Through the World Health Organization’s definition of midwifery, midwives are frequently heard to describe themselves as autonomous practitioners. In this article this notion is refuted. An overview of individual and collective autonomy is first presented to contextualize the subsequent discussion. Then the notion of autonomy in relation to midwifery practice in Scotland and New Zealand is critiqued through tracing the history of midwives and midwifery in these two countries. Issues relating to midwifery registration, medicalization of birth and consumerism are discussed. Each of these categories is suggested as limiting to autonomous practice within midwifery.
Hayes BA.Scholarship in a practical discipline: the logical consequences. In: Gray G , Pratt R eds. Scholarship in the discipline of nursing. Melbourne: Pearson Professional , 1995: 169-190.
4.
Clarke RA.Midwives, their employers and the UKCC: an eternally unethical triangle . Nurs Ethics1995; 2: 247-253 .
5.
World Health OrganizationInternational definition of the midwifeGeneva: WHO , 1966.
6.
Kant I.The foundations of metaphysics of morals. (Beck LW trans.) Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill , 1959.
7.
Rousseau JJ.Discourse on the origin of inequality. (Cole GDH trans.) London: Dent , 1968.
8.
Curtin LL.The nurse advocate: a philosophical foundation for nursing . Adv Nurs Sci1979; 1(3): 1-10 .
9.
Batey M , Lewis F.Clarifying autonomy and accountability in nursing service: Part 1 . J Nurs Admin1982; 12(9): 13-18 .
10.
Snowdon AW.The challenge of accountability in nursing . Nurs Forum1993; 28(1): 5-11 .
11.
Fay B.Critical social science. London: Polity Press , 1987.
12.
Havighurst CC.Practice opportunities for allied health professionals in a deregulated industry . J Allied Health1989; 18: 9-32 .
13.
Otretviet J.Medical dominance in the development of professional autonomy in physiotherapy . Sociol Health Illness1985; 7: 76-93 .
14.
Goldsmith J.Childbirth wisdom: from the world’s oldest societies. Brookline, MA: East West Health Books , 1990.
15.
Hooker J.On childbearing in Australia and New Zealand . J Ethnol Soc Lond1869; 1: 68-71 .
16.
Donnison J.Midwives and medical men: a history of the struggle of the control of childbirth. London: Historical Publications , 1988.
17.
Towler J , Bramall J.Midwives in history and society. Kent: Croom Helm , 1986.
18.
Ehrenreich B , English D.For her own good: 150 years of the experts’ advice to women. London: Pluto Press , 1979.
19.
Oakley A , Houd S.Helpers in childbirth: midwifery today. Washington, DC: World Health Organization .
20.
Litoff JB.The American midwife debate. A sourcebook on its modern origins. Westport, CO: Greenwood Press , 1986.
21.
Arney W.Power and the profession of obstetrics. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press , 1982.
22.
Stockham AB.Tokology: a book for every woman. London: Butler and Tanner , 1895.
23.
Koster H , Perrotta L.Elective painless rapid childbirth anticipating labour . Excerpts Med Surg1943; 1: 143-147 .
