This article offers a discourse analysis of domestic abuse's ‘Man Problem’ by combining and developing Naffine's, Foucault's and Bacchi's work in a new way. Taking the parliamentary debates around the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 in England and Wales as our focus, we critique how MPs problematise gender to justify a gender-neutral definition of domestic violence and abuse (DVA). We illustrate how MPs reframe DVA's ‘man problem’ not as the problem of men as perpetrators of violence against women. But rather, they represent the law and policy ‘problem’ as men's invisibility as victims of DVA. We develop a new theoretical innovation to advance our critique: discursive co-option, and we uncover two gender paradoxes. We argue that MPs co-opt gender equality discourses to advance masculinist politics and patriarchal logics in ways that have detrimental effects for the less powerful, and which elide the reality of women's experiences of DVA.
AldridgeJ (2021) Not an either/or situation: the minimisation of violence against women in United Kingdom ‘domestic abuse’ policy. Violence Against Women27(11): 1823–1839.
2.
BacchiC (2009) Analysing Policy: What’s the problem represented to be?Frenchs Forest: Pearson Education.
3.
BacchiC (2012) Why study problematisations? Making politics visible. Open Journal of Political Science2(1): –8.
4.
BarkerKJuraszO (2020) Online violence against women as an obstacle to gender equality: a critical view from Europe. European Equality Law Review1: 47–60.
5.
BettinsonV (2022) A Comparative Analysis of Non-Fatal Strangulation Offences: Will the Proposed s. 75A Serious Crime Act 2015 Work for Victims of Domestic Violence and Abuse?. The Journal of Criminal Law86(2): 75–93. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00220183221086426.
6.
BishopC (2021) Prevention and protection: will the domestic abuse act transform the response to domestic abuse in England and Wales?Child and Family Law Quarterly33(2): 163–183.
7.
BowsHHerringJ (2020) Getting away with murder? A review of the ‘rough sex defence. The Journal of Criminal Law84(6): 525–538.
8.
BoydSSheehyE (2016) Men's Groups: Challenging Feminism. Canadian Journal of Women and the Law28(1): 5–10.
9.
BradleyE (2022) Reacting to rough sex: The Unexpected toll of section 71 Domestic Abuse Act 2021. In BowsHHerringJ (eds) ‘Rough Sex’ and the Criminal Law: Global Perspectives. Leeds: Emerald Publishing Limited, 167–183.
ButlerJ (2009) Frames of war: when is life grievable?New York: Verso.
12.
CollierR (2009) Fathers’ rights, gender and welfare: some questions for family law. Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law31(4): 357–371.
13.
CostonBKimmelM (2012) White men as the new victims: reverse discrimination cases and the men's rights movement. Nev. LJ13: 368–385.
14.
DaviesP (2022) How far has multi-agency policing travelled in 30 years? Reflecting on progress in the context of ‘policing’ domestic abuse in England and Wales. Crime Prev Community Saf24: 311–327. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41300-022-00161-1.
15.
de JongSKimmS (2017) The co-optation of feminisms: a research agenda. International Feminist Journal of Politics19(2): 185–200.
16.
DobashRDobashR (1992) Women, violence and social change. Abingdon: Routledge.
17.
DonovanCBarnesR (2020) Help-seeking among lesbian, gay, bisexual and/or transgender victims/survivors of domestic violence and abuse: the impacts of cisgendered heteronormativity and invisibility. Journal of Sociology56(4): 554–570.
18.
DragiewiczM (2011) Equality with a vengeance: men's rights groups, battered women, and antifeminist backlash. Lebanon, New Hampshire: University Press of New England.
19.
EdwardsS (2020) Consent and the ‘rough sex’defence in rape, murder, manslaughter and gross negligence. The Journal of Criminal Law84(3): 293–311.
20.
EisensteinH (2009) Feminism seduced: how global elites use women’s labour and ideas the exploit the world. Boulder, CO, and London: Paradigm Publishers.
21.
Fitz-GibbonKWalklateS (2023) What is to be done about violence against women? Gendered violence(s) in the Twenty-first Century. London: Routledge.
22.
FitzgeraldSFreedmanJ (2022) Gender, Equality and Social Justice: Anti Trafficking, Sex Work and Migration Law and Policy in the EU. London: Routledge.
23.
FoucaultM (1977) In: BouchardDF (ed) Language, counter-memory, practice: selected essays and interviews. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press, 139–164.
24.
FoucaultM (1984) Polemics, politics and problematizations. In: r. L. Davis. (Trans.), Essential works of Foucault (Vol. 1), Ethics, New York: New Press. Available at: https://edisciplinas.usp.br/pluginfile.php/4256765/mod_resource/content/1/FOUCAULT_Polemics_Politics_Problematizations.pdf.
25.
FoucaultM (1985) Discourse and truth: the problematisation of ParrhesiaEvanston, IL: Northwestern University.
26.
FoucaultM (1986) The use of pleasure: the history of sexuality. New York: Vintage.
27.
FoucaultM (1988) The concern for truth. In: KritzmanLD (eds) Michel Foucault: politics, philosophy, culture. Interviews and other writings, 1977-1984. New York: Routledge, 255–267.
28.
FoucaultM (1994) So it is important to think? In: FaubionJD (ed) Power: essential work of Foucault 1954–1984. London: Penguin, 456–457.
29.
