Italy was the first European country to be involved with the COVID-19 pandemic. As a result, many healthcare professionals were deployed and suddenly faced end-of-life care management and its challenges.
Aims
To understand the experiences of palliative care professionals deployed in supporting emergency and critical care staff during the COVID-19 first and second pandemic waves.
Research design
A qualitative descriptive design was adopted, and in-depth interviews were used to investigate and analyse participants’ perceptions and points of view.
Participants and research context
Twenty-four healthcare professionals (physicians, nurses, psychologists, physiotherapists, and spiritual support) from the most affected areas of Italy were recruited via the Italian society of palliative care and researchers’ network.
Ethical considerations
The University Institutional Board granted ethical approval. Participants gave written informed consent and agreed to be video-recorded.
Findings
The overarching theme highlighted participants’ experience supporting health professionals to negotiate ethical complexity in end-of-life care. Crucial topics that emerged within themes were: training emergency department professionals on ethical dimensions of palliative and end-of-life care, preserving dying patients’ dignity and developing ethical competence in managing end-of-life care.
Conclusions
Our study showed palliative care teams’ challenges in supporting health professionals’ ethical awareness in emergencies. However, while they highlighted their concerns in dealing with the emergency staff’s lack of ethical perspectives, they also reported the positive impact of an ethically-informed palliative care approach. Lastly, this study illuminates how palliative care professionals’ clinical and ethical competence might have assisted a cultural change in caring for dying patients during COVID-19 and future emergencies.
GjerbergEFørdeRPedersenR, et al.Ethical challenges in the provision of end-of-life care in Norwegian nursing homes. Soc Sci Med2010; 71(4): 677–684.
2.
SchofieldGDittbornMHuxtableR, et al.Real-world ethics in palliative care: a systematic review of the ethical challenges reported by specialist palliative care practitioners in their clinical practice. Pall Med2021; 35(2): 315–334.
3.
AhmedzaiSCostaABlenginiC, et al.A new international framework for palliative care. Eur J Cancer2004; 40: 2192–2200.
4.
HuiDNooruddinZDidwaniyaN, et al.Concepts and definitions for “actively dying,” “end of life,” “terminally ill,” “terminal care,” and “transition of care”: a systematic review. J Pain Manag2014; 47(1): 77–89.
5.
O’ConnorS. End of Life Care Definitions and Triggers for Assessment: A Summary and Discussion of the Literature. Discussion Paper. Canterbury Christ Church University, 2016.
6.
MaselEKKreyeG. Demystification of palliative care: what palliative care teams don’t want you to think about them?Memo - Mag Eur Med Oncol2018; 11(3): 193–195.
7.
BishopJ. The Anticipatory Corpse: Medicine, Power, and the Care of the Dying. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 2011.
8.
GawandeA. Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End. London: Macmillan, 2014.
9.
BandiniJI. Negotiating the ‘buffet’ of choice: advances in technology and end‐of‐life decision‐making in the intensive care unit setting. Sociol Health Illn2020; 42(4): 877–891.
10.
AkdenizMYardımcıBKavukcuE. Ethical considerations at the end-of-life care. SAGE Open Med2021; 9: 20503121211000918.
11.
ChamberlinPLambdenJKozlovE, et al.Clinicians’ perceptions of futile or potentially inappropriate care and associations with avoidant behaviors and burnout. J. Pall Med2019; 22(9): 1039–1045.
12.
LarkinMEBeardsleeBCaglieroE, et al.Ethical challenges experienced by clinical research nurses: a qualitative study. Nurs Ethics2019; 26(1): 172–184.
13.
JiaYChenOXiaoZ, et al.Nurses’ ethical challenges caring for people with COVID-19: a qualitative study. Nurs Ethics2021; 28(1): 33–45.
14.
SandmanLMolanderUBenkelI. Developing organisational ethics in palliative care: a three-level approach. Nurs Ethics2017; 24: 138–150.
15.
NicoliFGasparettoA. Italy in a time of emergency and scarce resources: the need for embedding ethical reflection in social and clinical settings. J Clin Ethics2020; 31(1): 92–94.
16.
Falcó‐PeguerolesAZuriguel‐PérezEVia‐ClaveroG, et al.Ethical conflict during COVID‐19 pandemic: the case of Spanish and Italian intensive care units. Int Nurs Rev2021; 68(2): 181–188.
17.
TimmermansS. Death brokering: constructing culturally appropriate deaths. Sociol Health Illn2005; 27(7): 993–1013.
18.
KwonSKimMChoiS. Ethical dilemmas and care actions in nurses providing palliative sedation. Nursing Ethics2022; 29(5): 1220–1230.
19.
