The purpose of this phenomenological-hermeneutic study was to illuminate the meaning of being in ethically difficult care situations. The participants were 20 enrolled nurses employed in six intensive care units in Sweden. The results reveal a complex human process manifested in relation to one’s inner self and the other person, which transforms desolation into consolation through becoming present to the suffering other when perceiving fragility rather than tragedy. The main point of significance here is for all health professionals to create an ethical work environment and strive for praxis that fosters ‘athomeness’, which renders us free to transform desolation into consolation. Consolation is of significance in ethics because it makes us available and helps us to fulfil the demands of life, while desolation makes us unavailable to others.
Kendrick K , Cubbin B.Ethics in the intensive care unit: a need for research . Nurs Ethics1996; 3: 157-164 .
2.
Walker RM , Miles SH , Stocking CB , Siegler M.Physicians’ and nurses’ perceptions of ethics problems on general medical service . J Gen Intern Med1991; 6: 424-429 .
3.
Söderberg A , Norberg A.Intensive care: situations of ethical difficulties . J Adv Nurs1993; 18: 2008-2014 .
4.
Udén G , Norberg A , Norberg S.The stories of physicians, registered nurses and enrolled nurses about ethically difficult care episodes in surgical care . Scand J Caring Sci1995; 9: 245-253 .
5.
Norberg A , Udén G.Gender differences in moral reasoning among physicians, registered nurses and enrolled nurses engaged in geriatric and surgical care . Nurs Ethics1995; 2: 233-242 .
6.
Norberg A , Udén G , Andrén S.Physicians’, registered nurses’ and enrolled nurses’ stories about ethically difficult episodes in the care of older patients . Eur Nurs1998; 3: 3-13 .
7.
Nelson RM.Ethics in the intensive care unit. Creating an ethical environment . Crit Care Clin1997; 13: 691-701 .
8.
Udén G , Norberg A , Lindseth A , Marhaug V.Ethical reasoning within nurses’ and physicians’ stories about care episodes . J Adv Nurs1992; 17: 1028-1034 .
9.
Söderberg A , Norberg A , Gilje F.Meeting tragedy. Interviews about situations of ethical difficulty . Intensive Crit Care Nurs1996; 12: 207-217 .
10.
Söderberg A , Gilje F , Norberg A.Dignity in situations of ethical difficulty in intensive care . Intensive Crit Care Nurs1997; 13: 135-144 .
11.
Ricoeur P.Interpretation theory: discourse and the surplus of meaning. Fort Worth, TX: Texas Christian University Press , 1976.
12.
Ricoeur P.From text to action. Essays in hermeneutics 2 (French original published 1986). Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press , 1991.
13.
Lindseth A , Marhaug V , Norberg A , Udén G.Registered nurses’ and physicians’ reflections on their narratives about ethically difficult care episodes . J Adv Nurs1994; 20: 245-250 .
14.
Rasmussen B , Sandman PO , Norberg A.Stories of being a hospice nurse: a journey towards finding one’s footing . Cancer Nurs1997; 20: 330-341 .
15.
Ricoeur P.Main trends in philosophy. New York: Holmes and Meier , 1997.
16.
Corley M , Selig P.Nurse moral reasoning using the nursing dilemma test . West J Nurs Res1992; 14: 380-388 .
17.
Mishler E.Research interviewing: context and narrative. London: Harvard University Press , 1986.
18.
Marcel G.The mystery of being I. Reflection and mystery. London: Harvill Press , 1950.
19.
Marcel G.The existential background of human dignity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press , 1963.
20.
Marcel G.Homo viator. Introduction to a metaphysic of hope (French original published 1951). New York: Harper and Row , 1965.
21.
Marcel G.Being and having (French original published 1935). London: Collins , 1965.
22.
Marcel G.Presence and immortality. Pittsburg, KA: Duquesne University Press , 1967.
23.
Marcel G.Tragic wisdom and beyond (French original published 1968). Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press , 1973.
24.
Marcel G.The mystery of being II. Reflection and reality, Vol. II (French original published 1951). New York: University Press of America , 1979.
25.
Marcel G.Creative fidelity (French original published 1964). New York: Crossroad Publishing , 1982.
26.
Nabert J.Elements for an ethic. Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press , 1969.
27.
Ricoeur P.Freedom and nature. The voluntary and the involuntary (French original published 1950). Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press , 1966.
28.
Ricoeur P.The problem of the foundation of moral philosophy . Philos Today1978; 22: 175-193 .
29.
Ricoeur P.Oneself as another (French original published 1990). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press , 1992.
30.
Weil S.Selected essays 1934-1943. Chosen and translated by R Rees. London: Oxford University Press , 1962.
31.
Miles S ed. Simone Weil: an anthology. London: Virago , 1986.
32.
Polkinghorne D.Narrative knowing and the human science. New York: State University of New York Press , 1988.
33.
Carr D.Time, narrative and history. Indianapolis, IN: Indiana University Press , 1986.
34.
Stern DN.The interpersonal world of the infant. A view from psychoanalysis and developmental psychology. New York: Basic Books , 1985.
35.
Webb RE , Sells MA.Lacan and Bion: psychoanalysis and the mystical language of ‘unsaying’ . J Melanie Klein Object Relat1997; 15: 243-264 .
36.
Sells MA.Apophasis in Plotinus: a critical approach . Harvard Theol Rev1985; 78: 47-65 .
37.
Randall AB.The mystery of hope in the philosophy of Gabriel Marcel 1888-1973. Hope and homo viator (Problems in contemporary philosophy, vol.33). Lewiston, NY: Edvin Mellen Press , 1992.
38.
Cain S.Gabriel Marcel’s theory of religious experience (American university studies, series VII; theology and religion, vol. 182). New York: Peter Lang , 1995.
39.
Schilpp PA , Hahn LE.The philosophy of Gabriel Marcel. La Salle, IL: Southern Illinois University , 1984.
40.
Norton DL , Kille MF.Philosophies of love. Totowa, NJ: Rowman and Littlefield , 1988.
41.
Gilje F.Being there. An analysis of the concept of presence. In: Gaut DA ed. The presence of caring in nursing. New York: National League for Nursing , 1992: 53-67.
42.
MacIntyre A , Ricoeur P.The religious significance of atheism. New York: Colombia University Press , 1970.
43.
Gallagher KT.The philosophy of Gabriel Marcel. New York: Fordham University Press , 1962.
44.
Zingmark K , Norberg A , Sandman PO.The experience of being at home throughout the life span. Investigation of persons aged from 2 to 102 . Int J Aging and Human Dev1995; 41: 47-62 .
45.
Ricoeur P.The hermeneutic of action. Kearney R ed. New York: Sage , 1996.
46.
Jönsson L.The Bible’s word about consolation (in Swedish). Stockholm: Bokförtaget Piccolo , 1962.
47.
Dagerman S.Our need for consolation (in Swedish). Lagercrantz O ed. Stockholm: Nordstedts Förlag , 1955.
48.
Aristotle . Nicomachean ethics.
49.
Allmark P.Is caring a virtue?J Adv Nurs1998; 28: 466-472 .
