Conducting research with vulnerable populations involves careful attention to the interests of individuals. Although it is generally understood that informed consent is a necessary prerequisite to research participation, it is less clear how to proceed when potential research participants lack the capacity to provide this informed consent. The rationale for assessing the assent or dissent of vulnerable individuals and obtaining informed consent by authorized representatives is discussed. Practical guidelines for recruitment of and data collection from people in the middle or late stage of dementia are proposed. These guidelines were used by research assistants in a minimal risk study.
Canadian Study of Health and Aging Working Group . Canadian Study of Health and Aging: study methods and prevalence of dementia . CMAJ1994; 150: 899–913 .
2.
Statistics Canada . Projections of population and families for Canada, the provinces and territories. Statistics Canada , 2000.
3.
Bartlett H , Martin W . Ethical issues in dementia care research. In: Wilkinson H ed. The perspectives of people with dementia: research methods and motivations. Jessica Kingsley , 2002: 47–61.
4.
Gwyther LP . The perspective of the person with Alzheimer disease: which outcomes matter in early to middle stages of dementia?Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord1997; 11(suppl 6): 18–24 .
5.
Hubbard G , Downs M , Tester S . Including the perspectives of older people in institutional care during the consent process. In: Wilkinson H ed. The perspectives of people with dementia: research methods and motivations. Jessica Kingsley , 2002: 63–81.
6.
Moore TF , Hollett J . Giving voice to persons living with dementia: the researcher's opportunities and challenges . Nurs Sci Q2003; 16: 163–167 .
7.
Dewing J.From ritual to relationship: a person-centred approach to consent in qualitative research with older people who have dementia . Dementia2002; 1: 157–171 .
8.
Jonas-Simpson C.From silence to voice: knowledge, values, and beliefs guiding healthcare practices with persons living with dementia . Nurs Sci Q2001; 14: 304–310 .
9.
McCormack B.The person of voice: narrative identities in informed consent . Nurs Philos2003; 3: 114–119 .
10.
Alzheimer Society of Canada . Alzheimer care ethical guidelines: participation in research. 2004. Retrieved 2 September, 2005, from http://www.alzheimer.ca/english/care/ethicsresearch.htm
11.
Moody HR . Issues of equity in the selection of subjects for experimental research in senile dementia of the Alzheimer's type. In: Melnick VL , Dubler NN eds. Alzheimer's dilemmas and clinical research. Humana , 1985: 83–94.
12.
Bahro M , Silber E , Sunderland T . How do patients with Alzheimer's disease cope with their illness? A clinical experience report . J Am Geriatr Soc1995; 43: 41–46 .
13.
Keyserlingk EW , Glass K , Kogan S , Gauthier S . Proposed guidelines for the participation of persons with dementia as research subjects . Perspect Biol Med1995; 38: 319–362 .
14.
Post SG . Full-spectrum proxy consent for research participation when persons with Alzheimer disease lose decisional capacities: research ethics and the common good . Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord2003; 17(suppl 1): S3–S11 .
15.
Edelman P , Fulton BR , Kuhn D , Chang CH . A comparison of three methods of measuring dementia-specific quality of life: perspectives of residents, staff, and observers . Gerontologist2005; 45(suppl 1): 27–36 .
16.
Lawton MP . Assessing quality of life in Alzheimer disease research . Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord1997; 11(suppl 6): 91–99 .
17.
Reimer MA , Slaughter S , Donaldson C , Currie G , Eliasziw M . Special care facility compared to traditional environments for dementia care: a longitudinal study of quality of life . J Am Geriatr Soc2004; 52: 1085–1092 .
18.
Alzheimer's Association . Ethical issues in dementia research. 1997. Retrieved 25 June, 2005, from: http://www.alz.org/AboutUs/PostionStatements/overview.asp
19.
Dresser R.Dementia research: ethics and policy for the twenty-first century . Georgia Law Rev2001; 35: 661–690 .
20.
Medical Research Council of Canada, Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada and Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. Tri-council policy statement: ethical conduct for research involving humans. Ottawa: Authors , 2003.
21.
National Advisory Council on Aging . The NACA position on Alzheimer disease and related dementias. NACA , 2004.
22.
Beauchamp TL , Childress JF . Principles of biomedical ethics, fifth edition. Oxford University Press , 2001.
23.