RobertRKentish-BarnesNBoyerA, et al.Ethical dilemmas due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Ann Intensive Care2020; 10(1): 1–9.
20.
FernandoGVMCHughesS. Team approaches in palliative care: a review of the literature. Int J Palliat Nurs2019; 25(9): 444–451.
21.
KaufmanSR. Ordinary Medicine. Durham: Duke University Press, 2015.
22.
DonkersMAGilissenVJHSCandelMJJM, et al.Moral distress and ethical climate in intensive care medicine during COVID-19: a nationwide study. BMC Med Ethics2021; 22: 73.
23.
KimJ. COVID-19 tells us we have work to do in end-of-life care: a plea to improve medical education. Voices Bioeth2020; 6.
24.
SinghGKRegoJChambersS, et al.Health professionals’ perspectives of the role of palliative care during COVID-19: content analysis of articles and blogs posted on twitter. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2021; 39: 487–493.
25.
MorleyGGradyCMcCarthyJ, et al.Covid-19: ethical challenges for nurses. Hastings Cent Rep2020; 50(3): 35–39.
26.
DellasegaCKanaskieML. Nursing ethics in an era of pandemic. Appl Nurs Res2021; 62: 151508.
27.
SilvermanH.J.KheirbekREMoscou-JacksonG, et al.Moral distress in nurses caring for patients with Covid-19. Nurs Ethics2021; 28(7–8): 1137–1164.
28.
MitchinsonLDowrickABuckC, et al.Missing the human connection: a rapid appraisal of healthcare workers’ perceptions and experiences of providing palliative care during the COVID-19 pandemic. Palliat Med2021; 35(5): 852–861.
29.
DriessenABorgstromECohnS. Ways of ‘being with’: caring for dying patients at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic. Anthropol Action2021; 28(1): 16–20.
30.
McMillanJ. COVID-19 and justice. J Med Ethics2020; 46: 639–640.
31.
SavulescuJPerssonIWilkinsonD. Utilitarianism and the pandemic. Bioethics2020; 34.
32.
BrowningHVeitW. Utilitarian lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic for non-pandemic diseases. Am J Bioeth2021; 21: 12–42.
33.
Fossum-TaylorIHDihleAHofsoK, et al.Intensive care nurses’ experience of withdrawal of life-sustaining treatments in intensive care patients: a qualitative study. Crit Care Nurs2020; 56: 2–7.
34.
HamricABBlackhallLJ. Nurse-physician perspectives on the care of dying patients in intensive care units: collaboration, moral distress and ethical climate. Crit Care Med2007; 35(2): 422–429.
35.
McAndrewNSLeskeJSchroeterK. Moral distress in critical care nursing: the state of the science. Nurs Ethics2018; 25(5): 552–557.
36.
Istat [Italian Institute of Statistics] – ISS. Impatto dell’epidemia covid-19 sulla mortalità totale della popolazione residente. Year 2020 and January-June 2021, 2021.
37.
BongiovanniMArientiRBiniF, et al.Differences between the waves in Northern Italy: how the characteristics and the outcome of COVID-19 infected patients admitted to the emergency room have changed. J. Infect2021; 83(1): e32–e33.
38.
GaglianoAVillaniPGCo’FM, et al.COVID-19 epidemic in the middle province of Northern Italy: impact, logistics, and strategy in the first line hospital. Disaster Med Public Health Prep2020; 14(3): 372–376.
39.
IsersonKV. Healthcare ethics during a pandemic. West J Emerg Med2020; 21(3): 477–483.
40.
JeffreyDI. Relational ethical approaches to the COVID-19 pandemic. J Med Ethics2020; 46(8): 495–498.
41.
ValerioMARodriguezNWinklerP, et al.Comparing two sampling methods to engage hard-to-reach communities in research priority setting. BMC Med Res Methodol2016; 16: 1–11.
42.
MaguireMDelahuntD. Doing a thematic analysis: a practical, step-by-step. Guide for learning and teaching scholars. AISHE-J2017; 3: 3351–33514.
43.
BraunVClarkeV. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual Res Psychol2006; 3: 77–101.
44.
RolfeG. Validity, trustworthiness and rigour: quality and the idea of qualitative research. J Adv Nurs2006; 53(3): 304–310.
45.
MarcoCALarkinGLFeeserVR, et al.Post‐traumatic stress and stress disorders during the COVID‐19 pandemic: survey of emergency physicians. JACEP Open2020; 1(6): 1594–1601.
46.
LoweySE. Withholding medical interventions and ageism during a pandemic: a model for resource allocation decision making. J Hosp Palliat Nurs2021; 23(3): 200–206.
47.
