Many scholars have argued that Nietzsche's dementia was caused by syphilis. A careful review of the evidence suggests that this consensus is probably incorrect. The syphilis hypothesis is not compatible with most of the evidence available. Other hypotheses — such as slowly growing right-sided retro-orbital meningioma — provide a more plausible fit to the evidence.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
HollingdaleRJ. Nietzsche: The Man and His Philosophy (revised edn). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999: p. 258.
2.
VerrecchiaA.Nietzsche's breakdown in Turin. In: HarrisonT, Ed. Nietzsche in Italy. Saratoga: Stanford University Press, 1988: pp. 105–12.
3.
Ibid.: 108–12.
4.
ColliGMontinariM, Eds. Nietzsche: Sämliche Briefe, Kritische Gesamtausgabe. Berlin: de Gruyter, 1986: vol. III, p. 579.
5.
Ibid.: 572.
6.
Ibid.: 549.
7.
MerrittHH. A Textbook of Neurology. Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger, 1959: p. 146.
8.
PodachE.The Madness of Nietzsche. VoigtFA (trans.). New York: Putnam, 1931: pp. 170–1.
AdamsRVictorMRopperA.Principles of Neurology (6th edn). New York: McGraw-Hill, 1997: p. 173.
12.
GretterTE. Headache associated with intracranial abnormalities. In: TollisonDKunkellR, eds. Headache: Diagnosis and Treatment. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins, 1993: pp. 221–5.
13.
SouthardEE. Neurosyphilis: Modern Systematic Diagnosis and Treatment Presented in One Hundred and Thirty-Seven Case Histories. Boston: W M Leonard, 1917: p. 79.
14.
ColliGMontinariM (op. cit. ref. 4): vol. VI, p. 479.
15.
GilmanSL. Conversations with Nietzsche: A Life in the Words of His Contemporaries (ParentD, trans.). New York: Oxford, 1987: p. 173.
16.
ColliGMontinariM (op. cit. ref. 4): vol. II, p. 506.
17.
KochCSchlechtaK, Eds. Nietzsche: Frühe Schriften. Munich: C H Beck'sche, 1994: vol. V, p. 205.
18.
HaymanR.Nietzsche: A Critical Life. New York: Penguin, 1982: pp. 275–6.
19.
MerrittHH (op. cit. ref. 7): 146.
20.
VolzPD. Nietzsche im Labyrinth seiner Krankheit: Eine medizinisch-biographische Untersuchung. Würzburg: Königshausen & Neumann, 1990: p. 229.
21.
HaymanR (op. cit. ref. 18): 339.
22.
Ibid.: 24, 30, 38.
23.
ColliGMontinariM (op. cit. ref. 4): vol. V, p. 385.
24.
FuchsJ (op. cit. ref. 9): 632–3.
25.
GowersWR. Syphilis and the Nervous System. Philadelphia: Blakiston, 1892: p. 74. This book is a transcript of three lectures that Dr Gowers gave on syphilis in 1889. This is the same Dr Gowers who was famed for his descriptions of muscular dystrophy.
26.
SouthardEE (op. cit. ref. 13): 88.
27.
GilmanSL (op. cit. ref. 15): 253.
28.
PodachE (op. cit. ref. 8): 193.
29.
Ibid.: 200.
30.
Maurice-WilliamsRDunwoodyG.Late diagnosis of frontal meningiomas presenting with psychiatric symptoms. British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition)1988; 296: 1785–6. See also: HutchinsonGAustinHNeehallJ.Psychiatric symptoms and an anterior cranial fossa meningioma. West Indian Medical Journal1998; 47: 111–12.
31.
RenvoizeEGaskellRKlarH.Results of investigations in 150 demented patients consecutively admitted to a psychiatric hospital. British Journal of Psychiatry1985; 147: 204–5.
32.
ShaffiCLekiasJ.Meningiomas. Medical Journal of Australia1975; 10: 589–94.
33.
ColeG.Intracranial space-occupying masses in mental hospital patients: necropsy study. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry1978; 41: 730–6. See also: AnderssonP.Intracranial tumors in psychiatric autopsy material. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica1970; 46: 213–24.
34.
GhadirianAGauthierSBertrandS.Anxiety attacks in a patient with a right temporal lobe meningioma. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry1986; 47: 270–1.
35.
AndersonDKhalilM.Meningioma and the ophthalmologist. Ophthalmology1981; 88: 1004–9.
36.
Ibid.
37.
AndersonDKhalilM.Meningioma and the ophthalmologist: diagnostic pitfalls. Canadian Journal of Ophthalmology1981; 16: 10–15.
OliveroWCListerJRElwoodP.The natural history and growth rate of asymptomatic meningiomas: a review of 60 patients. Journal of Neurosurgery1995; 83: 222–4.
40.
Ibid.: 243.
41.
AschheimSE. The Nietzsche Legacy in Germany, 1890–1990. Berkeley: University of California, 1990: p. 27.
42.
VolzPD (op. cit. ref. 20): 230.
43.
TheopoldW.Paul Julius Möbius, 1853–1907. Medizinhistorische Journal1983; 18: 106.
44.
MöbiusPJ. Ueber das Pathologische bei Nietzsche. Wiesbaden: J F Bergmann, 1902: p. 103.
45.
Ibid.: 106.
46.
PetersHF. Zarathustra's Sister. New York: Wiener, 1977: p. 184.
47.
PodachE (op. cit. ref. 8): 54–8.
48.
HildebrandtK.Gesundheit und Krankheit in Nietzsches Leben und Werk. Berlin: Karger, 1926.
49.
Ibid.: 151.
50.
Podach E (op. cit. ref. 8): 49.
51.
Lange-EichbaumW.Genie, Irrsinn, und Ruhm. Munich: Reinhardt, 1928.
52.
Lange-EichbaumW.Nietzsche als psychiatrisches Problem. Deutsche medizinische Wochenschrift, 5 September 1930: 1538.
53.
Ibid.: 1539.
54.
This rejoinder appeared in the Preface to the English edition of Podach's The Madness of Nietzsche (op. cit. ref. 8): pp. 17–19.
55.
Lange-EichbaumW (op. cit. ref. 52): 1537.
56.
Lange-EichbaumW.Nietzsche: Krankheit und Wirkung. Hamburg: Lettenbauer, 1947: p. 89.
57.
GilmanSL (op. cit. ref. 15): 258.
58.
Lange-EichbaumW (op. cit. ref. 56): 16.
59.
Ibid.
60.
VolzPD (op. cit. ref. 20): 190–2.
61.
BlunckR.Friedrich Nietzsche: Kindheit und Jugend. Munich: Reinhardt, 1953: p. 161.
62.
HollingdaleRJ (op. cit. ref. 1): 30.
63.
KaufmannW.Nietzsche: Philosopher, Psychologist, Antichrist. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1974: p. 69.
