In this article we focus on female genital mutilation. We analyse this problem as one of the most important issues of multiculturalism, which is also coming to the attention of the public in Italy as a consequence of the growing number of immigrants from African countries. The fundamental problem is about the acceptability of this practice: can female genital mutilation be permitted and, if so, on what basis? We will try to cope with this as a genuine conflict between culture-relative values and universal values, such as human rights. Some attention will be drawn to Italian law. Finally, the impact on nurses of requests for genital mutilation will be described.
Kopelman LM.Female circumcision and genital mutilation. Encyclopedia of applied ethics (vol. 2). San Diego: Academic Press , 1998: 249-259.
2.
Dakouo M, Manara DF. Grossesse, accouchement, fécondité. In: Institut National de Recherche en Santé Publique. Santé, nutrition, fécondité, dans la région de San et Tominian: une étude socio-nutritionnelle et sanitaire du milieu. Bamako, Mali: Diocese of San, 1993: 104-105.
3.
Macklin R.Against relativism. Cultural diversity and the search for ethical universals in medicine. New York: Oxford University Press , 1999.
4.
Camilleri C , Vinsonneau G.Psycologie et culture: concepts et méthodes. [Psychology and culture: concepts and methods.]Paris: Armand Colin , 1996.
5.
Camilleri C.La communication dans la perspective interculturelle. In: Camilleri C , Cohen EM eds. Choc de cultures: concepts et enjeux pratiques de l’interculturel. [Communication in culture shock: concepts and practical consequences of intercultural perspectives.]Paris: l’Harmattan , 1989: 363-397.
6.
Galeotti AE.Neutrality and recognition. In: Bellamy R , Hollis M eds. Pluralism and liberal neutrality. London: Frank Cass , 1999: 37-53.
7.
Raz J.Multiculturalism: a liberal perspective . Dissent1994; (Winter): 67-79 .
8.
Kymlicka W.Multicultural citizenship: a liberal theory of minority rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1995.
9.
Taylor C.Multiculturalism: the politics of recognition. Princeton: Princeton University Press , 1992.
10.
Young MI.Justice and the politics of difference. Princeton: Princeton University Press , 1990.
11.
Lukes S.Toleration and recogniton . Ratio Juris1997; 10: 213-222 .
12.
Gewirth A.Is cultural pluralism relevant to moral knowledge?Soc Philos Policy1994; 11: 22-43 .
13.
James SA.Reconciling international human rights and cultural relativism: the case of female circumcision . Bioethics1994; 8: 1-26 .
14.
Callahan D.Universalism and particularism. Fighting to a draw . Hastings Cent Rep2000; 30: 37-44 .
United Nations . Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Adopted and proclaimed by General Assembly resolution 217 A (III) 10 December 1948, New York: UN .
17.
Council of Europe . Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. (European Treaty Series no. 5.) Rome , 4 November 1950.
18.
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights . Declaration of the Rights of the Child. Proclaimed by General Assembly resolution 1386 (XIV) 20 November 1989, New York: UN .
19.
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights . Declaration on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women. Proclaimed by General Assembly resolution 2263 (XXII) 7 November 1967, New York: UN .
20.
Codice Civile. Approvato con Regio Decreto del 16 marzo 1942, n. 262, G.U. 4-4-1942, n. 79 e 79bis.
21.
Codice di Deontologia Medica, 2-3 ottobre 1998.
22.
Livio M.La situazione in Italia. [The situation in Italy.] In: Mazzetti M ed. Senza le ali: le mutilazioni genitali femminili. Milan: Franco Angeli , 2000: 57-66.
23.
Manara DF.Verso una teoria dei bisogni di assistenza infermieristica. [Towards a theory of care for care assisstants.]Milan: Lauri Editrice , 2000.
24.
National Federation of Colleges of Italian Nurses . Deontological code of nurses. Rome: NFCIN , 1999.
25.
Sala R , Manara DF.The regulation of autonomy in nursing: the Italian situation . Nurs Ethics1999; 6: 451-467 .
26.
Gastmans C.Care as a moral attitude in nursing . Nurs Ethics1999; 16: 214-223 .
27.
Bishop AH , Scudder JR.Nursing ethics: therapeutic caring presence. London: Jonas and Bartlett , 1996.
28.
Gastmans C , Dierckx de Casterle B , Schotsmans P.Nursing considered as moral practice: a philosophical interpretation of nursing . Kennedy Inst Ethics J1998; 8: 43-69 .
29.
Van Hooft S.Acting from the virtue of caring in nursing . Nurs Ethics1999; 6: 189-201 .
30.
Henderson V.The nature of nursing: a definition and its implication for practice, research and education. New York: Macmillan , 1966.
31.
Swanson K.Providing care in the NICU. Sometimes an act of love . ANS Adv Nurs Sci1990; 13: 60-73 .
32.
Benhabib S.The generalized and the concrete other. The Kohlberg-Gilligan controversy and moral theory. In: Feder Kittay E , Meyers DT eds. Women and moral theory. Totowa: Rowman and Littlefield , 1987: 154-177.
