John Goodsir, conservator and professor of anatomy at the University of Edinburgh, suffered an unidentified illness described by experts after his death as tabes. The features that led to this diagnosis, the understanding of tabes at that time and its relationship in some cases to syphilis, are discussed. It is concluded that the most likely diagnoses are subacute combined degeneration of the cord as a result of malnutrition or tabes dorsalis resulting from earlier syphilis. The presence of ‘lightning pains’ leans towards the latter diagnosis but evidence for a means of acquisition of syphilis is lacking. The disadvantages of retrospective diagnosis are discussed.
LonsdaleH. The anatomical memoirs of John Goodsir F.R.S. with a biographical memoir by Henry Lonsdale MD. Turner W, (editor).
Edinburgh:
A & C Black,
1868.
2.
BastonK.John Goodsir (1814–1867), Anatomist. In Oxford dictionary of national biography.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press,
2004.
KaufmanM.
Harry Goodsir and the last Franklin Expedition of 1845. Journal of Medical Biography2004;
12:
82–
89.
8.
GoodsirR. An Arctic voyage in search of friends with Sir John Franklin.
London:
John van Voorst;
1850.
9.
DonaldsonKHenryC.
John Goodsir and local opposition to Rudolf Virchow’s election to fellowship of the Royal Society of Edinburgh in 1868. Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh2020;
50:
188–
195.
SimpsonJAWeinerESC. The Oxford English Dictionary.
Oxford:
Clarendon Press;
1989.
16.
MonroThomas Kirkpatrick. A history of the chronic degenerative diseases of the central nervous system.
MacDougall,
Glasgow. (
1895).
17.
SmallAE. Diseases of the nervous system.
Philadelphia:
Rademacher & Sheek,
1856.
18.
GowersW. Manual of diseases of the nervous system. 2nd ed.
London:
J&A Churchill;
1892–
1899.
19.
HunterRHurwitzL.
The case notes of the National Hospital for the Paralysed and Epileptic, Queen Square, London, before 1900. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry1961;
24:
187–
194.
20.
GowersW. The diagnosis of disease of the spinal cord. An address delivered to the Medical Society of Wolverhampton, October 9th, 1879.
London:
J&A Churchill;
1881.
21.
NealeHSJ. Practical essays and remarks on that species of consumption incident to youth, and the different stages of life, commonly called tabes dorsalis with an account of the nature, causes, and cure of that distemper. 3rd ed.
London:
J Walker;
1809.
22.
SchillerF.
Venery, the spinal cord, and tabes dorsalis before Romberg: the contribution of Ernst Horn. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease1976;
163: p.
1–
9.
23.
RombergM. A manual of the nervous diseases of man.
London:
The Sydenham Society;
1853.
24.
NitriniR.
The history of tabes dorsalis and the impact of observational studies in neurology. Archives of Neurology2000;
57:
605–
606.
25.
RosenthalM. A clinical treatise on the diseases of the nervous system.
New York:
William Wood & Company;
1879.
26.
DowseT. The brain and its diseases part I. Syphilis of the brain and spinal cord.
London:
Baillière, Tindall and Cox,
1879.
27.
BuzzardT. Clinical lectures on diseases of the nervous system.
London:
J & A Churchill;
1882.
28.
DoyleA.
An Essay Upon the Vasomotor Changes in Tabes Dorsalis and on the Influence Which is Exerted by the Sympathetic Nervous System in That Disease.
1885. MD thesis. University of Edinburgh.
29.
RodinAKeyJ.
Arthur Conan Doyle’s thesis on tabes dorsalis. Journal of the American Medical Association1982;
247:
646–
650.
30.
University of Edinburgh Library Special Collections. GB 237; Gen 291, 292, 391, 305, 306.
31.
BrowneE.
The making of the memoir of Edward Forbes, F.R.S. Archives of Natural History1981;
10:
205–
219.
32.
BanksW.
Introductory address to the Anatomical Society of the University of Liverpool.
Liverpool:
Liverpool University Press;
1906.
33.
MeyerG.
Occupational infection in health care; the century-old lessons from syphilis. Archives of Internal Medicine1993;
153:
2439–
2447.
34.
MorrowPA.
Notes on syphilis. Syphiloma of the nose of unusual form and evolution: the diagnostic value of syphilitic cicatrices: extra-genital chancres, prognostic significance of professional syphilis. Journal of Cutaneous Genito-Urinary Disorders1896;
14:
129–
140.
35.
BulkleyL.
On the dangers arising from syphilis in the practice of dentistry. International Dental Journal1890;
11:
449–
457.
36.
RussellJBattenFCollierJ.
Subacute combined degeneration of the spinal cord. Brain1900;
23:
39–
110.
37.
Anonymous.
The late John Goodsir. Edinburgh Medical Journal1867;
12:
959–
962.
