Drawing on in-depth interviews, participant observation, and digital materials, this paper examines how legal consciousness is constructed and operated across coexisting legal systems. The data show that legal consciousness is not confined to a single dominant order but is shaped through processes of comparison, negotiation, and contrast among multiple legal orders, and that participants’ legal consciousness is plural and relative. Legal consciousness also emerges as relational—formed not only through individuals’ social relationships, but also through how they relate themselves and their communities to multiple legal systems. While existing scholarship shows that emotions influence legal consciousness, this study suggests that relational dynamics play a central role in mediating that process. Feelings about law are closely tied to how individuals understand their relationship to it—whether one of colonial domination, communal belonging, or religious duty. The article introduces three categories of legal consciousness—Outside-the-Law, Enmeshed with the Law, and Leveraging the Law—each capturing distinct ways participants give meaning to coexisting legal orders. These categories move beyond approaches centered on a single order and illuminate how legal consciousness is shaped in relation to multiple systems and through transnational awareness. Together, they offer new theoretical and empirical contributions and reveal how marginalized actors sustain complex, strategic, and emotionally grounded relationships to law across national and normative boundaries.
Abou El FadlK (2001) Islam and the theology of power. Middle East Report221: 28–33.
2.
Abou El FadlK (2003) Speaking in God's Name: Islamic Law, Authority and Women. Oxford, England: One World Publications.
3.
AbramsKKHKerenH (2010) Who’s afraid of law and the emotions?Minnesota Law Review94(6): 1997.
4.
AbramsKR (2014) Performative Citizenship in the Civil Rights and Immigrant Rights Movements. UC Berkeley Public Law Research Paper no 2409971.
5.
AbregoLJ (2011) Legal consciousness of undocumented latinos: fear and stigma as barriers to claims-making for first and 1.5 generation immigrants. Law and Society Review45(2): 337–369.
6.
AbregoLJ (2018) Renewed optimism and spatial mobility: legal consciousness of latino deferred action for childhood arrivals recipients and their families in Los Angeles. Ethnicities18(2): 192–207.
7.
AbregoLJ (2019) Relational legal consciousness of US citizenship: privilege, responsibility, guilt, and love in latino mixed Status families. Law & Society Review53(3): 641–670. http://www.jstor.org/stable/45217740.
8.
AdamskiJFlorczakI (2022) Exploring the model of legal consciousness formation among foreigners working in Poland. Preliminary insights. Studia Migracyjne – Przegląd Polonijny3(185): 85–115.
9.
AkandeR (2023) Entangled Domains: Empire, Law, and Religion in Northern Nigeria. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
10.
AkhtarP (2014) “We were muslims but we did not know islam”: migration, Pakistani muslim women and changing religious practices in the UK. Women’s Studies International Forum47: 232–238.
11.
AkhtarRC (2019) Plural approaches to faith-based dispute resolution by Britain's muslim communities. Child and Family Law Quarterly31(3): 189–214.
12.
AkhtarRC (2020) Rebecca Probert and Patrick Nash (eds): Cohabitation and religious marriage: status, similarities and solutions. Briston: Briston University Press.
BandesSABlumenthalJA (2012) Emotion and the law. Annual Review of Law and Society8: 161–181.
15.
BasuS (2006) Playing off courts: the negotiation of divorce and violence in plural legal settings in kalkota. The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law38(52): 41–75.
16.
BergerPLLuckmannT (1966) The Social Construction of Reality. London: Anchor Books.
17.
BermanPS (2017) The Evolution of Global Legal Pluralism. GWU Law School Public Law, Research Paper No. 2017-42; The Evolution of Global Legal Pluralism, in Authority in Transnational Legal Theory: Theorising Across Disciplines 151 (Roger Cotterrell & Maksymilian Del Mar eds., 2016); GWU Law School Public Law Research Paper No. 2017-42; GWU Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2017-42. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract.
18.
CalavitaK (1998) Immigration, law, and marginalization in a global economy: notes from Spain. Law & Society Review32(3): 529–566.
19.
ChappeV-APelisseJEgeaA (2018) Importations, diffusions et inflexions des legal consciousness studies dans la recherche française. Droit et Société : Revue Internationale de Théorie du Droit et de Sociologie Juridique100: 665–684.
