Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

In the context of prolonged occupation, it has long been argued that the Israeli Supreme Court (ISC), in High Court of Justice (HCJ) formation, is facilitating the entrenchment of a permanent regime of legalized control by moving away from a model of exception to ordinary civilian jurisdiction over the West Bank. This was recently demonstrated in the Khan-al-Ahmar case, in which a group of settlers petitioned the ISC/HCJ demanding the execution of a pending Israeli demolition order over a school in a Bedouin village in Palestine. The court sided with the army, deferring to a political solution for the transfer of the entire Bedouin community elsewhere. Drawing on existing scholarship and the author’s first-hand impressions of the final hearing, this article interprets the Khan-al-Ahmar case as an illustration of how the exceptional military nature of the occupation has shifted to a permanent regime of legalized control overseen by an ordinary civilian court.

Keywords

Israeli Supreme Court/High Court of Justice jurisdiction occupation Palestine West Bank

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Israeli Supreme Court in High Court of Justice formation.

Kfar Adumim Community Settlement and others v Minister of Defense and others, HCJ 7969/13 (24 April 2014) (Khan-al-Ahmar case), before Judge Esther Hayut, Judge Uzi Vogelman and Judge Isaac Amit [Hebrew]. Unofficial translation into English on file with the author, who also attended the final hearing on 23 April 2014 in Jerusalem.

Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, Advisory Opinion, I.C.J. 136 [2004].

Al-Haq (2010) Legitimising the illegitimate? The Israeli high court of justice in the occupied Palestinian territory. Available at: http://www.alhaq.org/advocacy/topics/military-administration-and-legal-remedies/380-al-haqs-new-study-legitimising-the-illegitimate- (accessed 8 March 2016).

Al-Haq (2016) Field update: A review of the situation in the OPT in 2015. Available at: http://www.alhaq.org/documentation/field-updates-2015/1010-special-focus-a-review-of-the-situation-in-the-opt-in-2015 (accessed 28 January 2016).

Alexandrowicz

(director) (2011) The Law in these Parts [Hebrew, English subs].

Allo

(2016) Marwan Barghouti in Tel Aviv: Occupation, terrorism, and resistance in the courtroom. Social & Legal Studies, June 16, 2016, doi:10.1177/0964663916651000.

Arai-Takahasi

(2009) The Law of Occupation: Continuity and Change of International Humanitarian Law, and its Interaction with International Human Rights Law. Leiden: Martinus Nijhoff Press.

B’Tselem (2011) The separation barrier. Available at: http://www.btselem.org/separation_barrier/map (accessed 8 March 2016).

10.

B’Tselem (2012a) The E1 plan and its implications for human rights in the West Bank. Available at: http://www.btselem.org/settlements/20121202_e1_human_rights_ramifications (accessed 8 March 2016).

11.

B’Tselem (2012b) Levy committee report: Where are the Palestinians? Available at: http://www.btselem.org/setllements/20120711_levy_committee_report (accessed 8 March 2016)

12.

B’Tselem (2013) Acting the landlord: Israel’s policy in area C, the West Bank. Available at: http://www.btselem.org/download/201306_area_c_report_eng.pdf (accessed 28 January 2016).

13.

Bauck

Omer

(2013) The Oslo accords 1993–2013: A critical assessment. Cairo: American University in Cairo Press.

14.

Bedouin Transfer Roundtable, Jericho (2015) Public statement. Available at: http://jahalin.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/2015.01-Roundtable-Statement_Final_signed.pdf (accessed 29 July 2015).

15.

Benvenisti

(2012a) The International Law of Occupation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

16.

Benvenisti

(2012b) Expert opinion: On the prohibition of forcible transfer in Susya Village. Available at: https://www.diakonia.se/globalassets/documents/ihl/ihl-resources-center/expert-opinions/the_prohibition_of_forcible_transfer_in_susya_village.pdf (accessed 30 July 2015 ).

17.

Bhuta

(2005) The antinomies of transformative occupation. European Journal of International Law 16: 721–740.

18.