FadulNElsayemAFBrueraE. Integration of palliative care into COVID-19 pandemic planning. BMJ Support Palliat Care2021; 11(1): 40–44.
48.
HannaJRRapaEDaltonLJ, et al.Health and social care professionals’ experiences of providing end of life care during the COVID-19 pandemic: a qualitative study. Palliat Med2021; 35(7): 1249–1257.
49.
Di LeoSAlquatiSAutelitanoC, et al.Palliative care in the emergency department as seen by providers and users: a qualitative study. SJTREM2019; 27(1): 1–11.
50.
SapetaPCentenoCBelarA, et al.Adaptation and continuous learning: integrative review of coping strategies of palliative care professionals. Pall Med2022; 36(1): 15–29.
51.
FinufKDLopezSCarneyMT. Coping through COVID-19: a mixed method approach to understand how palliative care teams managed the COVID-19 pandemic. Am J Hosp Palliat Care2022; 39(7): 874–880.
52.
SleemanKETimmsAGillamJ, et al.Priorities and opportunities for palliative and end of life care in United Kingdom health policies: a national documentary analysis. BMC Palliat Care2021; 20: 108.
53.
OluyaseAOHocaogluMCrippsRL, et al.The challenges of caring for people dying from COVID-19: a multinational, observational study (CovPall). J Pain Symptom Manage2021; 62(3): 460–470.
54.
SeibelKCounéBMuellerM, et al.Implementation of an acute palliative care unit for COVID-19 patients in a tertiary hospital: qualitative data on clinician perspectives. Palliative Med2022; 36(2): 332–341.
55.
WalsheCPawłowskiLShedelS, et al.Understanding the role and deployment of volunteers within specialist palliative care services and organisations as they have adjusted to the COVID-19 pandemic: a multi-national EAPC volunteer taskforce survey. Pall Med2022; 2022: 026921632211353.
56.
MercadanteSGregorettiCCortegianiA. Palliative care in intensive care units: why, where, what, who, when, how. BMC Anesthesiol2018; 18(1): 1–6.
57.
WilsonJGEnglishDPOwyangCG, et al.End-of-life care, palliative care consultation, and palliative care referral in the emergency department: a systematic review. J Pain Manag2020; 59(2): 372–383.
58.
Julià-TorrasJde MontellàNDIGPorta-SalesJ. COVID-19: quick reflections from palliative care before the next epidemic. Med Clin (English Ed.)2021; 156(1): 29–32.
59.
EgnewTR. The meaning of healing: transcending suffering. Ann Fam Med2005; 3(3): 255–262.
60.
SheahanLBrennanF. What matters? palliative care, ethics, and the COVID-19 pandemic. J Bioethic Inq2020; 17(4): 793–796.
61.
SchönDA. The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action. Routledge, 2017.
62.
RosaWEMeghaniSHStonePW, et al.Opportunities for nursing science to advance patient care in the time of COVID‐19: a palliative care perspective. J Nurs Scholarsh2020; 52(4): 341–343.
63.
RosaWEFerrellBRWiencekC. Increasing critical care nurse engagement of palliative care during the COVID-19 pandemic. Crit Care Nurse2020; 40(6): e28–e36.
64.
KochAMantzourisS. Nurses’ role in providing comprehensive communication, prognostication, and palliative care during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Hospice Palliative Nursing2020; 22: 442–446.
65.
CastaldoALusignaniMPapiniM, et al.Nurses’ experiences of accompanying patients dying during the COVID‐19 pandemic: a qualitative descriptive study. J Adv Nurs2022; 78: 2507–2521.
66.
MillsJWandTFraserJA. Examining self-care, self-compassion and compassion for others: a cross-sectional survey of palliative care nurses and doctors. Int J Palliat Nurs2018; 24(1): 4–11.
67.
BuenoJMVLa CalleGH. Humanizing intensive care: from theory to practice. Crit Care Clin2020; 32(2): 135–147.
68.
Dreher‐HummelTNickelCHNiccaD, et al.The challenge of interprofessional collaboration in emergency department team triage–an interpretive description. J Adv Nurs2021; 77(3): 1368–1378.
69.
MichalsenALongACGanzFD, et al.Interprofessional shared decision-making in the ICU: a systematic review and recommendations from an expert panel. Crit Care Med2019; 47(9): 1258–1266.
70.
RosaWEKrakauerELFarmerPE, et al.The global nursing workforce: realising universal palliative care. Lancet Global Health2020b; 8(3): e327–e328.
71.
de CamposAPDanielsS. Ethical implications of COVID-19: palliative care, public health, and long-term care facilities. J Hosp Palliat Nurs2021; 23(2): 120–127.