FraserN (2009) Feminism, capitalism and the cunning of history. New Left Review56: 97–117.
30.
GotellLDuttonE (2016) Sexual violence in the ‘manosphere’: antifeminist men's rights discourses on rape. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy5(2): 65–80.
31.
Halperin-KaddariRFreemanMA (2016) Backlash goes global: Men's groups, patriarchal family policy, and the false promise of gender-neutral laws. Canadian Journal of Women and the Law28(1): 182–210.
32.
Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICRFS) (2021a) A duty to protect: police use of protective measures in cases involving violence against women and girls. London: HMICRFS.
33.
Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICRFS) (2021b) Interim report: inspection into how effectively the police engage with women and girls. London: HMICRFS.
34.
Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICRFS) (2021c) Police response to violence against women and girls—final inspection report. London: HMICRFS 2021.
35.
Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary, Fire and Rescue Services (HMICFRS) (2017) A progress report on the police response to domestic abuse. London: HMICRFS.
36.
Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary (HMIC) (2014) Everyone’s business: improving the police response to domestic abuse. London: HMIC.
37.
Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary (HMIC) (2015) Increasingly everyone’s business: a progress report on the police response to domestic abuse. London: HMIC.
38.
HineB, et al. (2022) I have guys call me and say ‘I can’t be the victim of domestic abuse: exploring the experiences of telephone support providers for male victims of domestic violence and abuse. Journal of Interpersonal Violence37(7-8): NP5594–NP5625.
39.
HM Government (2014) Transforming the Response to Domestic Abuse Consultation Response and Draft Bill. London: HM Government.
40.
Home Office (2022) Home Office Abuse Act 2021 statutory guidance consultation. London: HMSO.
41.
Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC)(2023) Referrals Analysis - Violence against women and girls Referrals analysis. Available at https://www.policeconduct.gov.uk/publications/referrals-analysis-violence-against-women-and-girls-may-2023 (Last accessed 2/2/224)
42.
Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) (2022) Learning the lessons issue 41—call handling. Available online at: https://www.policeconduct.gov.uk/learning-lessons-41-call-handling (Last accessed 2/2/24).
43.
JakobsenH (2014) What’s gendered about gender-based violence? An empirically grounded theoretical explanation from Tanzania. Gender and Society28(4): 537–561.
44.
JohnsonMP (2006) Conflict and control: Gender symmetry and asymmetry in domestic violence. Violence against women12(11): 1003–1018.
45.
JohnsonMP (2011) Gender and types of intimate partner violence: A response to an anti-feminist literature review. Aggression and Violent Behaviour16(4): 289–296. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.avb.2011.04.006.
46.
KellyLWestmarlandN (2014) Time for a rethink—why the current government definition of domestic violence is a problem. (last accessed 1/2/2024).
47.
KellyLWestmarlandN (2016) Naming and defining ‘domestic violence’: lessons from research with violent men. Feminist Review112(1): 113–127.
48.
KimmelMS (2002) Male victims of domestic violence: a substantive and methodological research review. Violence Against Women8(11): 1332–1363.
49.
MathiesenT (2005) Silently silenced: Essays on the creation of acquiescence in modern societySherfield on Loddon. Hook, Hampshire: Waterside press.
50.
McLeodD, et al. (2024) Male survivors of domestic violence, challenges in cultural response, and impact on identity and help-seeking behaviours: a systematic review. Trauma, Violence & Abuse25(2): 1397–1410.
51.
McNayL (1992) Foucault and feminism: Power, gender and the self. London: John Wiley and Sons.
52.
McpheeDHesterMBatesL, et al. (2022) Criminal justice responses to domestic violence and abuse in England: An analysis of case attrition and inequalities using police data. Policing and Society32(8): 963–980.
53.
Monckton SmithK. (2020) In control: Dangerous relationships and how they end in murder. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.
54.
NaffineN (2020) Criminal Law and the Man Problem. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
55.
Sharp-JeffsN (2021) Understanding the economics of abuse: an assessment of the economic abuse definition within the Domestic Abuse Bill. Journal of Gender-Based Violence5(1): 163–173. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1332/239788220X16076181041680.
56.
SpeedARichardsonK (2022) Should I stay or should I go now? If I go there will be trouble and if I stay it will be double: an examination into the present and future of protective orders regulating the family home in England and Wales. The Journal of Criminal Law86(3): 179–205.
57.
State of Victoria (2016) Ending Family Violence: Victoria’s 10-year plan for change (last accessed: 18/03/23).
58.
StratigakiM (2004) The cooptation of gender concepts in EU policies: the case of ‘reconciliation of work and family’. Social Politics: International Studies in Gender, State and Society11(1): 30–56.
59.
WalbyS (1990) Theorising patriarchy. London: John Wiley.
60.
WalbySTowersJFrancisBJ. (2016) Is violent crime increasing or decreasing? A new methodology to measure repeat attacks making visible the significance of gender and domestic relations. British Journal of Criminology56(6): 1203–1234.
61.
WelshK (2008) Current policy on domestic violence: a move in the right direction or a step too far?Crime Prev Community Saf10(4): 226–248.
62.
WHO (2021) Violence Against Women (Last accessed 23/8/23).
63.
Women’s Aid, et al. (2021) Gendered experiences of justice and domestic abuse. Evidence for policy and practice. Bristol: Women’s Aid.