Boutruche

Sassòli

(2014) Expert opinion on the displacements of Bedouin communities from the Central West Bank under international humanitarian law. Available at: http://www.jlac.ps/data_site_files/file/studies/Legal_Opinion_on_Forcible_Transfer_of_Bedouin.pdf (accessed 8 March 2016).

19.

Byman

Sachs

(2012) Rise of settler terrorism: The West Bank’s other violent extremists. Foreign Affairs 91(5): 73–86.

20.

Cassese

(1992) Power and duties of an occupant in relation to land and natural resources. In: Playfair

(ed) International Law and the Administration of Occupied Territories. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 419–442.

21.

Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories Unit (COGAT) website (2015a) Civil administration in Judea and Samaria. Available at: http://www.cogat.idf.il/1279-en/Cogat.aspx (accessed 28 May 2015)

22.

Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories Unit (COGAT) website (2015b) Who we are. Available at: http://www.cogat.idf.il/896-en/IDFG.aspx (accessed 28 May 2015).

23.

Declaration of Principles on Interim Self-Government Arrangements (Oslo Agreement) (1993) Available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/3de5e96e4.htm (accessed 8 March 2016).

24.

Del Sarto

(2015) Borders, power and interdependence: A borderlands approach to Israel-Palestine and the European Union. In: Del Sarto

(ed) Fragmented Borders, Interdependence and External Relations: The Israel-Palestine-European Union Triangle. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 3–24.

25.

Diakonia (2013) Planning to fail: The planning regime in area C of the West Bank: An international law perspective. Available at: http://www.diakonia.se/globalassets/documents/ihl/ihl-in-opt/planning-to-fail.pdf (accessed 28 January 2016)

26.

Diakonia (2014) International law and Israeli settlements in the occupied Palestinian territory. Available at: http://www.diakonia.se/globalassets/documents/ihl/ihl-resources-center/fact-sheets/international-law-and-israeli-settlements-in-the-occupied-palestinian-territory.pdf (accessed 8 March 2016).

27.

Diakonia (2015) A locked garden: Declaration of closed areas in the West Bank. Available at: http://www.diakonia.se/globalassets/documents/ihl/external/alockedgarden_keremnavot_finalversion.pdf (accessed 28 January 2016)

28.

Dinstein

(2009) The International Law of Belligerent Occupation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

29.

Etkes

(2015) For one Palestinian village: A judge, settler and demolisher’, 972 mag, 18 May. Available at: http://972mag.com/the-palestinians-judge-jury-and-house-demolisher/106844/ (accessed 8 March 2016).

30.

Falah

(1985) How Israel controls the Bedouin in Israel. Journal of Palestine Studies 14: 35–51.

31.

Falah

(1989) Israeli state policy toward Bedouin sedentarization in the Negev. Journal of Palestine Studies 18: 71–91.

32.

Falk

(1989) Some legal reflections on prolonged Israeli occupation of Gaza and the West Bank. Journal of Refugee Studies 2: 40–51.

33.

Falk

Weston

(1992) The relevance of international law to Israeli and Palestinian rights in the West Bank and Gaza. In: Playfair

(ed) International Law and the Administration of Occupied Territories. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 125–150.

34.

Gordon

(2008) Israel’s Occupation. Berkley: University of California Press

35.

Greenwood

(1992) The administration of occupied territory in international law. In: Playfair

(ed) International Law and the Administration of Occupied Territories. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 241–266.

36.

Hague Convention (IV) Respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land and Its Annex: Regulations Concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land (1907) In: International Conferences, The Hague, 18 October 1907. Available at: https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/0/1d1726425f6955aec125641e0038bfd6 (accessed 8 September 2016).

37.

Hajjar

(2005) Courting Conflict: The Israeli Military Court System in the West Bank and Gaza. Berkley: University of California Press.

38.

Harpaz

Shany

(2010) The Israeli supreme court and the incremental expansion of the scope of discretion under belligerent occupation law. Israel Law Review 43: 514–550.

39.