20.
ChuaLEngelDM (2019) Legal consciousness reconsidered. Annual Rev Of Law and Social Science15: 335–353.
21.
CooperD (1995) Local government legal consciousness in the shadow of juridification. Journal of Law and Society22(4): 506–526.
22.
De GenovaNP (2002) Migrant “illegality” and deportability in everyday life. Annual Review of Anthropology31: 419–447. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4132887.
23.
de HartBBesselsenE (2020) ‘Everything went according the ‘rules’: female citizen sponsor’s legal consciousness, intimate citizenship and family migration law. Identities: Global Studies in Culture and Power28: 37–55.
24.
DossaP (2009) Racialized Bodies, Disabling Worlds: Storied Lives of Immigrant Muslim Women. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
25.
DossaP (2020) Social Palliation: Canadian Muslims’ Storied Lives on Living and Dying. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
26.
DossaP (2023) The Circle Unfolds: Envisioning Social Justice from the Margins. Illustrated by Charlotte Corden.
27.
DourgnonPPouratNRoccoL (2023) European immigrant health policies, Immigrants’ health and Immigrants’ access to healthcare. Health Policy127: 3743.
28.
EdwinMELQuintanaFC (2024) Sexual violence and the formation of legal consciousness among the indigenous arhuaco women. Revista De Estudos Empíricos Em Direito, Vol. 11.
29.
EngelDM (2016a) The Myth of the Litigious Society: Why We Don’t Sue. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
30.
EngelDM (2016b) Blood curse and belonging in Thailand: law, buddhism, and legal consciousness. Asian J. Law and Society3: 71–83.
31.
EngelDMEngelJS (2010) Tort, Custom, and Karma: Globalization and Legal Consciousness in Thailand. Stanford: Stanford Univ. Press.
32.
EwickPSilbeySS (1998) The Common Place of Law: Stories from Everyday Life. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
33.
FallonSM (2013) Justice for all: American muslims, sharia law, and maintaining comity with American jurisprudence. Boston College International and Comparative Law36(1): 153.
34.
FloresAEscuderoKBarciagaE (2019) Legal-Spatial consciousness: a legal geography framework for examining migrant illegality. Law and Policy41(1): 12–33.
35.
FloresRDAzarA (2023) Who are the “immigrants”? how Whites’ diverse perceptions of immigrants shape their attitudes. Social Forces101(4): 2117–2146.
36.
FritsvoldED (2009) Under the law: legal consciousness and radical environmental activism. Law & Social Inquiry34(4): 799–824.
37.
GalliC (2018) The ambivalent U.S. Context of reception and the dichotomous legal consciousness of unaccompanied minors. Social Problems67: 763–781.
38.
GalliC (2020) The ambivalent U.S. Context of reception and the dichotomous legal consciousness of unaccompanied minors. Social Problems67: 763–781.
39.
GarciaASDiaz-StrongDXRodriguezYR (2024) A matter of time: the life course of deferred action for undocumented Latin American immigrants in the United States. Social Problems71: 958–974.
40.
GomezL (2016) Connecting critical race theory with second generation legal consciousness work in obasogie’s blinded by sight. Law and Social Inquiry41(4): 1069–1083.
41.
GracaS (2018) Portuguese Culture and legal consciousness: a discussion of immigrant women's perceptions of and reactions to domestic violence. International Journal of Law in Context14(3): 416–436.
42.
GracaS (2021) Resistance and the paradox of legal entitlement - a theoretical analysis of migrant women’s responses to domestic abuse in the host country. Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial law53(2): 290–314.
43.
GracaSKapageorgiadouV (2025) “ (…) here I have freedom”—A study of Refugees’ and asylum Seekers’ legal consciousness in Greece: self-identity, human rights, and expectations from European union law. Law & Policy47(1): e12256.
44.
GraceBDoering-WhiteJRothB (2025) The violence of uncertainity: theorizing everday immigrant necropolitics across three cases. Comparative Migration Studies13(1): 26–14.
45.
GriffithsA (2002) Legal pluralism. In: BanakarRTraversM (eds) An Introduction to Law and Social Theory. Oxford, Oxforshire: Hart Publishing, 289–310.
46.
GrilloRBallardRFerrariA, et al. (2009) Legal Practice and Cultural Diversity. Aldershot: Ashgate.
