President Franklin D Roosevelt (1882–1945) and Doctor Frank Howard Lahey’s (1880–1953) dilemma: The complexities of medical confidentiality with World Leaders
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online February, 2016
President Franklin D Roosevelt (1882–1945) and Doctor Frank Howard Lahey’s (1880–1953) dilemma: The complexities of medical confidentiality with World Leaders
In the months before the Presidential Election of November 1944, there were serious concerns about the health of President Franklin D Roosevelt. He had lost considerable weight and his once robust appearance had given way to a tired and haggard look. Despite these worrisome observations, Vice-Admiral Ross T McIntire, who served as Franklin Roosevelt’s personal physician from 1933 until Roosevelt’s death, lied when he proclaimed Roosevelt to be in ‘excellent condition for a man of his age’. The truth about Roosevelt’s health was further obscured when Roosevelt’s medical records disappeared.
ChurchillWS. Triumph and tragedy, Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1953, pp. 477–477.
2.
McIntireRT. White House physician, Chapter 2. New York: GP Putnam's Sons, 1946, pp. 17–17.
3.
McIntire, White House Physician, p.14.
4.
LomazowSFettmanE. FDR's deadly secret, New York: Public Affairs, 2009.
5.
GoldmanASSchmalstiegEJFreemanDHJr. What was the cause of Franklin Delano Roosevelt's paralytic Illness?Journal of Medical Biography2003; 11: 232–240.
6.
BruennHG. Clinical notes on the illness and death of President Franklin D Roosevelt. Annals of Internal Medicine1970; 72: 579–591.
7.
GallagherHG. FDR's splendid deception, New York: Dodd, Mead, 1985.
8.
McIntire, White House Physician, p.64.
9.
McIntire, White House Physician, p.226.
10.
McIntire, White House Physician, p.19 and p.139.
11.
McIntire, White House Physician, p.243.
12.
Interview with Dr Howard G Bruenn, Cardiologist to President Franklin D Roosevelt, conducted by Jan K Herman, Historian, Bureau of Medicine and Surgery, Riverdale, NY, 31 January 1990. Excerpts published in Navy Medicine March–April 1990 pp.6–13. Also see Bruenn, Annals of Internal Medicine, p.591.
13.
The three were Captain John Harper, MC, USN, Commanding Officer of the National Naval Medical Center, Captain Robert Duncan, MC, USN executive officer of the hospital and Vice-Admiral Ross T McIntire.
14.
Breunn, Annals of Internal Medicine, 1970; 72: 579–591.
15.
MandelLR. Endocrine and autoimmune aspects of the health history of John F Kennedy. Annals of Internal Medicine2009; 151: 350–354.
16.
Some of President Kennedy's treatment was administered at Dr Lahey's Clinic.
TooleJF. Dementia in world leaders and its effects upon international events: the examples of Franklin D Roosevelt and T Woodrow Wilson. European Journal of Neurology1999; 6: 115–119.
19.
Lomazow and Fettman, p.52.
20.
McIntire, White House Physician, p.58.
21.
AdamsHD. The knife that saves: memoirs of a Lahey Clinic surgeon, Boston: The Francis A Countway Library of Medicine, 1991.
Interview with Dr Howard Bruenn conducted by Jan Herman.
24.
LernerBH. Crafting medical history: revisiting the ‘definitive' account of Franklin D Roosevelt's terminal illness. Bulletin of the History of Medicine2007; 81: 386–406.
25.
BruennHG. Clinical notes on the illness and death of President Franklin D Roosevelt. Annals of Internal Medicine1970; 72: 579–591.
26.
MesserliFH. This day fifty years ago. New England Journal of Medicine1995; 332: 1038–1039.
27.
Bruenn interview with Jan K Herman, 31 January1990.
28.
Bruenn interview with Jan K Herman, 31 January 1990.
29.
Bruenn interview with Jan K Herman, 31 January 1990.
30.
Bruenn interview with Jan Herman.
31.
Bruenn, Annals of Internal Medicine, p.583.
32.
Lerner BH, Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 2007.
33.
Bruenn in his interview with Jan Herman says Paullin asked for Bruenn's notes on Roosevelt but he did not give them to him.
34.
Personal communication with a retired Lahey Clinic physician who worked at the Lahey Clinic with Mrs Strand.
35.
AdamsHD. The knife that saves: memoirs of a Lahey Clinic Surgeon, Boston: The Francis A. Countway Library of Medicine, 1991, pp. 170–233.
36.
Personal communication.
37.
Personal communication.
38.
Adams, The knife that saves, p.170–194.
39.
Adams, The knife that saves, p.216.
40.
Goldsmith, Conspiracy of Silence, p.124.
41.
GoldsmithHS. Unanswered mysteries in the death of Franklin D Roosevelt. Surgery, Gynecology & Obstetrics1979; 149: 899–908.
GoldsmithHS. Roosevelt’s pigmented lesion: probably not a melanoma. Archives of Dermatology2009; 145: 339–339.
46.
14 December 1944, letter to Stephen Early signed Edgar.
47.
GoldsmithHS. A conspiracy of silence: the health and death of President Roosevelt, Bloomington, IN: iUniverse, Inc., 2007, pp. 45–45.
48.
Goldsmith, A conspiracy of silence, p.25.
49.
Goldsmith, A conspiracy of silence, p.23.
50.
Goldsmith, A conspiracy of silence, p.125.
51.
Goldsmith, A conspiracy of silence, p.132.
52.
Goldsmith, a conspiracy of silence, p.129.
53.
Dr Goldsmith told me that, despite her age, Mrs. Strand was cognitively intact.
54.
Linda M. Strand v. Herrick and Smith and Others, 396 Mass. 783; 489 N.E. 2d 179; 1986 Mass. Lexus 1177.
55.
Adams, The knife that saves, p.217.
56.
Linda M Strand v. Herrick and Smith and Others, 396 Mass. 783; 489 N.E. 2d 179; 1986 Mass. Lexus 1177.
57.
Goldsmith called Ed Hanify on 3 April 1990 and told him he planned to keep the Lahey Memorandum a secret until publication of his book. (See Adams, The knife that saves, footnote, p.219).
58.
Goldsmith HS. A conspiracy of silence: the health and death of Franklin D Roosevelt. iUniverse, Inc., 2007.
59.
On 12 August 1944 at the Bremerton Navy Yard, Roosevelt developed chest pain while giving a speech. He had just returned from consultations with Nimitz and McArthur in Hawaii. Testing was interpreted as showing evidence of coronary artery disease.
60.
KeenWW. The surgical operations on President Cleveland in 1893, Philadelphia: George W Jacobs & Company, 1917, pp. 17–17.
61.
Annas GeorgeJ. The health of the President and presidential candidates: the public's right to know. New England Journal of Medicine1995; 333: 945–949.
62.
MarkelHSternAM. Presidential health and the public's need to know. Journal of the American Medical Association2008; 299: 2558–2560.
63.
Medicine in history (editorial). Annals of Internal Medicine 1970; 72: 593.
64.
HawassZGhadYZIsmailS. Ancestry and pathology in King Tutankhamun’s family. Journal of the American Medical Association2010; 303: 638–647.
65.
MarkelH. King Tutankhamun, modern medical science and the expanding boundaries of historical inquiry. Journal of the American Medical Association2010; 303: 667–668.