Hass

(2014) Israeli government plans to forcibly relocate 12,500 Bedouin. Haaretz, 16 September.

40.

Home

(2003) An ‘irreversible conquest’? Colonial and postcolonial land law in Israel/Palestine. Social & Legal Studies 12: 291–310.

41.

Human Rights Watch (2010) Separate and unequal: Israel’s discriminatory treatment of Palestinians in the occupied Palestinian territories. Available at: https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/reports/iopt1210webwcover_0.pdf (accessed 28 January 2016).

42.

Imseis

(2003) On the fourth Geneva convention and the occupied Palestinian territory. Harvard international Law Journal 65: 44–138.

43.

Imseis

(2005) Critical reflections on the international humanitarian law aspects of the ICJ wall advisory opinion. American Journal of International Law 99: 102–118.

44.

International Committee of the Red Cross (2006) Customary IHL database. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

45.

International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) (1949) Geneva Convention Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War, 12 August 1949, 75 United Nations Treaty Series 287 (‘Fourth Geneva Convention’, ‘GCIV’). Available at: https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/ihl/385ec082b509e76c41256739003e636d/6756482d86146898c125641e004aa3c5 (accessed 8 September 2016).

46.

International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) (1977) Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts, 8 June 1977, 1125 United Nations Treaty Series 3 (‘Protocol I’, ‘API’). Available at: https://treaties.un.org/doc/publication/unts/volume%201125/volume-1125-i-17512-english.pdf (accessed 8 September 2016).

47.

Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs Website (2015) The judiciary: The court system. Available at: http://www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/aboutisrael/state/democracy/pages/the%20judiciary-%20the%20court%20system.aspx (accessed 28 May 2015).

48.

Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip (Oslo II) (1995) Available at: http://www.unsco.org/Documents/Key/Israeli-Palestinian%20Interim%20Agreement%20on%20the%20West%20Bank%20and%20the%20Gaza%20Strip.pdf (accessed 8 March 2016).

49.

Jamjoum

(2008/2009) Al-Naqab: The ongoing displacement of Palestine’s Southern Bedouin. Al Majdal 39/40: 27–32. Available at: http://www.badil.org/phocadownload/Badil_docs/publications/al-majdal-39-40.pdf#page=29 (accessed 8 March 2016).

50.

Judea and Samaria Region Subcommittee of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Nineteenth Knesset, Minutes: Illegal Palestinian construction in the C Territories (2014) English translation Available at: http://jahalin.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/2014.04.27-Minutes-Judea-and-Samaria-Region-Subcommittee-of-the-Foreign-Affairs-and-Defense-Committee.pdf (accessed 22 July 2015).

51.

Kattan

(2007) Legality of the West Bank Wall: Israel’s high court of justice v. the international court of justice. Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law 40: 1425–1522.

52.

Ki-Moon

(2016) Secretary-general’s remarks to the security council on the situation in the Middle East (26 January). Available at: http://www.un.org/sg/statements/index.asp?nid=9417 (accessed 27 January 2016).

53.

Kirchheimer

(1961) Political Justice: The Use of Legal Procedure for Political Ends. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

54.

Koskenniemi

(2008) Occupied zone – A zone of reasonableness. Israel Law Review 41: 13–40.

55.

Kretzmer

(2002) The Occupation of Justice: The Supreme Court of Israel and the Occupied Territories. New York: State University of New York Press.

56.

Kretzmer

(2005) The advisory opinion: The light treatment of international humanitarian law. American Journal of International Law 99: 88–102.

57.

Kretzmer

(2012) The law of belligerent occupation in the Supreme Court of Israel. International Review of the Red Cross 94: 207–236.

58.

Kretzmer

(2013) The law of belligerent occupation as a system of control: Dressing up exploitation in respectable garb. In: Bar-Tal

Schnell

(eds) The Impacts of Lasting Occupation: Lessons from Israeli Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 31–60.

59.

Maidhof

(2014) Living the middle-class dream – beyond the green line, in a West Bank settlement. Vox Tablet, 17 January. Available at: http://www.tabletmag.com/podcasts/159838/middle-class-dream-settlement (accessed 27 January 2016).

