Previous studies have illustrated the existence of a double standard in the attribution of responsibility in contested sexual consent scenarios whereby intoxicated defendants tend to be held less responsible for subsequent sexual events than their sober counterparts while intoxicated complainants tend to be held more responsible. This study examined the extent to which the means by which the complainants' intoxication was secured would influence this process.1 Mock jurors, having been exposed to a trial reconstruction in which intoxicated sexual consent was at issue, deliberated towards a unanimous, or failing that, majority verdict on whether rape had occurred. Across the trial scenarios, the only variables related to the type of intoxicant ingested and the means of its administration. In a context in which the Sexual Offences Act 2003 purports to restrict reliance in the jury room on questionable stereotypes about socio-sexual behaviour, this article considers the extent to which participants' views about responsibility for intoxication shaped their conclusions on the occurrence of, and liability for, rape. It also examines the ways in which the social acceptability of some intoxicants (alcohol) and the social unacceptability of others (Rohypnol) supported the construction of `drug-assisted rape' as distinguishable from more mundane instances of intoxicated sex.
Abbey, A. (1991) `Acquaintance Rape and Alcohol Consumption on College Campuses: How Are They Linked?', American Journal ofCollege Health39: 165—70.
2.
Abbey, A. and R. Harnish (1995) `Perceptions of Sexual Intent: The Role of Gender, Alcohol Consumption and Rape Supportive Attitudes', Sex Roles32: 297—313.
3.
Abbey, A., L. Ross, D. McDuffie and P. McAuslan (1996) `Alcohol, Misperceptions and Sexual Assault: How Are They Linked?', pp. 138—61 in D. Buss and N. Malamuth (eds) Sex, Power, Conflict: Evolutionary and Feminist Perspectives. New York: Oxford University Press.
4.
Abbey, A., T. Zawacki, P. Buck, A. Clinton and P. McAuslan (2001) `Alcohol and Sexual Assault', Alcohol Research andHealth25(1): 43—51.
5.
Amnesty International ( 2005) `Sexual Assault Research Summary Report' (prepared by ICM), URL: http://www.amnesty.org.uk/news_details.asp?NewsID=16618
6.
Anderson, I., G. Beattie and C. Spencer (2001) `Can Blaming Victims of Rape be Rational? Attribution Theory and Discourse Analytic Perspectives', Human Relations54(4): 445—67.
7.
Anglin, D., K. Spears and H. Range Hutson (1997) `Flunitrazepam and its Involvement in Date or Acquaintance Rape', Journal of AcademicEmergency Medicine4: 323—6.
8.
Berkowitz, A. (1992) `College Men as Perpetrators of Acquaintance Rape and Sexual Assault: A Review of Recent Research', Journal of American College Health40: 175—81.
9.
Bernat, J., K. Calhoun and S. Stolp (1998) `Sexually Aggressive Men's Responses to a Date Rape Analogue: Alcohol as a Disinhibiting Cue', The Journal of Sex Research35(4): 341—8.
10.
Bonazzoli, M. (1998) `Jury Selection and Bias: Debunking Invidious Stereotypes Through Science', Quinnipiac Law Review18: 19—31.
11.
Bradbury, T. and F. Fincham (1990) `Attributions in Marriage: Review and Critique ', Psychological Bulletin107: 3—33.
12.
Branscombe, N., M. Wohl, S. Owen, J. Allison and A. N'gbala (2003) `Counterfactual Thinking, Blame Assignment and Well-Being in Rape Victims', Basic and Applied Social Psychology25: 265—73.
13.
Braunack-Mayer, A. (2002) `The Ethics of Participating in Research', Medical Journal of Australia177: 471—2.
14.
Burt, M. and G. Albin (1981) `Rape Myths, Rape Definitions and Probability of Conviction', Journal of Applied Social Psychology11(3): 212—30.
15.
Calhoun, K. and R. Townsley (1991) `Attributions of Responsibility for Acquaintance Rape', pp. 57—70 in A. Parrot and L. Bechhofer (eds) Acquaintance Rape: The Hidden Crime. New York: Wiley.
16.