47.
GüdükADesmetE (2022) Legal consciousness and migration: towards a research agenda. International Journal of Law in Context18(2): 213–228.
48.
HallPALamontM (2013) Social Resilience in the Neoliberal Era. Boston: Harvard University Press.
49.
HallaqW (2009) Sharīʿa: Theory, Practice, Transformations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
50.
HallaqWB (2005) The Origins and Evolution of Islamic Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
51.
HallidaySMorganB (2013) I fought the law and the law won? Legal consciousness and the critical imagination. Current Legal Problems66(1): 1–32.
52.
HardingR (2010) Regulating Sexuality: Legal Consciousness in Lesbian and Gay Lives. Newyork: Routledge.
53.
HayekFA (2011) The Constitution of Liberty: The Definitive Edition. Edited by Ronald Hamowy. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
54.
HeadworthS (2020) The power of second order legal consciousness: authorities’ perceptions of “street policy” and welfare fraud enforcement. Law and Society Review54(2): 320–353.
55.
HernandezD (2010) ‘‘i’m gonna call my lawyer’: shifting legal consciousness at the intersection of inequality. Studies in Law Politics and Society51: 95–121.
56.
HertoghM (2004) A ‘European’ conception of legal consciousness: rediscovering eugen erhlich. Journal of Law & Society31(4): 457–481.
57.
HertoghM (2009) What's in a handshake? Legal equality and legal consciousness in The Netherlands. Social & Legal Studies18: 221–239.
58.
HertoghM (2018) Nobody’s Law: Legal Consciousness and Legal Alienation in Everyday.
59.
HertoghMKuckchiyanM (2016) When politics Come to play, law is no Longer law: images of collective legal consciousness in the UK, Poland and Bulgaria, comparative study of Poland and Bulgaria. International Journal of Law in Context12(4): 404–419.
HullK (2016) Legal consciousness in marginalized groups: the case of LGBT people. Law and Social Inquiry41(3): 551–572.
62.
HullK (2019) Same-sex marriage: principle versus practice. International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family33(1): 51–74.
63.
Islamicity. (2005) Question number 9716, dated 10/18/2005. Available at: www.islamicity.org.
64.
JacksonSA (1996) Taqlīd, legal scaffolding and the scope of legal injunctions in post-formative theory muṭlaq and ʿĀmm in the jurisprudence of shihāb al-dīn al-qarāfī. Islamic Law and Society3(2): 165–192. http://www.jstor.org/stable/3399454.
65.
JonesJE (2000) How effective has the United States system of justice been in accommodating islam?Journal of Islamic Law & Culture5(1): 1–10.
66.
KalraS (2024) Double vision’ in the interlegal: the situated pluri-legal consciousness of British muslim women. Journal of law and Society51(1): 136–152.
67.
KostinerI (2003) Evaluating legality: toward a cultural approach to the study of law and social change. Law and Society Review37(2): 323–368.
68.
KostinerI (2006) “That’s right”: truth, justice, and the legal consciousness of educational activists. In: Fleury-SteinerBNielsenLB (eds) The New Civil Rights Research: A Constitutive Approach. Burlington: VT: Ashgat, 17–36.
69.
Kozak-IsikG (2014) Institutional Reproduction: Reproduction of the Umma in the U.K. within the Context of the Muslim Council of Britain and Its Key Affiliates. Unpublished PHD thesis, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN.
70.
Kozak-IsikG (2024) Contemporary legal pluralism, the modern metropole, and immigrant integration L negotiating the law and legal institutions in immigrant contexts. Social and Legal Studies34(2): 224–253.
71.
KurkchiyanM (2011) Perception of law and social order: a cross-national comparison of collective legal consciousness. Wisconsin International Law Journal29(2): 366–392.
72.
LarsonEW (2004) Institutionalizing legal consciousness: regulation and the embedding of market participants in the securities industry in Ghana and Fiji. Law and Society Review38(4): 737–768.
73.
LiuQ (2018) Legal consciousness of the leftover woman: law and Qing in Chinese family relations. Asian Journal of Law and Society5(1): 7–27.
74.
LiuQ (2023) Relational legal consciousness in the one-child nation. Law and Society Review57(2): 214–233.
75.