Weijer C.The ethical analysis of risk . J Law Med Ethics2000; 28: 344–361 .
24.
King MP . Defining and describing benefit appropriately in clinical trials . J Law Med Ethics2000; 28: 332–343 .
25.
Cohen-Mansfield J.Consent and refusal in dementia research: conceptual and practical considerations . Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord2003; 17(suppl 1): S17–S25 .
26.
Faden RR , Beauchamp TL . A history and theory of informed consent. Oxford University Press , 1986.
27.
Malloy DW , Darzins P , Strang D . Capacity to decide. New Grange Press , 1998.
28.
Roberts LW . Informed consent and the capacity for voluntarism . Am J Psychiatry2002; 159: 705–712 .
29.
Ki SYH , Caine ED , Currier GW , Leibovici A , Ryan JM . Addressing the competence of persons with Alzheimer's disease in providing informed consent for participation in research . Am J Psychiatry2002; 158: 712–717 .
30.
Bravo G , Paquet M , Dubois MF . Opinions regarding who should consent to research on behalf of an older adult suffering from dementia . Dementia2003; 2: 49–65 .
31.
Scott K , Karlawish J . Ethics and politics of research involving subjects with impaired decisionmaking abilities . Neurology2003; 61: 1645–1646 .
Personal Directives Act2003. Retrieved 1 April, 2004, from: http://www.qp.gov.ab.ca/documents/Acts/P06.cfm?frm_isbn=0779721837
34.
Bravo G , Gagnon M , Wildeman S , Marshall DT , Paquet M , Dubois MF . Comparison of provincial and territorial legislation governing substitute consent for research . Can J Aging2005; 24: 237–250 .
35.
Weisstub DN , Verdun-Jones SN . Biomedical experimentation involving elderly subjects: the need to balance limited, benevolent protection with recognition of a long history of autonomous decision-making . Health Law Can1998; 18(3): 95–104 .
36.
Widdershoven GAM , Berghmans R . Advance directives in dementia care: from instructions to instruments . Patient Educ Counsel2001; 44: 179–186 .
37.
Beck C , Shue V . Surrogate decision-making and related issues . Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord2003; 17(suppl. 1): S12–S16 .
38.
Dresser R.Missing persons: legal perceptions of incompetent patients . Rutgers Law Rev, 1994; 46: 609–719 .
39.
Post SG . Alzheimer's disease and the ‘then’ self . Kennedy Inst Ethics J1995; 5: 307–321 .
40.
Fellows L.Competency and consent in dementia . J Am Geriatr Soc1998; 46: 922–926 .
41.
Buchanan AE , Brock DW . Deciding for others: the ethics of surrogate decision making. Cambridge University Press , 1989.
42.
Hunter K , Jensen L . Obtaining informed consent for participation from cognitively impaired adults . J Wound Ostomy Continence Nurs2003; 30: 241–244 .
43.
American Geriatrics Society Ethics Committee . Informed consent for research on human subjects with dementia . J Am Geriatr Soc1998; 46: 1308–1310 .
44.
Brodaty H , Dresser R , Eisner M et al. Consensus statement: Alzheimer's disease international and international working group for harmonization of dementia drug guidelines for research involving human subjects with dementia . Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord1999; 13: 71–79 .
45.
Cahill M , Wichman A . Research involving persons with cognitive impairments: results of a survey of Alzheimer disease research centers in the United States . Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord2000; 14: 20–27 .
46.
World Medical Association . Declaration of Helsinki. 2004. Retrieved 18 February, 2005, from: http://www.wma.net/e/policy/b3.htm
47.
Berghmans R , ter Meulen R . Ethical issues in research with dementia patients . Int J Geriatr Psychiatry1995; 10: 647–651 .
48.
Baylis F.IRBs: protecting the well-being of subject-participants with mental disorders that may affect decision-making capacity . Account Res1999; 7: 183–199 .
49.
Stocking C , Hougham G , Baron A , Sachs G . Ethics reporting in publications about research with Alzheimer's disease patients . J Am Geriatr Soc2004; 52: 305–310 .
50.
Guerrero M , Heller PL . Sociocultural limits in informed consent in dementia research . Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord2003; 17(suppl): S26–S30 .
51.
Reisberg B , Ferris SH , De Leon MJ , Crook T . The global deterioration scale for assessment of primary degenerative dementia . Am J Psychiatry1982; 139: 1136–1139 .