Cameron, C. and W. Stritzke (2003) `Alcohol and Acquaintance Rape in Australia: Testing the Presupposition Model of Attributions of Responsibility and Blame', Journal of Applied Social Psychology33(5): 983—1008.
17.
Catania, J. (1997) `A Model for Investigating Respondent-Interviewer Relationships in Sexual Surveys', pp. 417—35 in J. Bancroft (ed.) Researching Sexual Behaviour: Methodological IssuesBloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
18.
Chaikin, A. and J. Darly (1973) `Victim or Perpetrator? Defensive Attribution of Responsibility and the Need for Order and Justice', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology25: 268—75.
19.
Corbin, W., J. Bernat, K. Calhoun, L. McNair and K. Seals (2001) `The Role of Alcohol Expectancies and Alcohol Consumption Among Sexually Victimised and Non-Victimised College Women', Journal of Interpersonal Violence16(4): 297—311.
20.
Cowan, G. (2000) `Women's Hostility Towards Women and Rape and Sexual Harassment Myths', Violence Against Women6(3): 238—46.
21.
Crowe, L. and W. George, (1989) `Alcohol and Human Sexuality: Review and Integration ', Psychological Bulletin105: 374—86.
22.
Davis, D. and E. Loftus (2004) `What's Good for the Goose Cooks the Gander: Inconsistencies Between the Law and Psychology of Voluntary Intoxication and Sexual Assault ', in D. Davis and E. Loftus (eds) Handbook of Forensic Psychology: Resources for Mental Health and Legal Professionals. Boston: BostonAcademic Press.
23.
Dowd, S., P. Janiak and A. Negrusz (2002) `The Behavioural and Cognitive Effects of Two Benzodiazepines Associated with Drug Facilitated Sexual Assault', Journal of Forensic Sciences47: 1101—7.
24.
Fillmore, M. (1984) `When Angels Fall: Women's Drinking as Cultural Preoccupation and as Reality', pp. 7—36 in S. Wilsnack and L. Beckman (eds) Alcohol Problems in Women: Antecedents, Consequences and Interventions. New York: Guilford.
25.
Finch, E. and V. Munro (2003) `Intoxicated Consent and the Boundaries of Drug-Assisted Rape', Criminal Law Review: 773—87.
26.
Finch, E. and V. Munro (2004) `The Sexual Offences Act 2003: Intoxicated Consent and Drug Assisted Rape Revisited', Criminal Law Review: 789—802.
27.
Finch, E. and V. Munro (forthcoming) `Lifting the Veil: The Use of Focus Groups and Trial Simulations in Legal Research', Special Issue on `Researching Law and Justice: Case Studies in Empirical Socio-Legal Research', Journal of Law and Society.
28.
Finney, A. (2004) Alcohol and Sexual Violence: Key Findings from the Research, Home Office Findings 215. London: HMSO.
29.
Fischer, G. (1995) `Effects of Drinking by the Victim or Offender in a Simulated Trial of an Acquaintance Rape', Psychological Reports77: 579—86.
30.
Foley, L. and M. Pigott (2000) `Belief in a Just World and Jury Decisions in a Civil Rape Trial', Journal of Applied Social Psychology30(5): 935—51.
31.
Frinter, M. and L. Rubinson (1993) `Acquaintance Rape: The Influence of Alcohol, Fraternity Membership, and Sports Team Membership', Journal of Sex Education and Therapy10: 272—84.
32.
George, W., S. Gournic and M. McAfee (1988) `Perceptions of Postdrinking Female Sexuality: Effects of Gender, Beverage Choice and Drink Payment', Journal of Applied Social Psychology18: 1295—317.
33.
George, W. and J. Norris (1991) `Alcohol, Disinhibition, Sexual Arousal and Deviant Sexual Behaviour', Alcohol Health & Research World15: 133—8.
34.
George, W.H., J.B. Skinner and G.A. Marlatt (1986) `Male Perceptions of the Drinking Woman: Is Liquor Quicker?', paper presented at Eastern Psychological Association , New York.
35.
Goldman, M. and L. Roehrich (1991) `Alcohol, Expectancies, and Sexuality', Alcohol Health & Research World15: 126—32.
36.