MaroneyTA (2006) Law and emotion: a proposed taxonomy of an emerging field. Law and Human Behavior30(2): 119–142.
76.
MaroneyTA (2009) Emotional common sense as a constitutional law. Vanderbilt Law Review62(3): 849–918.
77.
MaroneyTAAckerman-LibermanPJ (2014) As a father shows compassion for his children: ancient and contemporary perspectives on judicial empathy. Journal of Law, Religion, and State3(1): 240–275.
78.
MarshallA-M (2006) Communities and culture: enriching legal consciousness and legal culture. Law and Social Inquiry31(1): 229–249.
79.
MarshallA-MBarclayS (2003) In their own words: how ordinary people construct the legal world. Law and Social Inquiry28(3): 617–628.
80.
MassoudMMooreKM (2015) Rethinking shari'a: voices of islam in California. Boom5(4): 94–99.
81.
MassoudMMooreKM (2020) Sharia consciousness: law and lived religion among California muslims. Law and Social Inquiry45(3): 1–31.
82.
McMillanJ (2011) Colonial traditions, co-optations, and mi’kmaq legal consciousness. Law and Social Inquiry36(1): 171–200.
83.
MenjivarCKanstroomD (2013) Constructing Immigrant Ilegality: Critiques, Experiences, and Responses. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
84.
MenskiWF (2006) Rethinking legal theory in the light of south-north migration. In: MenskiWFShahP (eds) Migration, Diasporas and Legal Systems in Europe. London: Routledge, 13–28.
85.
MenskiWF (2007) Law, religion and south asians in diaspora. In: HinnellsJR (ed.) Religious Reconstruction in the South Asian Diasporas: From One Generation to Another. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 243–264.
86.
MenskiWF (2011) Islamic law in British courts: do we not know or do we not want to know?. In: MairJÖrücüE (eds) The Place of Religion in Family Law: A Comparative Search. Cambridge, UK: Intersentia, 15–36.
87.
MerrySE (1990) Getting Justice and Getting Even: Legal Consciousness among Working-Class Americans. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
88.
MoustafaT (2013) Islamic law, women's rights, and popular legal consciousness in Malaysia. Law and Social Inquiry38: 168–188.
89.
MunkresSA (2008) Claiming “victim” to harassment law: legal consciousness of the privileged. Law and Social Inquiry33(2): 447–472.
90.
NamukasaA (2017) Law and Labour Migration Struggles: Legal Consciousness of East African Healthcare Professionals in Britain. Kassel: Kassel University Press.
91.
NaqviZ (2020) Nikah ceremonies in the UK: a tool for empowerment?. In: AkhtarRNashPProbertR (eds) Cohabitation and Religious Marriage: Status, Similarities and Solutions. Bristol, UK: Bristol University Press, 103–116.
92.
NaqviZ (2021) Nikah ceremonies in the UK: a tool for empowerment?. In: AkhtarRNashPProbertR (eds) Cohabitation and Religious Marriage. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 85–102.
93.
NielsenLB (2000) Situating legal consciousness: experiences and attitudes of ordinary citizens about law and street harassment. Law and Society Review34(4): 1055–1090.
94.
NielsenLB (2004) License to Harass: Law, Hierarchy, and Offensive Public Speech. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
95.
ParveenR (2017) Do Sharia Councils Meet the Needs of Muslim Women? In: Gender and Justice in Family Law Disputes, pp.142–165. Brandeis University Press.
96.
ParveenR (2018) Religious-Only marriages in the UK: legal positionings and muslim women’s experiences. Sociology of Islam6(3): 316–337.
97.
ParveenR (2021) From regulating marriage ceremonies to recognizing marriage ceremonies. In: AkhtarRNashPProbertR (eds) Cohabitation and Religious Marriage. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 85–102.
98.
PatlerC (2018) To reveal or conceal: how diverse undocumented youth navigate legal Status disclosure. Sociological Perspectives61(6): 1–17.
99.
PowellE (2020) Islamic law and International Law: Peaceful Resolution of Disputes. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
100.
QuraishiASyeed-MillerN (2004) No Altars: A Survey of Islamic Family Law in the United States. Women’s Rights and Islamic Family Law: Perspectives on Reform. London, UK: Zed Books.
101.
