFinancial Dependence and Growthâ
, American Economic Review88:
559-587
.
48.
Sala-i-Martin, X.
(2002) â15 Years of New Growth Economics: What Have
We Learnt?â, Discussion Paper (0102-47).
New York: Columbia University
.
49.
Scholtens, B.
(1999)
âBank and Market Oriented Financial Systemsâ
, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review202:
301-323
.
50.
Strahan, P.E.
and
Weston, J.P.
(1998)
âSmall Business Lending and the Changing Structure of the Banking Industryâ
, Journal of Banking and Finance22:
821-845
.