Gomberg, E. (1982) `Historical and Political Perspective: Women and Drug Use', Journal of Social Issues38: 9—23.
37.
Grubin, D. and J. Gunn (1990) The Imprisoned Rapist and Rape. London: The Institute of Psychiatry.
38.
Hamilton, C. and J.Collins ( 1981) `The Role of Alcohol in Wife-Beating and Child Abuse: A Review of the Literature', pp. 253—87 in J. J. Collins (ed.) Drinking and Crime. New York: Guilford.
39.
Heider, F. (1958) The Psychology of Interpersonal Relations. New York: Wiley.
40.
Hepburn, J. (1980) `The Objective Reality of Evidence and the Utility of Systematic Jury Selection', Law and Human Behaviour4: 89—101.
41.
Hindmarch, I. and R. Brinkmann (1999) `Trends in the Use of Alcohol and Other Drugs in Cases of Sexual Assault', Human Pyschopharmacology14(4): 225—31.
42.
Hindmarch, I., M. Elsholy, J. Gambles and S. Salamone (2001) `Forensic Urinalysis of Drug Use in Cases of Alleged Sexual Assault', Journal of Clinical ForensicMedicine8: 197—205.
43.
Janoff-Bulman, R. (1979) `Characterological Blame Versus Behavioural Self-Blame: Inquiries into Depression and Rape', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology37: 1798—809.
44.
Kalven, H. and H. Zeisel (1966) The American Jury. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
45.
Kanin, E. (1984) `Date Rape: Unofficial Criminals and Victims', Victimology9: 95—108.
46.
Kanin, E. (1985) `Date Rapists: Differential Sexual Socialisation and Relative Deprivation', Archives of Sexual Behaviour14: 219—31.
47.
Kelly, L., L. Lovett and L. Regan (2005) `A Gap or a Chasm? Attrition in Reported Rape Cases', Home Office Research Study 293. London: HMSO.
48.
Kerr, N. and R. MacCoun (1985) `The Effects of Jury Size and Polling Method on the Process and Product of Jury Deliberation', Journal of Personality & Social Psychology48: 349—63.
49.
Kleinke, C. and C. Meyer (1990) `Evaluation of a Rape Victim by Men and Women with High and Low Belief in a Just World', Psychology of Women Quarterly14: 343—53.
50.
Kramer, K. (1994) `Rule by Myth: The Social and Legal Dynamics Governing Alcohol-Related Acquaintance Rapes', Stanford Law Review47: 115—57.
51.
Labianca, D. (1998) `Rohypnol: Profile of the Date Rape Drug', Journal of Chemical Education75: 719—22.
52.
Landrine, H., S. Bardwell and T. Dean (1988) `Gender Expectations for Alcohol Use: A Study of the Significance of the Masculine Role', Sex Roles19: 703—12.
53.
Lang, A. and W. Strizke (1997) `Attributions About Acquaintance Rape: The Role of Alcohol and Individual Differences', Journal of Applied Social Psychology27(4): 279—305.
54.
Leigh, B. (1995) `A Thing So Fallen, and So Vile: Images of Drinking and Sexuality in Women', Contemporary Drug Problems22: 415—34.
55.
Lerner, J. (1965) `Evaluation of Performance as a Function of the Performer's Reward and Attractiveness', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology1: 355—60.
56.
Lerner, J. (1980) The Belief in a Just World: A Fundamental Question . New York: Plenum.
57.
Marx, B., A. Gross and H. Adams (1999) `The Effect of Alcohol on the Responses of Sexually Coercive and Noncoercive Men to an Experimental Rape Analogue', Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment11(2): 131—45.
58.
Mills, L. (1973) `Six Member and Twelve Member Juries: An Empirical Study of Trial Results', Journal of Law Reform6: 671—711.
59.
Mosher, D. and R. Anderson (1986) `Macho Personality, Sexual Aggression and Reactions to Guided Imagery of Realistic Rape', Journal of Research in Personality20: 77—94.
60.
Muehlenhard, C. and M. Linton (1987) `Date Rape and Sexual Aggression in Dating Situations: Incidence and Risk Factors', Journal of Counselling Psychology34: 186—96.
61.