RichmanK (2006) LGBT family rights, legal consciousness, and the dilemma of difference. In: Fleury-SteinerBNielsenLB (eds) The New Civil Rights Research: A Constitutive Approach. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 77–100.
102.
SaguyA (2003) What is Sexual Harassment? From Capitol Hill to the Sorbonne. Berkeley: University of California Press.
103.
SaratA (1990) “The law is all over,” power, resistance, and the legal consciousness of the welfare poor. Yale Journal of Law and the Humanities2(2): 343–379.
104.
SchwiertzH (2016) Transformation of the undocumented youth movement and radical egalitarian citizenship. Citizenship Studies20: 610–628.
105.
ScottH (2022) Survival over safety: non-reporting of criminalised violence by young migrants excluded from protection. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies48: 4793–4810.
106.
ScottH (2024) “We can’t help you-it doesn’t concern us”: the legal consciousness of young people seeking asylum in Sweden who report violent crime. Journal of law and Society51: 36–56.
107.
ShaharI (2012) Legal pluralism incarnate: an institutional perspective on courts of law in colonial and postcolonial settings. The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law44(65): 133–163.
108.
ShaharI (2013) Forum Shopping between Civil and Shari’a Courts: Maintenance Suits in Contemporary Jerusalem. In: von Benda-Beckmann F, von Benda-Beckmann K. Ramstedt.
109.
ShaharI (2015) Legal Pluralism in the Holy City: Competing Courts, Forum Shopping and Institutional Dynamics in Jerusalem. London: Routledge.
110.
ShaharI (2017) Standing on the barricade of patriarchy: the Israeli Shari'a courts and their struggle against women arbitrators. The Family in Law8: 81–100.
111.
ShaharIYefetKC (2024) Rethinking the rethinking of legal pluralism: toward a manifesto for a pluri-legal perspective. Law and History Review42(2): 223–235.
112.
ShalalaEH (2024) Colonialism and islamic reform: bodies, minds and freedom. Hawwa22(1): 20–51.
113.
SilbeyS (1992) Making a place for cultural analyses of law. Law & Social Inquiry17(1): 39–48.
114.
SilbeyS (2005) After legal consciousness. Annual Review of Law and Social Science1: 323–368.
115.
SilbeySS (2015) Legal culture and legal consciousness. International Encylopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences (Second Edition), pp.726-733.
SilvaF (2022) Relational legal consciousness and anticorruption: lava jato, social media interactions, and the co-production of law’s detraction in Brazil (2017–2019). Law & Society Review56(3): 344–368.
118.
SwidlerA (1986) Culture in action: symbols and strategies. American Sociological Review51(2): 273–286.
119.
TenorioLE (2024a) Disclosure and the evolving legal consciousness of sexual and gender minority central American unaccompanied minors. Law & Social Inquiry50(1): 195–224.
120.
TenorioLE (2024b) “Work after lawful Status: formerly undocumented immigrants” gendered relational legal consciousness and workplace claims-making. Law and Society Review58(3): 383–414.
121.
Von Benda-BeckmannKV (1981) Forum shopping and shopping forums. Dispute processing in a minangkabau village in west sumatra. Journal of Legal Pluralism19: 117–162.
122.
Von Benda-BeckmannFvon Benda-BeckmannK (2006) The dynamics of change and continuity in plural legal orders. Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law38(53/54): 1–44.
123.
WangH-T (2019) Justice, emotion, and belonging: legal consciousness in a Taiwanese family conflict. Law and Society Review53(3): 764–790.
124.
WeissBG (1992) The Search for God’s Law: Islamic Jurisprudence in the Writings of Sayf al-Din al-Amidi. Salt Lake City, UT: University of Utah Press.
125.
WeissBG (1998) The Spirit of Islamic Law. Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press.
126.
WilsonJC (2011) Sustaining the state: legal consciousness and the construction of legality in competing abortion Activists’ narratives. Law and Social Inquiry36(2): 455–483.
127.
YoungKM (2014) Everyone knows the game: legal consciousness in the hawaiian cockfight. Law and Society Review48(3): 499–530.
128.
YoungKMChimowitzH (2022) How parole board members understand remorse: relational legal consciousness and the reproduction of carceral logic. Law & Society Review56(2): 237–260.