60.

Meindersma

(1994) Legal issues surrounding population transfers in conflict situations. Netherlands International Law Review 41: 31–83.

61.

Nasasra

Richter-Devroe

Abu-Rabia-Queder

. (2014) The Naqab Bedouin and Colonialism: New Perspectives. Abingdon: Routledge.

62.

Norwegian Refugee Council (2015) Bedouin rights under occupation: International humanitarian law and indigenous rights for Palestinian Bedouin in the West Bank. Available at: http://www.nrc.no/arch/_img/9211542.pdf (accessed 8 March 2016)

63.

Peled

(2012) From Oslo to Gaza: Israel’s ‘enlightened public’ and the remilitarization of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In: Stavrianakis

Selby

(eds) Militarism and International Relations: Political Economy, Security and Theory. Abingdon: Routledge, pp. 77–90.

64.

Pellet

(1992) The destruction of troy will not take place. In: Playfair

(ed) International Law and the Administration of Occupied Territories. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 169–204.

65.

Playfair

(1992a) International Law and the Administration of Occupied Territories: The Two Decades of Israeli Occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The Proceedings of a Conference Organized by al-Haq in Jerusalem in January 1988. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

66.

Playfair

(1992b) Playing on principle? Israel’s justification for its administrative acts in the occupied West Bank. In: Playfair

International Law and the Administration of Occupied Territories. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 205–239

67.

Ratner

(2005) Foreign occupation and international territorial administration: The challenges of convergence. European Journal of International Law 16: 695–719.

68.

Rishmawi

(1992) The administration of the West Bank under Israeli rule. In: Playfair

(ed) International Law and the Administration of Occupied Territories. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp 267–294.

69.

Roberts

(1984) What is a military occupation? British Yearbook of International Law 55: 249–305.

70.

Roberts

(1990) Prolonged military occupation: The Israeli-occupied territories since 1967. American Journal of International Law 84: 44–103.

71.

Roberts

(2006) Transformative military occupation: Applying the laws of war and human rights. American Journal of International Law 100: 580–622.

72.

Sassòli

(2005) Legislation and maintenance of public order and civil life by occupying powers. European Journal of International Law 16: 661–694.

73.

Shamir

(1990) Landmark cases and the reproduction of legitimacy: The case of Israel’s high court of justice. Law & Society Review 24: 783–789.

74.

Shamir

(1996) Suspended in space: Bedouins under the law of Israel. Law & Society Review 30: 231–257.

75.

Shehadeh

(1985) Occupier’s Law: Israel and the West Bank. Washington: Institute for Palestine Studies.

76.

Shehadeh

(1992) The legislative stages of the Israeli military occupation. In: Playfair

(ed) International Law and the Administration of Occupied Territories. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 151–168.

77.

Sultany

(2014) Activism and legitimation in Israel’s jurisprudence of occupation. Social & Legal Studies 23: 315–339.

78.

Tawil-Souri

(2012) Uneven borders, coloured (Im)mobilities: ID cards in Palestine/Israel. Geopolitics 17: 153–176.

79.

United Nations General Assembly (1998) Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, 17 July 1998, United Nations Treaty Series vol. 2187, No. 38544 (‘Rome Statute’). Available at: https://www.icc-cpi.int/NR/rdonlyres/ADD16852-AEE9-4757-ABE7-9CDC7CF02886/283503/RomeStatutEng1.pdf (accessed 8 September 2016).

80.

United Nations Human Rights Council (UN-HRC) (2012) Resolution 19/17, Israeli settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and in the occupied Syrian Golan. (A/HRC/RES/19/17) .

81.

United Nations Human Rights Council (UN-HRC) (2013a) Report of the independent international fact-finding mission to investigate the implications of the Israeli settlements on the civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights of the Palestinian people throughout the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem 7 february 2013 (A/HRC/22/63). Available at: http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/HRBodies/HRCouncil/RegularSession/Session22/A-HRC-22-63_en.pdf (accessed 8 September 2016).