Murphy, S. (1992) `Assisting the Jury in Understanding Victimisation: Expert Psychological Testimony on Battered Women Syndrome and Rape Trauma Syndrome', Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems25: 277—312
62.
Nario-Redmond, M. and N. Branscombe (1996) `It Could Have Been Better or It Might Have Been Worse: Implications for Blame Assignment in Rape Cases', Basic and Applied Social Psychology18: 347—66.
63.
Norris, J. and L. Cubbins (1992) `Dating, Drinking and Rape: Effects of Victims' and Assailants' Alcohol Consumption on Judgments of their Behaviour and Traits ', Psychology of Women Quarterly16: 179—91.
64.
Payne-James, J. and D. Rogers (2002) `Drug-Facilitated Sexual Assault, “Ladettes” and Alcohol', Journal of Society and Medicine95: 326—7.
65.
Richardson, D. and J.Campbell (1982) `Alcohol and Rape: The Effect of Alcohol on Attributions of Blame for Rape', Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin8(3): 468—76.
66.
Richardson, D. and G. Hammock (1991) `Alcohol and Acquaintance Rape', pp. 83—95 in A. Parrot and L. Bechhofer (eds) Acquaintance Rape: The Hidden Crime. New York: Wiley & Sons.
67.
Ross, L. (1977) `The Intuitive Psychologist and his Shortcomings: Distortions in the Attribution Process', in L Berkowitz (ed.) Advances in Experimental Social Psychology . New York: Academic Press.
68.
Schwartz, R., R. Miltear and M. LeBeau (2000) `Drug Facilitated Sexual Assault ', Southern Medical Journal93: 558—61.
69.
Scott-Ham, M. and F. Burton (2005) `A Study of Blood and Urine Alcohol Concentrations in Cases of Alleged Drug-Facilitated Sexual Assault in the UK over a 3-Year Period', Journal of Clinical Forensic Medicine13: 107—11.
70.
Scully, D. and J. Marolla (1984) `Convicted Rapists' Vocabulary of Motive: Excuses and Justifications', Social Problems31: 530—44.
71.
Shaver, K. (1990) `Defensive Attribution: Effects of Severity and Relevance on the Responsibility Assigned for an Accident', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology17: 101—14.
72.
Shortland, R. and L. Goodstein (1983) `Just Because She Doesn't Want to Doesn't Mean It's Rape: An Experimentally Based Causal Model of the Perception of Rape in a Dating Situation', Social Psychology Quarterly46: 220—32.
73.
Slaughter, L. (2000) `Involvement of Drugs in Sexual Assault', Journal of ReproductiveMedicine45: 425—30.
74.
Stormo, K., A. Lang and Q. Stritzke (1997) `Attributions about Acquaintance Rape: The Role of Alcohol and Individual Differences', Journal of Applied Social Psychology27(4): 279—305.
75.
Testa, M. and K. Parks (1996) `The Role of Women's Alcohol Consumption in Sexual Victimisation', Aggression and ViolenceBehaviour1(3): 217—34.
76.
Thornton, B. (1984) `Defensive Attribution of Responsibility: Evidence for an Arousal-Based Motivational Bias', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology46: 721—34.
77.
Visher, C. (1987) `Juror Decision Making: The Importance of Evidence ', Law and Human Behaviour11(1): 1—17.
78.
Wall, A. and R. Schuller (2000) `Sexual Assault and Defendant/Victim Intoxication: Jurors' Perceptions of Guilt', Journal of Applied Social Psychology30(2): 253—74.
79.
Wertheimer, A. (2001) `Intoxicated Consent to Sexual Relations', Law and Philosophy20(4): 373—401.
80.
Workman, J. and E. Freeburg (1999) `An Examination of Date Rape, Victim Dress, and Perceiver Variables Within the Context of Attribution Theory', Sex Roles41(3/4): 261—77.
81.
Zander, M. and P. Henderson (1993) `The Royal Commission of Criminal Justice: Crown Court Study', pp. 203—44 in Research Study No. 19. London: HMSO.
82.
Zeisel, H. and S. Diamond (1974) `Convincing Empirical Evidence on the Six Member Jury', University of Chicago Law Review41: 281—95.