82.

United Nations Human Rights Council 27 august 2013 (UN-HRC) (2013b) Report of the Human Rights Council on its twenty-second session (A/HRC/22/2) including Resolutions 2/26 (Israeli settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory), 2/27 (Right of the Palestinian people to self-determination), 2/28 (Human rights situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem) and 2/29 (Follow-up to the report of the independent international fact-finding mission to investigate the implications of Israeli settlements). Available at: http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/HRBodies/HRCouncil/RegularSession/Session22/A-HRC-22-2_en.pdf (accessed 8 September 2016).

83.

United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN-OCHA occupied Palestinian territory) (2011) Bedouin Relocation: Threat of displacement in the Jerusalem periphery. September 2011. Available at: https://www.ochaopt.org/documents/ocha_opt_bedouin_factsheet_october_2011_english.pdf (accessed 8 September 2016).

84.

United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN-OCHA occupied Palestinian territory) (2012) East Jerusalem: Key Humanitarian Concerns. December 2012. Available at: http://www.ochaopt.org/content/east-jerusalem-key-humanitarian-concerns-update-december-2012 (accessed 8 September 2016).

85.

United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN-OCHA occupied Palestinian territory) (2014a) Area C of the West Bank: Key Humanitarian Concerns. August 2014. Available at: https://www.ochaopt.org/documents/ocha_opt_area_c_factsheet_august_2014_english.pdf (accessed 8 September 2016).

86.

United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN-OCHA occupied Palestinian territory) (2014b) Bedouin communities at risk of forcible transfer. September 2014. Available at: http://www.ochaopt.org/sites/default/files/ocha_opt_communities_jerusalem_factsheet_september_2014_english.pdf (accessed 8 September 2016).

87.

United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN-OCHA occupied Palestinian territory) (2014c) 10 years since the ICJ advisory opinion. 9 July 2014. Available at: https://www.ochaopt.org/documents/ocha_opt_10_years_barrier_report_english.pdf (accessed 8 September 2016).

88.

United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) (2009) The rubber tyre school. Available at: http://www.unrwa.org/newsroom/features/rubber-tyre-school (accessed 8 March 2016).

89.

United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) (2013) Al Jabal: A study on the transfer of Bedouin Palestine refugees. Available at: http://www.unrwa.org/userfiles/2013052935643.pdf (accessed 19 July 2015)

90.

Weill

(2007) The judicial arm of the occupation: The Israeli military courts in the occupied territories. International Review of the Red Cross 89: 395–419.

91.

Weill

(2014) The Role of National Courts in Applying International Humanitarian Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

92.

Weill

(2015) The legitimating role of the Israeli high court of justice: From occupation to segregation. Global Jurist 15: 1–35.

93.

Weizman

(2016) Cause lawyering and resistance in Israel: The legal strategies of Adalah. Social & Legal Studies 25: 43–68.

94.

Weyrauch

(1978) Law as mask – legal ritual and relevance. California Law Review 66: 699–726.

95.

Yesh

Din

(Blog) (2016) Levi report (Tag). Available at: http://blog.yesh-din.org/en/?tag=levy-report (accessed 1 March 2016).

96.

Yesha Council Website (2016) Frequently asked questions about Judea and Samaria. Available at: http://theyeshacouncil.org/content/frequently-asked-questions-about-judea-and-samaria (accessed 28 January 2016).

97.

Yiftachel

(2003) Bedouin Arabs and the Israeli settler state: Land policies and indigenous resistance. In: Champagne

Abu-Saad

(eds) The Future of Indigenous Peoples: Strategies for Survival and Development. Berkley: University of California Press, pp. 21–47.

98.

Yiftachel

(2006) Ethnocracy: Land and Identity Politics in Israel/Palestine. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.

99.

Zarchin

(2012) Israel’s high court rules residents of settlements can serve as justices. Haaretz, 9 January.

Jurisdiction as Sovereignty Over Occupied Palestine

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References